ipl-logo

A Tour Of The Lowell Mills Analysis

1061 Words5 Pages

I decided to select the two documents, “A Tour of the Lowell Mills” and “A Dialogue on Female Labor” for the reason being that women were obligated to work at home taking care of their children rather than actually having the opportunity to join the work force. However, once it became the norm for them to have a job it was shown to be under some rough circumstances. These two documents ultimately contradicted what I was always taught in school, instead of the awful surroundings I believed they lived through they explained how good they were housed and paid. The theme that connects them both is the idea of the women were given the opportunity to work and essentially enjoying their workplace. The author of “A Tour of the Lowell Mills” is Davy …show more content…

“A Dialogue on Female Labor” has an anonymous author. Its purpose was to inform the people of the two views there were about female labor in the factories, one who sees labor as degrading and the other who actually works in the factory mills and sees nothing wrong with it. There was no intended audience for this document, it was written to express the objections believed factory girls went through and what someone who worked in the factory said …show more content…

In “A Tour of the Lowell Mills” Crockett stated “the dinner bells were ringing, and the folks pouring out of the houses like bees out of a gum” (2). In “A Dialogue on Female Labor” Miss. Bartlett states “Because we are reminded of those hours by the ringing of a bell, it is no argument against our employment, any more than it would be against going to church or to school” (2). Another huge similarity found is the idea of female workers enjoying their workplace with no type of complaining. In “A Tour of the Lowell Mills” Davy Crockett identified the young women as “not one expressed herself as tired of her employment, or oppressed with work; all talked well, and looked healthy” (2). In “A Dialogue on Female Labor,” Miss. Bartlett points out to Miss. S “a factory girl’s work in neither hard or complicated; she can go on with perfect regularity in her duties while her mind may be actively employed on any other subject”

Show More
Related

  • The Impact Of The Lowell Mills On The United States

    644 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Lowell Mills had a big impact on the U.S. because women could work for the first time ever. The Lowell Mills hired young single women between the ages of 15 to 35 to work in the mills. The girls would work about 20 hours a week in the mills. One day the Lowell Mill Girls went on strike because they found out that the wages would be cut down the mills were shut down and the girls were no longer working in the Lowell Mills. Single women were chosen because they could be paid less than men.

    Read More

  • Southern Women In Robert Morgan's Gap Creek

    895 Words  | 4 Pages

    In today’s world, there is a stereotype of the typical Southern woman who always has her hair and nails done to perfection, kind, and is the ideal wife. However, Drewitz-Crockett goes on to argue that “people praised a woman by saying she is a fine woman and a hard worker, back in twentieth century.” Back then, work was appreciated, whether that entailed household chores, child birth, or farm work––that is how Robert Morgan portrays Julie Richards in his novel, Gap Creek. In Robert Morgan’s novel, Julie Richards is represented as strong, hardworking, and knowledgeable about her surroundings in South Carolina.

    Read More

  • Women As Bread Winners Summary

    1260 Words  | 6 Pages

    This organization aimed to support workers by implementing agreements between employers concerning pay, hours, and other work-related topics (“Samuel Gompers and the AFL”). O’Donnell was clearly very prejudiced towards women. He believed that they had no place in working traditionally male jobs (specifically craft jobs) and that their employment in such fields could destroy American families and ideals (Shi et al 28-29). As evidenced by his thoughts in this pamphlet, his ideal family consisted of a father who worked a craft job and a mother who either worked a feminine job or stayed at home to raise the children.

    Read More

  • Mills Ethos

    810 Words  | 4 Pages

    Macaul Mellor Many women decided to work in Mills in the 1900’s in order to gain wealth and give to their family. The ideas of the Mills gave a reassuring balance of work, opportunity, and pay to all the women, yet, these ideas were not always fulfilled. Many workers were unhappy with their working condition and the money they were granted. Each different statement reflects a different emotional voice: “Orestes Brownson Questions the Lowell System portrays pathos, “A Lowell Worker Defends the System portrays logos, and “A Worker’s Memories of the Mills” portrays ethos. Ethos gives the strongest voice because it gives the reader liability and experience in the Mills that is needed to truly understand the argument in which, “A worker’s Memories

    Read More

  • Betty Friedan's The Importance Of Work By Betty Friedan

    1088 Words  | 5 Pages

    In her essay, “The Importance of Work,” from The Feminine Mystique published in 1963, Betty Friedan confronts American women’s search for identity. Throughout the novel, Betty Friedan breaks new ground, concocting the idea that women can discover personal fulfillment by straying away from their original roles. Friedan ponders on the idea that The Feminine Mystique is the cause for a vast majority of women during that time period to feel confined by their occupations around the house; therefore, restricting them from discovering who they are as women. Friedan’s novel is well known for creating a different kind of feminism and rousing various women across the nation.

    Read More

  • Rosario Castellanos: Gender Stereotypes In Her Work

    1284 Words  | 6 Pages

    Castellanos was joined by other feminists and writers of her era, who always encouraged women to write about women. She thought that only a woman could successfully and accurately project the thought and emotions of a women. It was commonly felt that men’s portrayal of women was superficial and insulting as it focused purely on appearance and their own idyllic views on what a woman should be, look and act like. ‘Negotiation of gender is a part of that fragmentation, in that the re-writing of women by men makes them nothing more than ‘acesario inventado por la imaginacion

    Read More

  • Dust Bowl 1930

    491 Words  | 2 Pages

    At the start of the Great Depression male unemployment rates were at 30 percent, and working women were being viewed as unjust (DuBois 2).Women were being accused of stealing men’s jobs, despite the fact that many of the women were already employed before the Depression began. Eventually, would worked their way up to being 25 percent of the workforce (DuBois 3). That is not the only place the roles of women changed though. In the household, women were critical to their family’s survival. Their abilities to recycle and produce necessary items from their home, like food from their home gardens or preparing goods to sell was the difference in some of the families barely surviving or not surviving

    Read More

  • Florence Kelly's Speech To The National American Woman Suffrage Association

    74 Words  | 1 Pages

    In her speech to the National American Woman Suffrage Association, Florence Kelly descriptively vocalizes about chid labor. She talks about the horrible conditions young children face in the states. Kelly uses repetition to put emphasis on little girls working in textile mills, “while we sleep” is repeated 3 times this makes the audience feel guilty for enjoying life while little girls are working. Kelly also uses pathos, appealing to the emotion of her

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Florence Kelley's Speech On Child Labor

    785 Words  | 4 Pages

    On July 22nd, 1905, Florence Kelley, a United States social worker and reformer who fought successfully for child labor laws and improved conditions for working women, delivered a speech on child labor before the convention of the National American Woman Suffrage Association in Philadelphia. The purpose of her speech was to convince her audience that the only way to stop child labor was by allowing women the right to vote. Florence Kelley uses certain rhetorical strategies, such as pathos, diction, and an extensive use of figurative language, to appeal to her audience and accomplish her goal. Kelley’s speech is composed of a substantial amount of emotional appeals to aid her in connecting with her intended audience. In paragraph four she says, “Tonight while we sleep, several thousand little girls will be working in textile mills, all the night through, in the deafening noise of the spindles and the looms spinning and weaving cotton and wool, silks and ribbons for us to buy.”

    Read More

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of Florence Kelley's Speech

    478 Words  | 2 Pages

    As a social worker and reformer, Florence Kelley utilizes asyndeton, juxtaposition, and rhetorical questions in her ardent speech for the attendees of the convention for the National American Women Suffrage Association to “enlist the workingmen voters” in helping with the implementation of more stringent child labor laws to encourage the protection of children, especially girls, from working in factories at such young ages. Kelley’s employment of asyndeton in the second paragraph as she states, “Men increase, women increase, youth increase in the ranks of the breadwinners…”, makes her speech more passionate and effective by speeding up its rhythm and pace. She applies this rhetorical strategy to segue into the fact that despite the increase across different demographics, none is so exponential as the growth of “girls between twelve and twenty years of age.” She describes this fact before the convention to depict the extensive hindrances this particular contingent faces.

    Read More

  • How Did The Market Revolution Affect Women

    354 Words  | 2 Pages

    The market revolution was a period in the early 1800s that expanded the marketplace and changed how farmers and manufacturers approached their work. The market revolution however had some negative impacts . The market revolution had many negative impacts on women. In Eli Whitney’s “Complaint of a Lowell Factory Worker”, she describes these negative impacts on young women. She says that most unmarried young women compared themselves to slaves.

    Read More

  • American Women During World War 2 Essay

    848 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the article it says that women entered jobs like engineering, other professions, and manufacturing jobs that many people believed that those jobs were too dangerous for women and women were too weak. In their jobs, women made airplanes, warships, munitions, and tanks working in technical and scientific fields. Also, after the war, women were still employed as secretaries, waitresses, or in other clerical jobs. This was often called the “pink collar” force. This article shows how sometimes women are given clerical jobs that show people underestimate the abilities of women.

    Read More

  • Industrial Revolution Gender Roles

    1383 Words  | 6 Pages

    This goes along with the gender inequality within the household. They brought that attitude into the workforce which helped transition the gender hierarchy that existed in the household, into the factories and other production facilities. Ideas of women’s placement in society were underpinned by legal, political, and social practices which subordinated women. They were seen as less important. One circumstance that made women seem less powerful was how poorly they were paid compared to men.

    Read More

  • How Did The Homestead Act Affect Women

    1652 Words  | 7 Pages

    The women were expected to create a happy home, guard the religion, and the morality of her family. The unmarried and married women who tried to seek work outside the home faced limited employment opportunities because of their gender. Women were expected to only focus on domestic duties and her role were limited to continue living in the man’s world. Women roles were expected to be in line with the culture and norms set by the society. The American culture perceived that women were not intellectually and emotionally stable to be involved in the complex world of work and, therefore, women did not take up leadership and political roles.

    Read More

  • Sexism In The Workplace Essay

    1213 Words  | 5 Pages

    Women. Women’s involvement in the working world have contributed to many items that would be missing from the world today; if they had not been allowed to work.. Women have struggled with sexism in the workplace since before they were even given the chance to try to work. They were taught from a young age that their job was to provide children, cook, and clean for their husbands, while the husband worked and provided the money. What men did not know however was that women were capable of so much more(Jewell, Hannah).

    Read More

More about A Tour Of The Lowell Mills Analysis

Open Document