ipl-logo

Merleau-Ponty's Relationship To The Other

1411 Words6 Pages

This essay will focus on Merleau-Ponty’s account of our relations with Others, as well as its relation to Sartre’s philosophy and how effective of a critique Merleau-Ponty offers to the Sartrean understanding of our relationship to the Other. Throughout the essay i shall refer to the relationship between the Individual and the Other, this is simply to mean the relationship found between the ‘I’ and the other humans they interact with who have questionable similarity to the ‘I’. Our relationship to Others is a significant area of discussion because it opens the problem of Other Minds, which entails the idea that I, as an individual, cannot verify that any other individual I interact with is conscious in the same way I am. Both Sartre and Merleau-Ponty …show more content…

As such the following is a brief explanation of the Sartrean standing, within Being and Nothingness. Sarte saw that the Other is necessary to one 's identifying as an Individual, and so the sense of the Other is seen as prior to one 's sense of selves. Sartre 's understanding of the Other is two fold, where firstly the Individual views the Other as an object, and secondly where the Individual understands the Other as a …show more content…

We will first outline what Merleau-Ponty understood and then move to evaluate his theories effectiveness as a critique.In opposition to Sartre, Merleau-Ponty argues that our relationship to the world is not simply a closed perspective and instead the individual and the Other exist in a shared world. The way we experience events is always in time, and can be understood by explanation of Traditional Synthesis. This is the idea that the present is always open to the past and the future, but also most importantly open to the perspectives of Others, because one’s world is not closed to the observation of Others. It is the openness of one 's world which necessitates one 's awareness of the Other, under the idea that we must inhabit the same would to affect each other. Thus, the Other and oneself “must learn to find the communication of consciousnesses in a single world [..] gathered together in a single world in which we all participate as anonymous subjects of perception” (Merleau-Ponty, 2013, pp 369). Meaning that one 's experience of the Other s intrinsically related to the Individual 's own experience and existence. Moreover, for Merleau-Ponty, there are three main characteristics which demonstrate the relation between the Individual and the

Show More
Related

  • Personhood In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    1234 Words  | 5 Pages

    Through analysis of a few of the proposed necessities of personhood–consciousness, intelligence, and self-awareness–the

    Read More

  • Lucretius On The Order Of Things Summary

    1396 Words  | 6 Pages

    Analysis of “On the Order of Things” by Lucretius Name Course Institution Introduction In the book “On the Order of Things,” Lucretius explains that human beings leave in fear because they chose to. Lucretius further claims that people fail to perceive things the way they should be; as a result, they worry about the things that do not even affect; people look for pleasure and luxury in the wrong places. He further explains that people worry about the things that are not even dangerous and they neglect what is important; for example, people worry about dreadful diseases, but they fail to consider the role the parts of body play in making things real or imaginary. The author also suggests that the mind plays a significant role in the lives

    Read More

  • Ordinary Theology Analysis

    1671 Words  | 7 Pages

    They "serve as the lens through which we see everything else and as the compass that situates us" (36). In the center segment of the book, a couple test social writings are inspected, for example, motion pictures, music, and design. No social surprise butt sex is thorough; altogether, we can see differing writings and see the way of life's prevailing story or metanarrative. By this, we mean how social power is resolved and what is the trust that drives individuals (143-148). In this manner, Vanhoozer attests social interpretation will be affected by our own philosophical presuppositions.

    Read More

  • Themes In Vanier's Becoming Human

    1047 Words  | 5 Pages

    Rather than reasoning a logical solution, Vanier tries to glean as much understanding as he can from the nature of things through his own experience. Through his passage on page 86 of his book Becoming Human, he emplores

    Read More

  • Jean Paul Sartre's Existentialism Analysis

    1661 Words  | 7 Pages

    The statement of Jean Paul Sartre (2004) we led with offers a way out of such misguided thinking, words that can remind us of the immensity of human potential and what that signifies for every person. Admittedly, Sartre’s existentialism is a harsh landscape barren of faith or hope beyond this world, yet even in his Godless realm the philosopher has found ground for exercising human freedom in a way that, though atheistic, contains profound insights and wars against any compromise of the human capacity that lies within each of us. The first insight involves Sartre’s conviction that every individual through conscious choice must determine who he or she will become. While Christianity would assert that we would have no choice at all were it not for a God who created us with free will, it would agree that each person, by virtue of that freedom, is called to fashion his or her own truest identity. As Peter Kreeft (1988) delineates, “God makes our what, we make our who.

    Read More

  • Thomas Calloway Brothers Analysis

    154 Words  | 1 Pages

    Contemplating each other’s presence, while fragments of themselves

    Read More

  • No Exit By Jean Paul Sartre Existentialism

    1197 Words  | 5 Pages

    Perhaps Sartre 's obscure way of thinking can be traced back to his childhood - he was a small and cross-eyed little boy who generally did not fit in with the “ordinary” children. The way that he was treated and viewed by others forced Sartre, at an early age, to view people, thoughts,

    Read More

  • Analysis: A Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality By John Perry

    1250 Words  | 5 Pages

    INTRODUCTION: This paper will argue that in John Perry 's “A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality”, despite Weirob being correct in her belief that personal identity is not purely represented by the immaterial/unobservable soul, personal identity is the product of the integration of the material and immaterial experience of an individual. (50) EXPOSITION: Perry 's “A Dialogue...”, features Gretchen Weirob, a philosophy professor, coming to terms with her own mortality after suffering life-threatening injuries from a motorcycle accident. Two friends come to chat with Weirob, and the three engage in a debate over how to qualify personal identity and the possibility of identity existing beyond death of the physical body.

    Read More

  • John Locke Personal Identity Analysis

    1970 Words  | 8 Pages

    In this paper, I will look at and criticize John Locke’s account of Personal Identity as well as put forward arguments of my own of what I consider to be the unreliability of that which Locke terms as consciousness in relation to and as a composition of ‘Personal Identity’. Before we can arrive at a discussion of consciousness it is essential to follow Locke’s thought process and see how he arrived at a differentiation between substance, person, self (an alternate term for person used in the latter half of the chapter) and consciousness. It is essential to realize that for Locke personal identity consists in the identity of consciousness. We know this because he says as much in the following passage: “[T]he same consciousness being preserv’d…the

    Read More

  • Opposing Views On Sartre And The Existence Of God

    750 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although Sartre agrees with Dostoevsky who says, “If God does not exist, then everything would be possible,” he tries to pull back from nihilism by saying that each human must act “for all humanity” and before the audience of all of humanity. Sartre claims that all humans have no nature or essence, he disqualifies himself from calling them “all humans.” First Sartre affirms that human beings lack a nature, but if we lack a nature, then the term “human being” has no reference at all. The descriptive term that applies to something with inherent qualities and do what is required of the qualities can be identified as “human being”.

    Read More

  • Augustine Confessions Rousseau Analysis

    2244 Words  | 9 Pages

    Rousseau’s age did not perceive man to be only as associated with God and his teachings and principles, but, more so that man could be defined as unique individuals with their own teachings, principles and rights. This emphasises why Augustine’s and Rousseau’s discovered truths are so different, because Augustine confessed his faults, in the eyes of God, to God, seeking absolution and forgiveness whereas Rousseau confesses to no one but himself, based on his own principles of what he considers, in hindsight, to be right or wrong, appropriate or inappropriate. The move from the “pre modern to the modern era” (Naugle 8) is what is presented by Rousseau to his readers. It is a version of the modern human self where people are “no more or no less what they manifest themselves to be” (Naugle 8), this is how Rousseau presents his truth to the readers, as a recount of events he believed to be important to his building character and self, a makeup of the general truths within his life. He presents himself and his actions with his own critical eye and judgement whereas Augustine applies mainly the eye of

    Read More

  • Worst Effects Of Socialization

    769 Words  | 4 Pages

    This is a fatal event in Rousseau’s mind as unlike ‘the savage’ who ‘lives in himself’, an individual in society ‘is always outside himself and knows how to live only in the opinion of others’. Very unlike the Hobbesian war-like state of nature where ‘vainglory’ cause people to act like barbarous beasts, Rousseau argues that egocentrism derives solely from social interaction believing that his predecessors were projecting ideas of modern corruption onto the state of nature. Therefore, Rousseau’s analysis of moral psychology reveals how humans have become duplicitous and false through socialisation as the foundations of competition and bettering people are laid and consequently, a ‘desire for inequality’ governs the

    Read More

  • Jean-Paul Sartre's Existence Precedes Essence

    911 Words  | 4 Pages

    The argument Jean-Paul Sartre, a French philosopher, presents on existentialism helps to prove the foundation which is “existence precedes essence”. Existentialism is normally understood as an ideology that involves evaluating existence itself and the way humans find themselves existing currently in the world. For the phrase existence precedes essence, existence’s etymology is exsistere or to stand out while the term Essence means “being” or “to be” therefore the fundamental of existentialism, literally means to stand out comes before being. This can be taken into many different ideas such as individuals having to take responsibility for their own actions and that in Sartre’s case the individual is the sole judge of his or her own actions. According to him, “men is condemned to be free,” therefore “the destiny of man is placed within himself.”

    Read More

  • Madness In Wide Sargasso Sea

    1870 Words  | 8 Pages

    In Lacan terms it is a constituted ego formed by the recognition of what one is seen and spoken as by others (84). This is divided into two phases. The first phase, The Mirror Stage, occurs in

    Read More

  • The Mirror Stage Theory

    1381 Words  | 6 Pages

    I has been established as a distinct entity, the child still depends upon others for coherence and stability. This he calls transitivism. He reaches the conclusion that the experience of the self is connected with the presence of others. For Lacan, our ‘being’ can only be measured in relation to other people. Even the private desires we harbour are shaped by the desires of others.

    Read More

More about Merleau-Ponty's Relationship To The Other

Open Document