ipl-logo

Boundary Waters Pros And Cons

616 Words3 Pages

The Topic that I propose to write my literary review on is the issues of Sulfide mining in the regions around the Boundary Waters. Main topics of discussion will be the pros and cons of a proposal made by several large mining company’s that want to capitalize on the mineral recourses of the Boundary Waters region. The most notable out of these companies is Polynet with the most amount of leverage and progression in enacting mining operations. The importance of this issue is substantial affecting the state of Minnesota environmentally, economically, and the risk to human health. While the economic gains for the region may be substantial it can be argued that regulation needs to be set up and enacted by such organizations as the EPA or DNR to …show more content…

With mining company Polylink claiming “We need the minerals!” “We have the know-how, we’ve have the labor, the financial resources, and the laws to do it here as well as or better than anywhere else in the world."(Breining, G. 2014, April 10). Along with these statements The Minnesota Department of Natural Recourses did an estimate and reported that schools would receive nearly $720 million over a 25-year period (LPSFC. (n.d.)). But on the other hand effects of sulfide mining is known to leach into the soil changing its pH level. What this does is prevents plants from getting vital nutrients they need to survive through a process known a liming (Nkongolo, K.,2013). To further understand the situation I also looked at other instances both internationally and nation wide were there might have been a similar situation to this. What a found was an instance at Yellowstone National Park. A company named Crown Mines proposed sulfide mining near this national park and more importantly the Yellowstone River. After the mine was built experts found that chemical sludge was being produced and being drained in the Yellowstone river. In response a large dam was built changing the region forever Gorman, S. (n.d. 1995). This ties into local concerns about the ST. Louis river that is a primary fishery resource for many native populations as well as an important agricultural

Show More
Related

  • Standing Rock Sioux Reservation Case Study

    760 Words  | 4 Pages

    Initial federal permits, and partnership with affected tribes, were treated as a “check the box” exercise. Nowhere was there a careful analysis of how much the Missouri River crossing threatened water quality and tribal treaty rights. Nowhere was there a thoughtful public discussion of whether a new major oil pipeline should be placed in a river providing drinking water to 17 million people. And one had to pore over hundreds of pages of technical data to learn that the original route of the pipeline crossed the river just north of Bismarck, N.D. — a capital city that is nearly 90 percent white — and was moved to Standing Rock only when regulators expressed concern over the risk of a spill to the city’s water

    Read More

  • Richard M. Donovan's Paddling The Wild Neches

    1104 Words  | 5 Pages

    Richard M. Donovan wrote the book “paddling the Wild Neches”. Once the story is fully read, the realization of what a human will do in order to keep an important place that values so much, it is magnificent. Richard was 66 years old during his 200 mile canoeing expedition, he did not think that he was going to make it happen. However, he accomplished what he felt he needed to do so he can open minds about a place that needs their help. He captured what was hidden in the river and wanted to tell his story about it.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Killing For Coal By Thomas G. Andrews

    810 Words  | 4 Pages

    A young William Palmer witnessed firsthand, the environmental damages inflicted by Britain industrial revolution. Palmer had a vision for Colorado as the hub of Western industrialization that promised a better society where business can thrive harmoniously with humans and the natural world. A dilemma arose when he realized that his vision for Colorado, railroad trains and mechanical missionary would destroy the country’s beautiful landscape. Andrews argues that Palmer’s had an inter struggle between profitability and ethical issues arising from the expanding and very expensive industrialization. One of the difficult situation was the working and living condition of the coal

    Read More

  • Comparing Glen Canyon And Lake Powells

    246 Words  | 1 Pages

    Despite the the lecturer says that the description of Glen Canyon and Lake Powell are true, he casts doubts on some of the arguments in favor of draining the lake. Therefore, he thinks that the lake should be drained for three main reasons. Firstly, the lecturer differs from the assumption that if drained, tourism in the lake could be affected and it directly damages a substantial source of revenue for the people that work with tourism in the lake. He explains that before the lake was formed, Glen was a Canyon, like Grand Canyon.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Arctic National Wildlife Refuge By Jimmy Carter

    412 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Jimmy Carter’s foreword to Arctic National Wildlife Refuge: Season of Life and Land, A Photographic Journey, he argues the reason why the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge should not be developed as an industrial site. The former U.S. President signed the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, which safeguards at least 100 million acres of parks, forests, and refuges in Alaska, as a monumental Legislation. To strengthen his argument, Carter uses evidence that supports his claims along with reasoning to connect the two, and uses pathos to appeal to the audience's’ emotion. Evidence and reasoning are used to support the claims that the Refuge should be kept a reserve.

    Read More

  • Foreword To The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge Rhetorical Analysis

    517 Words  | 3 Pages

    He describes the “roads and pipelines, drilling rigs and industrial facilities” that would take over a place so wild and beautiful as the Arctic Refuge. He describes animals’ homes being lost, a wildness no longer wild, he reasons that for this to be lost would be a “tragedy”. A tragedy that would also be for so little. Carter explains that “At best, the Arctic Refuge [could] provide 1 to 2 percent of the oil [the] country consumes each day” – a fractional profit for such a major loss. His reasoning stretches from the sentimentality of the beauty that would be lost, to the incredible losses unchallenged by miniscule

    Read More

  • Too Fishy For My Taste Judas Analysis

    820 Words  | 4 Pages

    With the River Project, all the water that the farmers need will be used to help restore the salmon. Farmers don’t just grow the crops for themselves. It’s for everyone else as well. Within a couple of years, there won’t be any need for that project, and all that money and water will have gone to waste. “And it’s coming at a time when water shortages already are killing the Valley’s west-side, farm-based economy.”

    Read More

  • Harvey Gap Reservoir Case Study

    540 Words  | 3 Pages

    Built in 1964, a 360 surface area reservoir lies near the base of the Grand Hogback, nine miles North of Rifle. The clear water of Rifle Gap reservoir provides excellent fishing, boating, sup, jet skiing, water skiing, and swimming for its visitors. I was lucky enough to talk to a lady ranger who graduated from Adams State University. I asked her what the biggest risk at Harvey Gap and Rifle Gap were and without any hesitation, she responded “Boating”.

    Read More

  • Emily Stanley And Pierre Dam Environmental Effects

    348 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dams come with an array of environmental impacts which include direct impact to the surrounding ecosystem. Dams block water flow and slow the velocity of water flowing in rivers overwhelming the surrounding ecosystem (Emily H Stanley and Martin W Doyle, 2003). Sediments and debris which are critical for maintaining habitats downstream of the damn often get trapped in reservoirs which is responsible for the alteration of a river's flow and sediment transport downstream causing the extinction of many fish and other aquatic species and the greatest sustained environmental impacts (“Environmental Impacts of Dams”, n.d). The most notable of all the impacts is the extinction of salmon in the country which has been heavily documented in the movie.

    Read More

  • Hetchy Dam Pros And Cons

    1025 Words  | 5 Pages

    The proposed dam in Hetch Hetchy Valley was to supply fresh water and electricity to San Francisco. The valley is in Yosemite National park would deliver power and water to the city over 100 miles away. This would also mean that park of the national park would be flooded destroying the forest and nature living in the valley. The common view among americans was that is was in the most part for the greater good. George Knapp held the view of the common American and stated “Our natural resources have been used, not wasted”.

    Read More

  • Theodore Roosevelt's Impact On The Environment

    1313 Words  | 6 Pages

    Under President Theodore Roosevelt at the turn of the century the role of the United States Federal Government in Environmental policy began to change. As President, Roosevelt’s contributions to American Conservation, such as the creation of numerous national parks, monuments, and forests, are historically significant. However, these natural resources were not managed by a centralized organization until 1916. Considered by naturalist John Muir, the founder of the Sierra Club, as the equivalent to the neighboring Yosemite Valley, the lesser known Hetch Hetchy Valley is seldom called by its name. More commonly, citizens of San Francisco refer to it as “the reservoir” which it became after the construction of the O’Shaughnessy Dam in 1923.

    Read More

  • Joseph Amato Local History Summary

    627 Words  | 3 Pages

    Subsequent chapters address literature and business. The author often looses focus to present a case of studying local history. At times it seems like Amato is delivering a history of the prairies of Minnesota, not making a case for local history. He does circle back to the concept of local history; however, I do not think that it is as strong as it should be.

    Read More

  • Advantages And Disadvantages Of Seawalls

    894 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ved : Cloud seeding Dikes - Holland Thames barrier Sea wall A seawall is a coastal defense system, constructed where the sea (or other coastal water bodies), impact directly upon the coastal land. The purpose of a seawall is to protect areas of human habitation, conservation and leisure activities from the action of tides and waves. As a seawall is a man made structure made of cement, it will interfere with the land and water sediment exchanging. Seawalls are classified as : “A hard engineering shore based structure used to provide protection and to lessen coastal erosion.”.

    Read More

  • Essay On The California Gold Rush

    808 Words  | 4 Pages

    "California presented to people a new model for the American dream—one where the emphasis was on the ability to take risks, the willingness to gamble on the future,” writes H.W. Brands, historian and educator of U.S. history. The gold rush, the event responsible for bringing several immigrants to California in search of gold, clearly displayed the idea of Manifest Destiny, the idea that the U.S.’ expansion was a given right. While the gold rush may have impacted history, not all of these effects were good. Through the gold rush, the environment was negatively affected and several Native Americans were pushed out of California. When gold was discovered in California during 1848, it acted as a renewal in the adventurous spirit of several Americans.

    Read More

  • Richard Muller Nuclear Waste Rhetorical Analysis

    915 Words  | 4 Pages

    Richard A. Muller a professor of physics at the University of California, Berkeley, expresses his concerns on the subject of nuclear waste. In his essay, Nuclear Waste, he writes about where the United States stores its nuclear waste, alternative ways to dispose of the waste and whether it would be effective. He also talks about how dangerous the nuclear by-product is, and other dangers regarding civilian’s safety. He effectively explains his concerns through pathos, logos, ethos, and other uses of examples to help readers understand his concerns. He attracts readers by talking about the future generation and their safety against potential nuclear waste contamination.

    Read More

More about Boundary Waters Pros And Cons

Open Document