ipl-logo

A Comparative Analysis Of '67' And Stephen Ambrose's Band Of Brothers

966 Words4 Pages

Although Andy Wiest's Boys of '67 and Stephen Ambrose's Band of Brothers are set in different historical periods, with the former taking place during the Vietnam War and the latter in World War II, both stories reveal similarities in the soldiers' experiences on the battlefield. These shared elements center around camaraderie, and the collective experience of trauma. However, notable differences also existed, such as the objectives of each war, the character of the conflicts, and the public perceptions surrounding them.
Despite the transformative shift in warfare from World War II to the Vietnam War, a consistent theme emerges in the narratives of Wiest and Ambrose- death and dealing with trauma. Wiest's depiction of the servicemen from Charlie …show more content…

Post World War II, soldiers were largely embraced by society, celebrated as heroes. Many veterans did not shroud their war stories but reflected on them with a mix of nostalgia and melancholy. Corporal Walter Gordon exemplified this sentiment when he described the war's profound impact, saying, "It had the most awesome effect... I'm incredibly lucky that I got through it and even more fortunate that I was with this group of outstanding men." (Ambrose, 118). Despite the grim realities of war, like many of his fellow WWII veterans, Gordon chose to adopt a more optimistic perspective. In stark contrast, the Vietnam War divided the nation, sparking widespread protests and civil unrest. The soldiers in Wiest's account faced a less welcome homecoming, often driving them to conceal their past military service. Moreover, many veterans from Charlie Company struggled with life after the war compared to their counterparts from Easy Platoon. Willie McTear, a Vietnam veteran, exemplified this struggle. On returning from Vietnam, he grappled with PTSD, “… spending all his money on booze and drugs.” (Wiest 352). Although McTear eventually managed to turn his life around, his story mirrors the path many Vietnam veterans had to tread. Overall, the stark difference in public opinion on both wars and the contrasting post-service careers of the soldiers demonstrates the fundamental disparities highlighted in 'A Band of Brothers and 'The Boys of

Show More
Related

  • Speaking Of Courage Symbolism

    1540 Words  | 7 Pages

    In the short story “Speaking of Courage”, from Tim O’Brien’s collection The Things They Carried, many foggy images that the reader may have about war are sure to be made clear. It turns out that some veterans struggle just as much back home as they did in the war, and O’Brien paints a clear picture of the struggles these veterans face. Readers of “Speaking of Courage” get to see America through a veteran's eyes, and attempt to discern the peculiar struggle of being back home from war. In “Speaking of Courage”, O’Brien’s fictional twist on a true story, Norman Bowker reflects on a disturbing experience that happened to him back in the Vietnam War as he drives around his hometown. He has a very hard time moving on from a traumatic moment he faced

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    841 Words  | 4 Pages

    Tim O’Brien writes us a wonderful fictional tale of a platoon of men in vietnam during the vietnam war, The Things They Carried shows the reader that when the men are over in this distant and strange land, not only do they carry physical objects, but emotional baggage and ideas that truly make, or break a man in war. Tim and his men show several signs of stress and turmoil while fighting the war, and while they survive they begin to understand what is really means to live, die, and what is right, and wrong. While over in vietnam the men are in a war, not a simple skirmish or fight, but a full on war against an enemy that they were not sure they are the enemy. The men would walk from location from location seeing what there is to do and trying

    Read More

  • Who Is Rat Kiley's Innocence In The Things They Carried

    1363 Words  | 6 Pages

    22 million American men were drafted for the Vietnam War, 30,000 men leaving the country to avoid the inevitable draft. In Tim O’Brien’s 1990 historical fiction novel The Things They Carried, 22 short stories of the war are told by a first hand soldier who had experienced the guilt and grief associated with war. These stories follow O’Brien’s fellow soldiers and friends as they go along the war and the audience sees the development of these soldiers whose life had just been turned upside down. The readers see the guilt and grief associated with the war and the variety of how these soldiers cope with this loss. Rat Kiley, Mary Anne, and Linda are all characters the readers see whose innocence is ripped away from them at such a young age and

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Rumor Of War By Philip Caputo

    1202 Words  | 5 Pages

    Philip Caputo’s narrative model of a “vicarious tour of duty” in his memoir A Rumor of War humanizes the American military in Vietnam by removing the reader from preconceptions, presenting a multifaceted account of combat, and describing the landscape and environment of the American War in Vietnam in vivid detail. As a Marine lieutenant and as a survivor of the war, Caputo’s account is limited by nature, but he maintains a broad representation of the American War through his descriptions of the environment and by reiterating the significance of his peers' deaths, especially as the American casualty rate increased. Caputo’s conclusion that the extent of suffering in combat cannot be described secondhand and his explicit goal of documentation

    Read More

  • The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien: Literary Analysis

    793 Words  | 4 Pages

    Rat writes a letter to Curt’s sister explaining to her what a great guy her brother was. “Her brother made the war seem almost fun… he had the right attitude, he knew how to have a good time.” (O’Brien 18) Curt copes with the horrors of the war through moments of joy and laughter. This impacts how we talk about war and how traumatizing experiences shouldn't be treated as a game or just something to get a good laugh out of.

    Read More

  • Guilt In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    539 Words  | 3 Pages

    The title of this group of stories is not solely based on the physical burdens the men had to carry through Vietnam but the mental and emotional issues they are stuck with after the war.

    Read More

  • How Does Tim O Brien Show Courage In The Things They Carried

    1955 Words  | 8 Pages

    During the time of the Vietnam War, most soldiers were young men, usually under thrity years old, who were especially susceptible to the unachievable masculine values

    Read More

  • War In The Things They Carried, By Tim O Brien

    1103 Words  | 5 Pages

    Between the danger of firefights, the suspense of night raids, and the explosions of mortar strikes soldiers experience many near-death experiences. These experiences, however, give soldiers an irreplaceable rush of adrenaline and endorphins. Throughout the novel “The Things They Carried,” Tim O’Brien uses many different stories from his friends and his time fighting in Vietnam to illustrate the ups and downs of war and the effect it has on those involved. Through the use of different perspectives, he is able to give the full Vietnam experience ranging from the fun with group members to witnessing the death of a close friend. In The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien illustrates how war can give soldiers a feeling of belonging, camaraderie, and

    Read More

  • Examples Of Trauma In The Things They Carried

    689 Words  | 3 Pages

    Shamus Colson Ms. Robinson Junior Humanities English 13 June 2023 Vietnam and the trauma carried by a soldier from a war fought in vane Throughout Tim O'brien's book The Things They Carried we are introduced to several young men who had been deployed to the Vietnam countryside to fight a war where there was no clear good guy or bad guy and no real objective other than to kill the spread of Communism. Unfortunately rather than addressing the horrible things these young men saw and experienced our government and some of our people shunned away these young men and the trauma they carry from a war fought in vane, where instead of valuing the lives and emotional well-being of America's sons, our government valued money and capitalism. The young man that arguably carries the most trauma throughout the book is Norman Bowker.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes In The Things They Carried

    1609 Words  | 7 Pages

    Traditionally, men have been looked upon as more stable, rational, and grounded than women. Men were typically looked upon for leadership within the household, workplace, and society as a whole. While this stereotype is now seen for its misogynistic origins, during the Vietnam War era, and even the 90’s when The Things They Carried was published, it was extremely prevalent. It was so prevalent that when Vietnam soldiers struggled with mental instability both during and after the war, most refused to get help or even admit that they needed it. However, Tim O’Brien’s novel shed a new light onto the internal issues Vietnam soldiers faced during the time.

    Read More

  • Spin By Tim O Brien Rhetorical Analysis

    791 Words  | 4 Pages

    In Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried, the author retells the chilling, and oftentimes gruesome, experiences of the Vietnam war. He utilizes many anecdotes and other rhetorical devices in his stories to paint the image of what war is really like to people who have never experienced it. In the short stories “Spin,” “The Man I Killed,” and “ ,” O’Brien gives reader the perfect understanding of the Vietnam by placing them directly into the war itself. In “Spin,” O’Brien expresses the general theme of war being boring and unpredictable, as well as the soldiers being young and unpredictable.

    Read More

  • Coping Mechanisms In The Things They Carried Essay

    2081 Words  | 9 Pages

    The soldiers in the Vietnam War are portrayed as losing themselves in the chaos and trauma of combat. Through the stories of the soldiers and their experiences, O’Brien explores the ways in which war strips away one's sense of identity and humanity. The author himself is depicted as losing himself in the war. O'Brien served in the Vietnam War, and his experiences inspired much of the book. Through the character of Tim O'Brien, the author explores the ways in which war can strip away one's sense of self and purpose.

    Read More

  • War In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    774 Words  | 4 Pages

    War has a profound and lasting impact on individuals and society. In “The Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien, he tells different stories of before, during and after war and how it affects the soldiers, mentally and physically. In these stories Tim O’Brien illustrates these traumas and the long-lasting effects and impact that the war will always have on these men. Even though all the men didn’t survive the ones that did continue to have traumatic flashbacks. War has a lasting impact on individuals and society, affecting not only the physical but the mental and emotional well-being of those involved.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Bloods: Black Veterans Of The Vietnam War

    1502 Words  | 7 Pages

    His 24-month long mission gave him the opportunity to use his journalism and educational experiences to cover the important roles that African American soldiers were playing in the Vietnam War. The military’s goal in this assignment was to show the American people and potential African American soldiers that African American soldiers were now treated equally. There was a stigma regarding the maltreatment of African Americans in the military, and with the passing of the Civil Rights Bill of 1964, the image of the African American soldier began to quickly change. The new breed of African American soldiers no longer tolerated bigotry and hatred. African American soldiers began uniting to combat the injustices in America as well as within the military overseas.

    Read More

  • Thesis For The Things They Carried

    999 Words  | 4 Pages

    The True Weight of War “The Things They Carried,” by Tim O’Brien, brings to light the psychological impact of what soldiers go through during times of war. We learn that the effects of traumatic events weigh heavier on the minds of men than all of the provisions and equipment they shouldered. Wartime truly tests the human body and and mind, to the point where some men return home completely destroyed. Some soldiers have been driven to the point of mentally altering reality in order to survive day to day. An indefinite number of men became numb to the deaths of their comrades, and yet secretly desired to die and bring a conclusion to their misery.

    Read More

More about A Comparative Analysis Of '67' And Stephen Ambrose's Band Of Brothers

Open Document