INTRO: In Mary Shelly’s novel Frankenstein, there are evident themes of responsibility and personal moral standards that are prevalent throughout the book. The reader is introduced to the moral dilemma which both Victor and the creature face, and the consequences that follow. With unchecked scientific curiosity comes a mountain of consequences, but whether to face them or simply ignore them is another story and one that Victor is all too familiar with. Victor's lack of personal responsibility from the beginning ultimately causes his situation and the death of his family, friends, and finally himself. Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein demonstrates an example of scientific responsibility which can be related to the scientists and medical researchers …show more content…
When we first meet him, the reader is meant to believe that Victor is capable of being morally and scientifically responsible. As the story goes on, Victor slips deeper and deeper into his work and seems to be blinded by drive and ambition. There is also no doubt that he is prepared for the responsibility he would soon hold after the creature was born during the creature’s design, but the realization of what he’s created soon dawns on him, and that sense of self-responsibility is gone. “During these last days, I have been occupied in examining my past conduct; nor do I find it blamable. In a fit of enthusiastic madness, I created a rational creature and was bound towards him to assure, as far as was in my power, his happiness and well-being. This was my duty, but there was another still paramount to that. My duties towards the beings of my own species had a greater claim to my attention because they include a greater proportion of happiness or misery” (Shelley 263). Victor’s feelings of responsibility shift from taking care of the creature to taking care of his own kind. His hopes of saving mankind from the creature’s wrath are shortlived as most of his family and friends die at the hands of Victor’s creation. He seems to be reluctant to take much blame for what he has bestowed upon society and instead blames the …show more content…
“Had I right, for my own benefit, to inflict this curse upon everlasting generations? I had before been moved by the sophisms of the being I had created; I had been struck senseless by his fiendish threats; but now, for the first time, the wickedness of my promise burst upon me; I shuddered to think that future ages might curse me as their pest, whose selfishness had not hesitated to buy its own peace at the price, of the existence of the whole human race” (Shelley 202). This is a moment of realization and dreads that if he were to create a second monster, he would be neglecting his responsibilities to the whole human race. This is really the first time in the story that Victor examines his options and takes responsibility for his previous actions by not creating another creature. He finally sees the error of his ways by inflicting the earth as such a being as what he’s created and realizes he cannot in good conscious do that again. Although he chose to take responsibility now, he never stops blaming the creature for his actions and never takes full responsibility for everything that he
When victor says he felt the duties of a creator, he means that he needs to kill what he created, his creature. First off, Victor's life has collapsed into nothing since the monster was created "Cursed be the hands that formed you. You have made me wretched beyond expression". (Victor page 85)This quote shows the reason why Victor should kill his creature. It has ruined every aspect of his life, leaving him feeling much misery.
In volume 1 of Frankenstein, Victor's selfishness unleashes the “monster” in Victor and leads to Victor losing connections. Through the portrayal of the monster inside Victor, Shelley argues the universal theme of obligation. Shelley argues the universe of obligation, through showing us the ways of Victor only thinking of himself. In the circle of individuals and groups toward whom obligations are owed, one's self is always in the center. After oneself in the middle, family and friends come very close behind in the second circle.
(Shelley 56). The quote highlights the emotional detachment towards his creation as he’s immediately repulsed by what he created and loses any sense of parental duty alongside his love for the natural philosophies. His repulsion towards the monster led him to abandon it, denying it the chance to have a meaningful and fulfilling life. In addition to Victor rejecting his creation due to physical appearance, he rejects
This decision is the first reason Victor should be held responsible for the murders of his family and friends. On page 35, the text says, “I saw the dull yellow eye of the creature open; it breathed hard, and a convulsive motion agitated its limbs.” (Shelley) If Victor had not given the creature life, then it would not have been able to murder anyone. He let his ambition impede his common sense.
The issue of the moral culpability of the Creature for his actions in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is marked by a complex closure with valid arguments supporting both sides. With the ambiguous nature of the creature's action, his upbringing being created by Victor Frankenstines lust for science, and other avenues, they all serve a purpose in portraying why and how the creature may be morally responsible. Although the nature of his actions can be argued through the Creatures initial benevolence the novelty of his life being faced with hardships, it is evident to state that the Creature had a moral responsibility through his acts with revenge and hatred towards Victor Frankenstein and the diction of his words making him knowledgeable/well aware
Frankenstein failed to consider the potential danger that his creation might pose. I will illustrate the irresponsibility and neglect that took place. Frankenstein’s lack of responsibility is evident in his creation of a horrifying creature, that he subsequently
Love and Responsibility are two complimentary themes which present themselves simultaneously on multiple important occasions throughout Mary Shelly’s: Frankenstein. Responsibility, for the circumstances of this essay, is defined as taking care of one whom does not have the necessary materials or intellect to take care of themselves. Love, subsequently, spawns from these positive relationships. Thus, Mary Shelly combines these two themes to create a super theme of love and family. For instance, when Victor Frankenstein’s mother, Caroline, adopt Elizabeth.
The only responsibility Victor had left was to nurture the creature he made, but instead, he abandoned him. The creature’s actions in return are parallel to what he told Victor. '' If I cannot inspire love, I will cause fear. (121).” Another instance in which Victor shirks responsibility is earlier in the story, when Justine, a family friend, is framed for the death of William, though it was the creature who killed him.
Mary Shelley’s, “Frankenstein,” is a thought-provoking novel that raises important ethical and moral dilemmas regarding Frankenstein’s creation of a female counterpart. Frankenstein’s experiment, the creature, embodies deontology, a belief system that relies on rules and principles to distinguish right from wrong. Opposing this mindset, the novel’s titular character, Victor Frankenstein, represents utilitarianism: a philosophy that prioritizes outcomes and consequences of actions. This thinking resulted in Victor changing his mind as he “tore to pieces” the partially constructed female. The dilemma revolves around this action.
When Victor broke his promise, describing how he, “left the room, and locking the door, made a solemn vow in my own heart never to resume my labours” (Pg 166), it seems that Victor is sacrificing the creature’s happiness for the greater good of humanity, justifying his actions by fabricating ethical validity; however, this can quickly be proven false. It seems that the real reason Victor denies the creature a mate is because his understanding of the creature is solely appearance based. Victor seems to have created the creature to live a life of suffering. The creature is left to take on the world all by himself, and seems to be destined by Victor for only one thing—pain. Victor unethically prohibits the creature from seeking any form of happiness for an arbitrary reason, proving that his first priority is not one of high moral
While working on the 2nd monster, Victor starts to ponder what may happen as a result of meeting his monster's request. “I was now about to form another being, of whose dispositions I was alike ignorant; she might become ten thousand times more malignant than her mate and delight, for its own sake, in murder and wretchedness”(Shelly, Chapter 20). As if by fate, The Monster appears in the window of his makeshift laboratory and grins at Victor. Every emotion Victor has felt through the ordeal with The Monster flooded back to him. With all of the sadness, anger, and guilt fresh in his memory, he decides that he can not risk creating a race of devils on earth.
Victor had to deal with all the guilt and take responsibility for all the bad things the creature had done because he created and left the creature. “Unable to endure the aspect of the being I had created, I rushed out of the room and continued a long time traversing my bed-chamber, unable to compose my mind to sleep”(Shelley 49). Victor realized what he created and could not even sleep knowing that he created a “monster”. His abandonment of the creature was even worse, because he let the creature out into the real world with no knowledge or morals. “The different accidents of life are not so changeable as the feelings of human nature.
The creature becomes defensive. "Life...is dear to me, and I will defend it" (Shelley 96), this is ironic because not only does the creature kill others showing his selfishness, which he is mirroring Victor 's earlier selfish intentions for creating the creature, but earlier he was suicidal. Now the creature has to ask permission for a better life from a person that doesn 't even seem to value it. The creature also reminds
Have you ever been held responsible for the tragedies caused to others? For most the answer is no, however, for some, their actions have led to the misfortune of guiltless lives. In the novel, Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, because of the absence of attention and teaching, the reanimated creation Frankenstein is unstable; Victor Frankenstein is who to blame. Two events that he should be accountable for are not training his creation to know right from wrong and abounding the monster which led to the murder of innocent people. Firstly, Shelley uses conflict of “human” versus nature to demonstrate the major idea that Victor Frankenstein is responsible for the loss of innocent lives.
Later when Victor is told by his monster that he would leave to South America if Victor makes a second creation, he agrees until he selfishly destroys the second creation. “You have destroyed the work which you began... Do you dare to break your promise?” (181). Victor knew the consequences.