In the book Evicted by Matthew Desmond, numerous accounts of tenants being evicted and the consequences of said evictions are depicted for the reader. As is seen throughout the book, the landlords, or the better off, upper class people in the book are the ones who benefit from the eviction process and the eviction itself, not the tenants who represent the lower classes. For the tenants, the eviction process becomes a way to further dig themselves into poverty and inequality and makes it harder for them to have a level playing field when they attempt to have a fresh start. For the landlord, tenants are seen as a dime a dozen, so the landowners are able to dictate how much the tenants owe and how much their manual labor earns them to pay their …show more content…
Most of these soon-to-be-evicted tenants never bother showing up to the court date for eviction court, but when the tenants do, the verdict never goes their way; as Desmond states in Evicted, the day turns out one of two ways: the landlord and the tenant work out a deal, which typically always includes stipulations, like a “$55 late fee” (Desmond, p. 96) and the landlord demanding for more money, thus dissolving the eviction, or in Arleen’s case, the eviction going through with added on money judgements that “carry consequences for tenants” that can “suddenly reappear in tenants’ lives several years after the eviction” with an “annual rate that would be the envy of any financial portfolio: 12 percent” (Desmond, p.103). The formal eviction process with the added on money judgements that are docketed on to a tenant’s credit perpetuate inequality in that the judgements punish these tenants only when they start to be doing better and begin to have credit. The money judgements come back at the tenant with a vengeance because of the high interest rate of twelve percent, which is a very high annual interest rate, making it hard to pay rent and survive on top of having to pay interest from a time when the tenant was worse off than they are now. Having the money judgement …show more content…
The book uses specific examples to show that the pricing of the units and lack of resources available to those of the lower class furthers inequality; the pricing and lack of resources results in a staggering amount of evictions that take place because these people are unable to keep up with the price of a place to live when there is no financial help available to them, which is not the case with the upper class, who have approximately the same or slightly higher rent, but way more means to gain money to pay that rent, thus resulting in the upper class tenants having fewer evictions on their record. The book also demonstrates how the formal eviction process makes it impossible for the lower class to create for themselves a fresh start because of the inclusion of docketed judgments that come back to haunt the previously evicted tenants at times when all is going well for them. Through these two aspects of forced evictions and never ending sanctions for obtaining an eviction, inequality is maintained and perpetuated for the lower class
Evicted by Matthew Desmond is a novel that tells the stories of families struggling to pay the rent in the city of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. In this book, just like Missoula, the stories are intertwined with each other. So far the stories have followed two landlords: Sherrena Tarver and Tobin Charney. Sheerena owns property all over the predominantly black north side of Milwaukee. She is strong and caring, but I think she is not fair to her tenants.
Their “large rooms were partitioned into several smaller ones, without regard to light or ventilation, the rate of rent being lower in proportion to space or height from the street; and they soon became filled from cellar to garret with a class of tenantry living from hand to mouth, loose in morals, improvident in habits, degraded, and squalid as beggary itself. ”(Riis 63-64) With Jacob Riis’s descriptive choice of words you could essentially vision the tenants that were many lived in the city. Crammed in spaces where two families could comfortably live in, ten families would live there instead.
“The Czar of all the Russias is not more absolute upon his own soil than the New York landlord in his dealings with colored tenants. Where he permits them to live, they go; where he shuts the door, stay out.” (Riis 148). By saying that, Riis said that the landlord has complete control over where the blacks live. The average African-American paid $10 to every white man’s $7.50.
Matthew Desmond, in his book Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City, writes about the destitution that the American society is facing with astounding specificity yet without any judgement or voyeurism. Several themes health issues can be inferred either directly or indirectly from the book. These are listed below 1. Despair According to Desmond, being evicted forces families to seek shelter on the streets, or even being forced to move into dilapidated and uninhibited houses.
The rising cost of housing in the bay area has made affordable housing harder and harder to come about. This is a situation where the city of Palo Alto does not have enough affordable housing to meet the needs of its population. To fix the situation instead of creating additional affordable housing venues is sticking the Jissers with the bill of providing affordable housing. The reason I chose this article is that it shows that the “system” doesn't work neither the Jissers are at fault nor are the tenants. This is a situation where the city of Palo Alto messed up and now are trying to pen the blame on some private
Matthew Desmond’s book Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City, reveals the dire reality of renting leading to evictions and poverty by telling the stories of multiple people. There are multiple issues within this topic that Desmond focuses on such as discrimination. Desmond tells the stories of people from different backgrounds, of different genders, and of different races. The book is all about poverty, human nature, human relationships, and human hopes. Due to the nature of this book, it is crucial that the events are examined through a socio-cultural lens.
State-led gentrification refers to the process where policies and initatives driven by the government facilitate gentrification, which of is seen as a widespread contovisal topic within the modern sustain society. This generayes the process of urban development, where lower income neighbourhoods undergo considerable change to create more of a appeal towards those of a middle and high income society. This process implemented by the government as a urban ‘renewal’ transformation causes an inflow of wealthier new residents to move in at the cost of evictioning existing residents in the area demonstrating the impacts surrounding the use of state-led gentrification. This essay will critically assess and evulate the impacts of state-led gentrification
For major social issues like racism and homelessness they are very hard to solve. Many times they are just being managed and not solved. Sometimes it’s easier to just manage an issue and keep pushing it away for a later time, until it starts being a big problem and costing society a lot of money. Like racism they try to manage it by having separate but equal, but it is still racist. Martin Luther King Jr fought for civil rights for many year, he used peaceful protest for his cause.
Wealth is one of the factors why residential segregation is an increasing problem. Golash- Boza explains, “Residential segregation happened when different groups of people are sorted into discount neighborhoods” (271). It is because of housing segregation
Gentrification is the process of renovating and improving a house or district so that it conforms to middle-class taste. Real Estate investors usually take low-income places that they feel have a chance to prosper economically, and turn them into areas that attract the middle and upper class workers. In doing so they feel like the low-income areas will be safer and more appealing, attracting more people to visit and live there. An improvement to a poor district sounds beautiful, but is gentrification as great as it’s sought out to be? Many residents have their doubts about gentrification due to the idea that the costs of their living will go up and they will be driven out of their neighborhoods.
This way can be proven by an example of Miss Ellen Collins who owned three Water Street houses. Her first task was to allow light in which caused the piles of trash by the sick to vanish and some of the most stubborn tenants. The tenants who stayed abided by the new rules that were set. Collins’ tenants were some of the poorest out there and she did it as an experiment between tenant and landlord. She even lowered the rent as low as possible to still be making a reasonable profit to still be considered successful.
Homelessness is a product of social inequalities. Karl Marx stated that the capitalist society produces two prominent classes which are in conflict with each other, bourgeoisie and proletariats. The bourgeoisie are the oppressors who own the means of production and the proletariats are the oppressed workers who labor for the bourgeoisie. Capitalism is distinguished not by privilege but instead by individuality of property ownership and that those who create the conditions of the oppressed group express this power in the form of laws that function to serve the bourgeoisie’s interests (Marx, 2004, p.129).
Matthew Desmond’s Evicted takes a sociological approach to understanding the low-income housing system by following eight families as they struggle for residential stability. The novel also features two landlords of the families, giving the audience both sides and allowing them to make their own conclusions. Desmond goes to great lengths to make the story accessible to all classes and races, but it seems to especially resonate with people who can relate to the book’s subjects or who are liberals in sound socioeconomic standing. With this novel, Desmond hopes to highlight the fundamental structural and cultural problems in the evictions of poor families, while putting faces to the housing crisis. Through the lens of the social reproduction theory, Desmond argues in Evicted that evictions are not an effect of poverty, but rather, a cause of it.
The relationship between society and the law is direct, and housing in America is a conclusive example of that. As argued by both authors, once society has made up its mind about a certain group of people or place such as the ghettos, even the law can’t change those facts. It often happens that people of color and minorities get overlooked and stereotyped into something that they are not due to the hierarchical and discriminatory principles of the law. It has been engrained into society to think that minorities are poor, lazy, and overall less productive in the public
(Homelessnessaustralia, 2015. Although the Federal government does provide supported accommodation, there is simply not enough (Homelessness in Australia 2012). While Australia is still considered a rich country, if there is a large inequality between social classes it could harm the country’s economic prosperity. Further increasing the gap making more Australian’s at risk of experiencing financial difficulties (Holmes, D.