Benchmark Argumentative

1401 Words6 Pages
Benchmark Argumentative Essay On average, 22 people die a day while waiting for a transplant, that is approximately 8,000 people a year. According to Dimitri Linde, a writer at the Wall Street Journal, “There are more than 77,000 Americans currently on waiting lists for a kidney.” (Linde paragraph 2) Sadly, she had the chance to get a new kidney until another woman got hers. Meaning she was at the top of the list, but another woman received the kidney because she was in a worse or life threatening situation where she needed that certain kidney. After the other woman received the kidney, Dimitri, who did not receive the kidney, was put right back on the transplant list. Unfortunately, many people will never get the chance to receive a kidney.…show more content…
Critics often argue that people can already be matched up perfectly by donating organs. Although by donating organs people have the possibility of never receiving the organ, if we sell organs people can put exactly what blood type, the organ condition, and more by selling them and never have the chance of it getting taken by another person in critical condition. For example, Dimitri Linde a writer at the Wall Street Journal, illustrates, “Additionally, by working with living donors, these matching services furnish kidneys that endure, on average, twice as long as equally compatible cadaver transplants.” (Linde paragraph 8) Linde is trying to point out that living donors are better than dead ones, which give you much more time to keep the organ fresh till use. For example, every human has two kidneys if you are willing to sell a kidney the chances of the transplant working for the person in need is higher because it is an alive organ. Linde also states, “The recipient 's health insurance incurs the expense of the donor 's pre-op, surgery and post-op recovery, as well as any unanticipated complications in the following year.” (Linde paragraph 11) This means that if people have a problem after being matched up with an organ health insurance pays for everything else so they could help with payments for the alive organ. In his article, "Brain Death and Organ Donation,”James DuBois, a writer for the magazine “America” confirms, “An organ that has been deprived of oxygen sufficiently long will die, and it is medically impossible to change dead brain cells to living brain cells.” (DuBois paragraph 7) Basically, DuBois is emphasizing that an organ that does not have much oxygen left to live on, will die, so by using living organs will be a beneficiary. In summary, it is absolutely essential that
Open Document