Albemarle Vs Moody Case Summary
I choose to discuss the Albemarle v. Moody case. This case was brought against Albemarle Paper Company by current and past African American employees. The main issues discussed in this the case was the companies seniority system and the employment ability tests utilized by the company (Albemarle Paper Co. v. Moody, 1975). According to Warren (1976), the majority of the testimony focused on a validation study completed by the organizations consulting psychologist right before the initial hearing. Validation studies determine whether employment selection tests correlate with relevant elements of work behaviors and tasks that the employees are being evaluated for (Moody v. Albemarle Paper Co., 1974). The Albemarle Paper Company argued that this …show more content…
More specifically the Supreme Court stated that the company failed to do a job analysis for the validation, and the performance criterion utilized was questionable (Warren, 1976). These practices caused African American employees to be discriminated against and caused an adverse impact by keeping them fixed in the lower paying positions (Albemarle Paper Co. v. Moody, 1975). I agree with the courts decision because adverse impact occurred because the company failed to appropriately defend its procedures and consider alternative selection methods. As a result, an imbalance in employment decisions and a differing treatment against nonwhites occured. Therefore, they are legally responsible for systematic discrimination against employees. Additionally, based on the court’s decision, the company failed to do a job analysis. A job analysis aids in determining the on the job tasks to be performed, and the knowledge, skills, and abilities required for the job (Pulakos, 2005). Furthermore, conducting a job analysis aids organizations in selecting an appropriate personnel selection method to utilize in the hiring process (Pulakos,
Matheson Flight Extenders Case Study
384 Words | 2 PagesAn employee has the right to work in a safe environment, one that is free from hazards that could lead to serious harm. Causing dissention and the hostile work environment for employees created the potential for a violent incident to occur. At the very least, the potential for a costly mistake due to duress they were under, which could have caused physical harm. The defendants’ faced discrimination and retaliation based on their race. This appalling treatment violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and by doing so, invoked the Civil Rights Act of 1991 allowing the monetary damages
Court Case Of Griggs V. Duke Power Co., 401 US
969 Words | 4 PagesFor the most part the opinion of the court in the Griggs case; held that the burden of establishing an employment requirement’s relationship to the performance of a job lies on the employer (Justia Law, 2017). Also, before Griggs, the employees or applicant had the burden of establishing a discriminatory intent behind an employment requirement (Justia Law, 2017). The Court concluded that the subtle, illegal, purpose of these requirements was a safeguard Duke’s long-standing policy to give job preference to its white employees (Justia Law,
Griggs V. Duke Power Company Selection Criteria And Analysis
600 Words | 3 PagesThe company claimed that the requirements were necessary to meet the qualifications of the position sought after, but it was later proven that those positions did not require those requirements. Mr. Griggs legal defense team claimed that “In-deed, the white employees hired before the requirements were imposed performed entirely satisfac-torily.” ( NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, 2016). Duke Power Company selection criteria was obviously flawed and wasn’t in accordance with the meaning of the Civil Rights Act. Their selection criteria limited people of a certain race and created a division among social classes.
Case Study: St. Mary's Honor Center Vs. Hicks
1603 Words | 7 PagesDiscrimination or Not As employer make decisions which affect employees’ positions, lives, and overall well-being, it is important that those decisions are made in a fair and equitable manner. Through avenues such as culture fit, position qualifications, and performance, management has a consistent and reasonable basis for adjustments, promotions, and terminations. However, when organizations make such judgements without this strong basis, they open themselves up for potential discrimination claims, litigation, and monetary judgements. One such controversial case is St. Mary’s Honor Center versus Hicks.
Ricci V. Destefano Case Study
1548 Words | 7 PagesCharles Mitchell (2013) went on to say, “by not promoting the more successful White employees, was this an act of illegal disparate treatment under Title VII (p. 43)? The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that it was illegal disparate treatment. Assisting the U.S. Supreme Court in their ruling is the established Uniform Guidelines on Employment Selection Procedures (UGESP). The guidelines state, when an employer determines that adverse impact was evident in its testing process, they shall (1) valid the procedures (test), (2) confirm the linkage to its job, (3) consider alternative testing procedures (Mitchell, p. 45).
Similarities Between Tom Robinson Trial And To Kill A Mockingbird
1719 Words | 7 PagesThe case between Tom Robinson and the Ewell’s seemed to have a predictable ending considering that it is very rare for a black man to win a case against a white man. But considering the great lawyer Tom Robinson was given, the outcome could go either way, in favor of the Ewell’s or saving Tom Robinson from going to jail. I was sitting in the front row ready to be bored to sleep by the jury but, instead I was surprised by the questions asked by the lawyers and the responses delivered by the four given testimonies from Heck Tate, Bob Ewell, Mayella Ewell and Tom Robinson.
Analyzing The Supreme Court Case Against The Lawfulness Of Affirmative Action
197 Words | 1 PagesIn the end the Supreme Court supported the lawfulness of affirmative action, but restricted its practice. The court’s ruling
Meimetea Discrimination
170 Words | 1 PagesThe general argument made by author Nathan Place and Erin Durkin in their work, “Because you’re black’: Queens Bakery fined in discrimination case”, is that people continue to discriminate against colored people. More specifically, they argue that the Meimetea’s are racist and discriminate people based on their race and won’t hire them to work for them due to that. Patty Meimetea wouldn’t hire Jamilah DaCosta because she was black and claimed that the only thing she will bring is problem. The article starts, “She was telling me all this negative stuff – she couldn’t hire me because I was black, and I would scare away her customers.”
Affirmative Action Vs Libertarianism
987 Words | 4 PagesThus, often without realizing it, the United States has practiced what, in effect, was white affirmative action on a highly generous and widespread basis, followed by a much more modest program of black affirmative action. By understanding this history, we can come to terms with the widening gap between blacks and whites noted by Lyndon Johnson and with the incapacity of many blacks to be able to make good this gap in the following four decades (Katznelson,
Employment Discrimination In Walter Mosley's Equal Opportunity
920 Words | 4 PagesIn Walter Mosley 's fictional short story, "Equal Opportunity" (1995), he describes employment discrimination through the character of Socrates Fortlow, an African American ex-convict attempting to find employment. Socrates lives in an abandoned building in Los Angeles neighborhood called Watts. He has been out of “prison eight years, fifty-eight years old, and ready to start life over again,” (Mosley 1). Socrates faces several conflicts, attempting to gain employment, because of his (1) age, (2) race, and (3) where he lives. He has to travel far to look for a job because everyone on his side of town, especially, Crenshaw and Washington, both store owners in Watts, knew that he collected bottles and cans for money and “they would not hire
Apush Dbq Gilded Age
1126 Words | 5 PagesTherefore, the reader can tell that the workers are advocating for themselves and aiming to create political change that treats workers more fair. This document is written from the point of view of leaders in the NAACP. This is significant because their interest is promoting and ensuring the advancement of colored people, and they believe that this policy is bringing them in the opposite direction. Sadly, segregation wasn’t the only problem in businesses. During the Gilded Age and the beginning of the Progressive movement, businesses were also preventing the formation of unions, which removed the employee’s main protection.
Earl Hutchinson Discrimination
250 Words | 1 PagesOne can’t help but wonder why? In his 2009 essay about discrimination and illegal immigration, Earl Hutchinson, an African American author who focuses on political and racial issues in America, considers the current stereotype of black people in America and how it impacts hiring discrimination. He shares that
Tennesse Valley Authority Case Summary
552 Words | 3 Pages3. Why did the plaintiff’s disparate treatment claim succeed? What was the evidence that the employer’s reliance on interview scores was a pretext for race discrimination? A complaint of disparate treatment can be proved if the plaintiff could prove that a candidate had been disfavored and others had been favored because of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin by the employer. (P.222) TVA's selection committee established an interview scores were the interview subjective criteria has a weight of 70% and the technical expertise (skills) would account 30%.
Argumentative Essay: The American Dream
908 Words | 4 PagesOnly 75 percent of blacks have received post-high school education, compared to 85 percent of whites. Not surprisingly, blacks on average also make less money than whites” (Philip M. Deutsch). It’s unjust that people of color are treated as inferior to white people, and it is that kind of social issue that interferes with the liberties of all Americans of
Summary Of Mis-Education Of The Negro By Carter Godwin Woodson
1158 Words | 5 PagesThis issue can be related to the story cited in the book; whereby, Woodson refers to the black employees who questioned the authority of an African-American
More about Albemarle Vs Moody Case Summary
Matheson Flight Extenders Case Study
384 Words | 2 PagesCourt Case Of Griggs V. Duke Power Co., 401 US
969 Words | 4 PagesGriggs V. Duke Power Company Selection Criteria And Analysis
600 Words | 3 PagesCase Study: St. Mary's Honor Center Vs. Hicks
1603 Words | 7 PagesRicci V. Destefano Case Study
1548 Words | 7 PagesSimilarities Between Tom Robinson Trial And To Kill A Mockingbird
1719 Words | 7 PagesAnalyzing The Supreme Court Case Against The Lawfulness Of Affirmative Action
197 Words | 1 PagesMeimetea Discrimination
170 Words | 1 PagesAffirmative Action Vs Libertarianism
987 Words | 4 PagesEmployment Discrimination In Walter Mosley's Equal Opportunity
920 Words | 4 PagesApush Dbq Gilded Age
1126 Words | 5 PagesEarl Hutchinson Discrimination
250 Words | 1 PagesTennesse Valley Authority Case Summary
552 Words | 3 PagesArgumentative Essay: The American Dream
908 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of Mis-Education Of The Negro By Carter Godwin Woodson
1158 Words | 5 Pages