Lit. Circle 2
Does Skeeter’s lie to Mrs. Stein about Aibileen being ready and willing to tell her story reflect a certain arrogance or overconfidence in her ability to make Aibileen talk? (pgs.106-107)
Yes. Skeeter doesn 't seem to understand just how dangerous participating in the book would be for Aibileen, leading her to believe that it will simply be a matter of some simple persuasion to get Aibileen to agree with her. She may understand objectively that challenging such deeply ingrained racial norms is dangerous from what she hears on the news or even from the warnings of people around her like Mrs. Stein or Aibileen herself, but because she is white and therefore privileged, she can’t fully comprehend how big of a sacrifice she is asking
…show more content…
However, when she suddenly changes her mind and agrees, her answer to Skeeter as to why she did it is that it was Hilly. This is interesting, because she doesn 't ever really elaborate on her answer to Skeeter. However, looking back at her recent interactions with Hilly an increasing reluctance to comply with her degrading demands and remarks can be seen. In particular, on page 111 when Hilly is pestering Aibileen about her new bathroom. “ ‘Aibileen’ Hilly continued, ‘how do you like your new bathroom out there? It’s nice to have a place of your own, now isn’t it?’ Aibileen stared at the crack in the dining table. ‘Yes ma 'am.’ ‘You know, Mr. Holbrook arranged for that bathroom, Aibileen. Sent the boys over and the equipment too.’ Hilly smiled. Aibileen just stood there and I wished I wasn’t in the room. Please, I thought, please don’t say thank you. ‘Yes ma 'am.’ Aibileen opened a drawer and reached inside, but Hilly kept looking at her. It was so obvious what she wanted. Hilly cleared her throat and finally Aibileen lowered her head. ‘Thank you ma 'am.’ she whispered.” This blatant and public harassment by Hilly is humiliating for Aibileen. She is being forced to thank someone who has made her life incredibly difficult and routinely bashes her and her entire race for a bathroom that was built solely so that Aibileen wouldn’t spread her “diseases” to the other white people in …show more content…
What significance does the word “truth” hold in the minds of Aibileen and Minny? (pgs.128-129)
The concept of truth is a recurring theme throughout the book. In a society where everyone is thinking the same things but no one is brave enough to say anything, the idea of finally speaking out about the blatantly racist injustices all black people in the south are forced to suffer seems simultaneously both terrifying and appealing. They both know that actively defying the status quo would be incredibly dangerous for both of them, but they are also incredibly fed up, and the idea of finally being able to speak their minds is inexplicably
During her first weeks at Princeton she had realized that Princeton had few women students and fewer Latinos. She was highly intimidated by this and it made her nervous to reach out in class, if she needed help. I feel like coming from a community when mainly everyone around you is alike in some sort of way made her understand that she wasn’t living in her old world anymore. Where she grew up, she wasn’t surrounded by many well-educated, brilliant
(page 297) Arnetta blames a girl from troop 909 that doesn 't even speak, Then after she finds this out she is quick to blame the next girl she
Nevertheless, her community started showing Bridges support, whether they were black or white. Some people supported her bravery for going to
She is motivated by her lack of rights and freedoms as a black woman. She knows that this is one step closer to her end goal, the luxuries, and freedoms that only white people
This incident shows the reader that she wants to be taken seriously by her colleagues. It also displays that Hilly deeply treasures her reputation because of her reaction towards the situation. On the other hand, Aunt Alexandra has also shown the reader signs that she values her family’s reputation. In chapter 23 of To Kill a Mockingbird, Aunt Alexandra did not allow Scout to play with Walter Cunningham because of his poor background. She said, “Because-he-is-trash, that’s why you can’t play with him.
She believed every bit of it, not even searching for evidence. Prudence was exposed to this rude gossip but with the help from Kit, she could glare right through it. As for Kit, she never believed that foolish gossip. She knew in her heart that Hannah was different just like her and that she was her friend. Gossip is an ugly pastime.
She believes that the assumed superiority of whites, and assumed inferiority of people of color is like “a smog in the air”. She believes it is our job to “clean up the air.” We need to be active in our antiracism to make a difference. We can’t just go along in life trying to ignore racism, and expect it to just clear up and go away on its own. Racism is always there, even if it is unspoken and not easily seen.
Skeeter also wishes to expose the injustice that the African Americans faced in the South. Many of the Southerns, including her friends, oppose this dream, and this conflict leads Skeeter to be hated by many white Southerners. Eventually, even her suitor and her friends leave
This is evident when she says “that- I consider- is a trifle impertinent, Inspector” this shows how arrogant she is, the inspector isn’t being inherently rude as he simply agreed with Sheila and because Mrs birling sees herself above the inspector in status she sees it as “impertinent” that the inspector should speak plainly to her because she is a fairly wealthy woman whose husband was a “lord mayor only two years ago and that he’s still a magistrate-“ and so the inspector should be giving her the proper respect. She sees herself as the most important person in the room at any given time and feels that everything affects her even when it doesn’t like when Gerald is talking about his affair with Eva, Mrs birling cuts in and says she doesn’t want to hear any more even when it doesn’t affect her and nothing is stopping her from leaving the room until it is her
To Aibileen, however, this is just another step down the path of disrespect and alienation by white women. Skeeter Phelan has a moment of understanding when she is talking to Aibileen about checking books out of a library and she realizes that there are so many more books at the white library than there are at the one Aibileen can go to. Even while shopping for Celia, Minny goes to a different store because the store she goes to for her own groceries has old food and spoiled
Hilly Holbrook, the prime cause of Skeeter’s isolation, forced most everyone in her community to shun Skeeter. This did not just include Skeeter’s friends. Anyone who had relations with Hilly knew that they could not publicly associate with Skeeter. Even people who did not know Skeeter, such as Mrs. Celia Foote, learned to dislike Skeeter. Celia refused to speak to her because “they said she’s the biggest embarrassment this town’s ever seen.”
Skeeter is seen to develop in two different ways: a young woman who doesn 't have marriage as a first priority anymore and a woman who later sees an injustice to the black help. Skeeter is a white socialite who just graduated from college with a degree in writing. She came back to Jackson Mississippi with the idea of starting to write for book publishing companies but arrives home only for her mother to question her about marriage. Upon the many
Although the black maids endure such indignity, none will share their experiences with Skeeter in fear of being discovered by the town’s whites. Aibileen is among those who refuse, but one day at church the preacher exhorts the congregation to have courage and speak the truth. He states that, "Courage isn't just about being brave. Courage is daring to do what is right in spite of the weakness of our flesh. And God tells us, commands us, compels us, to love."
Skeeter was very interested in Aibileen’s experiences as being a maid her whole life. Skeeter’s interest was sparked by her childhood friend and maid Constantine that basically disappeared from her life. Aibileen and Skeeter slowly started to become friends and talk about more than just cleaning tips. Aibileen found trust in Skeeter and felt comfortable enough around her to tell her stories about life as a maid. Skeeter
At the beginning of the film, Skeeter who is a white woman and is an anti-racist, wants to interview Aibileen in order to publish a book about what it is like to be a Black maid working for a white family. But Aibileen rejects Skeeter’s interview by saying in a low quiet careful voice, “You know what’d happen to me if Miss Leefolt knew I was tellin’ stories on her.” She is afraid of revenge from Whites, for example losing her job and being in danger, by telling about her life for Whites. By using this dialogue the director, Tate Taylor, portrays that Ailbileen has no courage and strong will to alter the view of the world about them because she doesn’t think racism would disappear and the world would be changed. In the comparison dialogue in the ending of the film shows that