Managing Ethnic Diversity and Federalism in Pakistan I. Introduction Ethnic mobilisation and conflicts are not new phenomenon but their contemporary globe manifestation in frequency and intensity is a new development, which needs careful reflection and detailed examination. Since more than 90 percent of the nations states are heterogeneous and this heterogeneity is likely to increase as a result of global migration patterns; ethnic conflicts and the resultant political tensions are likely to become even more pervasive in the coming years. This global manifestation of ethnicity has attracted significant attention from social scientists. Since developed as well as developing countries are experiencing ethnic tensions, the problem of political instability caused by ethnic conflicts seems to be more acute in the developing world. Managing Ethnic Diversity and Federalism in Pakistan 280 Empirical studies of developing states suggest some connections between political institutions and the proliferation of ethnic mobilisation. Policy recommendations to manage ethnic diversity in these multiethnic states suggest a variety of federal and power-sharing arrangements. Lijphart (1996) maintains that democracy is possible in deeply divided societies but only if their type of democracy is consociational. Certain European countries have managed diversity through consociationalism but overall performance of such arrangements remains mixed. McGarry (2006) argues that ‘Federalism is usually
The case of Pittonia is not a unique one; many times throughout history countries have made the transition from authoritarian rule to democratic rule. In these transitions, however, there are many differences in how a country can go about creating a democracy. Pittonia, for example, will draw inspiration from various nations around the world and use their precedence to mold a new democracy. Federalism studied in Canada, and the quasi-federalism of Spain, are influences for the benefits of a federal government, which include regional states having the authority to govern themselves. Bicameralism is chosen for its two-part representation system, ensuring that states are proportional represented in the lower house and equally represented in the
This concept is commonly accepted to refer to an intense degree of intragovernmental consultation, to the basic equality of the relationship, and to the decentralizing nature of the results in this period (Dyck, 1979). Perhaps the
Small states wanted equal representation, and large states wanted representation based on
At least, William Kimberling brings into relief that this system « enhances the status of minority interest ». This, however, is different in practise… Hence, territories
39). Often the glue used to bind nations into a cohesive state is nationalism, however this can also be adopted on a regional level just as easily to propel a separatist movement into action (p. 38). If federal nationalism is used to make distinct nations develop closer ties and prevent divisions, regional nationalism will have a similar effect on the peoples who make up distinct nations, creating the narrative that the nation is different from the rest of the state and may be better off governing itself (p. 39). The only method to prevent regional nationalism from prevailing is to build a more attractive brand of federal nationalism through the promotion of federal imagery and the connection of regional infrastructure to foster the feeling of interconnectivity (p. 39). The central government must also juggle regional autonomy and central authority while adapting to the dynamic nature of each region’s culture and interests, constantly evolving with the particular needs of each region to create a successful federal state
The African mainland has become very synonymous with these three words; war, yearning and enduring. Between the 1870s and 1900, Africa confronted European radical animosity, discretionary weights, military attacks, and consequent success and colonization. In the meantime, African social orders set up different types of resistance against the endeavor to colonize their nations and force remote command. By the mid twentieth century, be that as it may, quite a bit of Africa, with the exception of Ethiopia and Liberia, had been colonized by European powers.
Imagine if you were old enough to vote but still had the education levels of American kindergartner. For the women of Sudan and South Sudan this is a reality. The women are forced to play 1950’s housewife while the men develop their minds and command the household. Due to the lack of resources and the number of economical problems in Sudan and South Sudan, the women in these countries are unable to receive education and improve the lives of the future generations. Sudan has been a source of conflict and violence in an already unstable area of the world since the twentieth century.
I agree with his ideologies on conservatism and liberism, however, I think most of the political divide correlates to urban and rural counties. Most of the rural voters advocates liberty while urban counterparts chrish cooperation and equality. The rural-urban divide shapes the red and blue states ideologies. Nevertheless, I agree with the alaysts comments on cultural and historical characteristics as the influence for red and blue states. Third, the strength of the article shows where the author seems to place red states as those who fight for equality.
In the Era of Good Feelings, sectionalism was a very important thing; it improved the feeling of nationalism, helped the economy, and strengthened relationships between the states. But good things always have a consequence, and the result of sectionalism forced the people to rely on each other for their
Key words: devolution; federalism; policy practice; political activity; social justice The Body Social Policy at the Federal Level To begin, being considerate of individual justice and inequality of rights has been existent throughout the United States history. “In federal government systems, this can be justified on the grounds that it is within the scope of responsibility of the state or local government to select the areas in which equality of rights and opportunities should occur.” “Proponents of individual justice have used at least three tactics at the federal level to reduce the inequalities of rights that can exist at the state and local
Interactions amid the provinces and the federal government, from constitutional issues to the most irresistible topics bang up-to-date in the country, are indemnified beneath the umbrella of “Federalism”. Authorities are shared so that on some matters, the state governments are decision-holders, whereas on the other matters, national government grasps the autonomy. In last twenty-five years, the upsurge of federal fiats on both governments, local and state, has shifted the power amongst state and national governments. Now, the national government is beginning to have more governance over the state’s engagements.
However, Gordon S. Wood presents evidence social status was more of a deciding factor on who supported a strong central government or an independent state assemblies. Each of these positions are examined and their merits discussed as it relates to
In the conclusion of the book she creates a list of methods that cities and governments may use to further of equity, diversity, and democracy and achieve social justice. The list, as she argues, is very ‘‘context-dependent’’ and‘‘assumes societies with a preexisting commitment to democratic-egalitarian norms as well as a history of applying such norms’’ (p. 171). This is one of the many reasons why I feel that Fainstein's work is not truly applicable and relies too heavily upon idealistic views and perfect
In this paper, I have attempted to present an understanding of Pakistan-India conflict by using constructivism theory of international relations. There are many reasons other than strategic reason causing this conflict like differences in ideologies, norms and beliefs. There are also cultural differences between these two nations. 2. Pakistan-India Conflict an overview South Asia is considered a region of great importance in the world.
c. Regional Diversity: This element of diversity is closely related to the ethnicity and religious, but there are significant differences. There are six major geo-political regions, comprising of ‘related’ ethno-linguistic groups. The national politics tend to revolve around issues of representation from these six regions. A company such as our shoe company may not have to branches in each region, but in dealing with the public, it would help the image of the company if it is not seen to be dominated by any one of the