A Critical Analysis Of Claire Ironside's Apples To Oranges
The visual essay “Apples to Oranges” by Claire Ironside presents the reader with a series of infographics displaying the environmental impact of industrially farmed, non-local produce. The author attempts to approach the audience using primarily facts and statistics. Despite these efforts, the essay lacks an explicit statement of the author’s argument, while the infographics used are ambiguous and misleading. The obscure images, lack of logical connections and absence of an explicit claim leave the reader more confused than persuaded. These problems require the reader to infer most of the information and context, which is contradictory to the purpose of a visual medium. In short, the author is summoning many facts and statistics to establish a strong logical appeal, but is failing to structurally connect these points, clearly deliver her argument to the audience, or effectively utilize the format of a visual essay to her convenience. This is why I believe that “Apples to Oranges” is ineffective in persuading its intended audience. The first impression that I felt as a reader after reading this essay was confusion. This is largely caused by the ambiguous nature of the infographics. If you examine the first page after the title images [Everything’s An Argument p.644], you see a blue figure on the top, next to it an equal sign, and below ten gas pumps. Only after you turn over to the next page and read the explanation will you realize that the blue blob is a food calorie, and
The Carnivore's Dilemma By Nicolette Hahn Niman
699 Words | 3 PagesThe author's use of a compare/contrast structure and the appeal to ethos to support her claim was effective. However, her use of the hasty generalization and “Red Herring” fallacies caused the audience to doubt her claim, that meat from traditional farms was better for the environment, had sufficient evidence to
David Zinczenko's 'Don't Blame the Eater' : A Rhetorical Analysis
775 Words | 4 PagesHe shows that most are eating way more calories than they think. His usage of data and numbers in the last part of his essay reinforce what was already a strong
Analysis Of An Animal's Place By Michael Pollan
1213 Words | 5 PagesFor instance he considers Joel Alatin's opinion about "vegetarian utopia" that it is supported by animal rights activists,although it is a fact that in some places people cannot grow crops because the environment is not able to do it and the author has witness this in his own country where rain does not occur enough to grow crops. "Vegetarian utopia" illustrates a place where people stopped eating meat, but then they would need enormous portions of vegetables which would be unnatural and bad for the health of the environment as farmers would use chemicals to adapt in the new increased demand which would harm the earth and all the living organisms that live upon it. With logos the author wins his audience trust and inclines them to his ideas by leading them with reasons and using
A Carnivore's Dilemma Summary
795 Words | 4 PagesThe article was written in response to the statement farming and food production is leading to climate change. Niman, being a rancher who raises cattle, goats, and turkeys, effectively frames the situation logically by providing credible statistics and examples to help the reader better understand the impacts of different methods of food production. She does this by providing specific information regarding the greenhouse gases involved, being carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxides. Niman, the rhetor, has written this article to try and inform the readers about the differences between traditional style and industrial style methods of food production. She has directed the article towards those concerned about the carbon footprint, we as individuals, are leaving
Foer Eating Animals Analysis
732 Words | 3 PagesJonathan Safran Foer’s Eating Animals is a book about persuasion. Foer seeks to convince his readers to take any step in reducing what he believes is the injustice of harming animals. To achieve this, Foer employs many persuasion techniques and often changes his approach when he targets specific groups. His strategies include establishing himself as an ethical authority and appealing to his readers’ emotions, morals, and reason.
Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Attention Whole Foods Shoppers'
729 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis of “Attention Whole Foods Shoppers” In “Attention Whole Foods Shoppers” by Robert Paarlberg, the main emphasis in the article is that there is a struggle to feed people, particularly in South Africa and Asia due to economic and population issues. His focus is on the lack of involvement of countries around the world that do have food. Throughout the article, Paarlberg talks about how organic agriculture is not going to feed the world and exposes myths about organic food and industrial scale food.
The Locavore Myth Analysis: Argument
941 Words | 4 PagesDue to McWilliams’ strong claim, evidence, warrant, backing, and rebuttal to counter arguments, his argument is therefore an effective one, according to the Toulmin method. The most important and key components, that are vital to an argument, are the argument’s claim, qualifiers, as well as the evidence the author uses to support their argument. If there were no claim, then the author has no firm stance or basis for their argument, because they would have nothing to defend or persuade their readers of. The claim James E. McWilliams makes in the article “The Locavore movement: Why Buying from Nearby Farmers Won’t Save the Planet” is that since there are so many factors that are attributed to the destruction of the earth and the waste of tons of energy ,that the locavore movement is not quite saving the planet simply by focusing
Monsanto's Harvest Of Fear Summary
845 Words | 4 PagesThe three essays assigned this week had several common threads running through them. The strongest core theme is the rapid change in the food cycle in America and the vast changes that have taken place in the way by which we grow, produce, and process the food that average Americans eat. The food we eat now is drastically different from what our grandparents grew up eating and the three essays each examine that in a different way. Another theme is the loss of knowledge by the average consumer about where their food comes from, what it is composed of, and what, if any, danger it might pose to them. “Monsanto’s Harvest of Fear” by Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele is a harsh look at the realities of food production in a country where large corporations, like Monsanto, have been allowed to exploit laws and loopholes to bend farmers and consumers to their
Universal Health Care Ethos Pathos Logos
733 Words | 3 PagesThe second editorial argued that a universal health care plan would cause trouble and more burden than benefits. Both editorials utilize similar methods of persuading their audiences, specifically utilizing pathos to play with the audience's emotions and logos to provide statistical information. Though they used similar methods, the second editorial provided more logical evidence to support their claim and reasons. In this type of debate a more logical approach is necessary to solve this problem. The audience that would be receiving this information is more likely to be persuaded by a logical series of events then by a few sentimental stories.
A Rhetorical Analysis Of GMO OMG By Jeremy Seifert
799 Words | 4 Pages“Today in the United States, by the simple acts of feeding ourselves, we are unwittingly participating in the largest experiment ever conducted on human beings.” Jeremy Seifert certainly knows how to get viewers’ attention, as exemplified by the film blurb describing his 2013 documentary, GMO OMG. The frightening depiction of the food industry is one of many efforts to expose consumers of the twenty-first century to the powerful organizations that profit from national ignorance and lack of critical inquiry and involvement. Seifert effectively harnesses the elements of rhetoric throughout his phenomenal argument against remaining complacent about the food industry’s act of withholding of information about genetically modified organisms from
Rhetorical Analysis Of Let There Be Dark
442 Words | 2 PagesPaul Bogard is very convincing in “Let There Be Dark” he uses various methods and figurative language in order to convince the audience that darkness is necessary. By appealing to the reader’s emotions, logic, and to his credibility Paul Bogard builds a strong argument. The author uses logic to help make his argument more convincing. For example, in the first paragraph he uses a study to prove his point.
DBQ Essay: The Green Revolution
620 Words | 3 PagesThe graph in document 1, a food/population report by the UN, shows a direct relationship between a growing population and the amount of food supply. This rapid increase is made possible by Norman Borlaug's genetically modified crops that made more food on less land and were able to fight off plant diseases. Document 2, a speech given by a president Truman to the struggling citizens, says that many people in a food crisis are in misery and would do anything to escape it. This is fuel for the Green Revolution and its colossal effects on human’s food supply. Document 7 contradicts this thesis because it states that the people who experienced its effects thought it was a contamination to their culture and natural way of life.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Why Literature Matters By Dana Gioia
506 Words | 3 PagesIn conclusion, Dana Gioia applies vocabulary and rhetorical appeals to actively influence his audience to agree to his argument. Furthermore, connecting his audience to the subject and inspiring them to help his issues and understand his
The War That Made America By Fred Anderson
1207 Words | 5 PagesAnderson, Fred. The War that Made America. New York, New York: Penguin Publishing Group, 2006. Fred Anderson's work on the Seven Year War center's upon an argument that the events during the conflict led up to and contributed to the American Revolution and the founding of the United States. Moreover, Anderson argues that the seeds of civil strife between England and its colonial possessions were sown at a time when English victory in North America was assured.
Examples Of Rhetorical Analysis
780 Words | 4 PagesThe most challenging aspect of this paper is I still don't really understand what the purpose and use of writing such a paper is. I know how to break it down into specific appeals such as ethos and logos, but I struggled in using this to create an effective argument. Because of this I feel as though I created to many blunt statements proving little to no evidence to support any of my
More about A Critical Analysis Of Claire Ironside's Apples To Oranges
The Carnivore's Dilemma By Nicolette Hahn Niman
699 Words | 3 PagesDavid Zinczenko's 'Don't Blame the Eater' : A Rhetorical Analysis
775 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of An Animal's Place By Michael Pollan
1213 Words | 5 PagesA Carnivore's Dilemma Summary
795 Words | 4 PagesFoer Eating Animals Analysis
732 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of 'Attention Whole Foods Shoppers'
729 Words | 3 PagesThe Locavore Myth Analysis: Argument
941 Words | 4 PagesMonsanto's Harvest Of Fear Summary
845 Words | 4 PagesUniversal Health Care Ethos Pathos Logos
733 Words | 3 PagesA Rhetorical Analysis Of GMO OMG By Jeremy Seifert
799 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Let There Be Dark
442 Words | 2 PagesDBQ Essay: The Green Revolution
620 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Why Literature Matters By Dana Gioia
506 Words | 3 PagesThe War That Made America By Fred Anderson
1207 Words | 5 PagesExamples Of Rhetorical Analysis
780 Words | 4 Pages