From 1860-1900, America underwent hundreds of different social, cultural, religious, and political changes that forever shaped how the nation will be. Westward expansion played a huge role of how the country ran, and how thousands of Indigenous lives were treated. The effects of American westward expansion on Native Americans were negative, as Native Americans were forced to experience assimilation, injustice, dehumanization. To start, assimilation was a huge part of America, as hundreds of thousands of Native Americans were forced to assimilate to white culture, for the ideal American society. As one can see in document 6, A commissioner of Indian Affairs emphasizes the ‘issue’ with Native American culture, as well as being “ignorant” of …show more content…
Due to westward expansion, the need for American culture to be one destroyed hundreds of Native American lives, and many innocent lives were taken. The point of view of the speaker of this document is T.J. Morgan, a white man, which is significant considering how many white Americans had a mindset that Native American culture was a threat to having a successful and ideal society. Civilizing and assimilating Native American culture was thought to protect America and its people from corruption by white people, however, it ended up forcing thousands of Indigenous people to go through endless torture. Nonetheless, as one can see in document 7, one can see the disgusting efforts of white Americans to assimilate Native American culture, the scissors wanting to cut Natives’ hair, taking the land from Indigenous people, and white Americans …show more content…
Indigenous people were lied to constantly, given false promises, and false hope. Document 3 emphasizes this, Chief Joseph, leader of the Nez Perce, mentioning how “Good words do not last long,” and ,”Nothing is done.” The perspective of this document is significant considering how a chief of an Indigenous tribe speaks up about the injustice done to his people and dozens of other tribes as well. Native Americans were taken advantage of during westward expansion, their land forcefully taken from them and are treated inhumanely. Westward expansion caused for unjust treatment towards Indigenous people, they were given false hope of a country that would be better, however, their homes and people were taken away. Westward expansion will forever be a reminder of the horrors Native Americans endured for the sake of the country that never treated them justly to begin with. Likewise, one can see in document 5 the population of buffalo from 1800-1889, how it decreased drastically after the beginning of westward expansion. This elucidates that not only were Native Americans dealt with unjustly, but so were that which they held dear were dealt unjustly too. An important part of Native American culture revolved around the animals they would take care of, use for resources, and be apart of their daily lives. However, when westward expansion took place, Native Americans were not considered for, nor what they
The US’s treatment of native tribes emphasized their inferiority to white America, denying the founding value of equality. The Declaration of Independence states, “all men are created equal.” Unfortunately, the US did not uphold this value with its relations with
Westward Expansion: Impact of Natives Thesis Statement: Due to the taking of land and resources, Americans treated the Natives negatively during the Westward Expansion When watching the recent movie ‘The Revenant’, audiences wonder what the message of the story or the theme. Setting up in the 18th century it follows a man (Hugh Glass) that was helping the Americans collect game in exchange for money. He was taken in because he knows the language and land of the Native Americans, due to his wife and child being part of the culture of Indians. Natives were killed for defending their land and keeping the White men from claiming it. The movie also shows the violence directed toward the Native Americans such as the rape of the women.
For many years now history has been shown from one perspective, the winning side. For Example, Neither Wolf nor Dog by Kent Nerburn discusses the hardship the Native Americans suffered during the westward expansion. Most people only know it through the U.S. government’s view and not the people affected by it. The book gives a first-hand story about what happened and how the Native Americans felt about the movement. When reading the book, many people find something different about what they learned and see that looking through both perspectives will help them understand what actually happened.
First Semester Research Paper During the 19th century, there was a period of time where white settlers in the United States thought expanding throughout all of North America was justified. The Americans also thought it was their divine right to expand and that it was inevitable. This is just another instance where the Americans took the Native Americans for granted. The Native Americans shouldn 't have been kicked out because they had nowhere else to go, the settlers had peace treaties with the tribes and the reasons for pushing them out were illogical.
The white men went onto the Indians land, lied to them, stole land, and treated the Indians and tribes like animals. This is pretty much how the westward expansion happened. “A true story of westward expansion would be the account of actions, thoughts, emotions, words, and persons of the unnamed thousands, the people on the ground, who are the living flesh and blood of history.” (Morgan paragraph 6 line1) The true story of westward expansion was never truly told.
After the Civil War in the 1860s, there were Indian policies put in place to exterminate Native Americans and remove them from their homelands. The idea to “kill the Indian, save the man” was a common ideal that was believed during this time. The racial discrepancies established between white versus Indian, led to the killing of indigenous Americans, and relocation to reservations. These reservations were the significantly smaller pieces of land Native Americans were allowed to have. The reservations are a result of forceful migration which only occurred because of the choehold Manifest Destiny had on white Americans.
The United States wanted the Indians to conform and assimilate, “Because of these purchases of Indian land, it is our duty to make new efforts for the preservation, improvement & civilization of the native inhabitants… For the earth was given to mankind to support the greatest number of which it is capable,... ”(President Monroe, First Annual Message to Congress, 1817). The United States had been trying to civilise and assimilate Indians since the first prayer towns in the English colonies. We see this view changing in 1802 when Jackson addresses the attempts to civilize the Indians “It has long been the policy of the government to introduce among them the arts of civilization, in the hopes of gradually reclaiming them from a wandering life.
The information you showcase regarding the United States’ movement westward is very intuitive. Additionally, the information you showcase about the massacre of the Native American people during westward expansion is something that people often avoid discussing. Furthermore, the information regarding the governments’ incentive packages for moving west highlights how desperate the United States is to settle the new land. Now, consider that the military massacred hundreds of Native Americans, do you believe that those men should have stood trial for war crimes? Also, do you believe the government’s incentive packages are a contributing factor to settler’s clashes with Native Americans?
During the expansion of the West there was confrontation between the Whites and Native Americans. The white men believed that the removal of Native Americans was crucial to develop the America they imagined. To “Americanize” the Native Americans they were placed in a form of “concentration camps”. In these camps their hair was cut, not allowed to wear traditional dress, and they were not allowed to call one another by their Native names.
Indians had already, for them, been a nusiance and with many more Americans moving westward it was almost inevitable what they were going to do to them. Power hungry and land hungry people began pushing and pushing until finally many Natives broke. Many packed up and head westward without a problem, wanting to avoid any sort of conflict, many took in upon them selves to leave before things got to ugly. Others waited, signed treaties, and got manipulated into leaving as the whites kept on pushing. Others fought, eventually, as those whites that were power hungry, completly
One group affected by the westward expansion was Native Americans. As whites flooded into this “new” land there were about forty Americans to every one Native American. This became problematic because as the majority, the white population wished for control over all indigenous land. Whites worked to assimilate native tribes resulting in little space for Native Americans who refused to assimilate and a common hatred toward white people. The Native people yearned for the children to read and write but did not want their kids to be assimilated into European American culture.
America in the 1830’s was bigger than it had ever been, and expansion was just beginning. Americans were packing up their belongings and moving west to start new states, new cities and new lives for their families. Thomas Jefferson’s idea of Manifest Destiny was truly coming to light but sadly, it came at the expense of the many Native American tribes. Following the Indian Removal Act of 1830 that was signed by the current President Andrew Jackson, many Native American tribes living in what was now southeast America, were forced to leave their homes and migrate west. The removal of these tribes left more land for white Americans to settle in without the threat of attacks from Native tribes.
The letter written by Henry Dearborn addressed to Callender Irvine in 1803 stated, “policy encouraged Indians to adopt white American customs and economic practices.” It shows that some of the Native Americans that the U.S. government tried
As westward expansion con- tinued, white settlers forced Native tribes off their land, resulting in the Trail of Tears and many other forced migrations. The result for Native countries was long-lasting and detrimental as their homes were lost, and cultural traditions were disrupted or lost. The consequences of Manifest Destiny's negative effects represented an unsustainable approach to westward expansion, with Native Americans paying the ultimate price. As historian Frederick Jackson Turner writes in his essay "The Significance of the Frontier in American History," “the most powerful agent in shaping the American character and American institutions” was the “struggle with the wilderness” that led to westward expansion. However, this progress came at a great expense to indigenous people, a cost that cannot be
Throughout the 19th century Native Americans were treated far less than respectful by the United States’ government. This was the time when the United States wanted to expand and grow rapidly as a land, and to achieve this goal, the Native Americans were “pushed” westward. It was a memorable and tricky time in the Natives’ history, and the US government made many treatments with the Native Americans, making big changes on the Indian nation. Native Americans wanted to live peacefully with the white men, but the result of treatments and agreements was not quite peaceful. This precedent of mistreatment of minorities began with Andrew Jackson’s indian removal policies to the tribes of Oklahoma (specifically the Cherokee indians) in 1829 because of the lack of respect given to the indians during the removal laws.