Accuracy of "Platoon" (1986) in Depicting the Vietnam War
The Vietnam War was a period of struggle that lasted forty brutal years from 1955 to 1975 in Vietnam. It was between North Vietnam, which was backed by communist allies like China and the Soviet Union, and South Vietnam, which was supported by the United States and its allies. The purpose of the war was to unify the country of Vietnam under a communist government and attempt to prevent the spread of communism worldwide. The war originated back in Vietnam's post-World War II partition. Fearing the rise of communism in Southeast Asia, the United States became directly involved as part of its containment strategy. The war saw intense battles and millions of lives lost, with both sides
…show more content…
Many Americans opposed the war, and large figures like “leaders from politics, science, medicine, academia, entertainment, the press, and even business announced their opposition to the war”(Zimmerman 1). The film Platoon (1986), showed the story of Chris Taylor, a young American soldier who quit college and chose to volunteer for combat duty in Vietnam. The film shared his adventures in the war as he joined a company stationed in a detached forest location. Chris quickly faced the ugly realities of the war, watching both the mental and physical effects it had on the soldiers. In the movie, it showed two groups, each led by a different sergeant: Sergeant Barnes, who was a ruthless and harsh veteran, and Sergeant Elias, who was a caring and morally pure soldier. As Chris navigated the brutal environment, he got disgusted by the terrible acts committed and the loss of innocent people's lives. The film ended with a gruesome battle in which Chris had to face the challenges of war and make difficult decisions that would influence his future. The film Platoon (1986) accurately depicts the Vietnam War by depicting the brutal actions soldiers …show more content…
One of the reasons Americans began losing trust in the military and government was because the Vietnam War resulted in a huge number of deaths, both among American soldiers and Vietnamese citizens. The death toll and violent visuals displayed on television pushed the brutal reality of war into people's living rooms. The scale of the deaths caused doubts about the purpose of the war. The progress of the war was “not measured by cities won or territory taken but by body counts and kill ratios” (Locke and Wright 328). Towards the end of the Platoon, there was a major battle that cost the lives of thousands of men from both sides. The following morning it showed the mounds of the flesh of the men that didn't make it till morning. It was a graphic scene but genuinely showed how it would have felt to be there. People that died were only seen as a number and the mentality was the higher that number was the closer we would be to the end of the
A Better War¬-Part Two In the second half of the book written by Lewis Sorley, “A Better War, The Unexamined Victories and Final Tragedy of America’s Last Years in Vietnam” the American soldiers and the American public were in an uproar. The look into the last days of Vietnam for the United States is eye opening. In this review we will look at the affects of war on the American soldiers and a certain offensive.
Tim O’Brien writes us a wonderful fictional tale of a platoon of men in vietnam during the vietnam war, The Things They Carried shows the reader that when the men are over in this distant and strange land, not only do they carry physical objects, but emotional baggage and ideas that truly make, or break a man in war. Tim and his men show several signs of stress and turmoil while fighting the war, and while they survive they begin to understand what is really means to live, die, and what is right, and wrong. While over in vietnam the men are in a war, not a simple skirmish or fight, but a full on war against an enemy that they were not sure they are the enemy. The men would walk from location from location seeing what there is to do and trying
The United States was directly involved in the Vietnam War from 1964 through 1974. A major event in this war was the Tet Offensive, which profoundly affected American history by impacting our politics, economy, military, and society. The Tet Offensive affected politics by influencing the presidential elections of 1968. It affected the American economy, boosting personal prosperity with new jobs but greatly increasing the national debt, due mainly to the vast amounts of money spent on the war effort after the Tet Offensive. The military was affected by the offensive because of America’s increased involvement in South Vietnam, and the fact that many people in the military realized that this was a war we could not win.
O’Brien captures real-life events that he experiences first-hand in Vietnam. Including the incomprehensive presence of brutality, a disturbing lack of value for the lives of innocent Vietnamese civilians, and the soldier’s experiences with guerrilla warfare. These factors together encompass the main points in Tim O’Brien’s argument and give valid evidence that helps the reader grasp that America had little to no morally justifiable reason to become involved in the Vietnam
Most soldiers in the Vietnam War felt the shame of resisting war as, “Men Killed and died because they were embarrassed not to,” (21). For this reason, soldiers adopted cowardice towards themselves if their morals were not towards the Vietnam War. Society creates a margin where there is cowardice with choosing and not choosing to go to war. O’Brien reflects on this by saying, “I understood that I would not do what I should do,” (57), “I was a coward. I went to war,”
In If I Die in a Combat Zone, author Tim O’Brien argues that the Vietnam War was unjust by expressing his disapproval of the war through his own moral beliefs, sharing the descriptions of deaths in Vietnam of the innocent citizens, and by describing how much the war impacted himself and others negatively. In the beginning of the book, O’Brien openly stated his beliefs on the war. He believed it was wrongly accepted and unjust, but he battled his own opinions with society’s views anyway (18). Constantly, O’Brien discussed within his own head about the true definition of bravery and courage (147).
The Vietnam war took a major death toll in Vietnam, United States, South Korea, Thailand, New Zealand, and Australia. Just in the U.S., “more than 58,000 American soldiers were killed while more than 150,000 others wounded”. On both sides, there were almost 2 million civilians dead and 1.1 simply on the Vietnamese side. The My Lai Massacre, where soldiers brutally killed Vietnamese children and mothers, presents an example where the war mentally changed the soldiers in the war in a very horrendous way. On the other hand, the United States took brutal losses in the Tet Offensive, where the Vietcong slaughtered over 100 towns and twelve United States air bases.
The Vietnam War spanning over two decades was a complex conflict that was fought through America’s outlook of containing communism in Europe. The multifaceted perspectives of the Vietnam War and unclear military objectives caused confusion for soldiers. As a result, a majority of soldiers felt pushed into a war that they didn’t fully understand, leading to lifelong psychological consequences. Although many believe soldiers are fearless and can tolerate the trauma of war, in The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien illuminates the underlying effects of war on soldiers that aren't immediately apparent to the naked eye, highlighting the physical and emotional struggles within soldiers' daily lives. O’Brien’s use of figurative language immerses readers
The Effects People Don’t See Perspective is something that many people view differently in this world, some people may never know what it's like being put through hard circumstances and different experiences. But sometimes people never get to share or tell their perspective. This is relevant to soldiers because people never see the bravery or courage it took them in war and out of war. However, Vietnam was a civil war where it came to the needs of American assistance also why it's called the “American war” Tim’ O'Brien the author of The Things They Carried is in this war physically and emotionally, the battles he and his platoon had to go through experienced many different emotions. Tim O’Brien illustrates how soldiers go through
We believe that true, patriotic heroes go to war without cowardice or complaint. Yet, as O’Brien demonstrates in his novel, war is incomprehensible and lacks the morality we expect it to have. The Vietnam War was fought for reasons unknown to the soldiers involved as seen in the lines “The very facts were shrouded in uncertainty: Was it a civil war? A war of national liberation or simple aggression?
To them, Vietnam was just a small country in the middle of nowhere that posed no threat to the United States or world peace; because of this they moved from “village to village, without purpose, nothing won or lost” (O’Brien 1306). However, when the soldiers in this story lost a comrade with nothing to show for it, everything became pointless. A study showed that there are “strong associations between combat loss and psychological maladjustment in analysis of NVVRS ” (Currier). This is seen in “The Things They Carried”
The three movies – Platoon, Full Metal Jacket, and The Green Berets – are all movies based on the same historical event – the Vietnam war and US’s involvement in it. Yet, they all presented us with different and narrative point of view and authority figures in order to paint their individual values. The movies’ most obvious differences lie within the choice of their narrative point of view. The Green Beret, the earliest one, was directed by John Wayne and he also starred in the leading role. Wayne’s authority and influence in the 1960s was similar to the influence of Tom Hanks in the 21st Century.
The Vietnam War was a war the United States should have never been involved in. The “Domino Theory” was a direct cause of the war. The war resulted in much death; innocent civilians and young Americans were killed. The Vietnam war also resulted in rioting, distrust for the United States government, and the loss of many lives. 58,000 Americans were killed and 300,000 were wounded.
More than 58,000 Americans and over 3 million Vietnamese died in the war. Many soldiers returned home with physical and psychological injuries that changed their lives forever. The war also had a devastating impact on the Vietnamese
War can leave soldiers with life lasting consequences that steals you of your youth,innocence, purpose and mental health. These different emotional trauma that soldiers face can cause scars and permanent affect on the soldiers who served in the war. According to ptsd.va.gov 7 out of 100 veterans face ptsd or other mental issue after leaving war an only 30% of soldiers do not. In The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien the Vietnam War had stolen the brightness of American soldiers futures and lead them to have a negative impact mentally that eventually scared them for life. A few things vietnam war had stolen from Jimmy an his platoon would be resposiblity an accountability of it soldiers.