“No two persons read the same book ever” (Edmund Wilson). The way people comprehend books can vary from person to person. Some may be offended by it’s contents, but others may think it’s completely appropriate. The Marbury Lens by Andrew Smith, has had the same reaction.When Andrew Smith was writing this book, he was trying to get fired. He intentionally wrote this book so gorey. According to The Young Adults Library Services, a young adult is a person between the ages of twelve and eighteen. Some publishers will market young adult novels to ages as low as ten up to twenty-five. The book contains rape, violence, sex, addiction, and drugs. Things that may not be appropriate for twelve-year-olds to read. Although The Marbury Lens can bring awareness to certain situations, it is not appropriate that it is labeled as a young adult novel because of the gruesome descriptions and the actions the characters take part in throughout the book. The labeling of The Marbury Lens as a young adult novel is inappropropriate because of the promotion of underage drinking. “Hey Jack, want a beer?” The kid who was peeing next to me pulled a can of beer from his pocket. “Sure.” I took the beer and walked across the lawn, …show more content…
The promotion of underage drinking, the descriptive details of violence, and the sexual content in the book makes it highly inappropriate. The majority of young adults are not prepared to handle the situations mentioned in the novel. Most parents try their hardest to protect their children from these settings. Exposing young adults to these situations can result in problems because they are not emotionally mature. Society needs to be more sensitive to how this material can negatively affect a young person's development. In Andrew Smith’s attempt to get fired, by glorifying these issues to young adults, he has illustrated how truly inappropriate these topics are for
People’s opinions are stating that the book promotes disrespect towards parents and adults. The book will also give them many misbeliefs in the fantasy
In the text it said “gets off the boat, a pack of huskies violently attacks and kills her.” This proves that teens shouldn’t read “The Call of The Wild” because it has killing. If people complain of a book they should ban it. In the text it said “Mother of an 11th grader complained that the novel was too much for teenagers.” If parents are complaining they know that it's not right for teenagers to read it and it need to get banned.
In Ray Bradbury’s dystopian Fahrenheit 451, Guy Montag experiences a paradigm shift as he transforms from a disoriented fireman to a learner who wants to gain knowledge through literature. Montag struggles with his newfound fascination with what was once trivial items because of his inability to ask questions under the bonds of conformity. However, the society prohibits people from reading for fear that they would express individuality and perhaps even rebel once they gain knowledge. Through the use of characterization and diction, the Bradbury demonstrates Montag’s desire for individuality and the society’s command of conformity in order to build a suspenseful mood, which keeps the reader’s interest. First, through the use of characterization,
All books that young adults read have power. Their power results in their ability to sway and to change the reader in so many ways, not the least of these is morally. These books can create a moral sense in the young by demonstrating what is morally right and what is morally wrong. They can raise and resolve ethical issues. The reader may not agree with each resolution, but is certainly forced to think about issues he or she may never have thought about before (Smith 63).
“The state of kids publishing is such that it’s perfectly reasonable to be concerned about what agenda-driven and/or prurient content they’re peddling.” (Hemingway) This means it is very reasonable for everyone to be concerned about what the kids and young adults are reading. If parents are not concerned about what their child is reading, their child will follow many bad influences from books they have read. There are many influential books such as The Outsiders, by S.E Hinton that should be banned.
“I look at books as being a form of activism because a lot of times they’ll show us a side of the world that we may not have known about” (Angie Thomas). Fiction is not castles, and dragons that are slayed by knights anymore; as children become young adolescents the stories that nurtured their innocence matures and starts to question societal issues. “The Hate U Give” by Angie Thomas talked about the racial injustice and police brutality that specifically African-Americans face in their day-to-day life. Starr, a main character, witness her childhood friend, Khalil, get murdered by a white policemen who pulled them over for a broken taillight and later shot Khalil in the back 3 times because he “feared for his life”. Angie Thomas not only explained
Gatlin Farrington 12/1 P.4 Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury is an excellent utopian/dystopian fictional story about a man who fights for the freedom to read. The government in this world has made almost every book (with a few exceptions) illegal. They have done this due to the contradictory ideas found in them. It was thought that all of the contradictions might confuse citizens on what is the truth and what isn’t.
No piece of literature should ever be ban : Of Mice and Men should not be ban from young adults and libraries. The literature classic promotes good life lessons for students to learn from such as friendship and motivation. Simply banning the book would contradict the right of free press under the first amendment of the constitutions. The book also provides a considerable amount of historical context. Even though the book contains a tremendous amount of racism , sexism , and vulgar language , in today’s media , we are exposed to a similar content.
“The Outsiders” is a novel written by S.E. Hinton. Originally Published in 1967, Hinton was only 18 when her novel hit the shelves. Instead of using her real name Susan Eloise Hinton, she used her initial’s so people wouldn’t know she was a girl making the book less desirable. The Outsiders is considered a cult classic and is typically assigned reading across the U.S. She always loved reading but did not like the books they had for young adults
A parent or the student should be the one who decided whether or not the book is appropriate. Also, when a child is sheltered from the world, a book with just a bit of adult material could help them understand what really happens. It could prepare them so when they do become older and get a job, the world doesn’t put them into complete shock. Taken from Common Reasons for Banning Books, “…it is important that the reader makes his/her judgments on the book.” To elaborate on this, another person shouldn’t tell a student what and what not to read.
Others have decided not to ban it, because of the first amendment. Although banning Fahrenheit 451 would be an infringement on the author's right to speak freely, the long-lasting mental and physical devastation to the children reading this book that arises as a result of
Shall I start with the boy’s chapter, then move toward more ‘mature’ tragic conclusions? But that would underplay the boy’s wisdom. The middle-aged
In 1998, McClintock High School in Tempe, Arizona assigned students to read The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. The book has long been regarded as a controversial novel, and each generation that comes upon it has found something that rubs against the current societal norms. The mother of a student at McClintock took serious offense to the use of the word, “nigger” throughout the book and protested that it be banned due to the racial discrimination (Source I). Huck Finn is just one of the many pieces of literature that have been labelled “challenging,” and many feel that they do not deserve a place in schools’ curriculum. However, the study of challenging literature introduces students to new ideas and lessons that they can apply
It is unsuited for school age group. Besides, this book uses offensive words such as fuck, asshole, nigger and pussy etc. For example, in the book Arnold admits about masturbation “If there were a Professional Masturbator League, I’d get drafted number one and make millions of dollars” (Alexie 26). For this reason, the book is not appropriate for middle schools. For children, they are not capable enough to absorb these kinds of information from the book.
To some people it is not. Some teachers say that the book is challenging for students. Now, this novel may be difficult for students, but that is how students learn new information. If students weren’t to have read harder pieces of literature all throughout their schooling career, they would stay at the same level of reading for most of their life. The reason why students should read more challenging novels are because they learn new things, and they could also learn how to act in a certain situation based on the type of challenging story they read.