ipl-logo

Analysis Of Maria Montessori And Colin Powell

877 Words4 Pages

Children and their education are one of the if not most important factors for our future as a country and as individuals. Maria Montessori and Colin Powell take stances on opposing views when it comes to structure such as desks or basic learning opportunities in the classroom, to teacher intervention when it comes to helping a child.
Maria Montessori and Colin Powell have contrasting views when it comes to matters regarding education and structure. Colin Powell uses the quote “The kids who didn’t have that structure or minding in the beginning,... and they start to realize … and they’re on their way to jail or on they’re on their way to being dropouts” to directly support his claim that without any layout of structure in the students life, …show more content…

Montessori hopes this will connect with the readers more sensitive or humane sides in hopes that the reader will agree with her philosophy that is pushed all throughout the text In reference to how children should be raised. “What we all desire for yourself.. not to be disturbed..find hindrances.. this is what we need for happy companionship” Marias claims that children are due respect just as us adults. Finally, Maria and Colin may have opposing views when it comes to teaching kids, but they can still be connected with the others …show more content…

Powell and almost puts a superiorital tone in the atmosphere.Powell kills all individuality by saying ‘’Put them in Ranks.. All wear the same clothes.. cut off their hair so they look the same “ This supports powells philosophy by almost undermining the youngers, I think Powell uses his age as a bargaining tool to almost feel superior to the kids.In contrast, Montessori seems to claim an opposing view, one example being Montessori feels very passionately about teacher intervention, she mentions in the story a teacher needs to about interacting with a student so as “without letting him or her feel her presence.. but may never be an obstacle”. She says this to stress the importance of the balance a teacher must keep between themselves and the student. As stated over and over throughout the text, Powell claims that kids cannot function without structure. In the phrase “He does look good because kids need structure” Powell seems to highlight that a student looks good, only because he has structure, and without it, he would have nothing. In short, Montessori and Powell can have contrasting yet still passionate views towards

Show More
Related

  • Believability Of The Students In The Short Story Clover By Billy Lombardo

    316 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the short story "Clover" by Billy Lombardo, Graham made a plethora of actions towards the students, and toward other educators comments, and the author made a great deal of unique characteristics in the classroom. The author amplified the believability of the story by telling the students about his house, and how it is going which was stated in paragraph six. He also accurately brought the connections, and happy interactions in paragraph four, that were explaining how that the students, and Mr. Graham have already discussed the subject. The author shows that Mr. Graham has picked up on recurring events, such as how the girls meet in paragraph two.

    Read More

  • Colin Powell's Contributions

    161 Words  | 1 Pages

    Colin Powell’s choices directly affected the outcome of his life. Colin Powell was smart and served our country many different ways he liked working for the United States Of America. Colin Powell likes the USA better than Jamaica. Colin Powell served in our country. Others might think that he was an immigrant or that many other people that get shot don 't get famous.

    Read More

  • Still Separate, Still Unequal

    650 Words  | 3 Pages

    But we don’t have that. I wish that this school was the most beautiful school in the whole why world.” (p.206) I can’t help but want these things for these children too. I want those kids to have the most beautiful school in the whole why world and I find it perplexing, but I suppose not uncommon, that they do not. We spend so much time trying to circumvent these problems without really acknowledging them, without getting to the heart of it.

    Read More

  • What Is The Theme Of Death At An Early Age By Jonathan Kozol

    1246 Words  | 5 Pages

    Kozol talks about how he shared an auditorium with 120 other children and how it was impossible for the children to hear him. However, because the children were raised in such a way, they assumed that it was their fault that they could not hear Mr. Kozol talking. For example, Mr. Kozol states, “I remember several incidents of this kind when a pupil whom I knew for certain to be innocent was actually brought around to the point of saying “Yes I did it” or “Yes I was lying” simply from the force of a white adult’s accusation,” (55). This was so sad to read because a child should be excited to go to school, to learn new things, and to interact with their peers, not be afraid of those who are teaching them. Another notable part of the book is when Mr. Kozol talks about what the building looks like and the conditions of some of the materials that they use.

    Read More

  • Environment In Sonny's Blues And The Lesson

    963 Words  | 4 Pages

    Sylvia explains why Miss Moore wants to help children’s education, “She’d been to college and said it was only right that she should take responsibility for the young one’s education, and she not even related by marriage or blood” (304). Miss Moore wants to teach the children because she wants them to become aware of what is happening in their society. While they are in the toy store, Miss Moore asks the children what they think about their trip and one of the children, Sugar says, “that this is not much of a democracy if you ask me. Equal chance to pursue happiness means an equal crack at the dough, don’t it?” (309).

    Read More

  • Seven Lesson Schoolteacher

    575 Words  | 3 Pages

    The essay, The Seven Lesson Schoolteacher, by John Taylor Gatto addresses educational curriculum with a cynical truth that transpires around the United States. His brutal honesty grasps the reader by using common sense and a hint of sarcasm to appeal to humor. The main point of his argument in my perception, states that we must develop children to be critical thinkers and not always agree with authority. By allowing the schooling in a child’s development expecting them to not question an adult’s words does lead to a population that has accepted being dumbed down. Following what has been indicated, a direct quote positions people deprived forever of finding the center of their own special genius (Gatto, part III, pars 3).

    Read More

  • What Are The Rhetorical Strategies Used By Florence Kelley Ap Language

    309 Words  | 2 Pages

    Florence Kelley uses many rhetorical devices and strategies to convey her message about child labor and working conditions for women in the early 1900’s. Kelley uses each device effectively to produce a very powerful strategy. This strategy convinces the reader about her view and persuades them to take action. The beginning of the speech starts with a statistic, “two million children under the age of sixteen years are earning their bread.”

    Read More

  • 'Universal Pre-K: This Whole Thing Is A Scam'

    608 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the year 2013, President Barack Obama explained in his State of The Union Address that he would like to take the initiative to give every child the chance to have early on education. Despite many people agreeing that something should be done to help boost the education system in America, there were also argument that came up with this idea being presented. Some of these people argued that by going through with this idea, money would be taken away from taxpayers as well as the government. The supporters of this project state that by going through with this idea, this project could have outstanding effects on the children in their near future. The main driving factors that make these two sides so opposite is the targeted people that will be affected.

    Read More

  • Standardized Education In Charles Baxter's 'Gryphon'

    1005 Words  | 5 Pages

    Miss Ferenczi not only tries to instill a love of learning, but teach them to think about things complexly. Miss Ferenczi says things like, “’Do you think,’ she asked, ‘that anyone is going to be hurt by a substitute fact?’ … ‘Will the plants on the windowsill be hurt?’… ‘Your dogs and cats, or your moms and dads?’

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Every Kid Needs A Champion By Rita Pierson

    459 Words  | 2 Pages

    Rita Pierson, an educator of 40 years, as was her parents were as well as her grandparents. She appeals to educators on the issue of creating relationships with students, rather than just teaching a lesson she embraces each individual as a concerned educator. Being in a room full of educators means that she has to appeal to them in a way they want to learn. She does this by using powerful anecdotes to engage the audience. In the speech Every Kid Needs a Champion by Rita Pierson, she speaks to introduce, convince, and persuade educators that they should form relationships with their students due to higher academic achievement as well as self-esteem; she continues to use many rhetorical devices including soaps, ethos, pathos, and logos to achieve her argument.

    Read More

  • Boy Who Was Raised Dog

    446 Words  | 2 Pages

    Does he consistently come back to this idea in each case he examines? Explain using examples from the various chapters. In many of the sessions Dr. Perry has with the children, he describes doing a coloring activity with them. How does this help his relationship with the children?

    Read More

  • Strengths And Disadvantages Of Reggio Emilia

    810 Words  | 4 Pages

    In Reggio Emilia approach, there are many strengths as it supports children that a child’s image is viewed as having rights and not just needs and child has been viewed as beautiful, competent, powerful, curious, creative as well as full of ambitious desires and potentials. In addition, it supports children’s individual differences and needs, documentation that Reggio teachers collect about their students and a mix of long- and short term projects which provide students with a deeper understanding of the subject matter. While the strength in Montessori curriculum is children are 5 prepared for the real world, where they work side by side with people of all ages, they develop self-discipline, independence and analytical thinking, all materials in a Montessori classroom have a proper place, and it is the responsibility of each student to properly store their materials when they are done to maintain order, independence is greatly emphasized and focuses on individual intelligences. The weakness point in Montessori and Reggio Emilia Curriculum: There are some weakness point in Reggio Emilia approach such as this approach puts a lot of emphasis on the importance of large space as is considered educational, Reggio Emilia schools are found in wealthy countries and are attended by children from wealthy families while the poor cannot opt for the Reggio Emilia approach, public schools get limited funding while private schools mostly focus on results and not process and also the

    Read More

  • Autism Classroom Observation Report Sample

    663 Words  | 3 Pages

    The teacher reacts with the children to keep them interested and moving. Some of the time the children just likes to sit in the teacher 's lap and not get involved with the other children. One day, Mrs. Lauren sat on the rug during sensory play and two of the children wanted to sit in her lap while the other children wanted to play. Sometimes the children seem to get out of control. Mrs. Lauren always makes sure that she handles the children with love and care.

    Read More

  • How Did Marva Collins Become Successful

    1416 Words  | 6 Pages

    Marva worked at a public school in Chicago that did not believe in her role as a teacher, but that made Marva strive harder to make her students successful. Marva stated in her book, “As a teacher I now try to teach children how to deal with life.” (Collins, 48) Marva believed her role as a teacher was to teach students (one’s often below grade level) to be successful in life, and a way to be successful was to get a good education. She often worked with underprivileged students in the Chicagoland area, and Marva stated in her book, “Naturally my optimal goal was to get children in this class to see intrinsic value of education.”

    Read More

  • My Teaching Philosophy Essay

    1095 Words  | 5 Pages

    The success of this program can be attributed to one of its main principles where there is a strong parent-teacher-community cooperation, as Gandini said (2003), “Education has to focus on each child, not considered in isolation, but seen in relation with the family, with the other children, with the teachers, with the environment of the school, with the community, and with the wider society” (Values and Principles of the Reggio Emilia Approach section, para.

    Read More

More about Analysis Of Maria Montessori And Colin Powell

Open Document