ipl-logo

Analysis Of David Hume's Argument From Design

1204 Words5 Pages

Argument from Design
The argument from design builds its foundation on the following premise. There is evidence of design, or purpose, in the natural world. Therefore, a creator created the natural world. Despite its nature that has lead this type of logic to be a default in several cultures, this argument is unsuccessful in proving a creator—which is its goal. Many of Hume’s objections to the argument may be brushed off by those who are blindly religious and take offense, but many, from the same pool of objections, are simply logical and commonsensical, while some are too rigid.
This a posteriori argument for design comes from the desire to make a second case for God. The first was the ontological argument, or cosmological argument, which attempts to use pure reason to …show more content…

This leads to the discussion of the four sources or order that Hume develops: intelligence, instinct, vegetation, and generation. He found that all things he observed in the natural world were driven by one of the four. A fundamental source is one of the four sources that drives all other sources. For example, if instinct were the fundamental source, the natural world would be a result of divine instinct.
Playing off of that, the argument from design relies on intelligence being fundamental. That means that for the teleological argument to even begin with a sure foot, intelligence must be the source of all other sources of order. An assumption like that renders the argument weak already.
Another weakness Hume points out through Philo is that this argument is incredibly human centric. The argument that indirectly tries to prove that man was made in God’s own image does the contrary. Humans of course would rather be called a product of intelligent design than a result of divine instinct. As far as determining his origin, man generally prefers intelligence to instinct, growth, or

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Argument From Design By William Paley

    784 Words  | 4 Pages

    The conclusion, thus, is that Nature was created by intelligent design. This argument is the centerpiece of Paley’s “Argument from Design”, as he spends the previous two sections deliberately lining the specifics of a watch, the clear order a watch follows, and that there must be a creator for a watch. In this section, he puts forward an analogy that nature is like a watch in that both have specific orders and contrivances which thus mean that both were created by an intelligent

    Read More

  • Hambourger's Argument For The Existence Of God Essay

    829 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hambourger’s argument from design argues for the existence of god based on the perceived evidence of deliberate design in the world/universe. To further elaborate on the concepts he uses, Hambourger uses three main concepts; determinism, chance, and mere hap. Hambourger’s argument from design claims that though many things occur by chance, there are some things which we cannot simply accept to have happened by chance, and must therefore have some common explanation in the causal chain of events connecting the two events. For instance the universe is created by many states of affairs coming together. If some slight changes had occurred, the end result could have been vastly different than it currently is.

    Read More

  • William Paley's The Teleological Argument

    802 Words  | 4 Pages

    Again premise three says ‘Generally, when effects resemble each other, their causes do as well’. In Hume’s objection it says if two things are exactly alike, then they are general caused by things that are exactly alike. The world is not exactly like a machine though, some parts may be comparable but there are immense differences. One example from class was a crater created by a bomb and a crater created by a meteorite. Another example is a forest fire; it could be created by a lighting strike or by human fault.

    Read More

  • Paley's Argument Analysis

    846 Words  | 4 Pages

    William Paley’s argument from design starts off with a man seeing a watch on the side of the road. The argument is whether or not someone designed the watch, or if the watch randomly just showed up there itself by random chance. He makes an analogy of watches and humans. He says that since there is a designer that made the watch, there must be a designer that made us humans. The reason that he compares watches to humans is that is because they are both complex and have parts that work very well together.

    Read More

  • David Hume: Atheist Philosopher

    2021 Words  | 9 Pages

    When it comes to Hume’s theories, specifically the principles of ideas, we can evaluate them based on their identities. Out of the three associative principles, “causation is the strongest and the only one that takes us beyond our senses” (Morris and Charlotte). Causation establishes a link between the present and the past and this can be compared to the relation between the cause and effect. Hume tries to show the ways we associate ideas, and the reasons why it’s supposed to stay that way. He doesn’t focus on explaining why we do it this way, he automatically assumes that humans understand this concept.

    Read More

  • Teleological Argument For The Existence Of God

    1569 Words  | 7 Pages

    First, Paley’s so-called design that attempt to reason to God's existence from demonstrating the order of the whole Universe and its regularities or laws of nature. The attempt to reason to God's existence from the orderliness indicated in living organisms, their complexity, and being well-suited for the tasks of reproduction and survival. Paley's Natural Theology gives elaborate details of a local design argument. Hume work through his three characters presented his criticisms, but Cleanthes showed strong arguments that were similar in a way to Paley’s to counter his Hume’s explanations. In my opinion, Hume accepts the point that design argument is more likely that the universe had been designed and there was an intelligent designer.

    Read More

  • Teleological Argument

    518 Words  | 3 Pages

    The teleological argument, or otherwise known as the argument from design and the intelligent design argument, is a philosophical theory put forward by William Paley with its final premise of proving that god exists. The argument includes a handful of elements, however close to the fringe yet within the margin, of logic in order to assist the facilitation of accepting the premise as a truth. As we examine the argument, and its implications in the context in which it was given, we can begin to see the boundary of logic become veiled and intuition and assumptions start to interpose. The teleological argument is most commonly started with a supposition parable dealing with a watch, so lets start out with that. Suppose you are walking down along a river and along the way you spot something in the dirt.

    Read More

  • Paley Natural Theology Essay

    1133 Words  | 5 Pages

    Natural Theology, written by Paley is an argument of the design of the universe. This paper argues that there is an intelligent designer who designed the universe. His argument is a posteriori and inductive because it is based on sense experience and conclusions were drawn from what our senses tell us. Paley’s argument is based on three fundamental observations: the complexity of the biological world, the regularity of the orbits of ‘heavenly bodies’ and of the seasons of the year and finally, the purpose of a designer seen in this complexity and purpose. To explain his argument, Paley compares the universe to a watch and uses analogies to explain his argument.

    Read More

  • The Design Argument For The Existence Of God

    221 Words  | 1 Pages

    The design argument is an argument for the existence of God, and proving his existence is the major source of debate in the creation hypothesis. Rowe compared the universe to a pocket watch, with all parts arranged perfectly causing the other to move (Rowe, 2007, p. 57).   The design argument employs analogical reasoning to understand the way we are inter-connected to nature and the universe. In my opinion, the universe is similar to a machine, a teleological system, working in grand harmony for a purpose, .

    Read More

  • Cosmological Argument

    998 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Teleological argument was created by William Paley, human artifacts are products of intelligent design for purpose. The universe resembles these human artifacts. Therefore, the universe is probably a product of intelligent design. But the universe is vastly more complex and gigantic that a human artifact. Therefore, there probably is a powerful and vastly intelligent designer who designed the universe (Pojman 32).

    Read More

  • Cosmological Vs Ontological Argument

    1444 Words  | 6 Pages

    There have been an innumerable amount of arguments for the existence of God for hundreds of years. Some have become much more popular due to their merit, and their ability to stay relevant through changing times. Two arguments in particular that have been discussed for a very long time are the ontological and cosmological arguments. Each were proposed in the period of the high middle ages by members of the Roman Catholic Church. They each have been used extensively by many since their introduction.

    Read More

  • The Design Argument: Does God Exist

    965 Words  | 4 Pages

    Philosopher David Hume’s argument against William Paley’s addresses the most common criticism in why Paley is wrong. Hume’s points out two major flaws in Paley’s argument that there is a creator of the universe. The first argument is the lack of evidence, in which he states that the existence of such a creator can only be proved through the a pattern of observation, which there is no pattern for. This addresses how without any form of pattern through observation that it is difficult to make a correlation between the universe and its designer (Speaks). Secondly he argumes that there are limitations to the design argument that Paley does not address.

    Read More

  • Descartes And Paley's Argument Analysis

    925 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hume’s response to this is through is character Philo, Philo said that we should not judge the attributes of god on something like Paley proposes. Philo argues that we cannot judge the entirety of the universe on one single part of nature because nature has an infinite number of springs of principle. Also that we cannot base God on our

    Read More

  • The Cosmological Argument For The Existence Of God

    997 Words  | 4 Pages

    Two of the most important are Charles Darwin and David Hume. Hume criticizes the Argument from Design in his book Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion and Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. Hume is going to developed a case against the Argument from Design in where he is going to argue. We cannot validly reason from earthly parallels to the Universe as a whole. The order in nature could equally well result from the intrinsic properties of matter itself.

    Read More

  • Review Of Samuel Clark's Argument For The Existence Of God

    1137 Words  | 5 Pages

    According to Samuel Clark’s argument, things exist the way they are in order to show the existence of God. All things need an explanation for their existence according to Aristotle. For instance, why the earth is spherical, why different places experience different climatic patters, why different geographical areas have different time zones and why do creatures that are in found in different places have features that enable them survive in such conditions. These considerations lead to a belief that there must be a cause for the universe (Rowe 67). At the same time, this cause needs to be extremely perfect for the universe to align itself in its current manner.

    Read More

More about Analysis Of David Hume's Argument From Design

Open Document