ipl-logo

Autonomy's Role In Ethical Dilemmas

281 Words2 Pages

In my mind the most important unanswered question raised during our class meeting would be, “how to decide what to do in a situation like case 5-2 and living with the decision afterwards” case 5-2 regarded the 77 year old Jamaican woman and the dilemma the doctor was in, in terms of discharging her or keeping her and raising the prices for the other patients. During class we discussed what people would do but because I have different ideas on what I would have done. If I had decided to discharge her I would remember it all the time. I would feel so broken inside for doing that. I would neglect a person’s life to accommodate my place of employments financial situation. Further, the question is, how does a person or myself handle living with the effects of a decision that one is forced to make? …show more content…

I believe the most important point with the readings of chapters 6, 7 and 8 for this week is the way paternalism plays into ethical cases. Sometimes it is easy and others very difficult to solve a dilemma that might require paternalism, but in cases like 6-2, the case about the twelve year old girl that seems to be mature enough to reject a heart transplant that also has her parents on board. The doctor however doesn’t agree. The point to me is should paternalism be given to the doctor after court hearings? It’s a very complicated case. Beneficence and autonomy are clashing in this

Show More
Related

  • What Internal And External Forces Impact Kendra's Concerns In This Case?

    1504 Words  | 7 Pages

    APPENDIX C HIM 6018 – E-HEALTHCARE ETHICS – CASE STUDY ACTIVITIES TEMPLATE Name: Bayo Oshunlalu Unit #: 8 Unit Title: A Case That Hits Close to Home Qu. 1. What internal and external forces impact Sue’s concern in this case? Insert your response to Qu. 1. …………

    Read More

  • Book Report On The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks

    1588 Words  | 7 Pages

    These debates consist of patient’s rights and what they are entitled to that specifically relates to them. It explains her life from the viewpoint of other people but mainly her daughter who deals with these

    Read More

  • Arizona Health Care System Case Study

    2276 Words  | 10 Pages

    This case is complicated and there does not appear to be a clear/easy choice leading to a positive outcome overall. It is important to evaluate the ethical perspectives of a case in order to make an informed decision for the common

    Read More

  • Baby K's Case

    505 Words  | 3 Pages

    I think he could have relied heavily on non-maleficence in a strict sense of the term that doctor should not do any harm. Also, throughout all four cases I believed that we relied heavily on taking into account how the family would be affected by the decision, which shows a utilitarian perspective. I also, noticed that when it came down to the final decisions autonomy of the patient was not always respected by all three of us, such as the car accident victim. She wanted death, but we all denied her because we were worried about her mental health. Although with autonomy we should have still respected her wishes, if we were solly basing our decision on

    Read More

  • Statutory Frameworks That Underpin Service Provision Essay

    2771 Words  | 12 Pages

    [Outcome 3] Understand how to address conflicts or dilemmas that may arise between an individual's rights to choice and control and the duty of care 3.1 Explain why conflicts may arise between the duty of care and an individual’s

    Read More

  • Ethical Theories Of Ethics: Utilitarian And Deontological Approaches

    563 Words  | 3 Pages

    When it comes to justifying what an individual perceives as moral, there are several different ethical theories that provide perspectives as to how situations are evaluated. These theories look at the consequences of the actions, what the agent’s intentions are, and whether the individual is being used as a means to end (May, 2014). Two of the founding theories of ethics are the utilitarian and deontological approaches which are demonstrated through the trolley scenario. While the best option would be to divert to a track with no one tied to it, a utilitarian would pull the switch to lead the trolley down the track to where there was only one person.

    Read More

  • Tomcik Case Study

    785 Words  | 4 Pages

    After reading this case I was terribly shocked about the fact that something like this could happen in our medical history. I couldn’t believe how a patient could be neglected so much. Based on the material that we have learned the lack of ethical theory of deontology in Dr. Evan was disturbing. As a doctor Dr. Evan’s role is to care for patients, keep them away from harm and prolong their life. Though in the trial he stated as if he didn’t care.

    Read More

  • Atul Gawande Whose Body Is It Anyway Analysis

    590 Words  | 3 Pages

    Atul Gawande in his article “Whose body is it, anyway?” introduced couple of cases, which discussed a controversial topic, doctors dealing with patients and making important medical decisions. These are difficult decisions in which people might have life or death choices. Who should make the important decisions, patients or doctors? Patients don’t usually know what is better for their health and while making their decisions, they might ignore or don’t know the possible side effects and consequences of these decisions.

    Read More

  • Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks Essay

    919 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the case of Henrietta Lacks and her family, the mistreatment of doctors and lack of informed consent defined nearly 60 years of the family’s history. Henrietta Lacks and her children had little to no information about serious medical procedures and the use of Henrietta’s cells in research. Henrietta’s cells launched a multibillion-dollar industry without her consent and doctors even took advantage of her children’s lack of education to continue their research without questions: “[Doctor] did not explain why he was having someone draw blood from Deborah… he wrote a phone number and told her to use it for making more appointments to give more blood” (188). Deborah did not have the knowledge to understand the demands or requests the doctors made of her, and the doctors did not inform her explicitly.

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Doctors Dilemma By James Dillard

    329 Words  | 2 Pages

    A Doctors Dilemma I do not like the essay, “A Doctors Dilemma” written by James Dillard. The whole story was well written, but contradicting. The persuasion was driven by whether to help a dying person or save his future career.

    Read More

  • The Four Main Ethical Theory Of Beauchamp And Childress

    1167 Words  | 5 Pages

    Subsequently looking at the overall arch of such principles is the justice which should support fair, equitable and appropriate treatment and or intervention for the individual. A highly stressful time for family regarding decisions that need to be made, while others define the decision as a clinical one, where the doctor will

    Read More

  • Moral Dilemma Analysis

    765 Words  | 4 Pages

    A knob came into my room drunk, I have to decide whether to report him for underage drinking or whether to help him to his room. This decision can affect my relationship with him because if I report him he will not trust me. If I were not to report him, he would trust me because he knows that I care for him as a classmate. This also sets a precedence for him to continue this behavior which is not allowed per White Book rules. This situation is a true moral dilemma because it is applicable to 3 out of 5 tests: the legal test, the professional standards test, the gut feeling test, the front-page test, the role-mode test.

    Read More

  • Ethical Dilemma Paper

    444 Words  | 2 Pages

    Exploring this dilemma from the point of view of the doctor, it can be seen that his best self-interest is very different than that of Ashley’s parents. Defining the doctor’s self-interest, it can be noted that he is probably seeking to defend his position, allow Ashley’s parents to use the medical services to perform the treatment, and make some form of income. If he was an advocate of the procedure and there was substantial backlash against it, then he would be working against his own interests if he condoned it. As a result, it would be non-permissible for the doctor to do anything that would result in negative legal ramifications or critical backlash.

    Read More

  • Reflection On Ethical Decision Making

    1399 Words  | 6 Pages

    One of those most challenging areas I have experience during my current placement is ethical decision-making. We studied many possible scenarios during our Values, Ethics and Professional Issues class, and discussed the various types of decision-making models to help guide us when having to make difficult decisions. While the class was invaluable, because it helped me identify my own biases, and also shed light on how I have made decisions in the past and how I can possibly make decisions in the future, I knew that having to make real-life decisions would not be so cut and dry. This placement has been challenging for me, because my ongoing assignment with one of my supervisors requires constant ethical decision-making, sometimes even in the

    Read More

  • Communitarianism And Solidarity

    1039 Words  | 5 Pages

    As citizens may feel as their independence and individual rights are in question. From the bottom up, is perceived as a personal lifestyle choice, a greater connection to one’s community. Further, one main thought arising might also be: What good is this for me? How will this impact me? How to sell ‘solidarity’ and the ‘common good’ to the egocentric individual?

    Read More

More about Autonomy's Role In Ethical Dilemmas

Open Document