Why She Is Guilty “My door was open part of the time, and part of the time I tried to get a nap and their voices annoyed me, and I closed it. I kept it open in summer more or less, and closed in winter.” Lizzie Borden stated after the murder.(BrainyQuotes.com) The people who seem innocent are the real guilty ones. Some of them try to hide behind their shyness or the motive. Lizzie did not cover her tracks well enough to make her sister a culprit of the crime. Emma may have had an alibi but she knew that her sister did have part in the murder, Lizzie and Emma have various pieces of evidence to prove they killed their parents and withdrew information from the police. Lizzie and Emma worked hand in hand to commit the murder of Abby and Andrew Borden. According to my evidence of the Borden sisters’ family friction, Lizzie and Emma’s behavior, Andrew and Lizzie’s feud hold the facts to prove Lizzie and Emma committed this crime. Lizzie and Emma always protected each other like a sister pact. To begin with, Lizzie and Emma had family friction leading up to the murders. (Doug Linder, 2004) The …show more content…
Emma may have been quiet but her actions leading up to the murder has gotten made an accomplice. Overall, Lizzie made weird actions leading up to the murder. (Cheryl Eddy) Despite the validity of Alice Russell’s claim about Lizzie burning a dress covered in paint she missed the mark when it comes to Lizzie’s deep issues with Andrew and Abby, because Lizzie had a deep anger for her parents. Lizzie attempted to buy prussic acid away from Fall River so she knew she couldn’t be caught by someone that knew
For example, Eli Bence, a clerk at S. R. Smith's drug store in Fall River, told police that Lizzie visited the store the day before the murder and attempted to purchase prussic acid, a deadly poison. Lizzie could use that thing and poison her father and stepmother. She couldn’t get the poison, so she kill (maybe) her father and stepmother with an axe. There was rumors that Lizzie and her stepmother never got along together
Lizzie Borden’s Murder Case Lizzie Andrew Borden is the daughter of Andrew and Abby Borden and was accused by many of killing her parents. The murder case is still very famous today because it was the first nationally famous murder. Lizzie’s family consisted of herself, her older sister Emma Borden, step-mother Abby Borden, and her father Andrew Borden. The family also had a live in maid, Bridget Sullivan. On the day of the murder the only people present at the house were Lizzie, Bridget, Abby, and later on Andrew, which caused many people to believe that Lizzie committed the murders.
First of all, Lizzie Borden did not have a close relationship with her stepmother, she sent various people to complete many errands right after the murderers, and she was also accused as a thief by any people. To begin with, Lizzie Borden demonstrated a hateful relationship with her stepmother. She never accepted her stepmother into
This may well prove her guilt in that she tried to find the least suspicious place to be during the murders. The police found a bucket of bloody towels in the basement of the Borden home, and they were told that Lizzie had been menstruating. The head of an axe was also found (“Vengeful Daughter”). While Lizzie could have been on her period, it is a shocking coincidence that the two events coincided. Perhaps the most suspicious evidence would be the fact that Lizzie burned a dress the day after her parents funeral.
Other family members could be guilty of the crime, not just Lizzie. The first possible suspect that comes to mind is John Morse, Lizzie’s uncle who, after supposedly being made aware of the horrible murders, is said to have “ambled” into the back yard and proceeded to “eat pears in the shade” (King 27). The next possible suspect would have to be Emma, who, being out of town that day was sent a telegram telling her about the murders, but she “did not catch the next train,” or the next, in fact she did not “return” home “until after seven that night” (King 27). Doesn't that seem a little odd, seeing as her father was just killed; unless she had something to do with it and couldn’t get home until then, but we will never know. Another possible suspect is Bridget Sullivan, the maid who happened to be in and around the house at the time of the murders (“The Lizzie Borden Story”).
Have you ever killed some one? Over a 100 years ago Lizzie's parents were brutally murdered by someone and the only person they focused on was the daughter lizzie borden. Lizzie Borden was the axe murderer no doubt about it because all the signs pointed to no other than Lizzie herself. The reason I think Lizzie killed her parents was because she didn't like her stepmother and thought if she didn't kill her father her father would think its her. Lizzie is a true mastermind to have gotten away with murder because there is no other explanation to Lizzie's parents brutal death.
Is Lizzie Andrew Borden Guilty? I have a very simple answer, yet rather a complex answer to that. Most people in this day an age believe that she was guilty. Now, why out of everyone in the town of Fall River would you choose this poor innocent lady who supposedly loved her parents so much that she hacked her mother 18 times and her father 11. She brutally and viciously murdered her own parents in all under 2 hours.
Police and investigators believed that Lizzie Borden was the murderer because of the fact
Which I think they could've found out who did it if it had happened in this time were we can use computers , criminal investigators, microscopes and forensics to research evidence and we have more education in the human body and education on causes of death that were not available in 1892.. One of the daughter Lizzie displays actions that would make her a great suspect in her parents due to negative behaviors and actions, according to her neighbors that lived near them. However they did not have enough evidence in the trial to convict the two sisters. (Conclusion)
I have done enough research to know that there are three reasons why Lizzie didn’t commit this hideous crime. There were other people home at the time of the murder. The night before the murder John Morse, the uncle, showed up unexpectedly. In her statement to the police, Lizzie was outside at the time of the murder, so she wasn’t in the
Held in New Bedford, Massachusetts, the trial of Lizzie Borden contained many suspicious, unusual, and debatable reactions and pieces of evidence, causing the jury to decide on an unlikely verdict of not guilty (Berni 34). From the start, Lizzie Borden provided many inconsistent facts about the murders (Hazell). One example of Lizzie Borden’s changing story relates to the note her stepmother allegedly received prior to her murder. When asked for proof of the letter, Lizzie concluded that she had disposed of it. Ms. Borden’s suspicious stories also included the burning of a dress “stained by paint” and the eating of pears in a barn outside the home on the hottest summer day (Stuart).
Lizzie and her parents had a strong, devoted, and long-standing relationship, making a motive for murder unlikely. There is no incriminating evidence such as blood found on Lizzie. In addition, other possible suspects
Lizzie Borden is a name that has become synonymous with murder and intrigue. The case of Lizzie Borden has fascinated people for more than a century, and many theories and speculations have been put forth about what really happened on that fateful day in August of 1892. In this essay, we will explore the case of Lizzie Borden and argue whether she was guilty or innocent of the crime for which she was accused. First, let's review the facts of the case.
In Lizzie Borden: Murderess or Media Sensation it states that “There was no physical evidence linking her to the murders” There was no evidence that she did the murders. They didn't question anybody but Lizzie. Anyone could have done it. This just proves that Lizzie did not do