In Body Ritual Among the Nacirema, Horace Miner develops a weird, quirky society called the Nacirema that is made up of natives who go about their day doing odd rituals and tasks. The purpose of the story was to have people judge other cultures less harshly by making them step back and think about what they were perceiving. Additionally, Miner calls attention to how similar cultures are from region to region without even knowing. Sociologists from the perspectives of functionalism, conflict, and symbolic interaction would interpret Nacirema society differently and in a unique way. Throughout the story Body Ritual Among the Nacirema, many ideas that align with the three theoretical perspectives are blatantly displayed by the Nacirema natives. …show more content…
In the event that the magical materials get disorganized and not all get put back into the charm-box, then the worshipper may be unprotected. This action of ensuring that the materials are in their designated location so that the natives are protected communicates to functionalists that they are taking great care not to become an anomie. Functionalists would wonder what the consequences of an uncompleted task would be and how the unfinished task would affect others in the household. This need for structure and alignment is clearly displayed on several occasions throughout the story, therefore expressing the importance. The idea is stated again when “[t]he Nacirema have an almost pathological horror of and fascination with the mouth, the condition of which is believed to have a supernatural influence on all social relationships. Were it not for the rituals of the mouth, they believe that their …show more content…
The author states that “[m]ost houses are of wattle and daub construction, but the shrine rooms of the more wealthy are walled with stone. Poorer families imitate the rich by applying pottery plaques to their shrine walls” (503). Stone is associated with wealth in the community. When a native sees the stone in an individual’s home, they automatically know they are in a wealthy household. This symbol of wealth stirs up emotions, so much so that other natives try to copy the rich. Poor families get upset and try to appear as though they were at least somewhat wealthy to fit in. A symbolic interactionist would hold the questions of what emotions do the poor feel as they see stone, the symbol of wealth, when they are out and about or how do the rich feel when they see wattle and daub houses. The symbols are all around the natives, even on them physically, as “[g]eneral dissatisfaction with breast shape is symbolized in the fact that the ideal form is virtually outside the range of human variation. A few women afflicted with almost inhuman hypermammary development are so idolized that they make a handsome living by simply going from village to village and permitting the natives to stare at them for a fee” (506). Having very unnatural body parts, or in this case breasts, symbolizes several different things. The first is that people with
A little bit of perspective on the society and culture of the Nacirema people involve body rituals and how they go through great lengths to ensure physical wellness. It is difficult as a reader to make sense of the rituals the Nacirema performed and why they did. The Nacirema people believe that the human body is ugly and that it is susceptible to disease. They live a very bizarre lifestyle, not the stressing on the physical well-being part but the spiritual sense they put into their beliefs.
These arts are greatly designed and the stones which were used lasts long for
I claim the meaning and purpose of this sculpture and its setting is to exist as a place for all people to gather, reflect, pray and meditate but more importantly, to feel protected. This shrine for Saint Kateri Tekakwitha inspires these actions and feelings in a number of different ways. One way the sculpture conjures feelings of protection and safety is because of the mere fact that Saint Kateri is a woman. The individuals that look upon the sculpture are immediately met with a loving gaze, a gaze that looks similar to the look a cherishing and nurturing mother would give to her child. The Native Americans of this community can directly relate to this work of art due to the fact that the person being represented shares their ethnicity.
Junger describes the troubles of modern western society saying, “On a material level it is clearly more comfortable and protected from the hardships of the natural world. But as societies become more affluent they tend to require more, rather than less, time and commitment by the individual, and it’s possible that many people feel that affluence and safety simply aren’t a good trade for freedom” (16). He believes that the modern society has become too obsessed with the material objects and less attracted to being a part of a community. In the novel written by James M. Volo, he writes, “All the material wealth of the Indians belonged to the women, including the fields, gardens, dwellings, and the village itself” (Volo 45). Now one reason he said it would be ideal to have no emotional attachment to material belongings was that it would be easier to move whenever the circumstances called upon it.
I think that Horace Miner was attempting to be satirical in describing American culture in order for other anthropologist to look at their own culture more subjectively. He calls the tribe Nacirema, or American spelled backwards and calls everyday objects by there more literal names, like charm box (medicine cabinet) and mouth-rite ritual (brushing your teeth). Miner makes us think that this is a Native American tribe to play off our thoughts and stereotypes that we may have. He wants us to think this is a tribe of backwards people when in fact he is describing Americans. For example, he talks about the chest built into the wall of the shrine that holds magical potions that no one believes they could live without and people seek out the
After reading Laura Bohannan’s Shakespeare in the Bush and Horace Miner’s Body Ritual Among the Nacirema, a common theme presents itself between the two articles. Ethnocentrism, particularly within the U.S., is elucidated through the actions of Bohannan while in West Africa, and the reaction of any American reading Miner’s piece about the “magical” Nacirema culture. In Bohannan’s piece, she struggles to prove that Hamlet is a universal story that any culture can easily understand. She speaks to the elders of the Tiv people, and is shocked to conclude that they do not understand Hamlet the way Americans understand it. In Miner’s piece, he cleverly presents the idea of the culture of the Nacirema people who are sadistic in nature, and lack logic
Horace Miner, a American Anthropologist wrote an academic essay titled “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema.” In this article Miner described some of the bizarre rituals and practices of the “Nacirema” which the reader comes to find out that he is talking about North Americans. The way Miner goes into detail about how these people live makes them seem foreign. Thus making the norm for an American lifestyle seem odd because the certain type of lingo Miner uses to make this “tribe” more exotic then the actually are. His point in doing this is to show the reader how obnoxious anthropologist can be when they are explain a different culture.
Trying to understand the cultures of other groups of people is hard, whether the culture be extreme or not. After first reading Body Ritual among the Nacirema, this was the case as the culture seemed to be undoubtedly crazy. The rituals and customs of the Nacirema people are hard to understand as they hold spiritual and ritualistic reasoning. Every minor part of their days had some cultural meaning to it. Though, a comparison because the Nacirema people and the people of today shows that the rituals and customs are actually very similar, but thought of in a more cultural and spiritual way.
Symbolic interactionism is placing a meaning on an object and behave based of that meaning which might not be necessarily true. This theory is present within the novel because the Hmong ascribe a stigma to doctors and by doing so this causes them to interact with them differently. Another example of symbolic theory within the novel is the placenta that the Hmong symbolize. The placenta is symbolize as the passage for the soul and they were upset with the Western medicine for not being able to keep the placenta after child birth, however Dr. Fife did allow this which caused more interactions with Hmong for Dr. Fife. Also, even though doctors warn against the handling of the placenta because it may transfer disease, they ignore it because of the symbolic importance it have to them.
In Horace Miner’s “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” he describes various habits and traditions the Nacireman people go through in everyday life and throughout the year. Miner also describes different places and how the people interact with each other as a society. While describing some of the customs, he points out how barbaric and sometimes inhumane the rituals are. Another reoccurring topic is the Nacireman people’s ideas of beauty and what ways to make themselves better looking. Miner concludes with the fact it is arduous to understand a different culture other than our own when only looked at face value.
Jennine Selina G. Boado 11418877 INTHROP Reading #2 Body Ritual among the Nacirema Horace Miner’s “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” discusses the magical beliefs and practices of the North American group called “Nacirema”. By re-reading the article I have found out that Miner created this article to by using symbolization to look at the “vanity” of the lifestyle of the Americans and to provide an outside point of view of the “Nacirema” or “American’s” culture. From the article, Miner characterizes the Naciremas as highly focused on their appearance and health which signifies American’s obsession with their personal apperance. Their fundamental belief, according to Miner is that the “human body is ugly and the only way to avert these characteristics is through the use of rituals and ceremonies”.
This is an example of this because Miner was able to describe this culture in a positive way. Even though there are so many versions of what the world portrays of a culture, Miner tried to make his readers understand it without making positive or negative judgements towards the culture. The gender roles in this article relates to also the conceptions of gender discussed in class, because when Miner is talking about the “medicine men” the thought of a man playing the role – the medicine men is a doctor in reality. When Miner talks about the “listener” you get more of the vibe that it is a female – listening to people’s feelings. Another topic that the “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” is the ethnocentric Fallacy, this is true because as you read this article, it seems as though you can either take it on way, that the idea the belief’s and behaviors are right and true, which those of other peoples are wrong or
Some of those rituals are avoiding exposure of their body and bathing in secret. They believe that the body is an ugly thing. In order to make it better they have to perform a ritual and ceremony. Many of their homes have multiple shrines dedicated to this purpose. The more powerful
Technologically, only men possessed the knowledge about the materials used and the techniques of manufacturing the stone axes. Women and children could use the axes, but were not allowed to make them. The stone axe had become an integral part of the society and was used for many activities, such as obtaining food, household purposes, building huts, cutting firewood etc. There was a certain area where the stones necessary for making these axes were found. This formed a chain of tradesmen throughout the country.
Horace Miner, the author of “Body Ritual among the Nacirema”, used very interesting and descriptive choice of words to describe the routines that modern Americans go through from an outsider point of view. He gives different terms to describe mundane routines, like brushing your teeth, and exaggerate the details as something that is bizarre. Some rituals Miner described as illogical because there was a low rate of success in what they are trying to achieve. This reveals that what determines something to be socially acceptable is not through logic, but only though the popularity of the community. One of the rituals that Miner described as illogical but everyone still do the ritual was the fact that the people kept going to the “holy-mouth-man”, or also known as the dentist, even if their teeth are still decaying.