In the book, Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in College Town, by Jon Krakauer, the reader delves into how rape and sexual assault are treated in the town of Missoula, and the University of Montana. As the reader, we are informed on how the university, the police department, the district attorney’s office, and the community reacted to these rape and sexual assault allegations. We see how the criminal justice system has failed the victims, and are forced to live with what happened to them, while their assailants are free of any burden. The law is set in place to protect people from victimization, but when the men, in this book, are not legally held accountable, then any woman, or man, is more susceptible to victimization. It is interesting …show more content…
Rape myths are at the center of the problem of how rape and sexual assault cases are looked at, and treated as in society. Rape myths vary, some excuse the rape, others try to minimize the severity of the situation, while others doubt the act even happened in the first place (Levit and Verchick, 196). Some examples of rape myths include: a victim was “asking for it,” a victim’s previous sexual history, regretful sex is not rape, a woman’s “no” means “yes,” and women lie about rape all the time. Rape myths are targeted towards women, not the rapist. Despite, rape myths being proved false by empirical evidence, they are still prevalent in society. Krakauer uses the example of Missoula police chief, Mark Muir; Muir states, “The rate of false rape claims is around 50 percent” (Krakauer, 116). Muir uses the 2009 article, “False Rape Allegations: An Assault on Justice,” by Bruce Goss, to justify his reasoning. However, the studies used by Goss, have been discredited and highly criticized by other academics. Lisak criticized Eugene J. Kanin’s study, “False Rape Allegations,” one of the studies Goss used in his article, stating that Kanin’s article is an opinion piece, not a scientific study (Krakauer, 117). Despite being debunked, Kanin’s and McDowell’s, the other study Goss uses, their studies are still often used to persuade people that American society suffers from …show more content…
Rapes and sexual assaults are committed by the perpetrator, not the victim. The police department has an obligation to help the victim, not the rapist. In the book, we saw how some police officers empathized with the rapists, calling the situation a misunderstanding, while leaving the victim to handle the assault on her own. If a police officer is properly trained, it is possible, that more victims would feel more comfortable coming forward with their own assaults. Although the prosecution has the responsibility to act on behalf of the state’s interest, it seems as if the prosecution acts on behalf of their own interest. In Missoula, the DOA would not take cases of rape and sexual assaults to court, they would reject cases on the basis of insufficient evidence or lack of probable cause. Objectively, it appears that they would reject cases that they felt were difficult to prosecute, or they would not get a conviction out of a trial, only taking on cases that resulted in a conviction. By not rigorously pursuing cases, it showed to victims that their assaults would not be taken seriously, as they
In the case of R v. Ewanchuk many issue surrounding the use of rape myths allowed for Ewanchuk to justify the reasons for him sexually assaulting the young women. This begins with a harmless interview for the 17 year old women who is applying for a job for Ewanchuk’s woodworking business where they were scheduled for an interview in his van, which then Ewanchuk who is interviewing her suggests they go back to his trailer “to show her some of his work.” Once they got into the trailer that is when Ewanchuk initiates multiple incidents of him grabbing her where ever touch is more intimate. The women tells him multiple times to stop, but he doesn't and she fears that if she fights back it would provoke a violent response. The women contacts the
Policy Analysis: Megan’s Law Sexual violence, particularly against children, is a significant issue all around the world. In the early 1990’s in the United States, there were multiple well-publicized cases of sexual violence against children. From kidnappings, to rapes, and everything in between, violence was being committed against children and something needed to be done about it. In 1996, Megan’s Law was passed in response to the sexual assault and death of Megan Kanka, a seven-year-old from New Jersey (Corrigan, 2006).
Krakauer supports his argument of unfair rape trials by revealing bias towards the perpetrator in the court case. He does so by providing testimony that demonstrate how the overall image of the perpetrator leads jurors to disregard opposing evidence. In turn, this makes it harder for the perpetrator to receive deserved punishment for his actions and preventing further events. Krakauer quotes psychologist David Lisak, “Predators...get away with it over and over... because most of us are in denial. We’re disinclined to believe that someone who’s an attentive student or a congenial athlete could also be a rapist” (121).
One in five women and one in sixteen men are sexually assaulted while in college. 63% of sexual assaults are not reported to police and only about 2 to 10% of reports are found to be false. In Jon Krakauer’s book: Missoula, Rape and the Justice System in a College Town. Krakauer focuses on the many rapes that occur on the college campus in Missoula. Most of the rapes that happen on college campuses are done by men, but to say all men are rapists is unjust and sexist.
Furthermore, Griffin commonly sites credible studies and explores historical moments to provide context and support for her claims. One article in particular written by Griffin (1971) demonstrates her masterful use of ethos, “Rape: The All-American Crime.” This article was the first of its kind as it discusses rape from a feminist perspective and challenges common beliefs about rape. Up until this point rape and sexual violence was rarely discussed and when it was it was by a man. Griffin begins the article by explaining her credentials, describing her personal experiences with rape culture in America, and illustrating the urgency with which women and victims need to be heard.
In 2010, "False Allegations of Sexual Assualt: An Analysis of Ten Years of Reported Cases" ,David Lisak and three co-authors state "...that prevalence of false allegations is between 2 percent and 10 percent."[Krakauer 122] A fact that false reports are very uncommon. Krakauer uses this fact to give the reader an idea of how low false reports really are. To show that the overwhelming majority of rape cases are true yet the Missoula's police department right from the start don't believe the victim so much that they contradict her and deny that any of it although that's the opposite of what it the cops should be aspected.
Guilty Until Proven Innocent Today’s justice system claims that, you are innocent until proven guilty, yet they confine the so called guilty person until they can prove their innocents. On Native American reservation tribal courts don't have jurisdiction to prosecute non-tribal personnel for crimes committed like sexual assault and rape that occurs on the reservations. The tribal criminal justice systems have limited resources, little to no back from the local law enforcement and almost no funding from the federal government to help improve on these problems. Louise Erdrich shows this through Bazil, a tribal judge and how the legal system fails his family.
Every sixty-eight seconds, an American is sexually assaulted, and it is stated that only twenty-five out of every one thousand perpetrators will see the consequences of their actions (RAINN). Now, imagine if the world was a place where victims felt as if they could speak up and receive proper assistance without question and judgment. Imagine if every sexual assault case concluded with justice for the victim. Laurie Halse Anderson tells her own story of sexual violence and the struggles of the aftermath through the eyes of high school freshman, Melinda Sordino, in her work Speak. Throughout the novel, Melinda internally fights with herself on who to protect, herself and other females around her, or her attacker’s reputation.
Maria Cabrera Documentary Reflection The Hunting Ground is a documentary film targeting the frequent sexual assaults on college campuses in the United States. Colleges across the United States have failed to meet justice for victims with confrontations. The film is concentrated on Annie. E. Clark and Andrea Pino, two graduates of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, who decided to file a complaint about their assaults while they were attending the University.
Throughout the course of American history, Native American women have repeatedly become primary targets of sexual violence from non-native men. Around one in three Native American women has been raped or had undergone attempted rape, which makes them the largest race to experience sexual abuse than any other race in the United States. Before any contact was established between the Natives and the European settlers, the Native population had thrived off the land and they had their own criminal justice systems, which was meant to help all Native citizens find justice (Griffith, 5). Unfortunately, their efficient way of life would soon be interrupted forever following the arrival of white setters upon their lands.
At the beginning of the book, in the author’s notes, Krakauer states, “Rape is a much more common crime than most people realize, and women of college age are most frequently the victims.” Most college students are already on edge, especially because of the new environment and people, and introducing them to the possibility of being raped adds a new level of terror for many. Rape can scare anyone and tends to intrude on someone’s piece of mind. [5] Sadly, there is a higher probability that a rape will occur by someone an individual knows; for example, significant others, siblings, friends, and even parents than a complete stranger. Krakauer shows his readers what happens to a person when they are raped; he tells of the emotional and physical damage that can come from the rumors spread, the court cases, and the dirty feelings, and he stands to support victims of rape and stop people from falling victim to this
Tufano states, “Champaign police received 38 complaints of rape or attempted rape in the year this newspaper was published. Then the newspaper goes on to talk about the fact that 35 reports of rape were actually reported. However, in the previous year only 29 rapes were reported.” This is a high number of cases that have occurred, that could have been prevented. This is a significant fact, because all of the women
Victims play a major role in the criminal justice domain. The system developed many ways to improve services for victims of a crime. In crimes victims can become traumatized and frightening .According to Fred Garner, “Recent polls suggest this fear is derived from two influences: income and gender. People residing in poor neighborhoods often experience a greater fear of victimization; therefore, participation in the criminal justice system is extremely important.
The controversial idea of females being sex offenders is represented by the proportion of women in jail or accused is most likely disproportionate to reality. In the United Kingdom for example, the Lucy Faithfull Foundation estimates that up to 64,000 women are sex offenders, yet fewer than 2 percent of the people on the sex offenders registry are women (Townsend & Syal, 2009). Female sex offenders are often ignored and under reported due to gender roles that portray men who were assaulted or who believe they were assaulted as weak. Additionally low female offender percentage is due to police and other professionals not treating male rape victims as a serious concern. In addition, media portrayals of sexual assault and rape create an everyday
The similar study informed that 28% of ladies who are casualties of the most genuine sexual assault never enlighten anybody regarding it, and known from the experience inside the Rape Crisis development that just about 15% of girls and young ladies who experience sexual brutality ever appear for the police. This statistic bulletin was released by The Office for National Statistics, Ministry of Justice, and Home Office and titled ‘An Overview of Sexual Offending in England and Wales’. Women are regularly encouraged to stay away from sexual brutality by never strolling alone around evening time. In any case actually, just only around 10% of sexual assaults are reported by as strangers to the victim. About 90% of sexual assaults are submitted by known men; somebody who the survivor has beforehand known, trusted, frequently even cherished.