Throughout Jonathan Kozol’s essay “Still Separate, Still Unequal: America’s Educational Apartheid” (347) and “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?” (374) by Beverly Tatum, both Kozol and Tatum discuss racial issues in the educational system. Kozol and Tatum explain racial issues by presenting two different instances that racial issues have played a roles. These two instances being visiting different public schools by Kozol and noticing the cafeteria segregation by Tatum. Using their own personal experiences, their arguments essentially come to similar conclusions, so by comparing their essays, the most significant problems are brought to the table. Kozol begins by introducing the idea that Americans who live farther …show more content…
She points out that around the time the separations start, puberty and the questions of identifying themselves start to arise, making the black kids feel like outcasts to the white kids. While kids start to segregate themselves, the issues at hand being to strengthen, making them harder to fix as the kids age. With segregation rates as high as they still were, Kozol then goes on to argue that schools reflect lives of the students attending the schools, which corresponds to the dominant races of the school. I agree with what Kozol argues that white schools are normally better built and nicer, reflecting the higher income families. Dominantly black and Hispanic schools reflect much lower income families and are typically broken down, such as one elementary school he described. He states: In another elementary school, which had been built to hold 1,000 children but was packed to bursting with some 1,500, the principal poured out his feelings to me in a room in which a plastic garbage bag had been attached somehow to cover part of the collapsing ceiling. ‘This,’ he told me, pointing to the garbage bag, then gesturing around him at the other indications of decay and disrepair one sees in ghetto schools much like it elsewhere, ‘would not happen to white children.’(Kozol …show more content…
One of Tatum’s points in her essay “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria” is understanding racial identity development. As black children are growing up, they start to experience things other white kids do not. As little girls start to grow up, they start to compare themselves to other girls, particularly white girls. Tatum states that, “When their White friends start to date, they do not. The issues of emerging sexuality and societal messages about who is sexually desirable leave young black women in a very devalued position” (378). Tatum also explains how little boys face a devalued status when growing up. Black boys receive this image due to the medias, profiling them as violent criminals, filling peoples’ mind with fear of these Black boys. If not profiled as violent criminals, it’s athletically talented. She used The Autobiography of Malcolm X as an example of a young Black boy being shut down of his dreams by his teacher because he was black. “The message was clear: You are a Black male, your racial group membership matters, plan accordingly… and eventually left his predominantly white Michigan home to live with his sister in Roxbury, a Black community in Boston” (379). Boys and girls of racial differences are receiving messages like this on a normal basis now, adding to the racial issues that are already to come in educational
After few hours reading, “The Sanctuary of School” was written by Lynda Barry, grew up in an interracial neighborhood in Seattle, Washington State. Then, I think this article was interesting to read. I love the way how she told us her past experience by using her own voice to lead us step by step get into her story, then she also shares us about her feeling and how it impacted to her future life. Plus, at the end, she argues that the government should not be cutting the school programs and art related activities. Those programs definitely do help the students and the parents as well.
She highlights the disparity in how age influences the perception and treatment of Black girls compared to their white counterparts. Morris states, "Young black girls, like their peers, are influenced by societal norms and expectations about gender, sexuality, and age, yet these factors play out uniquely for them, creating distinctive conditions that make some girls vulnerable to school pushout" (Morris, 2015, p. 14). This quote emphasizes that societal treatment of Black girls is influenced by age, gender, and racial dynamics, resulting in specific conditions that increase their vulnerability to discriminatory practices and exclusion from the educational
Tyna L. Steptoe’s book, Houston Bound: Culture and Color in a Jim Crow City explores the significance of Wheatley High School, a public secondary school located in the heart of Fifth Ward, Houston, Texas, established in the 1930s to serve black and Creole students during the Jim Crow era. Despite being segregated, the students at Wheatley did not let this hold them down and instead made the best of the situation by getting heavily involved in their school. Wheatley High School gave their black and creole students tools for advancement and helped strengthen their cultural identity and in a historic period in which racial discrimination attempted to curtail their political and economic potential. In this Jim Crow era, the institutions of the city were divided by the racial categories of white and black, which would force everyone into one or the other category, even if they did not necessarily associate themselves with it. Accordingly, racially ambiguous people would either receive the benefits that accompanied the white label or the grim treatment that accompanied the black label.
Growing Up Black: Then and Now During the time in which this book was written, Black Boy by Richard Wright, the separate but equal doctrine instilled by Jim Crow laws were booming. Under Jim Crow, anything that could be done by anyone seemed to be under the analysis of laws to be abided by. For example, it became apparent in Louisiana that whites and blacks could not buy or consume alcohol on the same premises and if it were done, one could be charged with a misdemeanor and given a fine ranging from $50 to $500. Another big issue going on was the idea of interracial relationships.
Holding a fight was what needed to be done. The African American 's were given the same things as the whites, but that did not mean they had the same opportunities. This scenario reflects the educational structure in the bigger cities today. In these bigger cities de facto segregation continues to grow each year. The book, The Children in E4, dives deeper into the discovery of how segregation continues to affect, the children, the community, and the overall society.
In “If I Were A Poor Black Kid,” writer Gene Marks claims that poor inner city children have opportunities to be successful in life if they follow the advices/ideas he gives such as, to magnet/private school, have technology access and get good grades. Throughout the article Marks, emphasizes that poor inner city kids have the ability to be successful but they do not want to use the resource they have available. This article has been a controversial because Marks compare himself with the poor inner city kids without having knowledge about the challenges poor inner city kids face daily. The argument the author presents in the article may seem logical on the surface but investigating more deeply it can be unreasonable. Gene Marks is a man who comes from a middle class white background.
In Johnathan Kazol book, shame of a nation he brings up the current problem of segregation in inner city schools, that have only gotten worse since Brown vs. Board of Education. Kazol brought spent a decade with in the schools of Boston, observing students within schools that aren't as privileged as suburban schools in the categories of nice building, supplies and teachers. He also brings up the topic of of tax spending, on how schools in suburbs like Nassau County receive more money than NYC, and how schools even in a couple minute radiation have mast variety of educational opportunities. For example, they offer programs bases on the majority of the ethnicity of the school, a majority white school would have advanced classes and different
These constraints are used to distort and dismiss the true identities of the narrators and simply associate them with that of a racial group that exemplifies what it means to be held inferior and less than human. Comparatively, the experiences of both narrators illustrate the overall realities the majority of black individuals find themselves struggling with by trying to accurately define themselves on a spectrum that does not revolve around their race. Moreover, the humiliation of having to submit to the expectations of high class white citizens conflict with both narrators as they try to avoid racial anxieties and redefine the concept of self in a way that does not negatively impact their mental
Even though schools have been legally integrated for several decades, educational segregation still exist; it is a direct result of residential segregation and it keeps minorities at a disadvantage in this country while ensuring the dominance of the white race. One’s residence dictates the school they attend, and this school determines the eduction one will receive, and the education they receive will shape their future. Educational segregation ensure that the dominant group will remain dominant in our society. The goal of this paper is to analyze from a sociological perspective educational and residential segregation and to look at the controversy it causes in American society.
“Always driving around like idiots, tryna’ prove how macho they are… And they wonder why they get shot at.” This is what I have the pleasure of listening to when driving with my father. He spews venom towards every dark-skinned driver who runs a red light or changes lanes at the last minute, frequenting phrases like “gangsters” and “thugs.” In the passenger seat my mother chews her lip, never summoning the courage to silence him.
Secondly, it is often argued that African Americans are necessary to get educational equality as whites. Base on the data from By Susan Berfield (2016), she revealed the fact that black students still do not receive an equal education in diverse schools. In her explanation, she gave an example about Fleming’s experience. Fleming lived with her husband and her three children. She decided to send her kids to elementary school in south Evanston.
Being black in America has become a curse and a blessing for those who identify within the black community. Most mainstream artists that are successful are black, there is biracial president who identifies himself black, and black culture has become the popular culture. Ironically, there in lies the problem with black culture becoming the dominating culture. Everyone wants to be black until police brutality, racism, and a historical prejudice are brought into the mix. In my group our topic was the title of my paper, “Shades of Grey”: Narratives of Black Experience.
Black women are treated less than because of their ascribed traits, their gender and race, and are often dehumanized and belittled throughout the movie. They are treated like slaves and are seen as easily disposable. There are several moments throughout the film that show the racial, gender, and class inequalities. These moments also show exploitation and opportunity hoarding. The Help also explains historical context of the inequality that occurred during that time period.
This was the worst experience of my life. Counseling helped me overcome the terror of the shooting. ”5 After elementary school, she lived on the North side of town in a middle-class neighborhood and attended a predominately white elementary school. Her family was the only black family that reside in the community. “I was the only black girl in most of my classes throughout elementary and middle school and it didn’t bother me, my purpose was to learn and earn a good education”.6 She expressed that even
In the modern day, segregation in schools occurs too often in schools across America. This division has created the claim that “segregation in schools makes sense”, although inaccurate, this statement was created by African Americans deteriorated morals from segregation, segregation of races in their residences, and the lack of integration in public schools. It is no coincidence that racist attitudes exist when segregation exists in today's schools, causing prejudice individuals to encourage this division, claiming it makes sense. W.E.B. Dubois, an advocate for African American integration in white public schools reported the detrimental affect segregation has on its students. This generation of inferiority propelled students to believe