ipl-logo

Brenton Butler: The Case Of Jacksonville Florida

1910 Words8 Pages

Brenton butler, a 15 year old young man that lived in Jacksonville Florida was arrested for committing murder in 2000. A man, Mr. James Stevens and his wife were robbed at gunpoint in front of a Ramada Inn in Jacksonville Florida. During the course of the robbery, the wife was shot and killed in front of her husband. He was able to give a description of the assailant and so he did. The assailant committing this crime has been characterized as a six feet tall skinny black male of age in between 20 and 25 years of age (Mr. Stevens 2000). Although Brenton Butler is much younger than the description given, and Butler is much shorter than the description as well, at least half a decade younger, he was still positively identified as to being the …show more content…

I believe that even though Mr. Stevens had positively identified Butler as being the suspect, he should have still been given a picture line up or some other sort of process to either identify Butler or rule him out. Mr. Stevens admitted that butler was wearing different cloths than the first suspect, but was told by the officers that Butler went home and changed. The problem with this is the time frame that Butler had supposedly had to commit the crime, go home, see his family, do what he did at home, shower, change his clothes then go back to the same area where the crime was committed.
The murder was committed as a robbery in the first place and Mrs. Stevens purse was taken in the process of the robbery. This means that the suspect had touched the purse and under Locard’s exchange principal, there should be something at the crime scene and on the purse and also something on the perpetrator. The police or investigators did not process any evidence that they found. The purse was found by a can collector and called into the police. The purse contained about $1200 in cash and all of Mrs. Stevens property that was originally in her purse. The whole problem I find with the location where the purse was discovered is that it does not coincide with anything the police were trying to tie together for a timeline of the crime. There was no way that Butler, on foot, could have done what they said he did in their

Show More
Related

  • Court Case Brief: Maryland Vs. Pringle

    1242 Words  | 5 Pages

    The officer initiated a traffic stop and observed there were three men in the vehicle. The men were identified as the driver Partlow, and the passengers Pringle, and Smith. The officer asked Partlow for his license and registration. When Partlow opened his glove compartment to get his vehicle registration, the officer observed a large roll of money inside the compartment. He ran Partlow’s information for any wants or warrants and he came back negative for both.

    Read More

  • Execution Essay: The Case Of Jimmy Bain (1974)

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    On March 4, 1974 in Lake Walsh, Florida a nine-year-old boy was taken from his home, and dragged to a baseball field and raped. When he was questioned by the police he said his attacker was between the age of seventeen or eighteen, with bushy sideburns and a mustache. The boy’s uncle said that description sounds like a man named Jimmy Bain. When the police showed the victim the lineup photos, the victim pointed out Bain, but out of the six suspects only Jimmy Bain and one other man had sideburns. On March the 5, 1974 at midnight Jimmy Bain was questioned by the police.

    Read More

  • The Case Of 1992 Kennedy Brewer

    198 Words  | 1 Pages

    In 1992 Kennedy Brewer was arrested in the state of Mississippi and accused of killing his girlfriend’s 3 year old daughter Christine Jackson. Brewer was babysitting the child that evening and two days after she disappeared her body was found in a creek. After he waited in jail for three years a trial began and Brewer was convicted of capital murder and sent to death row. Police suspected Brewer because he was the only one home and there was no evidence of a break in. although there was a broken window by where the child slept that was overlooked that could have been an entry way for an intruder.

    Read More

  • Monster By Walter Dean Myers Sparknotes

    595 Words  | 3 Pages

    The truth is really not what one might think. In the novel, Monster by Walter Dean Myers, there is a young man named Steve Harmon is on trial for felony murder and robbery. King and Bobo said that Harmon was the person that went inside to check if there was anyone in there. That was Kings and Bobos truth because they made themselves think that Harmon was part of the robbery. But there was no actual proof because King and Bobo are two criminals and they just might want to lighten their sentences.

    Read More

  • Jimmy Grants To Blame For The Rape Case

    1822 Words  | 8 Pages

    David Lee, Yebin Cho, Cindy Hong Mr. Musselman Ap Psychology 31, January 2016 Our team has investigated on the crime of a suspect of serial killer. The victims were Mrs.Shelby, John G, Jimmy Grants, Teddy a.k.a. John Edward Gammell.

    Read More

  • Monster By Walter Dean Myers Sparknotes

    219 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the film Murder on a Sunday Morning, fifteen-year-old Brenton Butler is arrested and blamed for the murder of Mary Ann Stephens. While on trial,

    Read More

  • The Trial Of Sacco And Vanzetti

    1236 Words  | 5 Pages

    The trials of Sacco and Vanzetti goes on about how they were falsely executed for murdering a guard and armed robbery because of their immigrant background . After the murderers escaped the scene with the money the police searched a garage to claim a car it was connected to. Sacco and Vanzetti were arrested because victims said it was two Italian men who committed the crime but neither of them had previous trouble with the law. No one really know if they did it because witnesses only said there was two Italian men who did it when any Italian could’ve been a suspect. This trial shows that the 1920’s were prejudiced against certain ethnic group, specifically Italians.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Batson Vs Kentucky

    1033 Words  | 5 Pages

    1) On August 28, 1986, a woman named Queen Madge White was found dead in her home in Rome, Georgia. She was a 79-year-old widow and was found to be beaten, sexually assaulted, and strangled to death. Her home had also been burglarized. Timothy Foster, an 18-year-old black male, confessed to the crime and officers recovered some of the stolen items from Foster’s home. The State subsequently indicted him for malice, murder, and burglary and the jury that was selected convicted him of capital murder and assigned the death penalty.

    Read More

  • State V. Steele Case Study

    944 Words  | 4 Pages

    While Steele was investigating multiple robberies that occurred in the same vicinity a witness provided information of a vehicle that was possibly associated

    Read More

  • Who Is Lonnie Franklin Linked To Serial Killers?

    897 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the 1980’s a victim was linked to a string of murderers in the 1980’s. Lonnie Franklin is mostly known for being a serial killer, the Grim Sleeper. Throughout this documentary deviance is shown, one afternoon a man who worked for Lonnie who thought he was an insurance man received a car from Lonnie and he found splattered blood in the seats. Lonnie told his insurance man to set the car on fire and the man did so because nobody expected Lonnie to do anything that would cause harm and they never told him no. The environment Lonnie lived in influenced him, he lived in a very poor section of town, not many jobs, and bad schools.

    Read More

  • Scott Demeester Case Study

    357 Words  | 2 Pages

    12- 19- 2014 somewhere around 2400 and 0600 hours I Det. Scott Demeester was dispatched to 1710 Madrona Street. I was called in to investigate a homicide case. The victim was discovered tucked under a sheet in a vacant home in Atlanta Georgia.

    Read More

  • Who Is Wayne Williams Guilty Or Innocent

    943 Words  | 4 Pages

    Not five, ten but more than fifteen little boys were found dead in a lake, but all of a sudden , Wayne Williams gets arrested and no more bodies are found. Guilty or Innocent?Through out the videos you can see more and more evidence to why he is very guilty. As stated in the article, only American African kids were being taken away from their homes,being taken from families, and no one knew why. No one, literally no one , had any idea on who was doing this and why they were doing this. Wayne was born on May 27,1958, he is known to be an American serial killer who convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment in 1982 for killing two adult man.

    Read More

  • Zodiac Killer Research Paper

    1018 Words  | 5 Pages

    The first murder involved a 17-year-old male and his 16-year-old girlfriend who were shot dead near their car at a secluded location on Lake Herman port. The police could not establish the motive of these initial killings or a suspect to the murders. The second incident involved the shootings of a woman aged 22 and her boyfriend who was aged 19 who were sitting in a car that was parked in a remote location similar to the first incident. A man with a flashlight who fired several shots at them attacked the two killing the man and seriously wounding the woman. After the shooting, a man called the police, gave the location of the crime, and claimed responsibility for the attack and the previous attack.

    Read More

  • Murder On A Sunday Morning Analysis

    681 Words  | 3 Pages

    As you are shown in the film, after the identification of Brenton Butler and his so-called testimony to investigators, the police and prosecutors just stopped working on the case. Thus, evidence that would have supported Butler’s innocence and help find the actual killer weren’t discovered until Brenton’s defense attorney, Pat McGuinness did some investigation and research of his own. Thus, flowing from film from the trial to McGuinness’s investigation scenes shows the how he attained the information that he and his partner could present in the courtroom. While the prosecutors only had the one eyewitness, who claimed to have only caught a glimpse of the shooter and gave description that did not even match Butler. The film presents the conclusion that the police did not actually do the work to find the actual killer and if it wasn’t for Pat McGuinness and his partner wanting to find the culprit, it would never actually be solved.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Sacco And Vanzetti: The Men, The Murders

    558 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bruce Watson, the author of Sacco & Vanzetti: The Men, the Murders, and the Judgment of Mankind, breaks down many aspects of the case to help better understand it. He begins the novel by telling the life stories of both men to show the things that influenced them in their beliefs and also their thoughts on their new home in America. It was evident Vanzetti and Sacco weren’t happy in New York because they believed it was “the immense hell pit of the poor and paradise of the rich” (Watson 21). But their answer to the problem didn’t contain violence; they just contemplated “returning to simpler lives in Italy” (Watson 12).

    Read More

More about Brenton Butler: The Case Of Jacksonville Florida

Open Document