“Struck dead by an angel of God! Yet the angel must hang.” (Captain Vere) Some believe Billy Budd, the young and innocent sailor, should not have been sentenced to death. Others believe Billy Budd should have been sentenced to death. Billy Budd, the young and innocent sailor, should not have been sentenced to death, for these three reasons. Billy Budd was innocent, Billy Budd was impaired, and Billy was unaware. Billy Budd had the mind of an innocent and unexposed being. Billy Budd had no understanding of evil. Billy could not comprehend the evil acts others committed, some against him and some against his crewmates. Billy Budd thinks there is no evil in the world only good making him vulnerable in the eyes of some. Billy Budd was impaired
Overall, Stanley “Tookie” Williams did not deserve clemency. First, according to the article, “As a Criminal” it says “Williams scheduled to be executed at San Quentin State Prison Dec.13 for the shotgun murders of four people…” In other words Williams killed 4 people for what he was held in prison
Dr. Samuel Mudd was sentenced life in prison and Mary Surratt was hanged for her crimes. Should Mary Surratt not have been hanged for her crimes and should Samuel have been hanged for his crimes? Why did Dr. Mudd not get hanged for his crimes, instead of getting
Pete Rose: The Fall of a Star Athlete Often referred to by his nickname, “Charlie Hustle,” Pete Rose was one of the greatest players in the history of the Major League Baseball Association. Throughout his professional career, Rose played for the Cincinnati Reds, the Philadelphia Phillies, and the Montreal Expos as a stellar athlete. He also set a batting record that is still unbroken to this day (“Peter Rose Biography”). However, Pete Rose, a modern day tragic hero, fell in disgrace from stardom because of his limitless desire to gamble, resulting in his permanent ineligibility to be placed in one of baseball’s most important monuments, the Hall of Fame. His weakness for gambling led to his downfall and, like most tragic heroes, Rose could not see his own faults until it was too late.
Billy Bob Jr. was a normal man with massive strength. He would do everything extravagantly and in a very showoff fashion. When he made his bed he would Fluff the pillows by picking them up and punching them out of his hand like a bullet until it landed on the place he wanted. He didn’t even buy his house he built it himself brick by brick literally here is a picture- And it only took 5 days.
Then he snuck up on a guard and shot him to death with his own pistol. Then he got a double barreled shotgun and gunned down a second guard then he escaped. After he escaped death he went and hid out for a while but he didn't keep a low profile for long when sheriff pat garret rode up on a ranch he was staying at. Then billy rode up and went inside to his room where the sheriff was waiting for him where he shot him dead. He fired two shots one hit him in the heart killing him
Others might debate that if they had waited for a true trial, then Billy might not have been hung. This argument does not persuasive. Marshal Law is very clear in its meanings. An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. If you kill someone, you must be
The False Sentence For The First Woman Executed Mary Surratt shouldn’t have been executed. Her co- conspirators said she was innocent and she might have not known about how much John Wilkes Booth and his partners used her boarding house and tavern. Surratt's co-conspirators said that she had nothing to do with the plan to murder Lincoln.
Even though his testimony helped to indict one of the power House faction leaders, John Dolan, the district attorney defied Wallace’s order to set Billy free after testifying. However, Billy was a skilled escape artist and slipped out of his handcuffs and fled. For the next year, he hung around Fort Sumner on the Pecos River and developed a fateful friendship with a local bartender named Pat Garrett, who was later elected sheriff of Lincoln County. As sheriff, Garrett was charged with arresting his friend Henry McCarty, who by now was almost exclusively known as “Billy the Kid. ”At about the same time, Billy had formed a gang, referred to as the “Rustlers” or simply “Billy the Kid’s Gang,” who survived by stealing and rustling as he did before.
I believe that Billy was the most heroic character in “Billy Budd” than Captain Vere. He was a man that did not argue or be mad even though he was forced on a naval ship. He was generally kind and was liked by other sailors. Even when Captain Vere made him be hang, he accepted the situation, and sacrifice himself for other problems that could happen if he was not punished. While in the other hand.
James Earl Ray cared for himself and didn’t think about consequences, he just wanted to get by and live well no matter how he got
Should someone be convicted of murder even if they did it to protect themselves and their friends or should they remain guilty? In the fictional novel The Outsiders written by S.E. Hinton there are two main rival gangs, The Socs and The Greasers. One night Johnny Cade and Ponyboy Curtis were at a park Far East and the socs came and they fought. While they were fighting Johnny took a 6 inch switchblade and stabbed Bob in the back. This resulted o in the death of Bob.
Most people thought sentencing the 21 year-old bomber to death as “a fitting punishment for this horrific crime” (Lynch, n.d.). I believe the punishment was somewhat appropriate. Seeing the man that killed or caused immense suffering to many innocent people, being sentenced to death, was considered
Yes, he should’ve acted differently, although we don’t know what goes on in someone’s head when they see something so crazy happen so fast. How would it feel to see someone you are so close to kill someone you just met? I wouldn’t believe it or know what to do. As I’ve said before Dustin isn’t completely innocent but the charges he has aren’t accurate especially compared to Billy since he has less than Dustin even after admitting to being guilty of murder.
“Gentleman, Your Verdict”: A Moral Dilemma 1. In my opinion, I don’t think the jury should convict Commander Oram of murder because he wanted at least some people to survive and to do that, many men had to die. The fact that he commits suicide makes a difference because if he hadn’t it would have made it look like he killed 15 other men so that he could survive. If he hadn’t commit suicide, I would definitely change my answer to ‘yes, he is guilty’. I don’t think that the other crew members are guilty because they didn’t have a say in what was done.
A Brief Summation of Billy Budd Historical Setting/Context Set in 1797 during the Napoleonic Wars, shortly after the notorious Nore Mutiny in the British fleet. Main Characters Billy Budd (Protagonist) - Budd’s role as the “The Handsome Sailor” is his most important quality which leads to most of his trouble. He is quite a simple man that makes his confusion of situations throughout the story prominent.