ipl-logo

A Different Outlook On God's Battalions By Rodney Stark

558 Words3 Pages

A Different Outlook on the Crusades Rodney Stark, author of the monograph God’s Battalions: The Case for the Crusades, displays a different approach than most of what he believes was the cause of the crusades. The monograph displays the events of the crusades in chronological order to get an accurate understanding of what happened and when. The question that Stark is researching is the true cause of the crusades. In his introduction, Stark explains the general view of what historians believed caused the crusades. He explains many different popular interpretations on how and why the crusades began. Stark opposes all of these popular interpretations. Stark argues that the attacks of the Christians may not have officially begun until Pope Urban II famous speech, but the crusades have been provoked from nearly 600 years of the Muslims constantly attacking the Christians and eventually taking over the holy land. …show more content…

He also evaluates the pope’s speech declaring the crusades in depth, which he explains that the crusaders truly believed that they were fighting for god; they were fighting in “God’s battalions”. A major point Stark wants the reader to take away by the end of the monograph is that the Muslims did not hold a grudge on the Westerns because of the crusades. There was originally no hatred for the Christians and Westerners after the crusades; the hatred did not develop until later on. He provides examples from many historians saying that the Muslims hate Western Christians countries because of the crusades. Starks explains that the Muslims did not seem to pay much attention to the crusades when they were occurring and for centuries after. The crusades were not brought as a brutal attack onto the Muslims and it did not fuel their anger until the 20th

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of God's Battalions By Rodney Stark

    1663 Words  | 7 Pages

    These points can be seen in the recent historical attack on 9/11. Stark quotes, “It was argued that Muslim bitterness over the mistreatment by the Christian West can be dated back to the First Crusade” (Stark, 4). This shows the audience Stark’s idealism behind not only the start of the Crusades, but also the aftermath that has been left behind hundreds of years later, connecting back to the idea of Muslims to “moving east for lands, loot” and seeking revenge on the traditional explanations on the beginning of

    Read More

  • Review Of God's Jury: The Inquisition And The Making Of The Modern World

    1155 Words  | 5 Pages

    While reading the book “God’s Jury: The Inquisition and the Making of the Modern World”, I found a sense that while the book had very interesting and questioning connections with a variety of passed inquisitions and where or how there are similarities to our modern time. Which is explained greatly by Murphy, functioning as a guide to the readers, offering a tour of the Inquisition’s nearly 700-year-old. I also found that Murphy did a great job in defining and explaining in detail the various gruesome instruments and acts of torture through history and showing similarities and same techniques used today. My the one problem I had was I found it an overall amusing to read, but personally until the first 3-4 chapters the book is quite difficult to digest and connect with, but as the inquisitions began to be more modern era I could relate and see the points and connections that were being made. I found that Murphy’s focus was to demonstrate how the mind-set and some machinery of the Inquisitions are unpreventable products of the modern world that later surfaced in Stalin’s Russia,

    Read More

  • The Crusades DBQ Essay

    1086 Words  | 5 Pages

    Did you know that Christians in the middle ages were so dedicated to their religion that they held a children's crusade to take down the enemy that actual soldiers couldn’t defeat? That is just how dedicated people can be to their religion. I do not entirely blame them, in the middle ages religion was the one thing people can look forward to in life so it would just make sense that religious devotion, and the paradise of Heaven is what the religions were fighting for during the Crusades. The Crusades was a war between the Christians and Muslims during Europe's middle ages that is often viewed as a holy war, however some people are beginning to believe it was more about money or land. However this cannot be true because of how much people

    Read More

  • The Crusades Dbq Essay

    706 Words  | 3 Pages

    Introduction: Provide background information on the Crusades, restate the DBQ question, state thesis with reasons. (include academic vocabulary and underline) The results of the Crusades was probably more negative than positive. In “Doc 4”, It states that “Moreover, the assault of one Christian people on another, when one of the goals of the Fourth Crusade was reunion of Greek and Latin churches, made the split between the Greek and Latin churches permanent.” The Crusades had a lot of hatred to the religions, and by 1204 the Crusaders had lost some of their appeal because the knights agreed to attack the Byzantine Capital instead.

    Read More

  • Children's Crusade Failure

    65 Words  | 1 Pages

    A Children’s Crusade is a popular movement in Europe, in the time period of summer 1212. This effort to improve things allowed thousands of young people to set out to recover Jerusalem from the Muslims. Lasting around five months, the Children’s Crusade did not have the official approval and ended the crusade in failure. In the end, none of the travelers had reached Holy Land.

    Read More

  • How Did The Crusades Contribute To The Rise Of Anti-Semitism In Western Europe

    1396 Words  | 6 Pages

    It is also clear that the Crusades played a pivotal role in intensifying this sentiment. However, due to contributing factors, we can conclude that the Crusades were not a direct cause for the increase of anti-Semetisim during the eleventh and twelfth

    Read More

  • The Crusades Dbq Essay

    823 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Crusades were a violent series of battles that Christians fought against Muslims in order to gain back the holy land, Jerusalem. The Christians felt threatened by the intimidating rule of the Islamic Empire, and their response was the first Crusade. These attacks continued and grew unsuccessful throughout many years, and are often due to the intense bond between Christians and God, however there are other influences, like wealth and power. Some argue also that the actions committed during these events were not necessarily “barbaric”, considering the historical time period. The Crusades should be remembered as a series of attacks with a variety of motives and influences that were violent and barbaric.

    Read More

  • Essay On The Lost Battalion

    832 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Unbeatable Souls The Lost Battalion is based totally on a real story of an American battalion that was sent out to battle during the World War I. Major Charles Whittlesey, a New York lawyer, who ends up in the trenches of France having under his command mostly young, unexperienced men. When Whittlesey and his battalion of five hundred men are ordered to advance into the Argonne Forest they find themselves surrounded by Germans troops when the other battalions instantly withdrew, leaving Whittlesey’s battalion on his own. Confined behind enemy lines, Whittlesey’s battalion turned into the only force in the German army’s plans to move forward. Trapped and with no other way to rescue, Whittlesey is given an opportunity to surrender, but chose to continue fighting and keep his men together.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Social Injustice In The Crusades

    1573 Words  | 7 Pages

    So the Christians felt that this holy land should be recaptured. And the third justification was that Christ had commanded such an action. I am going to visit each of these points and prove that the social injustice of the Crusades was not justified by these points and try to provide solutions to how this social injustice

    Read More

  • Pope Urban II's Speech During The Crusades

    205 Words  | 1 Pages

    During the Crusades, religious conflict between Christians and Muslims was fueled by a desire to control holy sites in the Middle East. Pope Urban II's speech at Clermont, France in 1095, is a prime example of the religious fervor that drove Christians to fight for control of Jerusalem. In his speech, Pope Urban II urged Christians to provide aid to their brethren in the East, who were being attacked by Turks and Arabs. He emphasized that the Turks and Arabs had killed and captured many Christians, destroyed their churches, and devastated their empire. According to Pope Urban II, it was the duty of all Christians, regardless of their social rank, to carry aid promptly to their fellow Christians and to destroy the Turks and Arabs from the lands

    Read More

  • Comparison: The Crusades

    523 Words  | 3 Pages

    A crusade was a medieval military expedition, there were several created by the Europeans to get back the Holy Land from the Muslims in the 11th, 12th, and 13th centuries. There were four European crusades talked about; 1st Crusade, 2nd Crusade, 3rd Crusade, and the Children’s Crusade. The 1st Crusade began in 1096 when Pope Urban II agreed to help take back the Holy Lands of Jerusalem from Muslims or the Turks. There were many battles throughout Western Europe, Byzantine and Islam which were mostly won by Christians.

    Read More

  • Middle Ages Dbq

    471 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Middle Ages led to the Age of Exploration. The Middle Ages (500 CE-1500 CE) was a time in history after the Roman Empire collapsed (476 CE). The Age of Exploration was when people traveled off to foreign lands and explored or traded. The Middle Ages had a lot of important events that led to the Age of Exploration. Here are some examples the fall of the Roman Empire, Feudalism,The Crusades, the Black Death, the Commercial Revolution, the Renaissance, and the Vikings.

    Read More

  • Why Were The Crusades Justified?

    206 Words  | 1 Pages

    Many things happened during the crusades. First crusaders left there families, the women and children where left to fend for themselves. In the first and only successful crusade the crusaders killed all Muslim inhabitants of Jerusalem. Although the crusaded was successful, within 46 years the land had to be fought for agin. All thought there was other crusades they still didn 't manage regain the holy land.

    Read More

  • Christian View Of The Crusades Essay

    1495 Words  | 6 Pages

    The Muslim people were the ones being attacked and had opposing viewpoints of what was going on. The views of the crusades were vastly different from two of the largest religious groups of their time, the Christians and the Muslims. The Christians looked at the crusade as their religious and personal mission and duty. After all, the Christians were the ones who were leading the crusades and they were the ones who were the biggest advocates of them.

    Read More

  • God's Role In The Black Death

    777 Words  | 4 Pages

    Gods’ Hand in Devastation In the sixteenth century, a highly infectious disease known as the Black Plague, began to spread across the shores of Europe. The term the Black Plague was quickly recognized and feared by all Europeans. In just a short amount of time the disease had spread throughout the entire continent of Europe, killing roughly fifty percent of Europeans. Those who survived the disease were left wondering “why did this happen?”.

    Read More

More about A Different Outlook On God's Battalions By Rodney Stark

Open Document