ipl-logo

Cinderella And The Loss Of Father Love Analysis

1560 Words7 Pages

Nicholas Koontz Mrs. Pearce PNW Honors 12 Eng 2 November 2016 “Cinderella’ and the Loss of Father-Love” and “‘Cinderella:’ A Story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Conflicts” Comparative Critique The articles “‘Cinderella’ and the Loss of Father-Love” written by Jacqueline M. Schectman and “‘Cinderella:’ A Story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Conflicts” written by Bruno Bettelheim are about the effects of a father remarrying and the stepfamily inclusion of the children. Both articles state that the stepfamily is not the main villain in the story; they state that the real issue is in Cinderella’s mind because of her fear of losing her mother and now her father, whom she loves more than almost anything in the world. Bettelheim regards the stepfamily …show more content…

Bettelheim hints that the stepsisters in the story are actually not terrible humans but are normal children. According to Bettelheim, the stepsisters are portrayed evil because the story is told from the inner thoughts of Cinderella, who is in direct competition with the stepsisters for her father’s love and the attention of the stepmother (par. 12). He states that sibling rivalry is “‘natural,’” and the only way to improve their status in the eyes of their parents is to prove dominance over the other siblings. Sibling rivalry is told as being complex and that it is difficult to determine the cause because the emotions by all persons are running high. These emotions lead to children thinking that their parents think of them less or that they are less than their siblings, which leads to misunderstood feelings and misrepresentation of the actual event. This is the very basis of the “Cinderella” story, according to Bettelheim. Schectman, on the contrary, says that not just Cinderella has experienced a loss; in fact, it was that everyone in the story had experienced a loss. The father lost his wife, the stepmother lost a husband, and the stepsisters lost a father. This gives the reader a look at Cinderella in a new and more natural light. Cinderella wants to be pitied, but the stepmother won’t pity her because she is dealing with her own loss. Schectman also states that Cinderella is fighting her own battle of acceptance because, as she sees it, her father is now having to split his love and attention from just her to incorporate the stepsisters and stepmother. Cinderella does not understand how her father can still love her as much as he did before the stepfamily came into the

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Cinderella By Grimm Brothers

    1631 Words  | 7 Pages

    Additionally, there is a clear contrast between Cinderella’s item of choice which is used to honor her deceased mother versus her sisters’ desires to pursue vanity instead of respecting family. The Grimms then expounds upon this contrast between the protagonist and antagonists by using poetic juxtaposition. Later in the story, when the two sisters attempt to steal Cinderella’s love with the Prince by physically altering their feet to forcefully fit the shoe, the Grimms writes, “ ‘ Roo coo coo, roo coo coo, blood’s in the shoe: the shoe’s too tight, the real bride’s waiting another night’ (pg 184). Then, when Cinderellas effortlessly fits into the shoe without having to force herself, the Grimms writes, “Roo coo coo,

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Cinderella And Aschenputtel By Grimm Brothers

    1010 Words  | 5 Pages

    However, in the Middle Ages, it was a time when awareness of children was not important, so stepmothers used to abuse their wives' children before they remarried. And they were eventually sidelined. However, through meeting with a divine being, they escape from the hard times and face a happy ending with indirect help. However, the Algonquin Cinderella also features a girl who is abused and alienated from her family, but this is not a big theme. In the end, the girl overcomes the difficult process of crossing the pass to marry an invisible divine being and eventually succeeds in marriage.

    Read More

  • Determination In Grimm's Cinderella

    790 Words  | 4 Pages

    Determination in “Cinderella” “Cinderella”, the original fairytale, is found in a collection of stories created by the Grimm brothers. The story of “Cinderella” is used in order to display and teach children and adults a way of living. This fairytale reflects values such as perseverance and determination. Cinderella, the protagonist, is an outcast her family, as her father is her only blood relative. She is forced to do housework and is not allowed to take part fun activities or share luxuries with her stepsisters.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Grimm Brothers And Cinderella

    700 Words  | 3 Pages

    Similarly, in Walt Disney’s “Cinderella,” she is also treated horribly, and awarded a beautiful outfit by her fairy godmother, letting her attend a ball, encountering her true love. Cinderella gets married to the prince, however, the step-sisters are forgiven and live with Cinderella at the castle unlike the original story. Both stories have many similarities, especially in the climax. However, the

    Read More

  • Ruth Panttaja Cinderella Not So Morally Superior Analysis

    922 Words  | 4 Pages

    Elisabeth Panttaja uses her article, “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior,” in order to demonstrate that Cinderella is not the moral hero she is made out to be in modern versions of the ancient fairy tale. She accredits the majority of Cinderella’s triumphs to her recently dead mother in the form of supernatural gifts and assistance rather than Cinderella’s perseverance against a cruel step-family showing how she is craftier, willing to employ powerful magic to defeat the forces arrayed against her. Her argument is somewhat successful in dismantling the moral high ground built around modern day Cinderella, but Panttaja tends to interpret information to only support her argument and does not add in any

    Read More

  • Rogers And Hammerstein's Cinderella Analysis

    1294 Words  | 6 Pages

    On the other side you want to stay true to the original Rogers and Hammerstein musical that you are retelling. Yet there was also a clear message in the story that was not in the original Rogers and Hammerstein or the Disney version. In this version there is a crisis in the kingdom, where the poor are being exploited by the rich and powerful. This is not only shown in the situation between the evil advisor and the people, but also in the dynamic between Cinderella and her stepmother. Thus, as the story progresses, you can see the theme of reconciliation and justice in both the relationship between Cinderella and Madame, and also with the poor people of the kingdom, and their new king Topher.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Cinderella By Grimm Brothers Grimm

    830 Words  | 4 Pages

    The slipper reveals the flaws and cracks in the values that form the foundation of our society by being the embodiment of the human spirit. In order to comprehend how the slipper illustrates the lack of integrity in society’s morals, the influence it has on the populace needs to be considered. All three interpretations of Cinderella paints a picture of a materialistic world obsessed with wealth and status. Each variation, however, emphasizes different levels from the actions of an individual to the movement of an entire kingdom. In the Grimm Brothers version of this tale, the composition of the shoes change each day, ranging from “slippers embroidered with silk and silver”(Grimm 33) to slippers “of pure gold”(Grimm 46).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of What's Wrong With Cinderella

    1343 Words  | 6 Pages

    From its onset with its first feature-length animated film, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs in 1937, Disney has grown to become a worldwide phenomenon today. But over the years, various parent groups, scholars and film critics have accused Disney for creating shallow, stereotypical princesses whose ultimate aim was to find her 'prince charming ' and live happily ever after. In her article, “What’s Wrong With Cinderella?” in the New York Times, Peggy Orenstein expresses her concern over the effect of princess figures like Cinderella on young girls ' perceptions of themselves and how they should behave (“What’s Wrong With Cinderella?”).

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Grimms And Perrault's Cinderella

    790 Words  | 4 Pages

    Perrault’s version of Cinderella’s ending is happier and includes forgiveness. Although the step sisters were cruel and treated Cinderella horribly she forgave them in the end and even found good husbands for them, and they all lived happily ever after. You can see from this that this story is intended to teach a moral lesson of forgiveness and kindness like I explained above. In Perrault’s version you can be terrible and unpleasant but you will be forgiven because that’s part of life. The Grimm brothers however have a different point of view on that matter.

    Read More

  • Comparing Cinderella And Grimm's Cinderella

    680 Words  | 3 Pages

    She longs for love and affection. She finds it when at the ball, but when she has to leave, she leaves in a hurry and one of the slippers that she is wearing gets left behind at the ball and the Prince finds and starts to look for her. Even though they were separated for short periods of time they still find each other in the end. The Prince takes her to his palace and they get married. This general plot stays the same for all versions of the story, but the differences between Disney’s Cinderella and Grimm’s Cinderella are striking, and they deserve through examination.

    Read More

  • The Cinderella Games By Kelly Link: Literary Analysis

    496 Words  | 2 Pages

    This shows they are both willing to make sacrifices in order to get what they want. “The Cinderella Games” would not be considered a classic fairytale, instead it would be considered a modern fairytale. In “The Cinderella Games”, Kelly Link proposes that the characters have lots of hatred towards each other and want to break up their family. This is

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Cinderella And Ever After

    811 Words  | 4 Pages

    She has no more of a title or position than Perrault’s Cinderella, but we are given the opportunity to watch as she manages to rebel in a hundred different ways and to let her stepmother know that she refuses to quietly expect the arranged marriage, has setup in order to get her out of the way. This is not only entertaining for us as the viewers to watch, but also far more realistic in nature, when compared to that of Perrault’s Cinderella, who by the content of the story just seems to blindly expect the overwhelming cruelty shown to her by her stepmother and stepsisters, who throughout the story continue to try her as a

    Read More

  • Psychoanalytic Analysis Of The Disney Film 'Cinderella'

    1318 Words  | 6 Pages

    The story is about a young girl named Cinderella whose widowed father remarries but soon dies, leaving his daughter with the evil stepmother and her two daughters. The stepmother prefers her own daughters over Cinderella and has her perform all of the house chores. While Cinderella is kind, patient, and sweet, her stepsisters are cruel and selfish. Meanwhile, across the kingdom the King decides that his son the Prince should find a suitable bride and marry and so invites every eligible maiden in the kingdom to a fancy ball. Cinderella has no appropriate dress for the ball so her friends the mice namely Jaques and Gus, and the birds help her in making one, but the evil stepsisters tear apart the dress on the evening of the ball.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis: The Brothers Grimm

    1880 Words  | 8 Pages

    The stepmother and her daughters use Cinderella’s father for his riches and make her

    Read More

  • The Role Of Cinderella's Identity In Different Social Classes

    865 Words  | 4 Pages

    With her beautiful dress, she received “a pair of glass slippers, the prettiest in the whole world.” At the ball, no one is aware of Cinderella’s true identity. Despite that, the King’s son falls in love with her and she gets a happily-ever-after. Due to the different social classes Cinderella portrays to be, she is treated differently

    Read More

More about Cinderella And The Loss Of Father Love Analysis

Open Document