ipl-logo

Arguments Against Manifest Destiny

1106 Words5 Pages

The year 1845, the American newspaper editor John O’Sullivan first coined the phrase, “Manifest Destiny”. This term is the belief that the United States should expand their territory from coast to coast. The Americans thought God was in their favor and should have the ability to take land. Without a doubt, might does not make right since the Americans did not have the right to be justified in the American acquisition of Texas and Mexico. The Americans were invited by the Mexican government to trade and settle in the northern territory, under these circumstances: learn Spanish, adopt the Roman Catholic religion and bring no slave nor democracy, which was not followed by the Americans. The Americans also used techniques of murder toward the Amerindians …show more content…

These actions that the Americans committed due to the belief of Manifest Destiny, resulted in horrific outcomes that should have never happened.

Manifest Destiny had a major influence on expanding the US territory The Amerindians were people who lived in the western territory who did not believe in Manifest Destiny and instead believed in distribution. Compared to the Americans Amerindians had a more positive view on owning land, rather than Americans who wanted to grab all the land they could take. Americans were hungry for more land and wanted to take the Amerindians land for their own selfish needs. The Americans knew the Amerindians were against their civilization, which made the Americans find them useless toward …show more content…

The Mexican government was nice enough to invite the Americans to settle and trade in the northern territory. However the Americans had to agree to not bring any slaves nor democracy, Americans had to learn Spanish, and they had to embrace in the Roman Catholic Religion. Over the years, more and more Americans came to Texas and eventually conquered the population. These Americans did not obey the rules and brought slaves to their farms, spread Protestant, and did not learn Spanish. After Eleven year, Santa Ana became president. He did not fancy how the Americans brought slaves and lacked assimilation. Due to these reasons the battle of Alamo occurred. In April 1836 the Mexicans lost and the Americans took away their land, which goes against another rule in the Declaration Of Independence, “Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.”. If this was true then the Americans would not have taken away land that was not rightfully theirs. The Americans broke the Mexicans law and even broke their own just to seize more land to become

Show More
Related

  • Stephen F Justin Empresario And Borderlander Summary

    874 Words  | 4 Pages

    Starting off with how Comanches, Kiowas, Navajos, and other Indian tribes increased their attacks on Northern Mexican settlements which led to countless raids. Some of the reasons that cause this war were boundary disagreements and Manifest destiny. Americans overall outnumbered Mexicans during this time, which an advantage to Americans. In addition, Mexicans were viewed in a bad way, they saw them as weak and not intelligent. In 1845, Texas was annexed to the United States, the war ended in 1848 with the Treaty of Guadalupe – Hidalgo.

    Read More

  • What Was The Impact Of The Louisiana Purchase Aggressive Imperialism

    414 Words  | 2 Pages

    While the Louisiana Purchase was a key starting point for American expansionism, aggressive imperialism into the West didn’t begin until the middle of the Jacksonian Period. Many Americans considered Manifest Destiny as a benevolent movement and a divinely ordained right to move west toward the Pacific Ocean. It combined discourses of imperialism and freedom by claiming that it was the duty of the US as a Christian, democratic country to take over lands in the Southwest. Manifest Destiny was aggressive imperialism that created a greater need for slavery, oppressed natives, and lead to the Mexican-American War.

    Read More

  • Ap Us Expansionism Dbq Analysis

    447 Words  | 2 Pages

    Manifest Destiny is the belief of the nineteenth century that America was destined by God to expand westward. The author of Our Country: Its Possible Future and Its Present Crisis believed that God established Anglo-Saxons as the superior people whose purpose was to spread Christianity. (Doc B) This idea of spreading a superior culture or religion has been a motive for expansion for decades before this. Despite this support for expansionism, there were those who were against it.

    Read More

  • Manifest Destiny Research Paper

    193 Words  | 1 Pages

    How do you think manifest destiny set the stage for American imperialism at the end of the century? – Manifest destiny set the stage for American imperialism because in believing that expansion of the United States was justified and inevitable, we believed that whatever we did to expand was justified. Even if it meant using force to take more land. What were the motivations for manifest destiny?

    Read More

  • Manifest Destiny's Influence On The Settlement Of The West

    220 Words  | 1 Pages

    Manifest Destiny is the belief or doctrine about the US expansion. It is the assumption that white Americans were “special people” and this came back from the beliefs of the puritans. This doctrine influenced the the settlement of the west because it let white Americans believe that they could control the natives. This doctrine influenced the settlement to the west because it made the migration more likely. Americans attitude towards this was that they thought they deserved all the land.

    Read More

  • Manifest Destiny Research Paper

    1057 Words  | 5 Pages

    In 1846, America declared war on Mexico and fought to win much of what currently makes up the Southwestern portion of the United States. The war with Mexico was just one example of the many militant acts that undoubtably paralleled Manifest Destiny. Manifest Destiny emerged instinctively and inevitability out of fundamental want and need for people to explore, conquer new lands and establish new borders with other nations. With this growth came moral, cultural, social, ideological, and economic differences between people, states and countries. The term Manifest Destiny was often used by those who wanted secure territory in places like California, and Mexico.

    Read More

  • How Did The Americans Contribute To The Rise Of Manifest Destiny

    1449 Words  | 6 Pages

    In 1803, the United States negotiated a deal with France, called the Louisiana Purchase, that gave America a vast amount of land east of the Mississippi. This led to the American Frontier being expanded westward. As the people moved West, John L O’Sullivan dubbed the right for Americans to take this new land Manifest Destiny. The term Manifest Destiny is a term used to describe Anglo-Saxon superiority, and America’s right to expand to new territories to spread freedom. The American Frontier expanding towards the West and even the Caribbean led to the rise of manifest destiny; this yielded negative repercussions because it led to the mistreatment of Native Americans, the rise of greed, and the crippling of the U.S. as a whole by engaging in

    Read More

  • Summary Of Manifest Destiny And American Territorial Expansion

    1622 Words  | 7 Pages

    Manifest Destiny is a unique, yet mysterious fundamental series of events in American history. No other country’s history contains such an eventful history as the United States. Amy Greenberg’s book, Manifest Destiny and American Territorial Expansion, provides documented evidence that settlers believed they were destined for expansion throughout the continent. In other words, many religious settlers believed that it was a call from God for the United States to expand west. On the other hand, people believed that Manifest Destiny vindicated the war against Mexico.

    Read More

  • Concept Of Manifest Destiny

    1283 Words  | 6 Pages

    Based on the following three sources, did the concept of Manifest Destiny motivate Americans to try to develop a relationship with land and to control something that cannot truly be possessed? American Progress –John Gast “on Manifest Destiny, 1839” –John O’Sullivan “Reporting to the President, September 23- December 31, 1806” (pages 418-21) –Stephen Ambrose Use evidence from all three sources to support your ideas. __________________________________________________________________________________________ Manifest Destiny is the belief that the expansion of the US throughout the American continents was both justified and inevitable. This meaning that Americans believed they were destined to hold dominion over both of the American continents

    Read More

  • How Did Manifest Destiny Affect Native Americans

    110 Words  | 1 Pages

    How did the Manifest Destiny affect the lives and culture of native americans during the 1800’s? Manifest Destiny was devastating for the cultures of the majority of Native Americans tribes and even ended tribes completely. Manifest destiny was the idea that the United State would continue to expand in North America and that it “was God’s will”, that they would gain more power and and. This however affected native americans heavily because as the United States became aggressive and took more land after wars that occurred in that time period. Events such as the Trail of Tears, and the First Seminole War, and other events similar greatly affected the native

    Read More

  • How Did Manifest Destiny Affect Mexico

    541 Words  | 3 Pages

    Manifest Destiny changed the United States socially, economically and politically. It was affected socially because it became more culturally diffused; it also affected relationship with the Native Americans due to the Americans belief that they were the better race and others were inferior to them. It was affected economically because there was more land to profit off of and politically it damaged the United States and Mexico’s foreign relations. Those who believed in the manifest destiny forcefully removed Native Americans from their lands in order for the United States to gain more land. America was shifted politically, due to new tense relations with Mexico, as an effect of the Mexican

    Read More

  • Cause And Effect Of Manifest Destiny

    2016 Words  | 9 Pages

    “Once we became an independent people it was as much a law of nature that this [control of all of North America] should become our pretension as that the Mississippi should flow to the sea” –John Quincy Adams (Henretta, p. 384). In the 1840s, Americans had a belief that God destined for them to expand their territory all the way westward to the Pacific Ocean. This idea was called Manifest Destiny. In the nineteenth century, Americans were recognized for coming together and building up one another for one cause: westward expansion.

    Read More

  • Was The Mexican-American War Justified?

    1199 Words  | 5 Pages

    Jesús Velasco-Márquez, a modern-day Mexican professor of studies wrote an article in 2006 about the Mexican-American War. He said, “US historians refer to this event as ‘The Mexican-American War’, while in Mexico, we prefer to use the term ‘The U.S. Invasion... From Mexico’s point of view, the annexation of Texas to the United States was inadmissible for both legal and security reasons. ’’’ (Velasco-Márquez, 12). During the time of the independence of Texas, Mexico was ruled by the dictator General Antonio López de Santa Anna.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Manifest Destiny

    185 Words  | 1 Pages

    A wide range of Americans politicians, regular Americans, church leaders benefited from Manifest Destiny by gaining land and having the chance to share the American culture. They had the idea to spread democracy by taking over the land. They had a great idea but the execution wasn't well thought. You can't just kick the Native Americans out of their home and expect them to be ok with it. Making the American culture expanded is fine but it felt like they were trying to get rid of the Native American culture and make them accustomed to the culture, thoughts, and customs of the Americans.

    Read More

  • Cause And Effect Of Manifest Destiny

    930 Words  | 4 Pages

    Manifest Destiny was the term used by John O’Sullivan to describe America’s desire to expand West due to reasons including both the vast amount of unclaimed land and the opportunities Americans wanted to explore. During this time, Americans believed that it was their God-given right to expand West, and therefore they were entitled to push away any groups that were in their way. Due to the mindset that the Americans could do as they pleased with the groups of people who got in their way, Manifest Destiny affected many groups of people, including the American Indians and Slaves, and continued to build up the preexisting tension between the North and South. One of the groups of people affected greatly by Manifest Destiny were the Native Americans. Manifest Destiny affected the American Indians by spreading foreign diseases to them as they moved Westward, through the Native American territory.

    Read More

More about Arguments Against Manifest Destiny

Open Document