Ava Romina Colombo-Walzer
AP US History
Ms Rosen
02/27/2023
The Opposition Against Joining the League of Nations In the Senate After the First World War, there was a nationwide debate on whether or not to accept the Treaty of Versailles and therefore join the League of Nations, or the debate between the irreconcilables and the reservationists. The League of Nations was an organization created to support peace and promote healthy communication between countries in order to prevent widespread war. However, many US senators saw drawbacks in the idea of joining an international peace organization. The reasons why many US senators opposed the idea of joining the League of Nations were that it would be the abandonment of the Monroe Doctrine principles,
…show more content…
This was seen as an issue by many senators, such as Senator Henry Cabot Lodge. Lodge shares in an address on February 28, 1919 that the abandonment of the Washington policy would lead to Europe having the right to take part in the settlement of all American questions and issues. To agree to this treaty would be to would bind ourselves to submit “every possible international dispute or difference either to the league court or to the control of the executive council of the league,” which means before taking action to work on issues as a nation, the US would have to submit their conflicts and issues to the league of nations, stopping the US from truly having control of its politics and progress. Furthermore, as stated by Senator George Norris of Nebraska to the Senate in November, 11, 1919, if the League of Nations were to include the United States, the US would “mortgage thereby the lifeblood of unborn American boys to stifle this cry and uphold the cruel aristocratic reign of greedy kings and pagan monarchs the world over”. What this means is that the League of Nations was a trap to enthrall the US in a system that would only control them and stifle the cries of freedom and liberty, while the US would have little power in affecting other world powers such as Great Britain even in cases when interference is needed for the sake of proper …show more content…
The US was struggling with issues of lynching and racism towards African-Americans, Asian-Americans, and other people of color. If each conflict and issue was to be reported to the League of Nations before action was able to be taken, then the changes in the system would not be done with the support of the American people. Senator Hiram Johnson, in his Speech from June 2, 1919, stated “You, gentlemen from the South, would resent the suggestion that a race problem of yours should be decided by nations bound to the race affected by secret treaties”, meaning that if the League of Nations chose to enact change in policy regarding race in the US, then it would be detrimental to the Southern White way of life where white-supremacy is common. If the jurisdiction is given to outside countries to affect the politics of the US, racial conflicts and factions would
If this attempt is unsuccessful, we propose an alliance with Mexico.” this information is found in document H. the reason the US would have to join the war for this is because they felt personally attacked by the germans saying to mexico that is the united states decided to join the war and no longer be neutral that they would attack the areas closest to them distracting the military which in turn Mexico would regain all of the land they lost in the spanish American war. To show that the United States would not be disrespected, they joined the war after a threat was introduced. Earlier in the beginning of the war before the Us became an Allied power President Woodrow Wilson wrote a letter to the congressmen saying that being neutral was the best option due to America being a “place drawn from many nations, and chiefly from the nations now at war “. He also realized that if we went to war and had to choose a side to defend it would cause the United states to fall apart due to the citizens having different opinions on the war, and what should be done; this information was found on the document
They formed the League of Nations, the first intergovernmental organization established to promote world peace. It is also known as the “predecessor” of the United Nations. It was formed January 10, 1920 and had 48 nations as members by the end of that year. The founding document, The Covenant of the League of Nations, was drafted at the end of WWI. It contained 26 articles, of which included conditions of membership, functions of principal organs, the mechanisms to peacefully resolve disputes, and what was obligatory for Member States.
The League of Nations was set up in attempt to ensure a revived conflict would not arise. Wilson felt by putting this point into place we can avoid going into war with other nations. Unfortunately, Wilson’s plan failed due to the German Army who built their efforts on the European Western Front. However, within a few months the German Army began peace talks based on his Fourteen Points of
People like Henry Cabot Lodge who was in the Senate fought against the League of Nations and Wilson fought harder by campaigning to people the League of Nations and all of his perks. This was good until Wilson suffered a fatal stroke to where he was bedridden and no longer could speak on his part of the League of Nation. This eventually led to Congress vetoing the League of Nations and diminishing his
During the first world war, there was little support to the league and it resulted in world war two. However, after the war 50 counties have met up to discuss and prevent war to this
Once the United States became stronger and flourished in the western hemisphere, they began to look towards foreign areas of interest to help better the United States. By the turn of the 20th century, the United States had become a minor imperial power, fighting a war with Spain for Cuba and the Philippines and annexing Hawaii and several other territories. World War One brought the United States into European affairs, but after the war, many people were not happy with how many troops were lost and how much money we spent. Many people started to believe in isolationism and people wanted to stay out of foreign affairs. That is why the United States didn’t want to join the League of Nations because it would have brought them into European affairs even more.
Henry Cabot Lodge discussed his opposed opinion on the matter of the League of Nations, “I have always loved one flag and I cannot share that devotion with a mongrel banner created for a League” (Doc H). His opposition only proves that the world is not ready for a change of such magnitude, one which could have helped the situation African Americans were in. However all it ended in was a collapse of one dream that was recreated decades later. A map indicating the Woman suffrage in 1912 shows that most eastern states have achieved it, yet these are only white woman (Doc F). They would not even consider this for African American women because segregation was too prevalent and even though they saw some promise for socially advancing it was overcome with everything going back to the way it was after the war.
Some people agreed and others not so much, with the idea of America becoming a country who would take part in imperialism such as how other European countries were doing so. The people that did not agree with America going through with this then created a type of league which was a group formed to battle the idea on colonizing other countries. This league was named the American Anti-Imperialist League. The overall goal for this group was to help make America realize what type of country they were and how they fought for the same reasons that the Philippines were then fighting for. That America had fought for Independence themselves away from being controlled by a monarchy, why deprive the Philippines from having the same opportunity in creating their own government.
The American people had no desire to join WWII, we had just pulled out of The Great Depression and WWI and we didn't want anymore troubling times. We had lost many American Troops during WWI and we were just recovering from The Great Depression.
After World War I, Wilson came up with an idea which he called the League of Nations. Wilson wanted to create an organization that would help the world maintain peace or to help countries resolve conflicts before they got too out of hand. He asked the leaders of multiple countries, including France, Italy, and Great Britain, to meet and come up with a League of Nations. The League of Nations was successful in solving some issues, but Wilson failed with this idea because America never ended up joining. Many countries also ended up not joining, which meant that they didn’t have to follow the rules that were made by the League of Nations.
The Federalists opposed the Louisiana Purchase because of practical reasons. It increased conflict with American Indians. The Louisiana Purchase was also opposed because of the constitutionality. It was opposed because of the political balance in the new territory. Hamilton states “the territory is not yet populated”.
In 1920, Candidate Warren G. Harding accords a speech about why he opposes joining the League of Nation. Harding also included in his speech that he rejected obligation and how it will threaten America sovereignty (Doc A). Because the public opposes joining the League of Nation, there was no country powerful enough to force Japan to accept by the Kellogg-Briand pact. The Kellogg-Briand pact formally declared aggressive war, banning the use of war as a tool of national policy except only using it for
The reasons did United States foreign policy change between 1920 and 1941 was mainly because of World War II. In the 1920’s, historians have considered the United States to be an isolationist country. Presidential candidate Warren G. Harding said that he opposed the League because it does not correspond with our constitution, even saying it would be a “deadly blow at our constitutional integrity”
His program was an idealistic plan for peace promoting open diplomacy to remove cause for conflict, deal with territorial integrity and endorsed an international peace keeping organisation: The League of Nations. Although the Fourteen Points were imposed on the Treaty of Versailles that ultimately failed it became an important part of the idealistic ideas in Americas Foreign Policy during the 20th Century. The idea behind the League of Nations, which was also unsuccessful, has prevailed, having a lasting impact on modern day society in the United
The League of Nations was an international organization created 1919 by the American president, Woodrow Wilson, as a part of his Fourteen Points. The League was meant to maintain universal peace and resolve international disputes between nations to avoid a repeat of the First World War. The League of Nations had some successes in maintaining universal peace, however, there numerous failures as well. Some of the successes include the Åland Islands crisis and the Upper Silesia incident. Some of the failures of the League include the events that took place in Manchuria and Abyssinia.