Circle Inn Case Study
QUESTION PRESENTED
Does a business incur liability for a wrongful death claim if someone asks to use their phone to make an emergency phone call to police to prevent serious bodily harm of an individual?
BRIEF ANSWER
Yes. The Circle Inn employee’s actions displayed a disregard for human life and the burden on him was minimal. A person may not have a duty to help another, in case like this, a person has a duty not to hinder others who are trying to help.
FACTS
The plaintiff's father, Darrell Soldano was shot and killed at the Happy Jack Saloon. Soldano v. O’Daniels 141 Cal. App. 3d 443 Court of Appeal of California (1983). The defendant in this case owns and operates the Circle Inn, which is a restaurant directly across the street from Happy
…show more content…
v. Cappier case in 1921. Union Pacific Railway Co. v. Cappier 66 Kan. 649 (1903). A train struck a man. Railroad employees saw the incident and did nothing to help him. The injured man had died by the time when the help arrived. The court said that railroad had no duty to help the struck man. At this time the law in USA clearly stated that bystanders need do …show more content…
In 1969 Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff. Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California 17 Ca. 3rd 425 Supreme Court of California (1976). A patient, Poddar, informed his psychologist regarding his intent to kill Tatiana Tarasoff. Psychologist did nothing to warn Tarasoff and she was killed by Poddar. Tarasoff’ s relatives sued University of California claiming that doctor had to warned Tatiana and had to arrange Poddar’ s confinement. In this case court made an exception and said that doctor and patient had a special relationship. This fact made a case different from the general bystander law. Court said that therapist under applicable professional standards had a duty to protect victim from a danger.
CONCLUSION Our case is not identical to other cases I mentioned above and this fact created the new exception in the bystander law. The court decided that the bartender owed a duty to Soldano to permit a call to the police or to place a call by himself. This is different than actually aid someone in
Case Citation: Gallagher V. Cayuga Medical Center
1153 Words | 5 PagesCase Citation: Gallagher v. Cayuga Medical Center 151 AD 3d 1349 - NY: Appellate Div., 3rd Dept. 2017 Background: In this civil case Timothy W. Gallagher is the appellant, and Cayuga Medical Center (CMC) is the respondents. The case took place in the appellate division of the supreme court of New York, division three. The plaintiff’s complaint was that Cayuga Medical Center had asserted medical malpractice, negligence, wrongful death and emotional distressed.
Summary Of The Case Of Tammy Lou Fontenot V. Taser International
311 Words | 2 PagesThe case of Tammy Lou Fontenot v. Taser International, Inc. was about a wrongful death case named Darryl Tuner, a 17-year-old male employed by a grocery store. Darryl was fired for “insubordination” and refused to leave the grocery store. Police were called, and eventually used a Taser in order to take him into custody. Turner died as a result of the Taser being delivered to Turner’s body. Tammy Lou Fontenot filed suit against the City of Charlotte and Taser International seeking money damages for the alleged wrongful death of Darryl Turner.
Kuehn V. Pub Zone Case Study
1378 Words | 6 PagesLike the Pub Zone had the duty to protect Kuehn, the Circle Inn bartender had the duty to allow the use of the telephone. Although the bar fight had not taken place at the Circle Inn, it was a business open to the public, therefore the bartender should have allowed the call. Due to the emergency of the situation, the phone call was intended for the police. If the phone call was made to the police, it is possible that Soldano’s father would still be alive, thus O’Daniels is liable. In situations like these, businesses have the moral obligation to ensure the safety of their customers and the surrounding
Ford Motor Credit Co. 2d 956
525 Words | 3 PagesKey Facts: (Who are the parties? What are they fighting about? Who is suing whom for what?) Susan Kirkpatrick, Appellant; John Zitz and Transamerica Insurance Company, Appelles; Kirkpatrick originally filed a complaint in trial court for a skunk bite she received while in a pet store owned by John Zitz.
What Is The Difference Between Joseph And Susie Hurtado
346 Words | 2 PagesThe state brought Hurtado to trial where he was found guilty to murder and sentenced to death Procedural History: After his sentence the Supreme Court of California affirmed the case and scheduled a date for his execution. The defendant then asked the Supreme Court
Nathaniel Allanger Vs Swift Transportation Case Study
113 Words | 1 PagesTo conclude, according to Nathaniel Belanger statement in court the accident could not be prevented. But it did not seem to hold up because there was no evidence to prove his story. The court took sides with Swift Transportation Incorporation because they felt that Swift did not slander Belanger and had every right to report the accident on the Data Website. I feel that if Belanger had a good attorney than his attorney would have found the other people that was involve in the accident to help prove his case and maybe even get his job back. This is the case of Nathaniel Belanger v. Swift Transportation and my opinion on the
Racial Profiling Case: The Lloyd Rayney Case
852 Words | 4 PagesBoth men were successful in their appeals as a verdict of guilty could not be settled upon as the case was based on improbabilities and circumstantial evidence that could not lead to a definite
Competency Restoration Case Study
1019 Words | 5 PagesPart 1 Explain the process of competency restoration. According to Hubbard, Zapf, & Ronan, (2003), “Competency restoration is the process used when an individual charged with a crime is found by a court to be incompetent to stand trial, typically due to an active mental illness or an intellectual disability.” Before the legal process can continue, a suspect should be restored to competency. That gives the suspect the chance to consult with his or her defense lawyer to have a factual and rational understanding of the legal proceedings.
Sammy Yatim Case Analysis
1126 Words | 5 PagesIn today’s modern society, many feel that is okay for a police officer can kill a man armed with a harmful weapon at any cost. On many news channels, there are various amounts of articles and reports about a police officer committing this act. Even though a police officer has the right to take action against an armed man, this could be argued in many circumstances. In the 2013, Sammy Yatim was a young adult with a mental illness and was armed with a weapon on a streetcar in Toronto. Yatim was confronted by Const.
Just Mercy Essay
672 Words | 3 PagesMcMillian recorded a common claim against state and neighborhood authorities, which went the distance to the U.S. Supreme Court. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled against McMillian, holding that an area sheriff couldn 't be sued for cash harms. Along these lines, McMillian settled with different authorities for an undisclosed sum. McMillian 's case served as a catalyst for Alabama 's pay statute, which was
Suicidal Belief Case Summary
576 Words | 3 PagesOn February 26, 1986, a female student, whom the court records refer to as C.R., at Morton East High School in Illinois brought a note to her school psychologist, Dr. Rosario C. Pesce. The note informed the plaintiff that C.R.’s male friend (“J.D”) was struggling with shame, confusion, and suicidal thoughts because a male teacher at Morton East High School allegedly abused J.D. sexually. After hearing this, Dr. Pesce gave C.R. a professional therapist’s contact information to pass along to J.D., and later that day, J.D. chose to come see Dr. Pesce in his office to discuss his confusion and suicidal thoughts (“Dr. Rosario”). Before discussing the content of the letter and the student’s suicidal thoughts, Dr. Pesce “assured the student…of the
Tomcik Case Study
785 Words | 4 PagesAfter reading this case I was terribly shocked about the fact that something like this could happen in our medical history. I couldn’t believe how a patient could be neglected so much. Based on the material that we have learned the lack of ethical theory of deontology in Dr. Evan was disturbing. As a doctor Dr. Evan’s role is to care for patients, keep them away from harm and prolong their life. Though in the trial he stated as if he didn’t care.
Wrongful Death Case: The Hill V. Ohio County
165 Words | 1 PagesThe Hill v. Ohio County involves a wrongful death case in which the hospital refused to admit Juanita Monroe. She thought she was in labor. As a result, she delivered her child at home without medical attention and died shortly after giving birth. The plaintiff was Lorene Hill, administer of Monroe’s estate, against Ohio Country Hospital. The question arises whether there was a breach of duty by the hospital in accordance to the institution’s admission policy.
Atul Gawande Whose Body Is It Anyway Analysis
590 Words | 3 PagesAtul Gawande in his article “Whose body is it, anyway?” introduced couple of cases, which discussed a controversial topic, doctors dealing with patients and making important medical decisions. These are difficult decisions in which people might have life or death choices. Who should make the important decisions, patients or doctors? Patients don’t usually know what is better for their health and while making their decisions, they might ignore or don’t know the possible side effects and consequences of these decisions.
The Lindbergh Case: Bruno Richard Hauptmann
1140 Words | 5 Pagesthe defense appealed. October 9, 1935 The Supreme Court of New Jersey upheld the verdict. Hauptmann 's apeal to the Suppreme Court was denied on December 9th, 1935 now we move the corrections side. Bruno Richard Hauptmann was set to be electrocuted on January 17, 1936.
More about Circle Inn Case Study
Case Citation: Gallagher V. Cayuga Medical Center
1153 Words | 5 PagesSummary Of The Case Of Tammy Lou Fontenot V. Taser International
311 Words | 2 PagesKuehn V. Pub Zone Case Study
1378 Words | 6 PagesFord Motor Credit Co. 2d 956
525 Words | 3 PagesWhat Is The Difference Between Joseph And Susie Hurtado
346 Words | 2 PagesNathaniel Allanger Vs Swift Transportation Case Study
113 Words | 1 PagesRacial Profiling Case: The Lloyd Rayney Case
852 Words | 4 PagesCompetency Restoration Case Study
1019 Words | 5 PagesSammy Yatim Case Analysis
1126 Words | 5 PagesJust Mercy Essay
672 Words | 3 PagesSuicidal Belief Case Summary
576 Words | 3 PagesTomcik Case Study
785 Words | 4 PagesWrongful Death Case: The Hill V. Ohio County
165 Words | 1 PagesAtul Gawande Whose Body Is It Anyway Analysis
590 Words | 3 PagesThe Lindbergh Case: Bruno Richard Hauptmann
1140 Words | 5 Pages