ipl-logo

Summary Of Eleonore Stump's Analysis Of Love

907 Words4 Pages

We are boats subject to the tides and currents of our emotions. Strong and powerful emotions have been the ignition fueling countless social movements as well as horrid tragedies. Emotions are as unpredictable as they are complex. Implementing Eleonore Stump’s analysis of love as well as the arguments for eliminating anger by Owen Flanagan and the Stoic philosophers, the new sentient robots should not be given the ability to experience human emotions because of their characteristics of destructiveness and unpredictability.

Eleonore Stump argues that love is the desire for the objective good and union with the beloved. Stump comes to this view by first dissecting the relational, volitional and responsiveness accounts of love. Stump uses the example of Dante Alighieri and Beatrice as proof that the relational account for love is flawed. According to the relational account, Dante Alighieri did not love Beatrice because he had no real relationship with her and only admired her from afar. This unbelievable for Stump, as she believes Dante clearly had strong feelings for Beatrice that are not being measured or acknowledged by the relational account (Stump, 2006). Stump then shifts her focus on the main problem with the volitional account, which is that there is no reason assigned to loving someone. According to the volitional account, love gives us reasons to act, but leaves the cause of love as a mystery. This means that someone could love another person for no clearly defined

Show More
Related

  • What Are The Similarities Between Harrison Bergeron And There Will Come Soft Rains

    847 Words  | 4 Pages

    Compare and Contrast Essay There Will Come Soft Rains and Harrison Bergeron, by Kurt Vonnegut and Ray Bradbury,are both very famous stories written in the science fiction/Dystopian genre. Due to both their eerie foreshadowing for the future, both have a feeling of apprehension over the reader. Even though the both stories have different messages, there are important similarities between how they are shown, and how they relate to everything. With the authors using the settings that they did, it played a key role in setting the tone.

    Read More

  • Journey Of The Hero In Dante's 'La Vita Nuova'

    1268 Words  | 6 Pages

    He had this view of love because to him, love had changed his life completely by him meeting and immediately falling in love with Beatrice. Dante believed that romantic love was going to make him smarter and also make him a better

    Read More

  • Comparing Socrates And Agathon's Speech On The Symposium

    838 Words  | 4 Pages

    Comparing the speeches on The Symposium I will show the role of love based on Plato, Socrates and Diotima in which I believe is to follow a pathway that leads to a state of love that is asexual, unconditional and permanently. I also believe that all philosophers were lovers. Socrates states love can be anything like the simplest need to the deepest form of love like the love of a mother and a son. According to Diotima, when love is perceived is mostly seen as beautiful and good but she argues that love is not either sinister or good rather something in between. She also conveys love is infinite within humans this leaving our trajectories by reproducing.

    Read More

  • Irving Singer The Nature Of Love Analysis

    1231 Words  | 5 Pages

    Irving understands that love is more than a desire to be loved; it explains how love

    Read More

  • Love In Giovanni's Room By James Baldwin

    1693 Words  | 7 Pages

    Giovanni’s Room Love is a funny thing, it doesn’t always turn out the way we want it too and we can’t choose who we love. The main theme of James Baldwin’s story “Giovanni’s Room” is that love is difficult, scary, and not always what you expect. Although many people thrive on the love they feel for someone, David finds it to be a terrifying and confusing thing. In “Giovanni’s Room” David is reflecting on how he found love when he less expected it and was afraid, saddened, and even a little ashamed by it.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Sarah Cole A Type Of Love Story

    1494 Words  | 6 Pages

    We live in a society that has increasingly demoralizes love, depicting it as cruel, superficial and full of complications. Nowadays it is easy for people to claim that they are in love, even when their actions say otherwise, and it is just as easy to claim that they are not when they indeed are. Real love is difficult to find and keeping it alive is even harder, especially when one must overcome their own anxieties and uncertainties to embrace its presence. This is the main theme depicted in Russell Banks’ short story “Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story,” as well as in Richard Bausch’s “The Fireman’s Wife.” These narratives, although similar in some ways, are completely different types of love stories.

    Read More

  • Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep Analysis

    387 Words  | 2 Pages

    These emotions are programmed in the androids and are not

    Read More

  • Love In Flannery O Connor's Good Country People

    890 Words  | 4 Pages

    There are many things that factor into reasons for loving someone. Often times when people think of reasons for loving someone, they only think about the immediate motives. People do not consider reasons outside the obvious. However, there are many hidden motives that cause people t love one another. Flannery O’Connor’s “Good Country People” and William Shakespeare’s “My Mistress’ Eyes Are Nothing Like the Sun”, show that love can be influenced by an ulterior motive, through the use of specific word choice and storyline twists.

    Read More

  • Free Will In The Inferno Canto V Danus Victis

    1509 Words  | 7 Pages

    It is shown in this line how Dante perceives love and how it serves as a moving force that will be difficult to resist. It is seen in Francesca’s narration how she sees herself as a resistant victim of love and how love brought Paolo and her to hell. “Took hold of him because of the fair

    Read More

  • Clancy Merton The Symposium Summary

    919 Words  | 4 Pages

    His past experiences has led him to believe that love should be masked by lies that in a sense it should the truth should be a voluntary definition behind love. In Plato’s Symposium, Aristophanes’ delivers a speech about his experiences of have loved or being in love. Aristophanes’ speech captures how powerful the feeling of love, that since birth love has condition our lives involuntary and will remain so. Love to Aristophanes’ is a form of completion that a lucky couple receives once the meet each other. This completion is empowered by an enormous amount of love, intimacy, and affection that neither bonds can be separated.

    Read More

  • A Brave New World Essay: Truth And Happiness

    427 Words  | 2 Pages

    While these emotions give people great happiness and attachment, these also can cause grief, sadness, and anguish. In the “Brave New World,” people have sexual relationships for pleasure, although they never have relationships with emotions as it is considered abnormal to feel an attachment or love for someone. Marriages and families are non-existent (Huxley 60). Scientific truth includes discoveries, the beauty of language and conclusions made from experiences. These truths are sacrificed for happiness.

    Read More

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of The Robot Invasion

    616 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout history, the human has always envisioned living a lifestyle where chores were considered as a part of the past. With the development of humanoids and androids robots in the 1950’s, chores were really becoming part of the past. Therefore, because robots were able to adapt and meet the needs and wants of humans. As a result, we started to see an increase in both the use and production of robots in factories and households. In the article “The Robot Invasion” the author Charlie Gills, is really able to convey the relevance and effectiveness of a robot through the use of the tone, purpose, and credibility.

    Read More

  • Outside Influence In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    Love is inevitable. You can't choose who to fall in love with. What would you have done if the person you loved appeared to be dead? Sure, you could move on and live your life. But to Romeo and Juliet, they were each others life.

    Read More

  • Women In Dante's Divine Comedy

    1662 Words  | 7 Pages

    Moreover, he also states “the loveliness that I say not only surpassed our human measure… and only the Maker can enjoy it fully” (). This shows that Dante places Beatrice’s beauty beyond the level of human nature and supports this by saying it can only by enjoyed by the “Maker,” which is the God. Thus, Francesca and Paolo’s love is purely shallow; while Dante and Beatrice’s love is the quite opposite; it is a divine love, in which Dante concentrates on the emotional and spiritual aspects of

    Read More

  • The Role Of Courtly Love In Medieval Literature

    839 Words  | 4 Pages

    Some believed that the constant admiration for St. Bernard of Clairvaux or the Virgin Mary prompted the creation of the courtly love ideal. But courtly love works have been created even before the popularity of St. Bernard and there were hardly any courtly love works that directly praised the Virgin Mary. Additionally, loving God varies from loving someone because doubts or uncertainties could still occur when loving another person unlike loving God. Lewis also mentioned that the church does not focus on the passionate kind of love which was prevalent in most courtly love poems. Courtly love works focused more on either the physical or emotional aspect of love rather than a spiritual or virtuous kind of love.

    Read More

More about Summary Of Eleonore Stump's Analysis Of Love

Open Document