ipl-logo

A Time To Kill Analysis

1011 Words5 Pages

Francheska V. Ronquillo P-101 Sec 8 II- BS ENT Mrs. Jeanette L. Yasol-Naval A Time to Kill “What’s in us that seeks the truth, is it our minds? Or is it our hearts?” - Jake Tyler Brigance Summary: A 10 year-old black-girl named Tonya was brutally raped and almost killed by two overly intoxicated white-men named, Billy Ray Cobb and James Willard. After the incident, the two men were arrested by a black Sheriff Ozzie Walls at a local bar. The girl’s devastated father, Carl Lee Hailey seeks help to the young white lawyer, Jake Tyler Brigance who also has a daughter like Carl’s. Jake had a strong feeling that Carl might do something bad to the two men who almost slaughter the little Tonya. Jake told his …show more content…

The fallacies present were mostly Argumentum ad Hominem, Argumentum ad Misericordiam, Argumentum ad Populum and Argumentum ad Baculum. Let’s start with the Argumentum ad Hominem. In real life, the usual court hearings use the ad Hominem attacks because it is more likely to win an argument if you’re going to destroy your opponents’ credibility. There were a lot of witnesses who had experienced ad hominem attacks, but this one has caught my attention and I will use it as an example. The psychologist who tried to defend Carl by his factual statement, but then Atty. Buckley used ad Hominem attacks (by exposing the past statutory rape case that the psychologist had involved himself for whatever he says will become useless because no one will believe in him. But later on, it was found out that the girl was 17 and the psychologist was 23 when he was accused of statutory rape. The girl became the mother of his child and they were married. Also in the movie, the white’s used racism to destroy Carl Lee and put him into anguish. It is also said that just because he is black, he doesn’t deserve the equal rights and he must put to

Show More
Related

  • Scottsboro Trial: Most Tragic Epoch's Of African-American History

    662 Words  | 3 Pages

    When the black group prevailed, they couldn’t even imagine what laid ahead at the next stop. The train was brought to a halt in the town of Scottsboro, Alabama. Surrounding the train was a group of officers, and men, armed and looking irate. Two white women emerged from the train and stated that they have been raped. The group took the black boys to a jail to be tried in the coming days.

    Read More

  • Sam Hose Story

    509 Words  | 3 Pages

    It got to the point where they took Hose’s body parts and used them as souvenirs and trophies for people. Another example of African Americans being mistreated was the case of the then 16 year old African American female, Claudette Colvin. Author Danielle McGuire introduced Colvin in the story “ At the Dark End of the Street” when Colvin refused to give up her on the segregated bus. McGuire said that Colvin was then called a “ whore” by the officers and later manhandled by the both by getting jerked and then dragged off the bus. While she was in the police car she was terrified because she thought they were going to rape her or maybe even kill her because they could ( McGuire, 86).

    Read More

  • Why Is The Willie Francis Trial Important

    968 Words  | 4 Pages

    Forty white everyday ordinary men were pulled off the streets and placed as the jury pool of candidates for juror selections for the trial of Willie Francis. None of those men, with connections to the decreased were going to see past the color of his skin and be non-biased. I think not! The lack of lawyering by his attorneys led to his first execution; no one was fighting to hear the truth, discussion of coerced statements or evidence that indicated his innocence. The only person fighting on his behalf was his father; his father didn’t want to lose his son to the corrupt judicial system in the town of St. Martinville.

    Read More

  • Southland Jackie Ishida Analysis

    940 Words  | 4 Pages

    Little did Jackie know, that her Aunt Lois’s seeming easy and benign task of finding an acquaintance from her grandfather’s past, Curtis Martindale, which he bequeath a sizable amount of cash would be the catalyst of her political conscience. Early, she is challenged with the murder mystery that takes place in her grandfather’s store. Her odyssey of self-discovery, takes her to South Central, Crenshaw, Little Tokyo and Downtown Los Angeles where she learns their relevant historical significance. Our protagonist is confronted with the racial conflicts and prejudices that dictate how people reacted to one another in the past and present.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Tom Robinson Trial And To Kill A Mockingbird

    1302 Words  | 6 Pages

    It wasn’t until five years after the nine boys had been accused of rape that Ruby told the truth. Even though Ruby had told the truth the boys still where found guilty. Ruby had to live knowing that she wasn’t able to save their lives even when speaking up and telling the truth. Ruby had to live thinking that it was her fault they had died. Ruby lived knowing that the laws where unfair to the black

    Read More

  • Ida B Wells Essay

    617 Words  | 3 Pages

    For example, the narrator mentions the increasing fear of lynching laws and the collapse of law and order for blacks. Historian David Tucker substantiates this with a story regarding friends of Ida’s who had refused to close their grocery store which was in competition with a white-owned grocery story which resulted in them eventually having a mob against them and getting lynched. While Tucker explains the given events, there are images of newspaper articles regarding the event on the screen and following is a reading from Ida’s journal and her take of the

    Read More

  • What Is The Theme Of Until The Flood By Michael Brown

    1135 Words  | 5 Pages

    Connie is a thirty-five-year-old white woman who works as a teacher in University City. Her scene takes place inside a wine bar where she speaks about her relationship with her friend Margret and her own failed marriage. Hamm takes a different approach to the Brown case and sympathizes with both the victim and the accused as she addresses potential faults in their childhood. In Connie’s interview, she tells the audience the emotional story of the end of her friendship with Margret over a difference in opinions of the Michael Brown case. This difference in opinions and taking of sides is just one of the indirect effects of the new revolution of justice forming across cities sparked by the death of Michael Brown.

    Read More

  • Firekeeper's Daughter By Angeline Boulley

    755 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the novel, Grant Edwards, a prominent white man, is implied to have assaulted Daunis at Shagala. While the scene is non-graphic, it is triggering and jarring because it was unexpected. However, this scene provides powerful commentary on the mistreatment of Native women that happens today. Murder and sexual assault rates are significantly high in Native women across the United States. Many of these assaults are committed by non-Native white men, who are rarely reported and prosecuted.

    Read More

  • Why Did Ralph Myers Decided To Arrest Walter

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    After months of investigators not finding anything on the murder of Ronda; the young women killed at the local laundromat. They had decided to arrest Walter based off Ralph Myers word. They had no evidence and they weren't even fully sure what they should charge him with. Ralph was said to have been afraid of Walter. One day one of the officers had even hinted at Walter maybe even rapping Ralph.

    Read More

  • Travis Alexander Research Paper

    1523 Words  | 7 Pages

    Travis Alexander and the Beautiful Killer Sitting in a cell hundreds of miles away is a woman of small stature who is considered rather good-looking by today's standards. So innocent she seems, but don’t be fooled, for she is responsible for one of the most infamous and scandalous murders of the twenty-first century, the murder of Travis Alexander. This murder was exactly what the world wanted to read about. It was a murder of passion, lust, and betrayal committed by a beautiful woman. In the beginning stages it seemed so transparent, but the deeper America dove it became clear there was much more going on than met the eye.

    Read More

  • The Machine Of Death Analysis

    970 Words  | 4 Pages

    Death, it 's everywhere. It 's part of life, and it happens every day all around the world. Death is the black hole that threatens to consume us. In the book, The Machine Of Death is a fictional machine that tells people how they 're going to die. The question is should mankind allow this machine to come to life?

    Read More

  • Social Structural Factors In N. W. A

    797 Words  | 4 Pages

    The dominant social group in this movie (White Americans) including the police adds to their social structure by viewing the main characters as troublemakers and deviant to

    Read More

  • In The Heat Of The Night Essay

    1550 Words  | 7 Pages

    Beautifully atmospheric, Haskell Wexler's brilliant cinematography and Norman Jewison's first rate direction make you feel the humidity of the small Mississippi town in which a black detective teams with the redneck sheriff to solve the murder of an important industrialist. Here are many bad "issues" movies out there, but this is not one of them. In a bad movie, all of the racist characters would be one dimensional and one hundred percent evil; here, Steiger is allowed to play a prejudiced man who is actually sympathetic and capable of growth. In a great twist, Virgil Tibbs himself is shown to be capable of prejudice, as he pursues Endicott without sufficient evidence. It's refreshing to see a movie that portrays the entire spectrum of racism, from the crazy extremists (and there are plenty of those on hand here) to the more subtly prejudiced.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes In The Film Imitation Of Life

    418 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moreover, demonstrate consequences are taken to oppress racial and ethnic minorities to keep them in a subservient position. Overall, this film has provided me with a visual depiction of how stereotypes are a mental tool that enforces racial segregation and self-hate. The label of “White” became a necessity for Sarah Jane to achieve in society. To attain it she needed to move to a new city, change her name and deny her mother.

    Read More

  • Keith Douglass How To Kill Analysis

    277 Words  | 2 Pages

    "How To Kill," by Keith Douglas, addresses the idea of how simple it is to kill, and how easy it is to detach yourself from what that kill really means. In the second stanza of his poem , Douglas says, "Now in my dial of glass appears/The soldier who is going to die./He smiles, and moves about in ways/ His mother knows, habits of his." The speaker of the poem watches the person he is about to shoot and recognizes that, once he pulls the trigger, somebody's little baby will be gone forever.

    Read More

More about A Time To Kill Analysis

Open Document