Was Thomas Jefferson a Man of his Word? Thomas Jefferson was the third president of the United States, a helper in writing the Constitution and the U.S ambassador to France. Jefferson was responsible for U.S successes such as the Lousianna purchase, but did he follow through on all of his promises? Thomas Jefferson, who was loved by many, was not a man of his word. Jefferson’s writing and words were not always followed through by his actions.
In 1787 in a letter to Edward Rutledge Jefferson writes, “"I congratulate you, my dear friend, on the law of your state [South Carolina] for suspending the importation of slaves, and for the glory you have justly acquired by endeavoring to prevent it forever,” Congratulating his friend on the abolishing
…show more content…
As a Democratic-Republican, Jefferson believed that the Constitution should be interpreted strictly. Jefferson also believed in more of a “power to the people government.” Jefferson wrote this about government power in 1791. “I consider the foundation of the Constitution that 'all powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States or to the people.' [the 10th Amendment] To take a single step beyond these boundaries, is to take possession of a boundless field of power.” The government should not do things that are not explicitly stated as a power they possess. The Louisiana Purchase was actually a direct violation of the 10th Amendment. Despite Jefferson's desire to never violate the Constitution, it seemed he had crossed his own line. According to the 10th Amendment, the government cannot be granted powers not delegated to it by the Constitution and nowhere is it stated in the Constitution that the president has the ability to purchase land from foreign powers. Jefferson knew this was an amendment to the Constitution. However, he directly violated it by buying land from the French. Jefferson did not follow through with the things he said and
In 1803, Thomas Jefferson made the most controversial purchase regrading to the constitution. The Louisiana Purchase went against everything Jefferson believed in. Jefferson faced heat from both parties whether it was to accept or that he will be a hypocrite for accepting it. With this purchase Jefferson made the best decision of his time because of all the benefits the land gave the country. Thomas Jefferson was the direct definition of an anti-federalist.
When purchasing the Louisiana Territory, President Jefferson faced the risk of being prosecuted for violation of the Constitution, which was different from Hamilton’s creation of a national bank because it was illegal. To begin, after the French acquired the Louisiana Territory 1802, Jefferson worried that the French would no longer allow American farmers passage on the Mississippi River or the right to trade at New Orleans, so he sent Robert Livingston to France to negotiate to purchase New Orleans. When Livingston arrived, he was surprised by France’s offer to sell the US the entire Louisiana Territory for just 15 million dollars. Livingston knew he was not authorized to purchase the territory but he also knew that if he waited to ask Congress, the deal might be gone already, so he purchased the territory.
Yet, Jefferson violated the acts of Sedition and the federalist’s Alien. By accomplishing the Louisiana Purchase, Jefferson, overturned his principles against strict interpretation of powers. The agreement was not precisely listed as a direct right of the federal government in the Constitution. Violating his constitutional principles, Jefferson indicated that the Constitution would accept the purchase of new territories, and the creation of newly acquired territories as conclusive states, and he also used a certain perspective of the executive branches powers by using the President and the Senate’s power to accept the deal together without the need of Congress’s approval.
This purchase was also against Jefferson's beliefs as it involved treaties and circumventing the Constitution.
With the belief that it came from him they got fearful that French could take control of the Louisiana Territory. Now with bringing to happen Jefferson had to do something because that could be a big problem in the future. What Jefferson did was he had to send two of his people to France. They
I agree with the view that the Louisiana Purchase of 1803 contradicts Jefferson’s stance on not granting the federal government too much power because in fact, the purchase of this vast territory by the government did give federal authorities more power than was acceptable to the people. Additionally, purchasing new land was not stated in the Constitution; therefore, government did not have the right to take this course of action. As stated in “Jeffersonian Ideology” from Jefferson’s point of view: “Limiting the federal government flowed from his strict interpretation of the Constitution.” Jefferson had always been known to make strict interpretations of the federal government’s powers, but because of his desire to acquire new land in the
Was Thomas Jefferson a Hypocrite? “No man will ever carry out the Presidency the same reputation which earned him into it.” Thomas Jefferson was not a hypocrite, and his actions show it. He stuck to his beliefs throughout all two terms of his Presidency. Jefferson acted as a common man, helped educate the less fortunate, and made the government smaller while reducing the debt.
Thomas Jefferson, strict constructionist? One of our most contributing founding fathers, Thomas Jefferson, once stated that “A Bill of Rights is what the people are entitled to against every government, and what no just government should refuse, or rest on interference.” This clearly implies that he’s a man of the people. Although he thought a “president above parties” was the way to go or that “we are all republicans--- we are all federalists” he was sure enough an Anti-Federalist, by far, between the mid 1700s.
Thomas Jefferson was a founding father and the third president of the United States. He is an important part of American history and most people have a positive image of him. Jefferson’s Notes on the State of Virginia provides an instant shock to the reader by revealing a very negative side of the third president of the United States. In this work, he is very detailed in providing a undesirable description of the characteristics of African-Americans. His choice of words makes it easy to see how African-Americans and people in general could be offended by reading this part of his work.
However, later on, when Thomas Jefferson becomes President he abolishes the Alien and Sedition Acts. In addition, according to Document 4, it states "I informed the Indians inhabiting parts of Georgia and Alabama that their attempt to establish an independent government would not be allowed by the Executive of the U.S, and advised to emigrate beyond the Mississippi..." This shows how the early Presidents didn't have a positive outcome on the people since President Andrew Jackson decided to move the Native Americans out of their homelands which wasn't fair because in a way they were still people of the United States. However, he was trying to protect Native Americans from
Also, The purchase was nearly canceled by Congress and only passed by a vote of 59-57. And, Thomas Jefferson wanted to buy the settlement of New Orleans from the French. It was a major seaport
Many of those in the Federalist party (the opposing party to Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans) believed that he would have objected on Constitutional
I believe that Thomas Jefferson did the right thing even though he might have thought it went against the constitution. I also believe that if an offer comes up that you cannot refuse then you need to take it no matter what the consequences. The rest will work its self out. In 1803, Thomas Jefferson took the offer and bought the Louisiana
Thomas Jefferson postulated in the Declaration of Independence that slavery was inhuman yet was a callous hypocrite that treated his slaves brutally. Moreover, Jefferson asserted to Edward Rutledge, former governor of South Carolina, “I congratulate you… on the law of your state for suspending the importation of slaves… There is a bench reserved in heaven for those who hasten [slavery].” ( Jefferson letter to Rutledge: 1787, July 14). Jefferson incorporates religious beliefs into his letter to amplify the gravity of the situation similar to recent historical events such as the Salem witch trials which leveraged off of the skewed perception of religion.
Jefferson’s dilemma in the Louisiana Purchase In April of 1803 Thomas Jefferson was faced with many moral dilemmas in the process of buying the Louisiana territory. Though the price for the territory was beyond generous, Jefferson felt that by purchasing the territory he would be going against his beliefs that the constitution should be followed word for word. The constitution said nothing of the president having the power to purchase land from another government, or to use money of the states for the same purpose (“the moral dilemma”). Another problem was once the land was purchased, there was a fear that it could have been a waste since they had no way to know the layout of the land, and what it would be useful for.