People identify one another in a variety of different ways. Whether it’s their skills, their features, or what they say, identifying people can be difficult, especially while the rest of society preaches the opposite. In the events of the past as significant as war, society’s view of the enemy poses many burdens for the soldiers. One of the greatest war novels of all time All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque, starts to draw out these hardships of the war for the readers. The most common and most impactful trial war soldiers face is the a vague notion of the enemy. Embedded in that notion is a purposeful and problematic lack of humanity. A solution to this complication at hand lies within the identification of the enemy to …show more content…
As simple as this task, it takes its toll on every recruit due to the internal battle with their humanity. The character who readers follow Paul Baumer, represents complications the simple task entails. While fighting along the front line, Paul recognizes that “[they’ve] become wild beasts” (113) through the ferocious warfare. As an act of resistance and “with the butt of his rifle Kat smashes to pulp the face of one of the wounded machine-gunners. [They] bayonet the others before they have time to get out their bombs”(116). In this particular occurrence, Paul does not identify the enemy he attacks. He merely mentions his enemy’s face without specificity. By describing the man only as “a wounded machine-gunner,” Paul represents the lack of humanity created when soldiers view the enemy as nothing more than a pawn in war. Paul fails to distinguish his enemies making his attack much more vicious. The more monstrous the attacks, the more effect these blood bath’s have on the soldier's' mental conditions. While the wounded man remains faceless, Paul’s decreasing humanity becomes very evident. His humanity only returns once the enemy starts to be …show more content…
Through the growth of his rediscovered humanity, very humane feelings such as sympathy are revealed. Sympathy comes from the recognition that both sides of war are more similar than they care to admit. While bedridden in a hospital, Paul wrestled with the thoughts that “a man cannot realize that above such shattered bodies there are still human faces in which life goes its daily round. And this is only one hospital, one single station; there are hundreds of thousands in Germany, hundreds of thousands in France, hundreds of thousands in Russia. A hospital alone is war”(263). After the traumatic experiences he suffered through, Paul made mental growth in the human aspect. He figured out that “there are still human faces” even in his enemies. Further in this realization he sympathizes with the rest of the wounded soldiers stuck in similar hospitals all over the enemy lines. This identification attaches Paul to the enemy, positively affecting his mental condition. He recognizes that he is not as drastically different as he thought which ultimately changes his outlook on the war. By connecting himself to the enemy, it’s as if he is fighting his comrades and it is this revelation which was only feasible through the effects of recognition and identification with the
Kemmerich, Paul’s classmate, is visited by his fellow soldiers at the hospital after he wounded his thigh. He states to Paul that “they have amputated my leg”, and as Paul tries to comfort him, Kemmerich explains how he “wanted to become a head-forester once” (Remarque 27-28). After being incited through nationalistic pressures by his teacher, Kemmerich enlists in the army only to lose a part of himself. Kemmerich’s lose and the cold pointlessness of his eventual death disillusions the idea that there is honor in war. Remarque also shows opposition to the war later on in the book when he illustrates a scene of soldiers starting to question the actions of the higher authorities and pondering the reasons for war.
Paul and Albert were guarding an abandoned village when they got struck with bombs and got injured. They were taken to a catholic hospital where paul is noticing all the people who were hurt and dying in this hospital. “I am young, i am twenty years old: yet i know nothing of life but despair, death, fear, and fatuous superficiality cast over an abyss of sorrow” ( Remarque, ch10, pg 146). Paul has lost his sense of identity due to war because he is a young man who hasn't experienced life outside of war. He can’t live a normal life because of war and he can't experience what life is outside of war.
The Struggles of a Soldier The brutalities of war are shown through a soldiers experience through a war. In the book All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque tells the story of a group of friends in World War 1. Remarque uses the protagonist, Paul, to display the brutalities of war by experiencing some of them himself. Brutalities of war are expressed through Paul’s experience of the war harming soldiers by negatively impacting their physical bodies, making it hard for soldiers to reintegrate themselves into society and, damaging their psychological health.
Paul is constantly plagued with depression during his time at home and mistakes many sounds as bombardments. No matter how hard he tries, Paul can’t find a way to fit back into the civilian life, his life as a soldier is the only thing he can cling to as a person. As the war goes on the, Germans start lose. The soldier’s conditions continued to declined,
"This book is to be neither an accusation nor a confession, and least of all an adventure, for death is not an adventure to those who stand face to face with it. It will try simply to tell of a generation of men who, even though they may have escaped its shells, were destroyed by the war" (Remarque 1). The author of this book, Erich Maria Remarque discusses the reality of war and the detrimental affects it holds on our hard working soldiers. During the war era, survival comes first followed by comfort. Erich does an excellent job in showing the context and severe brutality used in the war front accompanied with the violence and terror used.
The inhumanity that he witnesses makes Paul conscious of the animal-like suffrage that the soldiers experience throughout their time in the war. To Baumer, the Russian soldiers “are so feeble” (Remarque 193) and have lost their sense of humanity as they are the “pitilessness of men” (Remarque 193). However, Paul can relate to the men as they are all soldiers fighting for a cause that they do not necessarily believe in, bringing out their inner beast in order to survive. He then begins to realize that the more he finds connections and a sense of
This is evidence that All Quiet on the Western Front is an incredibly engaging book. Many of these inquiries are centered on the willingness for one society to subordinate the desires and values of another in their own self-interest. Frequently gruesome detail coupled with Paul Bäumer’s emotions brings the reader into the shoes of one who has the misfortune of having to kill their own species. The actions of Bäumer bring to light the fact that each soldier on both sides of the conflict is a human-being. Bäumer’s comrades frequently pose rhetorical questions regarding the reasons behind their
When soldiers enlist in the war, they know they might have to kill people. Even though the soldiers are supposed to kill them, Paul realized he would have to live with it for the rest of his life. This also made his perception change on how he saw the Russians. On his leave, he went up to the fence where the Russians were and thought about how, “their life is obscure and guiltless; -if I could know more of them, what their names are, how they live, what they are waiting for, what their burdens are, then my emotions would have an object and might become sympathy” (Remarque 193). By knowing more of their lives, he would see them as more human.
Empathy vs. Dehumanization is depicted throughout All Quiet on the Western Front by showing how Paul can be both empathetic and indifferent on the battlefield, such as when he pitied a French soldier he wounded, or when he was reflecting on how a word of command could make Russians his enemies. Furthermore, on page 144 of All Quiet on the Western Front, Paul is hesitant to kill a wounded French soldier and states that "The eyes follow me. I am powerless to move so long as they are there." In this instance, empathy is represented through Paul feeling remorse for the soldier and Paul's lack of response. His emotions can be best explained as empathy, because his body freezes from guilt when noticing the scared soldier watching him.
The war has numerous positive effects on Paul. War makes a soldier more confident and experienced. Paul’s soft and quiet personality is contrasted by his strong and rough behaviour which he was forced to adapt into the war surroundings. “The shelling can be heard distinctly… They are beginning an hour too soon. According to us they start punctually at ten o’clock” (Remarque, 53).
I was a soldier, and now I am nothing but an agony for myself, for my mother, for everything that is so comfortless and without end. I ought never to have come on leave. " Paul cannot connect with his mother, father, or any of his personal possessions because he realizes that he is not the same person. He has to live in fear of the dangers of war, not of the superficial worries of his past. He has formed a new family, and eventually as all his friends die, he becomes satisfied with his own impending death because he knows that although his entire time has been filled with struggles, he will no longer have to fight and will be at peace.
War often has drastic and lasting effects on individuals; the violence and horror ages soldiers mentally and physically. World War I was a violent and distressing war; men came home with mental illnesses and never were fully able to sink back into society. Through these lasting effects common civilians with no affiliation were unaware to the consequences. In All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Remarque investigates the damaging effects of war on an individual’s identity using Paul Bäumer as a representation for all soldiers; he draws specific attention to the continuing loss of purpose and ability to relate to the rest of society.
Throughout the story Paul shows that he cares about his comrades by protecting them from the dangers of war, and he also displays that he will guide them in war. Paul uses his skills of intelligence to guide his team in the trenches and at the front, and he passes on his knowledge and tricks of war to the new recruits. Not many soldiers have all of these qualities, which makes Paul stand out more than his comrades. Even today some men don't express the passion and leadership Paul shows in All Quiet on the Western Front, which brings up the fact that the war needs more men like Paul. To sum up, Paul is an honest and true man who will always be there for his comrades when needed, and he is a man the troops are proud to say is a patriotic
During the rest of Paul’s time at the hospital, many people come and go, and on one occasion a man who exhibited deranged behavior after being injured was transported into the same room as Albert and Paul. On one occasion, he even attempted to stab himself with a fork to take away all the pain and madness. The time at the hospital is just one of many examples of the men viewing horrific scenes and experiencing horrid actions. By knowing these truths it can help end the glorification of war and give to the people the facts versus what one is spoon-fed by politician and
Moreover, commonly, soldiers are exhilarated to finally go home after long periods of time at the front, and the men dread when they have to return to battle. However, in Paul’s case, he desires to return to the front, rather than staying in his home town and seeing his mother in pain, he yearns to feel numb again. Therefore, Paul is in “agony” because before going on leave, he was hopeless and had no will to live, thus making him a better soldier. Although, after visiting his mother and sister, he has rediscovered a reason to survive, making it harder to go back. Moreover, the word, “comfortless,” illustrates how Paul feels isolated even at home, he feels little comfort where he grew up.