Julius Caesar: Effective Manipulation Using Rhetorical Fallacies People can be very quick to misjudge a situation when they don’t understand the full story. Mark Antony knows this, effectively manipulating the crowd he gathered at Caesar's funeral. In the play, Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Antony uses Pathos and Logos to create the more effective speech as a means to turn the people against Caesar’s murderers. Antony uses pathos to convince his audience that Brutus isn’t an honorable man. When he ascends the pulpit to speak at Caesar’s funeral, Antony repeatedly says that Brutus is an “honorable man”, (Act III, Scene II) but continues to disprove his own claim with multiple pieces of evidence. By disproving his claim while seeming compassionate, Antony makes his audience believe that he is caring yet naive. This allows the audience to let their guard down and think that their later ideas are their own. Antony uses the crowds’ emotions to convince them that Brutus and the Conspirators aren’t honorable. Antony says that he won’t do the Conspirators wrong by stirring up a mutiny. He would “rather choose to wrong the dead, to wrong myself, and …show more content…
Antony contradicts Brutus’ claim that Caesar was ambitious by recalling the times such as when he “thrice presented him a kingly crown, which he did thrice refuse.”, asking the audience “was that ambition?”(Act III, Scene II). Antony uses examples like Caesar refusing the crown 3 times to prove that he wasn’t really ambitious and slowly turning the crowd against Brutus. Antony also proves that Caesar was not ambitious when he recalls that even “when the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept.” (Act III, Scene II). By showing how Caesar acts like and empathizes with the people, Antony uses pathos while still proving that Caesar wasn’t actually ambitious, debasing Brutus’ earlier claim and framing him as a liar and a fraud in the eyes of the
Act III, Scene 2 of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Antony's speech effectively develops and supports the central idea of turning the people against Brutus and honoring Caesar, through his use of emotional appeal, rhetorical questions, and loaded words. Brutus manipulated the people but Antony uses good reasoning to turn the people against Brutus. Antony masterfully employs emotional appeal to evoke strong feelings in the audience and encourage them to turn against Brutus. “For when the noble Caesar saw him stab, ingratitude, more strong than traitor’s arms, quite vanqished him.” Therefore the noble Caesar so who stab him and brutus was his friend and did him wrong. ”
Both Brutus and Antony successfully incorporate a variety of rhetorical techniques into their speeches when addressing the crowd at Julius Caesar’s funeral. Brutus uses pathos to justify his rebellion against Caesar. He claims, “If then that friend demand / why Brutus rose against Caesar, this is my answer: / --Not that i loved Caesar less, but that I loved / Rome more” (III.ii.20-23). Brutus makes the people feel like Caesar’s death was for the good of Roman society and they become proud of Brutus for making a decision to benefit a movement bigger than himself.
And, sure, he is an honorable man.” Here, Antony is inquiring the civil men with questions leading to obvious answers whether or not the actions that Caesar has performed was him being selfish or just him being considerate. This quote highlights that the civilians start to realize that Brutus deceived them when he declared that the reason they killed Caesar was because he was doing it in honor of his country, but when Antony announces well known facts about the consideration he took with the Romans, it shows that he cared very deeply about them. The Romans comprehend the lies that had been told to them, so they started to riot by killing the Congressmen involved in the conspiracy. Accordingly, Antony shows the Romans the obvious truth that had been in front of them this whole time, so they’re able to understand that Caesar has been there for them this entire
He attended this burial to put things right for Caesar and for the public to see. With the help of his diction, he can draw the audience's attention and pique their interest in learning more about the excellent things that Caesar performed before his death. Although Antony does not disparage Brutus, he does call him "an honorable man" (III.ii.84). Antony uses irony to get attention from the populace rather than breaking the rule he was given. He uses logical appeal to dissect Brutus's proof in order to support his argument.
Mark Antony, still grieving at the death of Julius Caesar, delivers his manipulative speech to the crowd of people gathered around Caesar's place of death. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Mark Antony uses rhetorical devices to manipulate the crowd. In Mark Antony's anguished speech to the people, he utilizes pathos, logos, and ethos to argue that Caesar must be avenged. Doing this he convinces the people to join his side against Brutus and the other conspirators. To begin with, Mark Antony uses an abundance of emotional appeal to convince the crowd that the conspirators committed a great crime against Rome, this emotional appeal is called pathos.
In William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, Brutus and Antony both used different techniques in order to capture the audience's attention and approval in their speeches about Caesar's death. They both include repetition, rhetorical strategies, dramatic pauses, and parallelism in order to get the crowd on their sides. Both men use different strategies by knowing the audience and they use this to their advantage. Brutus and Antony both choose the use of Pathos and Ethos specifically appeal to the audience and their love for their country.
In his play, “Julius Cesar” William Shakespeare uses effective rhetorical devices to demonstrate the skills one must have in order to persuade an audience. In the play, Cesar is murdered by some of his closest acquaintances, one of them being Brutus. After killing him, Brutus decides to give a speech to all the citizens of Rome, explaining why he and some other senators decided to kill Cesar. By the end of the speech, it is clear that he has successfully manipulated the plebians into believing that what had been done to Cesar was justified. Though Antony, the closest and most trustworthy ally of Cesar gave a speech directly after Brutus.
In the beginning of Antony’s speech, he uses pathos and ethos to show repeated reminders that Brutus is ‘honorable’, he slowly imparts doubt that Brutus’ words can be trusted. First Antony is addressing the Roman citizens and explaining his feeling about the conspirators and Caesar, then Antony talks about how “Brutus is an honourable man;
Have you ever wondered how Antony was able to persuade the people to seek revenge on the senate in Act III of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar? To summarize the part in the play, after Caesar dies, they hold a funeral for him where Brutus invites Antony to speak his thoughts on Caesar. However, this soon turned into a debate to win the crowd over. In the end, Antony’s speech was victorious. Antony was able to persuade the people that Caesar was a great leader through rhetorical devices such as ethos and pathos.
He says Brutus is honorable in a way that suggests the opposite. This creates a sense of dramatic irony and builds tension, which helps to keep the crowd engaged and receptive to his message. Brutus saw Caesar as a competitor and a threat. Furthermore, Antony tells the crowd that they would have benefited from Caesar’s rule. In the closing words of his speech he delivers, “he hath left them you, And to your heirs for ever—common pleasures, To walk abroad and recreate yourselves.
He establishes his authority by referring to his personal relations with Caesar and also his position within the group of conspirators. He begins his speech by saying “I come to bury Caesar, not to praise him.” This shows that Antony didn’t feel the need to place him on a pedestal, as many Roman’s often did, but that he wasn’t trying to reiterate false doctrine. Antony’s strategic words allowed him to undermine the credibility of his opponents by consistently repeating the phrase “Brutus is an honorable man” which appealed to the audience’s emotions. Overall, this thoughtful use of ethos is an important factor in Antony’ success in persuading the citizens to his side and against the
Antony uses pathos he communicates to the people in a way that Brutus did not. Since, Antony is not allowed to say anything bad at the funeral he discretely criticizes Brutus and Cassius because he feels that what they did was wrong. For example, when Antony makes a comment that is contrary to what he means, he says “But Brutus is an honourable man”. Antony uses a lot of pathos because he wants the citizens to feel the way he is feeling. For example, he says he wants to read them the letter but he does not want to make them weep because of how much Caesar loved them.
Mark Antony knows this, so he is very careful with his words and makes sure not to say anything negative about Brutus, "Come I to speak in Caesar’s funeral. He was my friend, faithful and just to me. But Brutus says he was ambitious, And Brutus is an honorable man," (Shakespeare Act 3 Scene 2). Antony uses a more powerful way of argument using ethos, which will appeal to the emotions of the audience, by illustrating Caesar as a very noble, humble, caring man. Antony tells the people of Rome that Caesar was not ambitious and did love them very dearly, "When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept.
Though the rhetoric used by both Brutus and Marc Antony is highly refutable at times, it is safe to assume that Antony’s is the least refutable. Because he presents evidence that touches the audience in a more emotional way than Brutus does, Antony succeeds in persuading the audience to support his side of the argument. Not only that, but he even persuades them to take action after his speech is over. By appealing to his audience’s sense of pathos, Antony was effectual with regards to the purpose of his speech. Manipulating the use of multiple rhetorical strategies proved useful in surfacing feelings of sentiment and pity in the Romans, and, by doing this, Antony was able to salvage the reputation of his
Antony seems to contradict Brutus actually being honorable. Antony explains “He was my friend, faithful and just to me; / But Brutus says he was ambitious, / And Brutus is an honorable man” (3.2.94-96). By repeating “Brutus is an honorable man”, Caesar has a cumulative impact on the audience.