The Lizzie Borden case is popular and continues to keep our interest. Not only does it interest us, it keeps us guessing who did the crime. The public opinion that Lizzie Borden killed her parents is because she hated parents, the crime scene evidence, and her mental instability. Lizzie might have killed her parents out of hate. And, when her mom Died, Andrew Borden remained to Abby Gray, and at first they got along. After awhile Lizzie stopped called calling her mom. The Borden sisters no longer called Abby mother but " Mrs. Borden ". The sisters even stopped eating meals with Andrew because of Abby. Yet, the way that Lizzie's parents were clobbered must have meant Lizzie must have been harboring so much anger. Abby was hit on the side of the side of the head which cut right above the ear, Andrew was hit with the weapon and cut one of his eyes in two suggesting he was asleep. Both Abby and Andrew were almost unrecognizable. Last, the family did not get along they fought, but never shouted. Every member at the house bought toned of locks because of a disagreement that led Lizzie to steal jewelry and loose cash from Abby and Andrew. This might be why Lizzie killed her parents. …show more content…
In fact, when police searched the house they found a hatchet. The police suggested that a hatchet with a broken handle in the basement was the murder weapon. The hatchet was even rolled in ash to look unused and dusty. Next, Lizzie was seen burning a dress, a blue dress to be exact. Lizzie burned the dress claiming that it was stained with paint/ though police thought she was burning evidence. She even claimed that the paint was red paint. Even so, How many blows to the skulls might have broken off the hatchet handle. It took nine-teen blows to the head to finish Abby, and ten to eleven to kill Andrew. The density of the skulls might have broken off the handle after the job was done. All the evidence tells us Lizzie is
Lizzie and her sister Emma were very religious and attended church, Lizzie also helped out as being a sunday school teacher. Abby Borden was murdered between 9:00 am and 10:30 am. Andrew was murdered between 10:30 am and 11:10 am. What first triggered Lizzie was that she built a roost for the pigeons and her father claimed it attracted children so he killed the pigeons with a hatchet in which angered Lizzie. A family argument stirred in the household causing both sisters to take extended vacations to New Bedford.
The murder of Lizzie Borden’s father, Andrew borden, and her stepmother Abby Borden has been an ongoing mystery over 100 years now. No one has seemed to figure out the real murderer. A main suspect that the police had interviewed was Lizzie borden, the daughter to Andrew Borden and step daughter to Abby Borden. Yet no one has seemed to figure out the real murderer. I believe Lizzie borden murdered her parents with having satisfaction that she covered it up so well.
There are theories and speculations, but no real murder The murders of Andrew and Abby Borden still haven’t been uncovered. I personally think she is innocent. She is innocent because, she had no physical evidence against her in the trial , she loved her father deeply, and her father had an argument with a man just before that morning. These are the three reasons why I think Lizzie Borden is not the murderess of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. First, she had no real physical or forensic against her during the murder case.
At the time of the murder and soon after, Lizzie was seen wearing a light blue
Brynlee Endicott Murray Fifth Hour 13 January 2023 Why Lizzie Borden Is Innocent Why would such a kind-hearted person wish to murder their parents? Lizzie Borden was accused of murdering her father and step-mother in Fall River, Massachusetts on August 4th, 1892. Many people believe that Lizzie is guilty. Lizzie is innocent, here is factual evidence: there would have been no time to clean up, previous break-ins happened, no weapon was evident, and she was a good lady. Lizzie couldn’t have killed her parents because there was no time.
In the trial a lot of evidence came out against Lizzie, like how Lizzie was caught burning her brand new blue dress which supposedly had “ red paint stains “ on it, how she attempted to purchase poison the day before the murder, and how only the hatchet head was found after Lizzie used it the day before. (www.bio.com) From this evidence it seems to be clear Lizzie had been planning to kill her parents and was trying to cover it up. For instance, there was plenty of exiting family conflict such as, Lizzie and Abby always arguing and Lizzie getting angry with her father because of money. Family conflict was a big motive in the trial.
To begin, Robert Sullivan, an author and judge in Massachusetts, writes that “Lizzie was the only person who had both motive and opportunity to commit the crimes” (“Just Like O.J.”). The day before the murders, Lizzie reportedly tried to buy prussic acid, a deadly poison, from the local drugstore (Hewitt). The supports the theory by showing that her preferred method of killing might have been a peaceful poisoning, but that she had to resort to an axe murder. By all accounts, Lizzie was the only one in the house at the time of Abby’s murder (Mock). In court, Lizzie’s alibi was inconsistent, placing her in several different locations during the times of the murders (“Vengeful Daughter”).
At the time of the trial, Lizzie Borden, changed her story multiple times, she was inconsistent. Borden also had a history of stealing from her stepmother and would often blame someone else (Hartselle, 2013). During the trial she showed no emotion about her parents having been murdered (Hartselle,
Although it was not proven at the time, Lizzie Borden viciously murdered her stepmother and father. She was a hatred-driven assassin and had many motives to kill. One, Lizzie craved her father’s abundant money; not having received it while his living. Two, she was mentally unstable, and had a lying spree. Three, with failed attempts to buy poison (to kill?), she also had many arguments with her parents and a had a strained
So the confused answers that she gave may not have been because she was guilty, but because she was in shock. Although police at the time were to aware of this so when she was not able to give a convincing story and her stories continued to change, Lizzie became the prime suspect in her parents murder. Due to the fact that she could not keep her story straight and her distressed state led to her arrest. Two days after she was questioned about the murders, Police Chief Hilliard arrested Lizzie. The next day she pleaded “Not Guilty” to her charges and then was transported to a rail car to be taking to the jail in Taunton, which is eight miles from her hometown.
When Lizzie was growing up, she was not outgoing, and because of this she happened to be very shy with few friends (Criminal). The loneliness in her childhood could have been one factor leading her to become a part of such an evil crime. Leading into her teen and young adult years, she was accused of shoplifting a couple times, although there is no charges against her in those years. Having a suspicious past in criminal activity makes it reasonable to understand that she could have committed another crime later on in her adult life (Criminal). This leads up to the extremely strange and bizarre behavior that was exhibited by Lizzie the week of the murder.
I think Lizzie Borden is guilty because she tried to purchase poison the day before the murder happened. Also the day before the murder happened she visited her friend, and told her that her father was going to die soon. Also Lizzie was a thief. All in all, I strongly believe Lizzie killed her parents. The first reason, why I think Lizzie Borden murdered her parents is, she tried to purchase poison the day before the murder happened.
Three days after the murder, Lizzie was seen burning a dress because she had gotten paint on it. Anyone who knew that family knew that they would never burn a dress because of a stain. It doesn’t help that the “paint” was the color of dried blood (Borden Took an Axe). Finally, at the trial, despite her many glaring contradictions in her testimony, she was declared innocent. One may ask why when she had such obvious motive and trouble keeping her story straight.
There were lots of loose ends and unsolved questions. I am here to convince you that Lizzie did not do it and, that she is innocent. Firstly, imagine being accused of killing your parents. How would that make you feel?
To bring an end to her sister’s pain, Lizzie “for the first time in her life began to listen and look” for the goblins (Lines 327-328). In her attempt to buy fruit from the goblins, she was invited to feast with them but refused. Similarly, in Matthew 4 where Satan tried to tempt Jesus to turn the stone into bread. Lizzie 's actions are done out of as love as was Jesus’ and as a result “they trod and hustled her, elbowed and jostled her, clawed with their nails at her, Barking, mewing, hissing, mocking, tore her gown and soiled her stockings, twitched her hair from the roots, […] squeezed their fruits against her mouth to make her eat” (Lines 359-401). Rossetti uses this comparison adding to the effect of sacrificial atonement to redeem Laura.