Seal Of The Confessional Analysis
Watching the film Priest for the first time, not really focusing on the issue of the Seal of the Confessional, I was preoccupied with Father Greg’s many dilemmas about the Church, faith and homosexuality. The second time around, however, I watched the film with a clear question in my mind – is the Seal of the Confessional to be respected at all times, and are possible repercussions for the victim of the penitent worth the honouring of secrecy? It immediately became clear to me that in fact, there is no dilemma at all. The Seal of the Confessional was introduced in 1151 and states: "Let the priest who dares to make known the sins of his penitent be deposed." It is quite similar in function to the rule regarding psychotherapy and doctor-patient …show more content…
It seems as though he is willing to ignore the rules in order to satiate his physical desires, but experiences this huge personal dilemma when it comes to breaking the rules for someone else. “I can’t take on 2000 years of history, that would be pride, that would be arrogance, they’d crucify me!”, he yells in despair. Yet taking his relationship with Graham into account, he already took on 2000 years of history, if for a more selfish reason. In fact, it seems that he is able to act only when he is directly affected by a situation, which is explained nicely through the story about the poisoned wine – Father Greg would willingly drink the wine he knows is poisoned in order not to break the Seal of the Confessional, making himself “a martyr” in the process. But what would happen if someone else were to drink the poisoned wine, an innocent, 14-year-old girl, perhaps? The answer Father Greg seems to provide is that the Seal of the Confessional is more important than an innocent life. Although he regrets his decision in the end, we must take into account that Lisa’s mother learned about her husband’s horrific actions by coincidence. If that had not happened, Lisa’s suffering could be prolonged indefinitely, and Father Greg may never have spoken up. To me, that is not acceptable behaviour of a “moral guide” and to me, his decision not to speak
Mary's Innocence In Reading Allegegencies By Tiffany Jackson
1147 Words | 5 PagesThe largest trial upon doing so comes in the form of convincing everyone of the “true” events that took place that night. The trail of deceit she creates entangles almost everyone, maybe even herself. Mary rebuts the argument of her guiltiness by overwhelming others with her supposed “innocence”, yet Mary’s true, dark colors, that of a psychopath,
Darnell Martin's Lore Episode 'They Made A Tonic'
1165 Words | 5 PagesGeorge is lost as to what he should do as he sees his daughter die of the disease known as “consumption”, only a few short years after his wife died of the same disease. He is
Mexican Confession Research Paper
94 Words | 1 PagesHave you ever wondered how the United States formed and how history formed everything? Well, one important event in history was the Mexican Cession. The Mexican Cession was a land that the Americans obtained after the Mexican-American war. The Mexican Cession refers to lands surrendered, to the United States by Mexico at the finish of the Mexican War. It was a territory that included California, Nevada, Utah, and also parts of Colorado, Arizona, Wyoming, and New Mexico.
How Did Salem Get Confessions
623 Words | 3 PagesPreceding the Salem witch trails, the court fell under attack. Those who made confessions began to recant them. Though they played a direct role in the executions of innocent people, they insisted that they only made accusations out of force. In Document 77, Margaret Jacobs describes the ordeal of how she was told to either confess or be hanged. In another record, “Declaration of Mary Osgood, Mary Tyler, Deliverance Dane, Abigail Barker, Sarah Wilson, and Hannah Tyler,” the girls contend, “There was no other way to save our lives, as the case was then circumstanced, but by our confessing ourselves to be such and such persons as the afflicted represented us to be; they out of tenderness and pity persuaded us to confess what we did confess”
Betty Friedan's The Importance Of Work
1454 Words | 6 PagesFor example, Friedan says, "Psychiatrists have long used "occupational therapy" with patients in mental
The Rag And Bone Shop Analysis
529 Words | 3 PagesThe story “The Rag and Bone Shop,” is about the brutal murder of a seven-year-old girl named Alicia Bartlett. They interrogate a twelve-year-old boy, named Jason Dorrant, who is her friend and the last known person to see her alive. Trent is an expert interrogator, who does the interrogation of Alicia’s murder and summits Jason to a interrogation. Sarah Downes and Carl Seaton compare Trent to a Priest. They are similar because they both sit in a chair, in a silent place.
How Does Nathaniel Hawthorne Use Internal Torture In The Scarlet Letter
864 Words | 4 PagesBased on Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novel The Scarlet Letter the moral consequences of sin are conveyed as public shame and internal torture. Hawthorne also illustrates that one can be redeemed through open confession. Public shame is an indispensable
Analysis Of Little Tombstone
1138 Words | 5 PagesThe directors want to show us how the pursuit of their ideals actually end up meaning more to them than their lives, leaving their ears to be closed off to other options and ideas. The directors know the importance of a priest being shunned as it emphasizes the intensity of their ideals. These characters are so engrossed with their task, words that could possibly comfort or even guide The Good and The Bad towards a brighter path are completely ignored. This ignorance can be found in Julian
Ten Nights In A Bar Room Analysis
647 Words | 3 PagesHis mother warned him about his fate if he continued to drink, like his own late father, but he felt that a few drinks would not cause any issues. Little did he know that a few drinks would turn into endless nights of drinking, and the biggest tragedy of his life; the death of his daughter. His daughter, worried sick about him, went to look for him at the tavern so they
John Proctor's Confession In The Crucible
526 Words | 3 PagesGod does not need my name nailed upon the church! God sees my name; God knows how black my sins are! It is enough!” John feels that confession should be private between a man and God. On the other hand, the public believes that there should be strong evidence confirming one’s confession.
Should David Cash Be Expelled From Berkeley University
995 Words | 4 PagesHe refuses to apologize to the young girl’s family justifying his response by stating that he didn’t know this little girl, or dark children in Panama, or those dying of disease in Egypt. He only felt sorrow at the loss of his friend Jeremy
Organized Religion In John Wheelwright's A Prayer For Owen Meany
813 Words | 4 PagesOwen criticizes the sacrament of confession as he thinks the Catholics believe that confession equals automatic freedom, as he complains, “IF KENNEDY CAN RATIONALIZE ADULTERY, WHAT ELSE CAN HE RATIONALIZE? I’M FORGETTING HE'S A MACKEREL-SNAPPER! IF CATHOLICS CAN CONFESS ANYTHING, THEY CAN FORGIVE THEMSELVES ANYTHING TOO! CATHOLICS CAN’T EVEN GET DIVORCED! MAYBE THAT’S
Compare And Contrast The Minister's Black Veil And The Scarlet Letter
119 Words | 1 PagesIn the short story “The Minister’s Black Veil” and the novel The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne tells the stories of two men who keep their sins secret and are hurt deeply. In The Scarlet Letter, Reverend Dimmesdale does not reveal his sin to the community and experiences far more pain than Hester, whose sin is revealed. Years after the original sin, Hester has healed and is accepted by the community, while Dimmesdale still feels guilty, as can be seen when he mounts the scaffold. Dimmesdale’s experience is similar to that of Reverend Hooper, who covers his face after a secret sin and is eschewed by the community. When we refuse to admit our faults, we will feel guilty
Personal Confessions In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
472 Words | 2 PagesThis pattern suggests that complete honesty and openness leads one to the only fair consequence for wrongdoing: death. Even Victor dies only once he finishes telling his full story to Walton. The exception to this pattern, Henry Clerval’s death, reflects an undeserved death. Henry lives a righteous, selfless life, so no guilt burdens him, and the effects of Victor’s mistakes haunt him. Goal(s) for audience understanding: I will begin with a short story about a time I was direct and honest with my sister, and I will briefly discuss the effects of my words.
Barn Burning Sarty Character Analysis
866 Words | 4 PagesFor example, in the case of barn burning, his dad supposes that Sarty will give a statement, which helps him to be free from the charges, however, Sarty is no in such mood and has made up his mind to reveal the truth, irrespective of his risk of his own father’s imprisonment. But, luckily, magistrate doesn’t go deep in the case and avoids taking the evidences or statements from the Sarty. Nonetheless, when father and son meet the next night, his father explains him why he should not reveal the truth in the court and he also describes him the importance of the family responsibility and faithfulness (Ford, 1998). However, I feel that young Sarty has developed his own system of justice by that time and, nevertheless, he disagrees with his father, respecting his family status, he avoids conflict or further discussion on that
More about Seal Of The Confessional Analysis
Mary's Innocence In Reading Allegegencies By Tiffany Jackson
1147 Words | 5 PagesDarnell Martin's Lore Episode 'They Made A Tonic'
1165 Words | 5 PagesMexican Confession Research Paper
94 Words | 1 PagesHow Did Salem Get Confessions
623 Words | 3 PagesBetty Friedan's The Importance Of Work
1454 Words | 6 PagesThe Rag And Bone Shop Analysis
529 Words | 3 PagesHow Does Nathaniel Hawthorne Use Internal Torture In The Scarlet Letter
864 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of Little Tombstone
1138 Words | 5 PagesTen Nights In A Bar Room Analysis
647 Words | 3 PagesJohn Proctor's Confession In The Crucible
526 Words | 3 PagesShould David Cash Be Expelled From Berkeley University
995 Words | 4 PagesOrganized Religion In John Wheelwright's A Prayer For Owen Meany
813 Words | 4 PagesCompare And Contrast The Minister's Black Veil And The Scarlet Letter
119 Words | 1 PagesPersonal Confessions In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
472 Words | 2 PagesBarn Burning Sarty Character Analysis
866 Words | 4 Pages