ipl-logo

Robert Hall's To Blame In Into Thin Air

692 Words3 Pages

The book Into Thin Air is a book that outlines the Mount Everest disaster, as factually correct it can. However, there is a person that is too blame for this disaster to happen. The main person responsible for the deaths of the Mount Everest disaster was Robert Hall. However, that does not mean Robert Hall was the only one at fault. Ultimately the blame falls on Ang Dorje, Robert Hall, and Ian Woodall, each for their own reasons, and ultimately Hall, and Fisher were responsible for the others. Robert Hall is the one most responsible for deaths of those that died in the Mount Everest Disaster. One of the reasons that is, is that he was paid to keep them safe. “We guarantee the maximise the safety and success of your adventure (37).” Although he does say we agree to maximise safety, maximise being the keyword, he does …show more content…

This is because, in the end, the two guides were not careful or safe, each for their own reasons. “Likewise since he had failed to get anybody to the top in 1995, it would have been bad for Hall’s business if he failed again in 1996-- especially if Fisher succeeded(285).” This is Hall’s reason for pushing forward, the fact that it would be bad for his business if he didn’t keep on pushing forward, especially since he “was charging $65,000 a head to guide clients to the top of the world(37).” Fisher's reason was that “Fisher had never guided Everest before 1996. From a business standpoint, there was a lot of pressure on him to be successful(285).” Fisher needed to get his clients up to the summit because it would make his business look good and that would make others come to him for business instead of Hall, and because of this, that is what the two to keep on pushing for the summit even though they shouldn’t have because it wouldn’t have been

Show More
Related

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of Into Thin Air By Jon Krakauer

    299 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the article “Anatoli Boukreev (Responds to Krakauer)”, Boukreev argues against author Jon Krakauer and his initial allegations in his article “Into Thin Air”, which was published in the September 1996 issue of Outside Magazine. He claims that he was more than qualified to guide groups of paying clients to summit Mount Everest. This is due to his extensive experience in doing exactly that. For example, he has conquered a grand total of 22 mountains in more than twenty years. He has climbed all 22 of these without the assistance of any sort of supplementary oxygen.

    Read More

  • Climbers In Into Thin Air

    1249 Words  | 5 Pages

    For as long as anyone can remember, people have dreamed of reaching the summit of Mt. Everest. During May of 1996, an expedition set out to Nepal to attempt a climb up Mt. Everest. By the end of this expedition to the top of Everest, many climbers lost their lives due to the brutal weather. In Jon Krakauer’s novel Into Thin Air, he takes readers through the story of the expedition, and he talks about the climbers who died. Among the list of the dead was a man named Doug Hansen.

    Read More

  • The Life Of Another In Jon Krakauer´s Into Thin Air

    241 Words  | 1 Pages

    There are people in life who crave thrill and adventure; who feel their life is missing something. Some people choose to climb Everest to fulfill this. Desperate to summit, to experience a view beyond words, people risk their lives to get a sneak peek at the top of the world. Although Everest is the world’s highest mountain, it is also the world’s highest open grave. In Jon Krakauer 's Into Thin Air, eight climbers lose their lives; the most dead in one year.

    Read More

  • Into Thin Air Essay

    607 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many things could go wrong climbing the highest mountain in the world with an elevation of 29,029 ft. 12 people died climbing Mount Everest. No is responsible for those death. The climbers had chosen to climb the mountain. In the novel it states, “Hall was charging $65,000 a head to guide clients to the top of the world” (Krakauer 35). This shows that a person is willing to pay to go through so much pain, risk and sickness to summit the top of the world.

    Read More

  • Essay On Mount Everest Suicide

    708 Words  | 3 Pages

    There was also a incident where a ranger passed away trying to rescue two climbers who fell into a crevasse. (Source 3) “ranger at Mount Rainier National Park fell 3,700 feet to his death.” The ranger was a very skilled guy and it is sad that he passed away after trying hard to become skilled. If a skilled guy like that could pass away, then why would you want to climb a mountain when you’re not an expert? This mixing of skilled and unskilled climbers is causing may to die The climbers may feel more safe knowing that they can be rescued, but there are really not safe.

    Read More

  • Jon Krakauer's Into Thin Air

    1302 Words  | 6 Pages

    In Jon Krakauer’s masterpiece, Into Thin Air, he provides an in-depth explanation of what happened one disastrous day on Mount Everest. While the book is essentially a memoir, it incorporates the excitement of an adventure novel, the suspense of a mystery, and the factual detailing of a school textbook. Jon Krakauer doesn’t leave out any experience to the reader; he very carefully explains every detail so anyone can read his book, even those who have never heard of what happened in Spring of 1996 on Mount Everest. The story essentially explores Jon Krakauer’s months of preparation for and climbing of Mount Everest.

    Read More

  • Who Is Jon Krakauer's Motivations In Into The Wild

    693 Words  | 3 Pages

    While they were on this trip, they made it to the top but when they were descending down the mountain in the Himalayas Reinhold was a little bit ahead of his brother, which was typical on their hiking trips, when Reinhold had realized that he hadn't seen his brother in awhile he decided to go back and look for him. As Reinhold was put on trial he said “Then I stumbled on the debris from an avalanche… I couldn't believe that my brother might be buried there, might be dead”(Douglas 1). After the trip was over he was blamed for the death of his brother and put on trial but finally vindicated after 35 years, this shows how a mistake can lead to misery because it explains how just one mistake, in this case it's him getting too far ahead of his brother, can lead to misery, being that his brother is now

    Read More

  • Symbolism In 'Rob Hall' By Jon Krakauer

    379 Words  | 2 Pages

    Money plays a gigantic part in the economy with Everest. “By 1996 Hall was charging $65,000 a head…” (pg.36). To guides, gross amounts of money paid, Sherpa’s at the base of the mountain went from a small village with no wheels to having the children wearing baseball caps and American branded shirts. This even allowed anyone who could pay, could climb the mountain, even if guides had to drag them up the mountain. There wasn’t as much lack of trust due to the types of people, but their skill level.

    Read More

  • The Rhetorical Analysis Of Into Thin Air By Jon Krakauer

    974 Words  | 4 Pages

    Into Thin Air By Jon Krakauer Into Thin Air is a non-fiction and adventure book that details the disaster that occurred in 1996 at Mount Everest, and it started as a magazine article. The book is a personal account of the author Jon Krakauer, a professional writer and mountaineering hobbyist, who was sent on the Everest expedition by Outside Magazine with the task of writing an article about his experience. In my opinion, people should read Into Thin Air because it is a story about survival, and it consists of valuable lessons about, perseverance, determination, and character.

    Read More

  • Successful People Are Goal Orienteded

    384 Words  | 2 Pages

    Successful people are goal oriented. Where many become doubtful and pessimistic, successful people persist with their goal in mind. This is taught in business schools and indirectly in competitive sports. Failure is seen as something you learn from -- something that makes you stronger. In fact, many entrepreneurs with successful Internet businesses teach that you should fail often and quickly when starting out in order to achieve rapid success.

    Read More

  • Taking Risks In The Film '127 Hours'

    505 Words  | 3 Pages

    This amazing people by climbing the Everest enjoy the fear the life can give to us, they can set goals/dreams, and become successful by achieving their goal of climbing this powerful mountain. The Everest is also the obstacles that individuals have in life “Difficult times have helped me to understand better than before, how infinitely rich and beautiful life is in every way and i so many things that one goes worrying about are of no importance whatsoever” Isak

    Read More

  • Everest Persuasive Speech

    654 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mt. Everest is no different. The high cliffs and peak of the mountain have attracted explorers for over a century. If it’s unexplored, humans will find a way to explore it. This is why, no matter who they are, people all over the world should be allowed to scale Everest. First of all, risks allow humans to explore and push past their limits.

    Read More

  • Mt. Everest Research Paper

    594 Words  | 3 Pages

    Nevertheless, if I was given a chance to climb Mt. Everest, I wouldn’t do it because it is expensive, the view is not worth climbing, and I might risk putting my health and life in danger. First of all, climbing Mt. Everest would cost me a fortune. I can’t just come up to the mountain and start climbing. I’m expected to pay for these things before setting foot on the mountain: climbing gear, bottled oxygen, permit to climb, support, guide, and food.

    Read More

  • Achieve300's 'The Man Who Climbed Highest'

    147 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the article,"The Man Who Climbed Highest," from Achieve3000, the author states that Hillary was the man to survive Mt. Everest. Achieve3000 uses a descriptive structure in order to show how Hillary did on Mt. Everest. This text is intended for students and adults. A man named Hillary liked climbing snowy mountains. He wanted to climb Mt. Everest because nobody has survived climbing it.

    Read More

  • Mount Hood Case Study

    612 Words  | 3 Pages

    Keep in mind he was a “professional” and was supposed to guide the group. Even after being seven people down the rest of the group continued to climb up the mountain. They did not turn back until the weather got worse, on their way down they were caught in a complete blizzard where visibility was almost completely gone. At this point they made the decision to make a snow cave shelter. They managed to survive the night and the next morning a student and professional mountaineer hiked for 16 hours until they found help.

    Read More

More about Robert Hall's To Blame In Into Thin Air

Open Document