ipl-logo

Arguments Against Eliminative Materialism

824 Words4 Pages

People often refer to behavior as a reflection of one’s mental state. Though this claim is widely supported, it is also disproven by people known as eliminative materialists. Eliminative Materialism is a doctrine which claims that there are no mental states. Many materialists believe that mental states are apart of folk theory that almost everyone in today’s society takes for granted. Personally, I strongly disagree with this claim due to the overwhelming amount of evidence against it. Folk psychology is a commonsense theory of the mind that explains people’s behavior in terms of mental states, such as belief and desire. This theory also assumes that we have beliefs and desires which affect our behavior. Eliminative materialists reject these assumptions because they believe that beliefs and desires cannot affect our behavior. The first flaw I find in this theory is that materialists believe in their rejection of folk psychology, but they do not believe in beliefs as a whole. Beliefs are defined as an acceptance that a statement is true, or that something exists. Chemotherapy, for example, is believed to be a revolutionary tool in the medical world, which helps slow and/or halt the reproduction of cancerous cells in the body. Those who believe in the use of chemotherapy, accept that it is true, and that its positive effects truly do exist. …show more content…

Folk psychology was originally intended to explain the waking actions of normal adults. They believe that it cannot explain certain phenomena, and it would be a strike against it if it was intended to explain them. Many materialists believe that mental states are just theoretical entities which hold no value in life. They also believe that people only believe in mental states because they provide the best explanation for certain

Show More
Related

  • Mccandless Materialism Analysis

    154 Words  | 1 Pages

    Throughout all of McCandless’s adventures he often meets new people who take a liking to him, despite McCandless having trouble with the concept of intimacy, as he would rather be secluded from everything. Everytime he is confronted with a new acquaintance, he is always offered goods to help him on his journey. However, McCandless is against the fact that you need to have money to be successful in this materialistic world, and he is trying to challenge that idea by going on adventures without any money, as it would be to easy. In this passage he is resenting the fact that he himself cannot make it in this world without money, but he still chooses to live in that lifestyle because it is a much more free life, away from everyone.

    Read More

  • Examples Of One History Graded Influence

    716 Words  | 3 Pages

    1. Provide an example of one age graded influence, one history graded influence and one non-normative event that you have experienced. Explain it so that I know you understand the definition of the various influences. 2. Briefly describe the differences between psychoanalytic theories, behaviorists/social learning theories, Cognitive Developmental theories, Information Processing theories and Sociocultural/Ecological theories (remember to include pertinent terms).

    Read More

  • Not A Moonshot

    657 Words  | 3 Pages

    Jeffrey Kluger’s discusses in his article “Why Curing Cancer is Not a ‘Moonshot,’” his opinion on how, and why, the cure for cancer can not be compared to a moonshot. Many Presidents, including Barack Obama and Richard Nixon, have preached about the “war on cancer,”. Many have referred to curing cancer as a moonshot. According to Kluger, a moonshot is not nearly as difficult as curing cancer.

    Read More

  • David Foster Wallace's Analysis

    642 Words  | 3 Pages

    David Foster Wallace argues that reality can be mundane. However, if people focus on what others are going through, then they can learn to empathize and understand humanity better. A behavior is a snap shot of how that person is acting in that moment. There are lots of moments where behaviors may not accurately describe someone. If people are constantly operating unconsciously and only ever taking what they see face value then they are not relating or understanding others; even more what they are thinking about other’s is stereotypical and possibly hurtful.

    Read More

  • Essay On Dualism And Monism

    1457 Words  | 6 Pages

    Materialism or Reductive Physicalism (developed from Materialism) states that there is no differentiation between mind and matter because only what is material exists and as a result the mind is the formation of consciousness. Mental faculties occur because of the physical, for Materialists the brains purpose is to create consciousness. Phenomenalism states that physical objects are perceivable because of our mental faculties. The mind creates what we perceive as physical and what is physical is merely a mental construct therefore deducing that it is the mind that truly exists (McLeod, 2007). A study on hemiplegic victims demonstrated that when stimulated the mind can trick the body into believing a missing limb is still there contrary to the physical evidence, demonstrating that the “reorganized cortex is capable of processing sensory inputs so that they result in tactile perception” (Pons,

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Psychological Perspectives

    1231 Words  | 5 Pages

    Each perspective with their good and bad sides, there are many perspective ranging from: Behavioural Approach; Biological Approach; Clinical Approach; Cognitive Approach; developmental approach; evolutionary Approach, Forensic; et al. BEHAVIOUR APPROACH PERSEPCTIVE Behaviourism is different from the environment because people are viewed as being controlled by their environment and that humans are a products of what they learn from the environment (Saul McLeod 2007). It is a perspective that focuses on learned behaviour more of a man is a product of his environment that the genes has no influence on the way a human behaves, it focused solely on observable behaviours. For a long time in the 50s, this psychological thought was dominating until the early twentieth

    Read More

  • Skinner Vs Psychoanalysis

    1006 Words  | 5 Pages

    This was in stark contrast to behaviorists who believed that behavior was the product of the environment and its consequences

    Read More

  • Social Cognitive Theory Of Aggression Essay

    1301 Words  | 6 Pages

    However, this theory does not always state for all behaviors since thoughts and feelings are influenced by many other factors. Overall, with the amount of evidence, SCT is an important theory because it explains how behaviors are influenced by observational learning. It contributes largely to important human social behaviors as well as social implications. But the theory requires further research to overcome its limitations because we cannot be 100% sure that the aggressive behavior is the result of observing the

    Read More

  • Behaviourist Theory Vs Identity Theory

    1104 Words  | 5 Pages

    In addition, the causal role for mentality is removed. So it could be argued that theory that the mind causes behavior is equivalent to theory that the mind is behavior. The behaviorist theory solves the inverted qualia theory by the defining mental states in reference to their associated behaviours instead of of by reference to their conscious qualities thereby avoiding the inverted qualia problem altogether concluding that if two people behave as If they both see the same color then they probably do. (Jessica Lerm, personal communication, April 9, 2015).

    Read More

  • AP Psychology Outline

    1407 Words  | 6 Pages

    Rachel Danzig AP Psychology Dr. Eisen August 20, 2015 I. Psychology’s History A. Psychology’s Roots 1. Prescientific Psychology a. Socrates and his student Plato stated that the human mind is separate from the body and our knowledge is born within us b. Aristotle, Plato’s student, disagreed, concluding that knowledge can not be preexisting and we grow it from our experiences within our memories c. In the 1600s Rene Descartes believed that the mind can survive the body’s death and our brain holds animal spirits in its fluid and flow from the brain through nerves enabling reflexes d. In 1620 Francis Bacon established that humans functioned around order and patterns e. Adding to Bacon’s ideas was John

    Read More

  • Symbolic Interaction Theory In Social Work

    1651 Words  | 7 Pages

    It is believed people behave in a way they believe, whether it is objectively true or not. For example in our culture, when a husband passes away a woman is expected to wear black clothes that would symbol their mourning, if a woman does not adhere to that it is believed they bring badluck to their lives. The clothes the woman wears are a symbol and has meaning that had been imposed on

    Read More

  • Traditional Western Approach To Modern Psychology

    1382 Words  | 6 Pages

    The Traditional Western approach to modern psychology considers psychology as a science. The knowledge obtained needs to be free of values or predispositions as this could impact the theory or research completely. Our personal feelings need to be set aside to ensure accurate results. Psychology needs

    Read More

  • John B. Watson's Theory Of Behaviorism

    1558 Words  | 7 Pages

    John B. Watson Theory of behaviorism: The term behaviorism refers to the school of psychology founded by John B. Watson based on the belief that behaviors can be measured, trained, and changed. Behaviorism was established with the publication of Watson 's classic paper, Psychology as the Behaviorist Views It (1913). Behaviorism, also known as behavioral psychology, is a theory of learning based upon the idea that all behaviors are acquired through conditioning. Conditioning occurs through interaction with the environment.

    Read More

  • Eysenck's Theory Of Personality Development

    1458 Words  | 6 Pages

    Personality is the way one behaves, thinks and feels. Theorists are interested to learn what shapes personality, what causes one to behave, think and feel the way one does. Different theorists have different beliefs in what causes these individual differences. These individual differences can be split into two categories, nature and nurture. Nature would be environment while nature would be the brain and the genes, also known as genotype.

    Read More

  • Factors Affecting Human Behavior

    1816 Words  | 8 Pages

    The topic of this assignment is to discuss and analyse what factors affect human behavior and in doing so how human behavior is shaped. But before discussing that, it is important to understand what human behavior is. To define it in a few sentences or words would not be sufficient as human behavior consists of many factors and therefore contributes majorly to who we are as a person. But to put it simply, it is defined as all actions and emotions that an individual portrays in response to the different kinds of stimuli they receive no matter whether these responses are conscious or subconscious and voluntary or involuntary (Merriam-webster.com, 2015).

    Read More

More about Arguments Against Eliminative Materialism

Open Document