A Class Divided Analysis
The experiment of ‘A Class Divided’ is a lesson taught by Jane Elliot about discrimination and how it feels to be discriminated against. She first conducted this experiment in 1968 with her class of third graders, she divides people by eye colour and provides collars for them, and she then makes a group of rules separating them and observes how they’re discriminated against in a controlled environment.
The experiment breached many ethical guidelines, this is because the experiment wouldn’t have worked otherwise. The rights of the participants was breached in order to achieve accurate results and so that people would feel the humiliation and cage of discrimination. It is unknown if confidentiality was breached because it is uncertain as to whether or not a waiver was signed by the participants. In the case of the students, voluntary participation was not breached because the students decided beforehand that they wanted to participate in the experiment. However, with the prison guards, they were told that they simply were to attend a mandatory workshop, therefore not voluntary. Withdrawal rights was breached because in both cases because they weren’t allowed to leave the experiment before it was over. However while the children were informed about
…show more content…
However with the guards, she was more interested in creating empathy than the actual ethics of the experiment. Which was morally incorrect, because only so much can be done to build empathy and most empathetic people will be taught empathy at an early age so it becomes part of who they are. However, there was very little reason for it to be conducted with the guards in the first place and raises the question of when should it stop? To abide by the guidelines, Jane should’ve let the participants know that it was an experiment and that they were welcome to leave at any
A Class Divided Summary
919 Words | 4 PagesIn the PBS documentary A Class Divided third grade teacher Jane Elliot tried an experiment to let a class of her third graders experience discrimination. For Jane Elliot’s third grade class in a small town in Iowa discrimination was unheard of because there was only white Christians living in the town. She separated her class based on eye color, so one day she made the kids with blue eyes be superior and the kids with brown eyes be inferior. She did multiple test to see if the way they were treated changed the way they learned. The next day she switched it, so the kids with blue eyes were now inferior and the kids with brown eyes were superior.
SOC 150: Class Analysis
912 Words | 4 PagesThe five most important things I have learned throughout my semester in SOC 150 are about crime and perception of social problems, how fines and fees keep people in jails, about mobility and poverty, sexual assault on college campuses, and lastly about the school-to-prison pipeline. During our unit on crime I learned about the perception of a social problem in different parts of the country as well as to a single individual. The two readings about crime, “Crime Rates Have Plummeted” and “U.S. Crime Is Up but Americans Don’t Seem to Have Noticed” demonstrate that crime is a social problem to be interpreted differentially based on the person perceiving the problem. What happens with crime is that crime is more likely to be thought of as a social problem based on what the media is reporting. The media will broadcast the
Jane Elliot's Classroom Experiment And The Civil Rights Movement
586 Words | 3 PagesTheir rights to do things, such as play on playground equipment and get second helpings of food at lunch were taken away, and they were informed that they had to drink out of the water fountain with a paper cup. Elliot told the brown-eyed children that they were cleaner and more intelligent than blue-eyed children as well as encouraged them to cause physical harm to and belittle the others.2 This led to brown-eyed students ganging up on the children with blue eyes and beating them up, degrading them, and making comments that were conforming to the stereotypes that Elliot enforced on the children. The next day, Elliot switched the roles in the experiment and made the children with brown eyes inferior. After the experiment, children were 2 Bloom, S. G. (2022, BLUE EYES, BROWN EYES: On Race and Jane Elliott's Famous Experiment on Prejudice.
Discrimination In Ms. Elliot's Assassination
1002 Words | 5 PagesTherefore, the students and Ms. Elliot could not fathom why anyone would want to harm Mr. King. The assassination made her decide to teach her students a very challenging lesson on the significance of the word discrimination. This lesson would show the students how it felt to be discriminated against, and how it changed individuals. The experiment consisted of the class being divided by eye color. The first day of the experiment, the students that had blue eyes, were advised that they
Mean World Syndrome
736 Words | 3 PagesSegregation, separation and discrimination are three different words that share one definition. The documentary Brown eyes-Blue eyes allows its viewers to see segregation, separation and discrimination. Although many have seen segregation displayed in older people, the prominent fact was viewers see kids discriminating one another because he/she has blue eyes or brown eyes. Jane Elliot a third grade teacher created the blue eye brown eye experiment, in hope of creating a perspective for children to view people for what lies on the inside not the pigment of their skin. The experiment cultivated many children, as shown in the film the kids actually took something away from the experience.
Jane Elliot's Essay: The Eye Of The Storm
517 Words | 3 PagesMany students reacted in anger and disappointment because they didn’t feel like it was fair to be judged on the color of their eyes. This experiment illustrates discrimination perfectly. It put the students into an African Americans shoes and made the students realize how hard it is to live life when always being discriminated on the way that you look. This experiment was very successful and continues to be used today to illustrate discrimination, and its effects on the ones doing or being
Zimbardo Violation Of Research Ethics
409 Words | 2 PagesAshley, I concur that the Stanford Prison Experiment did, in fact, violate research ethics. I believe that Zimbardo’s research experiment violated the ACJS code, specifically, the experiment did expose participants to more than a minimal risk of personal harm, and the research purposes were not fully disclosed to the participants. Zimbardo himself also admitted that his research experiment violated these standards. I further believe that Zimbardo made several errors in his research including the fact that he gave himself a position in the experiment as “prison warden”. Clearly Zimbardo should have had another person play this role so he could remain independent, an error Zimbardo also admits to having done.
Essay On Stanford Prison Experiment
599 Words | 3 PagesThey also concluded that the environment of the prison played a vital role in the way the guards treated the prisoners. It is believed that this experiment changed the way some U.S. prisons are
A Class Divided Documentary Analysis
1170 Words | 5 PagesThe documentary titled, “ A Class Divided” introduces us to the experiment made in an elementary school in Iowa by the schoolteacher named Jane Elliot. The documentary begins with Mrs. Elliot reuniting with the students who she did this experiment with the first time. The students are much older now, and they willingly want to watch the experiment that they were part of when they were elementary kids. The experiment was done days after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. Mrs. Elliot has always thought about doing the eye color experiment, but she was never sure of when to do it. She asked her third grade student if it would be interesting to see what would happen if they were judged by their eye color.
The Lord Of The Flies: Are People Born Good Or Evil?
898 Words | 4 PagesDuring the Stanford prison experiment the actual boys who agreed to do the experiment had no idea what it was, they thought it would be a fun idea to help out with an experiment. The only reason why the experiment stopped after only a week was because a women who was one of the people behind it saw the prisoners walking to the bathroom and they had bags on their heads and they were in single file and she got upset. She was upset because they lost the purpose of the experiment and actually turned these boys into
Jane Elliot's Experiment
596 Words | 3 PagesJane Elliot was a third grade teacher that tried an experiment with her class to educate her students on the effects of discrimination. Elliot separated her class based on their eye color in order to explain how people are treated differently in the world. She tried to find a way to explain racism in the world in a way that third graders would understand. I was actually surprised when I heard there had been an altercation on the playground the day of the experiment. A blue eyed student teased a brown eyed student which resulted in the brown eyed student engaging in a physical altercation with the blue eyed student.
Argumentative Essay On Milgram's Experiment
810 Words | 4 PagesHe signed up just like I did without knowing what he was in for. If there were any signs of hesitation the experimenter would urge "teachers" to continue by saying "You must go on. The experiment requires that you continue. " If the "teacher" failed to comply the experimenter would tell them that they had no choice but to continue. Some of the "teachers" were very upset by this statement, I would be
Homecoming King Analysis
1528 Words | 7 PagesIn this way, he explains that they are racially differentiated upon, where the students are regarded as submissive while
Jane Elliott's Argument Analysis: The Blue Eyed Experiment
724 Words | 3 PagesJane Elliot Split her 3rd grade c lass into two different groups brown eyed group and the blue eyed group; before splitting them she asked them is being discriminating to others right and they answer the way she expected them to answer because it has been taught to them since they have been in her class, she then proceeded to ask them why was it wrong and they could not give her a clear answer she also ask them would they like to know how it feels to be discriminated against and they all said yes. She conducted this exercise for a total of two days she started the first day off letting the children know that the brown eyed students were more smarter and all around better than the blue eyed student. She then withness some of the sweetest kids turn into nasty discriminating adolescence they tease the blue eyed children every chance they could.
Inclusion In Physical Education
1477 Words | 6 PagesThrough SPHE children can become aware of some of the prejudices and attitudes that impinge on the dignity of others. They are given opportunities to develop an understanding of their own culture and traditions, and equally to acquire a growing appreciation of the positive contributions made by different groups in society. As children learn to understand and practice equality, justice and fairness in school situations they will be enabled to challenge prejudice and discrimination as they experience it in their own lives, both now and in the future. Inclusion can be dealt with in an SPHE class by showing DVD’s highlighting the importance of accepting people for who they are. For example throughout the strand of Myself and the wider world, children can develop citizenship by creating a ‘we all fit in Jigsaw’ (see appendix A)
More about A Class Divided Analysis
A Class Divided Summary
919 Words | 4 PagesSOC 150: Class Analysis
912 Words | 4 PagesJane Elliot's Classroom Experiment And The Civil Rights Movement
586 Words | 3 PagesDiscrimination In Ms. Elliot's Assassination
1002 Words | 5 PagesMean World Syndrome
736 Words | 3 PagesJane Elliot's Essay: The Eye Of The Storm
517 Words | 3 PagesZimbardo Violation Of Research Ethics
409 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Stanford Prison Experiment
599 Words | 3 PagesA Class Divided Documentary Analysis
1170 Words | 5 PagesThe Lord Of The Flies: Are People Born Good Or Evil?
898 Words | 4 PagesJane Elliot's Experiment
596 Words | 3 PagesArgumentative Essay On Milgram's Experiment
810 Words | 4 PagesHomecoming King Analysis
1528 Words | 7 PagesJane Elliott's Argument Analysis: The Blue Eyed Experiment
724 Words | 3 PagesInclusion In Physical Education
1477 Words | 6 Pages