ipl-logo

Analysis Of Opium And China Revisited By Joshua Fogel

723 Words3 Pages

In this in-depth article, Joshua Fogel discusses the details and importance of opium in China. Published in 2006, “Opium and China Revisited: How Sophisticated Was Qing Thinking in Matters of Drug Control?” takes us back to the nineteenth century and China's relationship with the outside world during the Mao years. Fogel begins by highlighting the significance of the Chinese government and nationalism in China during the 19th and 20th centuries. This then leads to talk of the opium in China and other area of Eurasia including Britain and Japan. Finally, Fogel succeeds in analyzing the studies done by other scholars, but fails to bring any new evidence or arguments in his work. Fogel also heavily relies on a singular source authored by Inoue …show more content…

“During the Mao years, China’s suffering at the hands of others in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, while never downplayed, was usually blamed on China's own weaknesses and specific evil regimes” (Fogel 43). The start of Fogel’s essay is intriguing, it is almost as he his telling a story of the history of this topic. About halfway through the work, Fogel changes topics and covers the subject of the opium wars. Fogel provides a brief history lesson about the opium wars, specifically on the Qing’s anti-opium legislation and on the “external ban” and “internal ban.” He refers to several other scholars at this point, ultimately restating and agreeing with …show more content…

“Let me now just briefly introduce the topics of Inoue’s chapters. Interested readers may find some more to their taste than others” (Fogel 48). Little did Fogel know, most of his readers probably lost interest after reading the rest of his article. He completely switches from attempting to locate evidence for an argument into a complete critical review of Hiromasa’s book, “Crisis for the Chinese Empire.” Fogel goes on to analyze Hiromasa’s for the next four pages of his article, as an attempt to strengthen his own points. He concludes the entire paper by the stating, “Let me note in conclusion that this book represents a revised version of Inoue’s doctorate, received in 2001,” (Fogel 50). By focusing on only one source for almost half of the article, Fogel is dependent on Hiromasa’s words, instead of his own opinions that he set up earlier in the

Show More
Related

  • Opium Trade Dbq

    268 Words  | 2 Pages

    Struggling to maintain social order and strength, the Qing Dynasty placed restrictions on opium trade; however, this backfired, provoking retaliation from British traders and leading to a war that would create the Unequal Treaties. The detrimental socio economic effects opium had on China were beginning to surface during the late 1830’s, causing an influx of smokers and a decline in bullion. Although China’s economy suffered, this was the most viable foreign trade option for the British. There was low demand for the cotton the British offered to China, but the increased profits from opium would do more than compensate. Thus, British merchants took various measures to circumvent China’s policies to stop the illicit trade and managed to find

    Read More

  • Opium Dialectical Journal

    173 Words  | 1 Pages

    Event: Tom accuses Matt of killing Furball, and Tam Lin is disappointed in Matt, but doesn’t see him as a beast, but as a human who made a mistake. “But Tam Lin had called Matt a human and expected much more from him. Humans, Matt realized, were a lot harder to forgive,” (138).

    Read More

  • Xacc 280 Week 1 Reflection Journal

    397 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this review he argues against Kataoka’s claims that the resistance to Japan, especially in its urban impact, may be a more significant explanation of the CCP in the Chinese Civil War than Mao Tse-tun’s 1928 rural policy. Seybolt stats that without Mao focus and peasant support on the rural areas, the CCP would have never gain enough manpower or strength to stand toe to toe with Japan and the Nationalist in the first place. In Garver’s “The Origins of the Second United Front: The Comintern and the Chinese Communist Party,” is focused on the Comintern and its role in the formation of the CCP-KMT Second United Front. He argues that it is important to recognize and understand Moscow’s role during the pivotal year and a half prior to the Xian Incident, and especially of possible conflict between the Comintern and Mao Zedong, over the issue of a united front with Chiang Kai-shek. Lastly, Zhang and Weatherley’s “Owning up to the Past: The KMT’s Role in the War against Japan and the Impact on CCP Legitimacy,” examines the emerging debate in China over the true contribution made by the KMT in the war against

    Read More

  • Spread Of Buddhism Dbq

    1110 Words  | 5 Pages

    Following the fall of the Han dynasty came the decline of practicers of the Confucian philosophy because of the downfall of the elite class and a centralized government. Buddhism, a religion with it’s roots from north India, has found its presence in China during the time when trade, along the silk roads, was crucial in all parts of Eurasia. Although the spread of Buddhism in China was greeted with devotion from new converts who supported the religion by spreading it and combining their cultures with the religion, it also was rejected by the ruling elite who opposed the spread of the religion that impacted China for the next following centuries.

    Read More

  • French Colonialism In Vietnam Analysis

    1277 Words  | 6 Pages

    The impact of Lenin’s victory over a capitalist monarchy defines an important change in the way Sino-Vietnamese relations would occur, since the focus on nationalism would slowly convert to communism as the dominant ideology to resist western capitalism. The rise of the communist resistance Ho Chi Minh in the early 20th century defines the overarching influence of Chinese/Soviet communist policies, which he followed by building a military force on the northern border of China and Vietnam in the 1920s: “By late 1924, Nguyen Ai Quoc (Ho Chi Minh) was in southern China, building a new revolutionary organization meant to operate inside Indochina. These efforts culminated in 1930 with the establishment of the Vietnamese Communist Party” (Ward 45). In this historical perspective, it is imperative to understand the impact that the Soviet Union had on Chinese Communism, which had been steadily growing as a counter-ideology to the capitalist nationalism of Sun Yat-sen.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Andean Cocaine By Paul Gootenberg

    947 Words  | 4 Pages

    Introduction Written and published in 2008 by Paul Gootenberg, History professor and Latin American studies at University of New York at Stony Brook, “Andean Cocaine: The Making of a Global drug” retraces the pivotal stages of the illicit cocaine trafficking, starting from the boundless coca fields in Latin America to the chemistry laboratories in Europe up until the streets of U.S. cities. The aim of this book review is to provide the reader with a short but detailed insight of what is the main content of the book, by paying particular attention to its structure, objectivity and style. Scope & Organisation Adopting a meticulous chronological approach, Gootenberg describes the infamous and complex untold history of cocaine, analysing and

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Age Of Ambition By Evan Osnos

    203 Words  | 1 Pages

    The book Age of Ambition written by Evan Osnos, a staff writer of The New Yorker who covers politics and foreign affairs, reveals life in the new China to be a battleground between aspiration and authoritarianism, in which only one can prevail, and he also describes the greatest conflict taking place in China: the clash between the rise of the individual and the Communist Party’s struggle to retain control. Evan Osnos states his idea in the book, “An account of the collision of two forces: aspiration and authoritarianism, shows a China river by moral crisis and explosive frustration, whose citizens are desperate to achieve wealth, even as they are terrified of being left with nothing. It is also a riveting and troubling portrait of a people

    Read More

  • African American Imperialism Analysis

    840 Words  | 4 Pages

    Despite the fact that the most significant method of European Imperialism in Africa was the “Standard Treaty” and the most significant method of European Imperialism in China was the Opium War, both instances of European Imperialism were quite similar. In both situations, the use of a treaty was present. The treaties being used in both situations were unfair and gave the European countries control over the region that was being imperialized. Both situations demonstrated Europe’s extreme power. The regions of Africa and China both knew that if they refused to sign the treaties, Europe would threaten conflict.

    Read More

  • Empress Dowager Cixi: The Imperial Woman

    2119 Words  | 9 Pages

    The past hundred y2ears of history have been largely unfair to Cixi, having been labelled as a devious despot who used much of the kingdom’s money for her own self-indulgence. The Imperial Woman is often blamed for the fall of the Qing Dynasty, failing to implement successful reforms to save China from the ‘foreign devils’(Chang 89). However, what her critiques failed to realize was that the problems that China faced did not originate from Cixi and that before she

    Read More

  • Opium Bride Research Paper

    193 Words  | 1 Pages

    The practice of turning young girls into ‘opium brides’ in the middle east is horrible and must be stopped. The poverty that many farmers are forced to deal with is so extreme that they must turn to growing drugs, and selling their daughters into marriage. Sayed Shah, an opium farmer from Afghanistan, describes his bleak situation by saying, “I never imagined I'd have to pay for growing opium by giving up my daughter” (1). In many cases, young girls are sold is an opium bride, but because they are too young to marry they are used as slaves until they can be married.

    Read More

  • Changes And Continuities In The 1750's To 1850

    1155 Words  | 5 Pages

    However, during this time period this control of Indian commerce was at its strongest because of British actions of conquering Indian territories. Whilst in China, the economic continuity was a bigger issue; it was the continuity of opium trade way before the Opium War and after. The only distinct is that before the war it was illegal, and after the war China was forced to legalize it. However, it was still a part of Chinese economy whether legal or illegal.

    Read More

  • Al Capone: Gangster During The 1900's

    821 Words  | 4 Pages

    Drugs are a way of life in some countries. Afghanistan is the leading producers of opium. The “Golden Triangle” is what some call the biggest opium crops known. (H. Warlord) Therefore, a lot of different individuals need to be involved in order to maintain the opium growth.

    Read More

  • Essay On European Interaction

    676 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the 15th and 16th centuries, European interaction and exploration began to increase. Europeans interacted with an abundant amount of societies that were all different from one another such as; The Americas, West Africa, and China. Throughout all of those societies, interactions differ exceedingly. Specifically in both the Americas and China had very dissimilar interactions with the Europeans. In the Inca and Aztec Empires, Europeans gained dominance and power as opposed to China, which failed to take over.

    Read More

  • China's Last Empire William Rowe Summary

    1046 Words  | 5 Pages

    Economic, political, both domestic and international, social and cultural factors all had various levels of impact and repercussions on the Qing regime, with chapters also dedicated to the formation and organisation of the Qing government, giving the reader context to the period. He traces the changes and continuity in these themes and argues against the orthodox interpretation of Qing history that the watershed in the Qing dynasty was the 1839-1842 First opium war and the resulting Treaty of Nanking. Instead, he argues that when the Western powers first came to assert their influence and dominance over the Qing, the Qing was already poorly equipped with the means of dealing with them and the Western powers, and later, Japan, simply proved too much for the Qing to handle. One specific reason behind this argument is the relationship between the Qing government and the people. Rowe explains the Qing approach to governing its huge empire as an attempt to conduct “government on the cheap”, referring to their principles of benevolent rule inclusive of light taxes and minimal direct involvement in local society, a pseudo laissez faire model through under governed China.

    Read More

  • Silk Road Religion

    794 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Prostitution, Religion, and the New Silk Road” Robb Gifford of National Public Radio takes the roads of China and uncovers information from the locals within China on a wide variety of subjects. This web series manages to capture the perspectives of the local people, which in turn provides a fresh perspective straight from the source itself. Focusing on the prostitution market, Christianity, and the changing markets along the Silk Road, what do all of these subjects have in common? Each subject is ever changing and developing. Prostitution in China is quite the interesting topic.

    Read More

More about Analysis Of Opium And China Revisited By Joshua Fogel

Open Document