In general, humans are superficial creatures that have judged others based on gender rather than ability over the many generations that passed. Likewise, in Their Eyes Were Watching God, by Zora Neale Hurston, the main protagonist, Janie Crawford, had suffered greatly under such proposition. During the 1930’s, the time period of the novel, many women lived constricted lives as women were expected to obey their husbands and the men around them due to society's expectations. During the events of the novel, both manipulation and abuse took place as well as love and marriage in the relationships that Janie Crawford had been pushed towards. Moreover, Hurston's novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, features Janie Crawford and her struggles to overcome …show more content…
As a result, through the deaths of her previous two husbands, she learns to let go in the moment she had killed Tea Cake, “The gun came up unsteadily but quickly and leveled at Janie’s breast…Maybe he would point to scare her… The pistol snapped once. Instinctively Janie’s hand flew behind her on the rifle and brought it round… She broke the rifle deftly and shoved in the shell as the second click…” (Hurston 182-3). Although Tea Cake had brought Janie so much joy as she was able to live a life of her choosing, it was his death that allowed her to finally realize that her life is her own to control and no one else's. Furthermore as Simmons, in his article states, “Janie's ability to free herself from the confinement represented by her first two husbands and, after the death of her third husband, Tea Cake Woods, to attain a new form of cultural power, the ability to shape her own story (Simmons para. 4)”, it depicts the hidden feelings that Janie had in the relationships she had been in. Specifically, in her last two relationships, she had started out deeply in love, but towards the end, she came to understand how much suffering and abuse she had received but was only able to come to peace with herself after their deaths. By the end of the novel, Janie returns to Eatonville, living a quiet life as she becomes content with having lived her dream of “a marriage filled with love”, content and happy at the life she had experienced, finally being able to let go with everything. By killing Tea Cake, in a self defense action, Janie overcomes the barrier of “men being superior” and not needing a man to live successfully. Through her experiences, she was able to ignore the gossip of her neighbors as she was criticized for overtaking her husband. By ignoring the gossip and unwavering towards the isolation, Janie overcomes the
Janie’s treatment of Tea Cake shows that she does not consider him to be suitable for a serious relationship. In a sense, she is using him so that she can have fun. Janie’s progress as a person is still being overshadowed by her fear of being judged by her community. She had to make Tea Cake leave after their night at the lake because she knows what people will say if they find out.
She endured a lot, and these romances that would inevitably break her didn't help her in the end. Greed is the demise of our society, and Janie's relationships are no exception. Tea Cake, her third husband, is gone for a whole day and when he returns home to Janie; he says, "Don't need tuh ast me where Ah been all dis time, 'cause it's
For Janie, her grandmother had the desire to see her “safe in life”, which meant planning Janie’s life so that Janie could have what she couldn’t. Janie and Logan Killicks marriage made Janie crave for love, which neither Logan nor her second husband, Joe could provide her with. Her last love, Tea Cake gave her the fulfillment of her long life search for happiness. All of the accomplishments and denials Janie had
Once she is free from Joe Starks, Janie is able to accept things about her life and move on. Although she realized things about her grandmother, and claims later that “Ah done lived Grandma’s way, now Ah means tuh live mine” (114), the lasting effects that Nanny and her marriages had on her can still be felt in her relationship with Tea Cake. Tea Cake’s and Janie’s relationship starts with Janie being insecure in Tea Cake’s motivations with her. Janie was hurt in her previous relationships, and so is not confident in her feelings towards him, even trying to resist the thoughts. Despite this, Janie marries him and is able to do things that she could not do before in her previous relationships, and
Therefore, when he dies, Janie feels a sense of liberation and freedom. Hurston showcases Janie’s independence as she takes over management of the store. In the succeeding months, Janie meets a younger man named Tea Cake, who helps Janie discover herself. Hurston uses Tea Cake to demonstrate a healthy, balanced relationship between a married couple. Tea Cake never forces Janie to do anything against her own free will and encourages her to try
With Joe’s death also came Janie’s freedom, although Joe’s lasting influence on her made it hard to let loose and show her beauty again as she “had tried to show her shine”(90), but she is so unconfident with herself from the impact of Joe. Additionally with Joe gone, it leaves Janie alone with a huge fortune and in a vulnerable position with many people wanting to take advantage of her, causing men to question her as a woman if she can do it “by herself”(90) or if she “needs aid”(90). Lastly, Janie shows to still be affected by Joe’s efforts to keep Janie’s life mostly revolving around the marketplace, as Tea Cake brings up that she still doesn’t go watch baseball games or learn new things because she's in “uh jug”(104), that's constrained her from living. With Joe leaving Janie in a state of vulnerability, Tea Cake offered her new opportunities and made her feel wanted which led her out of Joe’s jug and into becoming an independent and willful character. In the early relationship of Janie and Tea Cake, he asks her to play checkers with him and she starts “glowing inside”(96), after the realization that she is wanted, and learns that it's okay and “natural”(96) to try something new and
Next, Janie continues on her determined journey for love when she goes off to marry Tea Cake. In the quote,
After Jody dies Janie encounters Tea Cake, a young man that not only lets her assert her voice but encourages her to do so. Janie's feelings are revealed about Tea Cake when she thinks, “He looked like the love thoughts of women. He could be a bee to a blossom-a pear tree blossoms in the spring.” (Hurston 106) Tea Cake’s relationship is different for Janie for he taught her the value of a healthy relationship where “there is no imbalance of power,” they respected “each other’s independence” letting Janie form her ”own decisions without fear of retribution or relation, and share decisions” as proven in the article “What Does a Healthy Relationship Look Like?”
When tea cake shows up janie 's feels something she has never felt before, she is set free but the townspeople don 't think so. “‘Ain’t you skeered he’s jes after yo’ money him bein’ younger than you?’” (Hurston pg.133)Janie is in love with Tea Cake because he loves her for her youthful young side that was forced into hiding for so long because of her previous husbands. However the rest of the community is discouraging her and trying to keep her in the image as a mayor 's wife. They told Janie that Tea Cake was after her money
In the beginning Janie feels as if Tea Cake’s age would effect their relationship. She has strong feelings for him, but on the other hand people are saying he will run off with her money. Janie proves them wrong and runs off and gets married to Tea Cake. He makes Janie feel wanted, she feels like she could be herself. Janie states, "We been tuhgether round two years.
1. Unlike Janie’s previous husbands, Tea Cake treats Janie with compassion and respect. In addition, he loves Janie for her personality instead of her looks and her role as a woman (housewife). 2. The speech characteristic that Tea Cake encourages Janie with is truth.
Janie, however, now cares less about the judgment of the townspeople and more about her relationship with Tea Cake and decides to go as far as to marry him and go with him to Jacksonville. Once she begins prioritizing her husband over society’s judgment, she allows herself to be placed under the authority of another
The climax of Janie’s journey towards (re)finding her voice is when she returns to the new home she had made with Tea Cake, a lover of hers who she ran off with after Stark’s death, after Tea Cake Though Tea Cake’s presence also suppresses Janie’s voice, he is instrumental in teaching her her value, both sexually, and socially. In their relationship, Janie’s silence is for the first time empowering, a sacrifice that she willingly chose. When Tea Cake dies, she realizes that she is her own woman again. She has seen the horizon and what she has desired, and she Her return, alone and okay with that, represents a powerful assertion of her voice and her right to exist on her own terms.
Janie is presented at the start of the novel as a weak and obedient woman who has been shaped by the standards of the patriarchal culture she lives in. She is pressured into two marriages, the first with Logan Killicks and the second with Jody Starks, that do not satisfy her aspirations or provide her the freedom to be herself. Janie's relationship with Tea Cake, however, changes her and enables her to recapture her identity. Tea Cake values Janie as an equal, respects her perspectives and beliefs, and supports her independence. Janie has the flexibility to experiment and develop herself in this relationship, which helps her personality and assertiveness grow.
Thus it is still possible to see Tea Cake as having a degree of control over Janie until the moment of his death. In each of her relationships, we watch Janie lose parts of herself under the forces of male domination. The men are not the only characters who see the traditional take on gender relations, where the men are dominant, and the women are obedient, as necessary and