The American Identity.
When one thinks about the American Identity, one would automatically assume the virtues life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are what fulfils this definition. The American identity is defined solely on freedom. The freedom to do and say as one pleases. The freedom to act upon what one feels is right, also known as the Laws of Nature. These are not only personal rights, but the first amendment of the Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights was set forth by governing authority, and as an American, citizens must submit to. But citizens also have the right to choose not to submit to higher authority if it was to contradict one’s personal beliefs. To the governing authorities, one would be acting out in disobedience, to
…show more content…
Which decision is in the wrong? Although authority and disobedience complement each other, abused power in authority creates disobedience.
Disobedience occurs when authority lacks social order. When one thinks of ideal authority, one may think of a personal figure. Ideal authority is well qualified and is always working for the common good of society. Ideal authority is responsible for the actions taken realizing the decisions made affect everyone in the surroundings. Ideal authority is understanding and interactive, always willing to listen to ideas that may be reasonable. An ideal authority is powerful, but does take advantage of that power. In “The Declaration of Independence,” Thomas Jefferson expresses the importance of equality and personal freedom. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.” (Jefferson, pp. 108). This proves that equality is important no matter the authority level, all citizens were given the same amount of rights and freedom to express those rights in ways that feel personally correct.
…show more content…
Personal beliefs shape the way a person thinks and affects the way a person comes to a decision. When authority sets forth rules that must be followed, a decision is made whether to abide by them or to simply disobey them. Disobedience is an act of faith. In “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,” Mark Twain expresses the hesitation between doing what is right versus doing what is wrong. “Then I thought a minute, and says to myself, hold on,--s’pose you’d done right and give Jim up, would you feel better than what you do now? No, says I, I’d feel bad—I’d feel just the same way I do now” (Twain, pp. 106). This quote conveys the emotions Huck feels after doing what is right according to his personal beliefs, versus what is right according to the authority. Personal beliefs cause disobedience because they are solidified, whereas authority is only temporary. If authority proposes laws that contradicts one’s personal beliefs disobedience occurs because it is one’s right to personally choose what right and what is wrong. Although acting out in disobedience may cause consequences, it is important to stay true to personal beliefs because they allow freedom of choice rather than being forced to do something one feels is
Americans from different time periods see American identity differently. Different effects in the time period may change your views. Back when there were slaves people thought you had to be white. Back when my grandma was in school she said it meant you 're “free to make your own choices”(mary eaton). Finally our generation may think differently from that.
Thoreau would respond, “Under a government which imprisons any unjustly, the true place for a just man is also a prison” (Thoreau 552). Thoreau believes that if one has to break the law to follow the truth, then that is what one must do. There is no reason for anyone to conform to society if there is no truth there. “The virtue in most request is conformity” (Emerson 421). Explained perfectly by Ralph Waldo Emerson, society wants you to conform to the current way of doing things.
While Huck and Jim were traveling, a group of white men stopped them; they were looking for runaway slaves. Huck stated “... [I] says to myself, hold on; s’pose you’d a done right and give Jim up, would you felt better than what you do now… [no] I’d feel bad…” (67). Since the men were looking for slaves, Huck knew he didn’t want to betray Jim; Jim was one of the best friends Huck could ask for.
The Ideals of the Declaration: Which is Most Important? There are four ideals in the Declaration of Independence. The American Government became independent in July 1776. Five men wrote the Declaration of Independence, the main one being Thomas Jefferson.
Disobedience can be defined as failure or refusal to obey rules or someone in authority. Disobedience can also be defined as causing a disarray within society and causing a shift in social normals to more perfectly suit the conditions of a community at a given time, in the sense that it promotes the questions of poor social norms, and the change in our mortal standards and by the progressive though of one’s own mind. Oscar Wilde argues that it can allow society to progress and to allow science about different or certain topics to be broken or misplaced, and the way that it counter our social norms instead of disobedience leading to be a negative human and societal trait in our very way of life. He also argues about how disobedience can lead
Huck decides to act on his morals rather than be held captive by society; Huck believes that he has to act in the best interest of Jim and does not consider what society believes is acceptable behavior. By stating that he will “go to hell,” Huck reiterates what he promises Jim in the beginning- that he rather be a “low down abolitionist”; these statements combined supports his feelings to protect Jim from society. When Huck and Tom get back to the house, Huck states, “...it don’t make no difference whether you do right or wrong, a person’s conscience ain’t got no
“That, to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.” (Jefferson 120). This man believed the same as hobbes, that there needed to be something to control and regulate what was needed for a population to live
Today we are all called to enact on our own civil disobedience when we are faced with injustice and unfair laws, we are called to make a stand and a declaration to stand up for what we believe
Intolerance to injustice stands as a key component of American identity. If authority upholds just action, ethical progress can be made. This progress includes authority’s principled decision making and respect for its citizens. Progress is forward or onward movement toward a destination of nationwide justice. An individual’s civil disobedience to unjust authority promotes positive progress within America.
As this change in Huck begins to happen, Huck struggles with deciding whether to help Jim, going against what he has been taught, or to turn him in, doing what Huck believes, is the right thing. Huck feels compassion for Jim, but he thinks that helping him is directly defying God. “it [Huckleberry Finn] is an image of the conflict between social and personal virtues, between, on the one hand, people 's associations as social concepts and social products and, on the other, their associations simply as human beings”(Ostrom, 164). Huck grapples with his personal feelings, and what society has taught him. Jim is seen by most as simply a slave who is inferior.
The American person has no true ideals, or beliefs that make him or her up. Americans are free to believe in what they want, think what they want, preach what they want, and most importantly say what they want . Authors such as Ralph Waldo Emerson, Frederick Douglass, and Walt Whitman show in their texts such as “Self-Reliance” , The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass , and “I Celebrate Myself” that there is no true definition of the American identity. The American identity can be seen in the many aspects of peoples lives, and a a quality that many Americans portray is the ability to have individual thoughts and emotions as well as the capability to not conform to society because they stand up for their own individual rights. A
Bertrand Russell, a famous philosopher, once said “as soon as we abandon our own reason, and are content to rely on authority, there is no end for our troubles”. This quote reveals how authority can completely make our lives more difficult and unsuitable to live in. This symbolizes that authority may overpowers us, and how we are naturally prone to follow power people. Once we follow an authority figure we tend to lose hope in our dreams. Losing contact in our dreams pushes us to focus on reality.
Huck has been burned with the idea that he is to blame for Jim’s escape. Huck ultimately feels guilty because he knows he has not done wrong but he has no reason not to believe what society thinks because he was only taught one way. Huck imagines an alternate scenario, thinking “s’pose [he]’d’ a’ done right and give Jim up, would [he] felt better... No…[he'd] feel bad” (91). Huck is aware that the right decision based on society is to give up Jim.
This transition is the result of the extended period of time that the two spend together, which allows Huck to look past the differences that he has been taught to observe for his entire life and view Jim for what he is; a fellow man. By the end of this passage, Huck’s resolve to do right by Jim is so strong that he is willing to suffer eternal damnation rather than betray Jim. Perhaps Huck’s most important statement in this passage is “Alright then, I’ll go to hell”; here he decides he’s willing to go to hell for eternity rather than causing Jim to return to his life as a slave. At first Huck just thought of Jim the property of another person, a good to be bought and sold regardless of any evidence that he was a human being. As they travel together, this viewpoint is gradually weakened by examples of Jim’s humanity, culminating in a model shift that goes against everything Huck has been taught about the societal status of a
Bruno Bettelheim once said, “Punishment may make us obey the orders we are given, but at best it will only teach an obedience to authority, not a self-control which enhances our self-respect.” More often than not, those surrounded by rules feel pressured to adhere to them due to the fear of repercussions. Even so, it is not guaranteed people will comply. Sometimes, being bound by rules can only make one feel rebellious.