ipl-logo

Burlington Northern Santa Fe's Railway Company Case Summary

789 Words4 Pages

Burlington Northern Santa Fe’s Railway Company (BNSF) are accused of violating the Clean Water Act (CWA) by discharging coal dust into waterways from uncovered train cars without the proper permits. Plaintiffs include; the Sierra Club, Puget Soundkeeper, Columbia Riverkeeper, RE Sources for Sustainable Communities, Riverkeeper and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and Friends of the Columbia Gorge Spokane. In April, BNSF was sent a 60 day notice by plaintiffs, demonstrating the companies' responsibility and pertinent evidentiary support showing coal emissions in waterways. The plaintiffs requested a plan of action to curb the amount of discharge or they intended to take the case to court. BNSF and associates did nothing to attempt to curb their pollution or obtain the correct permit. Plaintiff's filed the joint lawsuit on July 24, 2013 accusing BNSF with dumping a pollutant into a waterway without a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit.
Waterways along the BNSF train routes have shown increased levels of lead, arsenic, and mercury, found in conjunction with the coal dust and chunks, and petroleum coke. BNSF’s Vice President of Transportation admits that;
"BNSF estimates that up to 500 pounds of coal dust may be lost from the top of each car.” -Gregory Fox
Currently …show more content…

The defense also sited precedence from higher court rulings, challenging that their particular form of pollution is legally defined as "non-point source pollution" because it does not come from "a discernible confined and discrete conveyance that transports the pollutants from land to water.” (Stark 2014). Such a ruling would prevent them from being found in violation of the CWA, pertinent only to point source

Show More
Related

  • A Case Of Montanile V. Board Of Trustees Of The National Elevator Company

    468 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the court case of Montanile v. Board of Trustees of the National Elevator Industry Health Benefit Plan, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 was used to determine if an employee wrongfully received funds from a third party after receiving funds from the National Elevator Industry Health Benefits plan. In the court case, the petitioner Robert Montanile was driving when he was struck by a drunk driver resulting in Mr. Montanile be severely injured. The health benefit plan paid upwards in of $121,000 in medical expenses for Mr. Montanile. In order to receive such funds, Mr. Montanile was required to sign a reimbursement agreement reaffirming his obligation to reimburse the plan from any recovery he obtained "as a result of any legal action or settlement or otherwise. After exiting the hospital Mr. Monanile sought legal action against the drunk

    Read More

  • Rapanos Case Study Essay

    1553 Words  | 7 Pages

    In Rapanos, the Corps sought to include within its CWA jurisdiction any land containing a channel through which rainwater might occasionally flow. The plurality in Rapanos would have held that, in order to assert jurisdiction, the agencies must establish a “continuous surface connection” between the property in question and traditionally navigable interstate waters.” By contrast, Justice Kennedy’s significant nexus test would require a more complicated assessment of the “chemical, biological and hydrological connection between the property and other regulated waters.” Under both tests, the burden of proof rests on the agency asserting jurisdiction. Although the Corps purports to rely on Justice Kennedy’s “significant nexus” formulation, their claim of jurisdiction in such cases deprives that formulation of any meaning.

    Read More

  • Northern Pacific Railway Research Paper

    395 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1864 Congress approved the Northern Pacific Railway to be built. The NPR is the first transcontinental railroad in the northern part of the country. It is 8,316 miles long, beginning in Minnesota and ending in Washington state, with many branches going off the main line. When congress approved it they also supplied nearly 40million acres of land grants to build the railroad on. Construction didn 't go underway until 1870, and the rail road was finally christened to open on Sept. 8 1888.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Hydrofracking By Paul Galley

    750 Words  | 3 Pages

    Paul Galley an accomplished environmentalist enters the controversial debate about Hydrofracking in New York, with his article “Hydrofracking: A bad Bet for the Environment and the Economy” published in the Huffington Post on January 05, 2012. Galley states “Net-Net, fracking is simply bad bet” fracking poses serious risk to New Yorkers. Galley, president of Hudson Riverkeeper has worked for over twenty-five years to protect the environment and support local communities, as a non-profit, public official and educator. This piece continues his devotion to protection of the Hudson River, and the drinking water supply of New Yorkers. Galley effectively convinces his audience through his use of appeals to pathos and logos that hydrofracking will have negative impacts on New Yorkers.

    Read More

  • Transcontinental Railroad Dbq Essay

    415 Words  | 2 Pages

    People always say that the best inventions ever are phones or computers, but there is one that people take for granted. This invention changed the way we look at shipping forever. The Transcontinental railroad changed the United States economically more than socially or politically because, it allowed western states export their goods easier, increased the amount of goods exported, and made it cheaper for states to export their products. The U.S was changed more economically, because it helped transport the western states goods to the east so it could be transported. Lovelock Nevada was a city that mined silver.

    Read More

  • Brief History And Influence Of The Texas Railroad Commission

    1510 Words  | 7 Pages

    History and Influence of the Texas Railroad Commission In my last 10 years working in the oilfield, whenever I was in Texas I always wondered why everything we did was reported directly to the Texas Railroad Commission. There was always a Railroad Commission Representative in all of our Pre-Spud meetings. The question of what power do they ultimately hold on the oil field. I decided to write a paper on the history of the Texas Railroad commission and any controversy that they could have been involved in.

    Read More

  • Northern Railway Essay Outline

    1505 Words  | 7 Pages

    After its 1869 debut, the Central Pacific’s Altamont Pass route provided the shortest all-land connection from Sacramento to the Bay Area. It remained, nonetheless, a long detour compared with a direct-line route between the two points. From the start, the Central Pacific’s principals recognized its faults and sought alternatives. In the mid-1850s, two businessmen—DeWitt C. Haskins and Doctor D. W. C. Rice—proposed a railway from Marysville south to Knight’s Landing on the Sacramento River.

    Read More

  • Railroad Strike Dbq

    1852 Words  | 8 Pages

    Railroad Strike of 1877 1877 In the late nineteenth century, the railroad industry was booming. But it’s growth was followed by labor arguments, including the Great Railroad Strike of 1877. This strike was the first major rail strike, and it was disputed with enough violence to bring in various state militias. The Strike began when northern railroads cut salaries and wages because they still felt the impact of the Panic of 1873.

    Read More

  • Corporate Personhood: Santa Clara County V. Southern Pacific Railroad

    298 Words  | 2 Pages

    For several years, the law has treated corporations as metaphysical persons. This means that the law regards corporations as persons, but only for certain legal purposes. For example, corporations have some of the same rights as natural people do, such as the right to freedom of speech. Corporate personhood has evolved into a highly controversial topic since it was first established in the famous supreme court case, Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad. This was a case where the Southern Pacific Railroad protested taxes placed on it by several counties in California.

    Read More

  • Oil Fracking In Texas

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    Michael Brune, executive director of the Sierra Club, states that, “The EPA’s water quality study confirms what millions of Americans already know—that dirty oil and gas fracking contaminates drinking water” and that “the EPA chose to leave many critical questions unanswered” (Malewitz). It is critical that the EPA works with the general public to answer every question so that we can begin to work together to understand the complexity of this

    Read More

  • R. Williams Construction Co. V. OSHRC: Case Study

    736 Words  | 3 Pages

    Luigi Vittatoe Dr. George Ackerman ELA2603 Administrative and Personnel Law December 2, 2015 Week 6 Case Study: R. Williams Construction Co. v. OSHRC 1. What were the legal issues in this case? What did the court decide? R. Williams Construction Company petitions for review of a final order of the OSHRC for violations of the OSHA Act.

    Read More

  • To What Extent Was The Transcontinental Railroad

    815 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Transcontinental Railroad was essentially built to link our country as one. Being about 1,776 miles long, it was the first completed railroad to connect land stretching from Sacramento, California to Council Bluffs, Iowa. Many people were involved in the creating the railroad. The excitement of people as well as some concerns were expressed in the Primary Source Documents. The Chamber of Commerce of New York invited The Chamber of Commerce of San Francisco to a congratulatory party.

    Read More

  • Case 20-1 Shoenberger V. Chicago Transit Authority Case Study

    773 Words  | 4 Pages

    Karla Coronel Chapter 20 Problems 6) In my opinion the director is not responsible for the destroyed antiquity. For the following reasons: The agent's careless actions were not within his job. If the agent acts negligently out of his employment with the principal, the principal is not liable for damages caused by the actions of the agent.

    Read More

  • Negligence In A Civil Action By Jan Schlichtmann

    968 Words  | 4 Pages

    The movie A Civil Action was about a group of parents whose children had developed leukemia. Some of the children died due to leukemia. Therefore Anne Anderson, who played a big role in this movie gathered all of the victim’s parents to seek legal advice from lawyers, but not a lot of lawyers were willing to touch the case due to the fact that there is little evidence and it could cost them a lot of money in the long run, if the case goes to trial. Jan Schlichtmann decided to pick the case and use the elements of negligence. In order to do that he had to prove that those hazardous wastes would somehow end up from one place and into the river, which is really hard to prove.

    Read More

  • Polluter Dilemma Case Study

    927 Words  | 4 Pages

    A Case Study on Polluter’s Dilemma I. Background/Point of View On a small plastic manufacturing, Jonica Gunson works as an environmental compliance manager. The company where she is working with is now facing a serious situation that needs to have a fast and decisive decision, decision whether to invest or not to invest money on new technology that will help decrease or as possible eliminate the level of toxic in the water which is flowing from the back of the factory up to lake. Though the company is compliant with the levels of emissions set by the Environmental Management board, the manager sees that environmental procedures for this specific toxic are sheathing behind logical evidence, particularly that there is a protest from a certain scientist that is publish in the newspaper.

    Read More

More about Burlington Northern Santa Fe's Railway Company Case Summary

Open Document