Argumentative Essay: Should We Celebrate Columbus Day?

They celebrate what they believe is the birth and discovery story of the Americas. Therefore, many are surprised to learn who Columbus was and the cruelties of his actions and his pursuits. Columbus Day is meant to be a day celebrating our country’s origin, however not only did Christopher Columbus not discover America, but he didn’t provide any new or useful information to European explorers of the time. The one thing he did do, though, was promoting terrorism and genocide, which even to this day has had an impact on Americans. In other words,

Almost everybody has heard of Christopher Columbus, but do you know that he tried to sail for 15 years. Christopher Columbus found new land, was a good navigator, and never gave up. Here are some reasons why Columbus should be considered a hero. The first reason that Christopher Columbus was a hero is because he found new land. Before Columbus found the new land people did not know there was other land.

Now known as the Columbian Exchange, this is a momentous point in history. Without Christopher Columbus journeying to America, the Native Americans would not have been exposed to much of Europe’s advanced technology such as gunpowder and the plow. Perhaps the most controversial point in the argument over if Columbus Day should be a holiday

The source, Christopher Columbus’s Journal, is a personal written account by Columbus of his time sailing to the New World and exploring it. Columbus's original Journals were lost. The original copies were sent to the King and Queen, however the parts that are left are from Bartoleme de Las Cases, one of the first men to come to the New World. He did not agree with Christopher Columbus’s way of treating the Indians, so it is certainly possible that the remaining parts may be tweaked to make Columbus look bad in the eyes of the people. (The Expansion of Europe and Rise of the Atlantic World, Enter Christopher Columbus) However, it is accepted that the remaining experts are more or less accurate.

Columbus finding America brought many positive and negative impacts to the world. Columbus day is a holiday in the United States that celebrates Christopher Columbus finding the new world otherwise known as America. As Columbus’s findings affected people worldwide it should be an International Holiday. Although, the Vikings were the first to discover America, Columbus was the first to communicate his findings. The Vikings were an insular group of people.

Columbus Day is an international holiday celebrated throughout the United StatesUS that particularly acknowledges Christopher Columbus and his arrival to thein the New World on October 12th, 1492. This holiday honors Columbus’ findings of America and is celebrated for Americans to truly recognize the effect in which he had made on our country and nation as a whole. With this being said, I strongly feel that Columbus Day should be an international holiday celebrated in remembrance of our homes being unearthed and opened to others around the globe. Though the holiday is embraced because of Columbus’ discovery of America, he however wasn’t the first to come across it. A group of European vikings had first stumbled across American land 500 years

Happy new year, happy valentines day, happy easter, happy porrum, happy Columbus Day? The day Christopher Columbus first landed in America in 1492 is not a day one should really celebrate. This time in History did mark a major change in the world globally and historically, however it is important to veiw all sides of the story. Many grow-up learning all about ‘the amazing explorer’ who found America, but that isn’t nearly the whole truth. This being said, celebrating the second monday of October as Indigenous peoples day would be like forgetting and pushing aside parts of the story just to honor the better side.

Very clever allusion, he did not say that but the notary told him that. A holy comparison! First, Christopher Columbus who discovered the New World, by chance, when he was looking for a short way to the Indian’s gold and spices. Second, Camille Douls who has the courage to go alone to Hades ( Western Sahara ) , as Hercules, with an excellent merit to the latter, which is, he does that not for gold, but rather, for the European knowledge for humanity and that is what made him a benefactor of humanity more than Columbus was. Let us dive into Vieuchange’s poem perhaps we find something else

Celebrating Columbus day has been adopted by many different countries, and ethic groups, “Italian-American, Hispanic, and other groups have embraced the holiday as an occasion to celebrate their ethnic heritage, though some Indian groups… refer to the day as “Indigeous Peoples Day” (M. Castronovo Fusco 1). Columbus day has become a celebration of freedom; freedom to be who you are, and freedom to celebrate where you come from. The day has also become a day of education, “The whole discussion around Columbus Day has been useful to the extent that it has reminded us of the many tragic consequences in contact” (M. Castronovo Fusco 1). The accomplishments of Christopher Columbus should be celebrated because although flawed, he was a great man who inspired freedom and by celebrating him, liberates people history has shunned to celebrate who they are and where they came

Carolyn Finney from University of Kentucky explains that because of this act the relationship we have with land forever changed. For before this, according to Locke land was given to us by God and needed to be used advantageously by labor. Christopher Columbus came and ‘found’ America in 1492 and began laboring the land but what about the Native American’s that had cultivated the land before? Who does this property belong to? Locke justifies this answer by explaining that they are in the state of nature so they lacked progression and were not using the land advantageously as God had intended.

Not only is Columbus praised upon but he is mentioned as the first man to discover the Americas which is untrue. And Loewen further states how textbooks minimize other expeditions and how those explores are no where near praised as much as Columbus. Rather textbooks, seem to act as if expeditions began in the 1400’s in Europe but they didn’t. As Loewen states, “Most textbooks make no use of primary sources. A few incorporate brief extracts that have been carefully selected or edited to reveal nothing unseemly of the Great Navigator.” (p.63).

Many Historians do not doubt that Zheng He “could’ve” discovered America first. Even if the Zheng He did discover America first, it wouldn’t matter because it didn’t change anything. We say Columbus discovered the New World because his discovery actually changed things. The only caveat to my statement is Menzies claim that Columbus had a map, which to me does not make much sense seeing as if he did have a map, he would not have gotten rejected so many times while trying to pitch his idea of sailing across the

However, some of the acts he committed afterwards I do not agree with. I could see how some people might still get upset over celebrating the holiday. According to our textbook, Columbus was convinced he was “an agent of God’s divine plan”. He also left about forty men on Hispaniola and captured a dozen Indians to present as gifts to the Spanish King and Queen. President Benjamin Harrison first declared Columbus Day a national holiday in 1892, four hundred years after the first voyage.

Although deep down inside the real story of Christopher Columbus is that he did overall change our history and he bravely came to America in 1492. Some historians differ on how he achieved this goal. According to certain historians, some have a negative attitude on Columbus. In the article, “Columbus Doesn’t Deserve a

Christopher Columbus is the one who founded America. In 1492, thinking he had landed on the other side of Europe, Columbus had found a new land called America. Therefore, this had happened because Christopher Columbus was trying to figure out a shorter route to get to the other side of Europe. In addition, this is important because, he was the explorer who found America. He had explored in the years of 1492, 1493, 1498 and 1502.