Compare and Contrast Essay
The novel “Catherine called Birdy” by Karen Cushman, is about a 14 year old girl named Catherine who records all her incidents in her journal. Catherine’s father arranges her to meet rich noble suitors, not wanting to be wed to someone she does not love she causes mischief with the suitors she meets. As in the romance story of Romeo and Juliet written by Shakespeare is about a young couple from different households whose love is forbidden due to their a deep ongoing family feud. The young couple is faced with many obstacles in order to be able to be together. Both novels share many similarities and differences in maturation/ coming of age, symbolism, and theme of fate.
An idea that is both shared in Romeo and Juliet and Catherine called Birdy is maturation/ coming of age. In Catherine called Birdy, Catherine knows that soon she has to be married off, so Catherine “grows less childish and more learned” (Cushman page 22). Like Catherine, Juliet is also mature for her age. She shows this through her love for Romeo and her independance. “My dismal scene I needs must act alone.” (Shakespeare act IV scene iii). Catherine and Juliet also share the common idea of coming age, since marriage at a young age was common during their time period. They are both about 13 years old moving on to 14, and are both introduced with the idea of marriage. …show more content…
Unlike Catherine called Birdy and Romeo and Juliet, Juliet’s way of maturity is different than Catherine’s. In Juliet’s case maturity is her showing independence, but in Catherine’s case maturity is being less childish and is able to take
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
Teenagers claim to be independent individuals, yet they still value their parents and constantly look to them for support. William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet is a classic play regarding two teenagers from feuding families who ultimately fall in love despite their parents' wishes. The tragic demise of the two lovers is a direct result of the Capulet’s disregard for Juliet’s emotional well being. The Capulet and Montague’s feud prompts Juliet to assume her own parents would disapprove of her relationship with Romeo. Thus, she is forced to keep their marriage private, causing her to perform elaborate schemes and eventually resort to committing suicide.
Romeo and Juliet make harsh decisions very quickly without really thinking them through. Many of their decisions are based on their parents because the children are rebelling against them. Romeo and Juliet act irresponsibly without even realizing it and they get themselves into trouble. When they act irresponsibly it
Romeo And Juliet Essay In the play Romeo And Juliet by William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet do not mature during the play. Throughout the play, Romeo and Juliet continually make stupid and extreme decisions out of love instead of thinking rationally.
Romeo and Juliet Compare/Contrast Sometimes, people are just not meant to be together. Romeo and Juliet are two different types of lovers. The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, by William Shakespeare, is about two teenagers who make quick decisions and it ends up coming back to haunt them. Romeo and Juliet are from to feuding families but somehow end up falling in love.
Beautiful women, Princesses, and love struck women. What do all these have in common? Juliet and the lady (princess) all have these descriptions in common; they share the same qualities. I believe that Juliet from Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare and the Lady from the Lady or the Tiger by Frank R. Stockton are similar and different. I think Juliet and the Lady are alike because they are very love struck.
Juliet tells Romeo, “How camest thou hither, tell me, and wherefore?/ The orchard walls are high and hard to climb,/ And the place death, considering who thou art,/ If any of my kinsmen find thee here (II.,ii, 62-65) Romeo risked his life for the person he loves, which shows a shift in maturity. “I would not for the world they saw thee here” (II., ii, 74). Juliet tells Romeo she wouldn’t let anything happen to him, which also shows a shift in maturity. The revenge, love, and secret marriage caused Romeo and Juliet to grow up quickly and become more of an adult and make more decisions on their own.
William Shakespeare's “Romeo and Juliet” is about, two young people falling in love two different rivaling households. Having faced the utmost odds, Romeo and Juliet fall in love upon first sight, and pursue each other. However, while trying to be together, they make some unfortunate decisions that ultimately lead to the tragic end. In the story
My opinion On Romeo and Juliet Love is so unique and powerful that there are many ways to express love that exists amongst us. The play Romeo and Juliet By William Shakespeare is about two teenagers, Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet, are madly in love, but their parents are enemies. Juliet’s mother would never let her marry an enemy. In Romeo and Juliet, there is three types of love. The first love is eros which is a love mostly by the body.
The differences between the two of them are the methods of the way that they each go about marrying Juliet. The methods that Paris would want to do would be by following regular tradition and ask Lord Capulet for Juliet’s hand in marriage because he prefers to do everything smoothly and does not mind to cause conflict. The way that Romeo would do this would be to just keep it between Juliet and himself and ask for her hand in marriage because he does not want any conflict to be involved. Between Romeo marrying Juliet and Paris marrying her it would probably be better for Romeo to marry her due to the fact that he knows her more and is also closer to her more than Paris is. The way that Paris had asked for Juliet’s hand in marriage was actually the right way because he asked Lord Capulet.
But now the 2014 play, 1996 movie, and the 1968 drama (all three films) are going to be compared together. All these films had the same exact plot, exactly just like Romeo and Juliet was written. They all kept the language of the original script from Romeo and Juliet, not even changing it a little. All of the films had all of the same characters, no more and no less. In all three films there was some type of religion, from a church, to a sculpture, to an image.
The Immaturity of Romeo and Juliet Immaturity can spread throughout things and people creating problems for the present and future. Similarly, Romeo and Juliet not only shows the development of love, but the loss of maturity that leads to tragedy. People develop maturity, but the amount of immaturity makes the process go backwards. From Romeo and Juliet’s fast evolving relationship to the hate between the two families, and the lack of thought in different characters is recurrent throughout the story. Therefore,the theme of Romeo and Juliet evolves around the idea of immaturity.
The majority of people regard adolescence as a tumultuous time, so it comes as no surprise that it is the focus of many literary works. Few, however, match the grandness of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. In the timeless tale, two “star-crossed lovers” meet their demise. Undoubtedly, their actions are lamentable, but fault lies on more sources than solely them. Romeo and Juliet cannot be entirely blamed for their love’s outcome because of rampant emotions, neglectful parents, and an increased enticement in harmful activities.
Romeo and Juliet represents two families of similar social economic status and wealth but are in an interpersonal conflict between a flourishing love and a gory family feud. Juliet immensely changes during the course of the movie from a young girl to a mature young lady because she must deal with a forced marriage, abusive parents, and the banishment of Romeo. However, Romeo is a flat character focusing more on love than understanding the seriousness of the feud. When the two beloved children die, the dynamic changes as both families have empathy towards each other, therefore peace emerges from the tragic loss. Romeo and Juliet, the star-crossed lovers are very relatable and that is why we still read and watch his play four-hundred years
First, a similarity between the movie and play is that both families/groups live in Verona. Romeo and Juliet takes place in the city of Verona, Italy. On the other end in Gnomeo and Juliet, the two families live on Verona Avenue. A second similarity is that in both movies, Romeo trespasses into the enemy’s territory.