ipl-logo

Arguments Against Free Will Essay

1075 Words5 Pages

This paper discusses whether or not our actions are controlled by free will. Someone can act freely whenever: (a) she could have done otherwise than she in fact does, or (b) it is up to her what she does. An example of an action of free will is I came to office hours today because I chose and wanted to come. An example of no free will is if I got pushed from behind and fell into the person in front of me and knocked them down. Acting with free will is very important. If we don’t act freely, then we cannot be held accountable for what we do. From my second example stated above, how can I be held accountable for pushing the person in front of me if I did not control it happening? We should only be held accountable if we are acting with free will. Being held accountable can both be positive and/or negative. For example, an employer promoting a new employee to a higher paid position would be an example of a being held accountable in a positive way. Another example, someone accusing his or her friend of stealing money from them would be an example of being held accountable in a negative way. It doesn’t make sense to hold someone accountable when you cannot determine if they were acting with free will or not. …show more content…

If determinism is true, we have no free will.
2. If indeterminism is true, we have no free will.
3. Either determinism is true or indeterminism is true.
4. So, we have no free will.
I am going to reject Premise 3 of the Consequence Argument and explain where the 4-Case Manipulation goes wrong.
Consequence Argument:
1. Determinism is the claim that every event is determined by the past and laws of nature
2. If every event is determined by the past and laws of nature, then each of my actions is determined by the past and the laws of nature
3. If one of my actions is determined by the past and the laws of nature, then I could not have done otherwise than action unless I can control the past and the laws of

Show More
Related

  • Baron D Holbach's Theory Of Determinism

    889 Words  | 4 Pages

    Determinism is a theory that all things in the world is governed by laws. This theory is based upon the materialist view of the body and mind. Materialists think that all things that exist in this world matter. We, humans, have mind or souls and desired interests are based upon actions. This principal argues that we have no moral responsibilities and choices.

    Read More

  • Wes Moore Street Culture Analysis

    454 Words  | 2 Pages

    Having the example above shows society or mankind in general thrives under expectations for a better life. A primary example of this is in World War Two, where new weapons technology was developed for the drive of nationalistic country 's expectations of success. To what extent we should hold ourselves accountable for our actions, depends on the person. With different individuals holding themselves to a higher standard than others creates more accountability for good and bad actions. This can, also happen in vise versa of the sentence above.

    Read More

  • Simon Wiesenthal The Sunflower

    603 Words  | 3 Pages

    Every person is responsible for his or her actions. As Smail Balic said in his response essay “No soul carries the burden of another. ”(110) Only the guilty can absolve their guilt, but sometimes it takes the acknowledgment and words of another human to reach this release. This can be as small as a person who makes a rude remark to another then someone else steps in and calls them out.

    Read More

  • The Seventh Man Analysis

    567 Words  | 3 Pages

    Survival doesn’t always come easy, most of the time you will have to make decisions that will make others judge you, whether you like it or not. For example, if someone left their friend to save themselves, should these people be held accountable for their actions? People shouldn’t be held accountable for those actions because when it comes to life or death that’s so much pressure to that person so of course they’re going to make mistakes and everyone makes mistakes we just have to learn from them. However, people will argue that if they put themselves in that situation they should be held accountable for their action In a story titled The Seventh Man, The story is about a boy and his friend who go to the beach after a storm and they end up in a life or death situation. When they were on the beach out of nowhere a huge wave starts to come towards them, which can kill them both, the Seventh man makes a decision “i told myself to to run over to K….

    Read More

  • Character In National Honor Society

    713 Words  | 3 Pages

    Responsibility means being in charge of your choices and accepting the consequences of your actions. Responsibility means being accountable for yourself, and recognizing that our actions have consequences. Being accountable means to not blame others for your actions or take credit of other’s actions. Responsibility also means showing self-restraint. Self-restraint means restraining yourself from short term activities that could have negative consequences on yourself or your reputation.

    Read More

  • Explain Why People Should Be Held Accountable In Life

    777 Words  | 4 Pages

    Equally people will say that that they should and shouldn 't be held accountable on this life or death situations. For instance… people have chosen this situation that they want to do and they know that they could be held accountable like for example in the story the life of pi, the boy was on a raft with the tiger and they were on each side of the boat but the boy was scared of getting eat by the tiger because the tiger had that look in his eyes of hunger so the boy decided to make a raft near the boat so he would still be alive. They should not be held accountable for this because it is there life and their choosing what they want to do to be free or take something off a bucket list. However... people can chose of what they want to do but they need to think before they do it to test if they are ready for it or that they won 't be scared and know the consequences of what might happen. Also how people even though they don 't know they should have checked first.

    Read More

  • Chisholm's Human Freedom And The Self

    1445 Words  | 6 Pages

    In my essay I will explain, why I agree with Chisholm for thinking that for an agent to be morally responsible for an event, the agent must cause the event so that he is held responsible for hic action when he could have chosen to act differently. I will illustrate why determinism fails in holding an agent responsible, opening up way for the Chisholm’s incompatibalist

    Read More

  • Fate In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    548 Words  | 3 Pages

    Failures and successes in life have led many people to believe that destiny plays a role in one's future life outcome. Some say destiny, the “hidden power believed to control what will happen in the future”, is unchangeable; fate has already decided how one will live their life. Although in some cases this may be true, one is able to change their destiny by the deeds and actions they commit during their lifetime. Many people disregard the idea that actions play a large role in forming one's future.

    Read More

  • The Moral Logic Of Survivor Guilt Summary

    1707 Words  | 7 Pages

    We should not be held accountable for the actions that we did not mean to do in survival

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech Outline On Abortion

    1277 Words  | 6 Pages

    “I believe the freedom to choose my course in life but I do not believe I am free to choose the consequences of my

    Read More

  • Examples Of Fate Over Free Will In Dante's Inferno

    644 Words  | 3 Pages

    Destiny over Free will Free will is a term unheard of nowhere days because of how much the media portrays that we have to do what other people say such as politicians. Some people are destined to think that everything we say and do has already been written out in a script somewhere in heaven and that God already knows what we are going to do before we even do it. People do not possess free will but are governed by fate because in Dante's Inferno the people who were brought down to hell were brought down because they were destined to go down the wrong path and that's why they are in hell and there are special places for people whose fate was a little too heinous and they were forced to go in the middle of heaven and hell and sometimes other people are also destined to lead us to our fate such as Virgil in Dante's inferno. People do not possess free will but are governed by fate because we think we have a choice to change our decisions but what if

    Read More

  • Impossibility Of Moral Responsibility By Galen Strawson

    878 Words  | 4 Pages

    He describes the nature of Moral Responsibility as an illusion. There is an argument which he calls “Basic Argument” which proves that humans can not be morally responsible for their actions. No matter if determinism is true or false Strawson still holds the view on validity of the Basic Argument. The Basic Argument is as follows.

    Read More

  • Difference Between Determinism And Libertarianism

    1216 Words  | 5 Pages

    Determinism and Libertarianism For many years, people have discussed how we choose what to do and what is the reason for choosing what to do. According to determinism, our actions are out of control. Determinism claims that whatever we do is determined by previous events; therefore, we should not be countable for whatever we do. Libertarianism, on the other hand, rejects the determinism and claims that everything we do is voluntary and we are free to make decisions. Unlike a determinist, a libertarian would argue that whatever we do could be different if we desired to choose differently and if it were physically possible to choose differently.

    Read More

  • Determinism Vs Free Will

    1777 Words  | 8 Pages

    Moritz Schlick is a representative of logical positivism doctrine. His definition of free will, determinism and moral responsibility derives from the definition of punishment. He supposes that “Punishment is an educative measure, and as such is a means to the formation of motives, which are in part to prevent the wrongdoer from repeating the act (reformation) and in part to prevent others from committing a similar act (intimidation). Analogously, in the case of reward we are concerned with an incentive." (Schlick, p. 152).

    Read More

  • Chronicle Of A Death Foretold Fate Analysis

    1202 Words  | 5 Pages

    In order for free will free will to be tangible, an individual would have to have control over his or her actions regardless of any external factors. It can be argued that the inevitability of

    Read More

More about Arguments Against Free Will Essay

Open Document