Abby G. Burke Mrs.Sargeant English 12 3 April 2023 Is Adnan Syed guilty? On January 13, 1999, an 18-year-old girl by the name of Hae Min Lee went missing. One month later, on February 9th, her body was found in Leakin Park in Baltimore, Maryland. After an autopsy, it was determined that Hae was strangled to death. Adnan Syed, Hae’s ex-boyfriend, was convicted of the murder and was sentenced to life in prison. Throughout the Serial Podcast, we are shown many different points of view of whether or not Adnan Syed was guilty or innocent. I believe that Adan Syed is guilty of murdering Hae Minn Lee because he doesn’t recall or remember much of what happened the day she went missing, and his location of where he was that day and what he was doing …show more content…
“The most incriminating piece of physical evidence against Adnan Syed was a fingerprint, or rather, a palmprint. On a map (Sarah Koenig-Serial- 128)”. There was one page ripped out from this map and come to find it was the page that showed Leakin Park and more places like their neighborhood, the malls, the school, and other places they drove 90 percent of the time. Although Adnan’s fingerprint or palm print wasn’t found on this page I can not help but wonder why this page would be ripped out. From my point of view, I see this as a very suspicious piece of evidence towards Adnan. It just so happens to be a page that shows Leaking Park, which is where Hae was buried. Now that is weird. Another thing that was brought to my attention was how Hae was killed, through manual strangulation. Adnan was an EMT and knew how to strangle someone and had the training to know how to revive someone if he needed to. Could Adnan have been heartbroken over the breakup? Could it have pushed him over the edge but no one knew? These questions circle through my head when I think about how Hae was killed knowing Adnan knew how to strangle someone. Here is a friend, Aisha, she states, “Classmate and best friend of Hae. Remembers Adnan being possessive with Hae (People Map).” If Adnan was possessive of Hae like Aisha said, he could have been so heartbroken and mad after the breakup that he wanted revenge. I am not saying this is what happened, this is just my thoughts and
Adnan Syed is a 36 year old who had been convicted of first degree murder at the age of 17 on February 28, 1999. Adnan’s friend Jay Wilds testified that he helped Adnan bury Hae Min Lee’s body back in 1999, but Adnan Syed mentions he had nothing to do with Hae’s death. Adnan was convicted with evidence of his cell phone call logs, Asia’s letters to him, and Jay’s description of the route they took during the day of Hae’s death. Adnan Syed is granted a new trial. Not only has there been mistrials, delay, and not enough evidence but also there has been a conviction towards Adnan resulting with doubt after more than 1 decade later.
Leakin park is nowhere near the school.”, as well as some more evidence from when Saad Chaudry was talking with Adnan while he was locked up and Adnan said “I have never been there. I don’t even know where it is” With this evidence it is evident that Adnan wouldn’t be able to kill Hae.
Adnan said he didn’t know what he did that day and that it felt like a normal day it being six weeks who couldn’t blame him. Except for the part of how could this be an ordinary day, Adnan claimed to be very close with Hae how would you not remember the day of her disappearance. This day should be engraved in your brain for awhile at least six weeks I would say. Adnan’s only claims was to be with Asia, Jay’s girlfriend and Hae’s friend at the time and she was nowhere to be found during the court hearings and investigation.
She discovers information that could potentially free Adnan or at the minimum give him another trial. The first reason why Adnan might be innocent is because when Hae and Adnan broke up he took it like a normal person would. He didn’t have rage in him according to his friends and the people around him.
In conclusion, Adnan is innocent because of how short the time frame of Hae’s death and school ending was, how Adnan barely can remember anything from the day of her disappearance, and because of Asia McClain’s testimony. Even though Adnan wasn’t the perfect Muslim son, he is overall innocent because at the time, everyone else was doing what Adnan was doing. He was a normal teenager, living a normal teenager life. In the end, Adnan is still very much innocent but he still faced life in prison. Unfortunately, there are times when bad things happen to good people.
Another piece of evidence that raises concerns is why Adnan wouldn’t call Hae the next day is maybe they went through a little argument and this pushed Adnan over the edge. The prosecutor in Adnan’s trial tells us “This was not a crime about love it was a crime about pride,” “he was so wounded by her,
To find Adnans whereabouts, they tapped into his cell phone records. Why did he call Jay so many times if he claimed to not know him? The cell phone records matched to the Best Buy location. Also Jay had brought up the phone booth at Best Buy, but there is no phone booth. Defense argued that the cell records can’t be used as evidence because they are sometimes inaccurate.
You can hear it, right? He's staunch.” Adnan will not hurt Hae. He really appreciates her so he says that he did not kill her. What is his motive to kill her?
This was not a crime about love, this was a crime about pride.” (serial ep 2 pg 29).The following reason of why i think he is guilty of killing hae’s is because The most incriminating piece of physical evidence against Adnan Syed was a fingerprint, or rather, a palm print. On a map.
Hae could have been murdered by a few people, but the jury for this trial settled on the killer being Hae’s ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed. Nobody can determine how he intercepted Hae, exactly where he killed her, and the exact timing
These people say that since Hae broke up with Adnan and that was enough reason to want her dead. However, Adnan was a smart kid who would realize that killing someone for breaking up with you is not a valid reason. Adnan was not hurt enough to kill Hae; he was devastated when she died and he didn't know about it when he was told. Also, they say that Adnan had enough time to kill Hae. What this opinion fails to take into account is that Asia saw Adnan at the library around the same time of the murder and she was never used in court as an alibi (Koenig, “The Best Defense is a Good Defense”).
The police said they gathered enough evidence on Adnan to prove that he was the one who killed Hae. Evidence meaning they found Adnans prints in her car, using testimony, and since Adnan could not remember where he was at the exact moment of Hae's death. He said he might have been at track practice. Koening looks at the phone records, maps out the route that Jay says they made the night of Hae's death. The phone records were correct but still a
In my opinion, I think Adnan Syed is innocent what do you think? This argumentative essay is about a serial podcast is about the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee. The person charged for her murder and sentenced to 15 years in prison was Adnan Syed but due to the evidence I do not think Adnan Syed is Guilty of the murder of Hae Min Lee. The first reason why I think Adnan Syed is innocent.
One of Adnan’s best friends Saad stated in episode 2 of the podcast named “The Breakup” that Adnan had been talking to and dating multiple other girls and was “a player” just a month after him and Hae broke up, which shows that he was in no way obsessed with Hae and therefore had no reason to want to kill her. It has been argued by Hae’s friend Aiesha that the relationship was slightly obsessive on Adnan’s part, but since the couple had to keep their relationship a secret from their families as explained earlier, they wanted to be sure they spent as much time as possible together. Although some behaviors exhibited during the relationship seemed slightly overpowering, overall Hae and Adnan had a very typical relationship and there is no proof that the breakup was anything but a normal high school split, which gives absolutely no reason for anyone to believe Adnan would have killed Hae because
This proves that Adnan was the one who killed her. Jay and Adnan both committed a serious crime. Adnan killed Hae with the help from