Civil Rights And Civil Liberties: Obergefell V. Hodges
Judi Herren GOV-140 American Government and Politics 9/30/15 J. Christopher Woolard, Ph.D. Civil Rights and Civil Liberties; Obergefell v. Hodges “By a 5-4 majority, the Supreme Court determined that a state can’t prohibit same-sex marriages and must also recognize valid out-of-state same-sex marriages, as both are protected under the due process and equal protection clauses of the fourteenth amendment.” (Karibjanian, 2015, p 34) In this landmark Supreme Court case, Obergefell v. Hodges, granted same sex couples the fundamental right to marry in any state and all other states now have to recognize that as a legal marriage. As a result of this Supreme Court ruling it has raised many questions pertaining to the violation of civil liberties. …show more content…
The justice system does work, and in the case of Obergefell v. Hodges there were civil liberties being violated when addressing same-sex marriage. With the different branches of the court system, it created a ripple effect which lead this case to the Supreme Court; starting with favorable rulings from the Federal District courts, which lead to reversals and bans from the Sixth Circuit courts, and finally a ruling in favor of same-sex couples from the Supreme …show more content…
The petitioners in the Obergefell v. Hodges case took a stand against what they believed was discriminatory against them, and although it took a great amount of time, money, and patience, they ultimately won the victory. Of course there are those that would disagree, Rowan County Clerk as an example. Although the rights and liberties of same-sex couples has been justified, her morals and values are now being objected to. It brings to light the question, if the civil liberties for same-sex couples is justified, are those who oppose it now suffering a violation of their civil liberties under the first Amendment; “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” Everyone has the right to practice, or not practice, the religion of their choice, but conversely, no one has the right to violate another’s civil liberties or rights in service of their choice of
Obergefell Vs. Hodges: Supreme Court Case Study
168 Words | 1 PagesObergefell v. Hodges is most popularly referred to as the Supreme Court case for same-sex marriage. It is one of the many cases related to the topic of same-sex marriage being a constitutional right. In this specific case James Obergefell and John Arthur filed a lawsuit against the state of Ohio to allow the state to recognize their marriage on death certificates. Obergefell and Arthur were married on the tarmac of the Baltimore-Washington International Airport in Maryland by Arthur’s aunt, Paulette Roberts, on July 11, 2013. Sadly, Arthur died from amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) just months into their marriage on October 22, 2013.
Case Study: Obergefell Vs. Hodges
1334 Words | 6 PagesThe case looks to the Equal Protection Clause and the Due Process Clause to determine whether same-sex couples have the right to marry, and whether the right to same-sex marriage is a fundamental right. The case was decided and the judges ruled in a 5-4 majority that it is Unconstitutional for states to deny same-sex couples the right to marry, or to refuse to recognize same-sex marriages that were performed out-of-state. Justices that voted in favor of the decision are Kennedy, Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan. The dissenting Justices are Roberts, Scalia, Thomas, and
DOMA Legislation Analysis
260 Words | 2 PagesThis situation was some time in coming, as events in recent years amplified the role of the federal government in the matter. Perhaps the most striking example of how that role has been carried out is the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) legislation of 1996. In 1993 the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled that it saw no constitutional basis for denying same-sex marriage; this created huge shock waves both in Hawaii and through the United States and the federal response was the creation of DOMA. The Constitution’s Full Faith and Credit Clause affirms that states are obligated to honor one another’s marriage licenses, as when age differences exist in different states. DOMA, very much a Republican administration reaction, reversed this and no state was
Era Of Cooperative Federalism
1810 Words | 8 PagesBut, as with its Commerce Clause jurisprudence, the Court’s expansive rights jurisprudence may not be taken for granted. Consider the 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges case, which legalized same-sex marriage in all states. That decision, undeniably, was an audacious assertion of power by the Supreme Court, one that brought the guillotine down on states’ internal deliberations as to the merits of same-sex marriage. I thus cannot deny that this decision counts in favor of the view that the Court holds a bias toward centralization, but there is another side to this coin, namely, the four impassioned dissenting opinions delivered by the Court. The principal dissent among these decried the Court for “invalidat[ing] the marriage laws of more than half the States” without their assent.
Brief Summary Of Article By Jack Pitney
1287 Words | 6 PagesHodges (2015): In Obergefell v. Hodges, the Supreme Court was asked to rule on whether the Fourteenth Amendment requires states and their departments to recognize Same-Sex marriage. In a 5-4 ruling, the court found that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the right to marry since it is one of the protected fundamental liberties. Additionally, the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the right of same-sex couples to marry. The Court also held that the First Amendment protects the rights of religious organizations to adhere to their principles, but it does not allow states to deny same-sex couples the right to
Civil Rights Act Of 1964 Essay
1000 Words | 4 PagesUnder the constitution, customers do not have the right to force a business to provide a service that would violate the owner’s religion—unless
Critical Analysis Essay On 13th Amendment
1228 Words | 5 PagesThe Supreme Court eventually held it was unconstitutional for States to deny same-sex couples the right to marriage (United States Supreme Court, "Obergefell v. Hodges. " 681). However, the States' misuse of the Tenth Amendment to defend its unconstitutional acts is blatant, and those acts will have negative
Religion Clauses Dwells The Free Exercise Clause
882 Words | 4 PagesUnder no circumstances should our license to exercise freedoms be ignored. Every person has the opportunity to express his or her religious belief or, to be free from pressure to believe.
The Importance Of The First Ten Amendments
483 Words | 2 PagesWe are allowed to voice our opinions. There is separation of church and state, which means that there can’t be laws made about religion. Recently, gay marriage was made legal in all fifty states. However, a judge in Kentucky has denied same-sex couples marriage licenses. It could be argued that if she denied it for her own religious beliefs, it violates the First Amendment.
What Are The Arguments Against The Separation Of Church And State
815 Words | 4 PagesMost recently, this has come into light in Kentucky where a county clerk, Kim Davis, refused to issue marriage licenses to gay couples, even though it is the law of the land as determined by the supreme court. However, actions such as these are considered unconstitutional and irrational because they violate the separation of church and state, are a misconception
Civil Liberties And Civil Rights (2016)
548 Words | 3 PagesAccording to fine, we have civil liberties and civil rights(fine,2016). There is a significant difference. As a United State citizen, we have civil liberties. These are defined as our rights that grants the ability to do and say things individually(Fine,2016). These relate back to the bill of rights(Fine,2016).
Kant Vs Foucault Analysis
1116 Words | 5 PagesPeople should have the right to defend themselves judicially and should obviously have the right to religious
Minority Rights In America
1008 Words | 5 PagesBrooke Teferra October 27, 2015 AP Government – 5R Quarter 1 Essay – Statement One A representative democracy is often characterized by the phrase, majority rule with minority rights. Throughout the history of this country the U.S. Constitution and by extension the U.S. government has been unsuccessful at keeping the majority from abusing the rights of the minority in many cases; one of the most widespread examples is the abuse of the rights African Americans, another more recent example being the abuse of rights of gay Americans. But these are not the only times the Constitution has failed at protecting citizens’ rights, the trials faced by Japanese American citizens during World War II are prime evidence for the abuse of minority rights.
SCOTUS Argument Against Gay Marriage
1022 Words | 5 PagesShould a craftsmen be able to discriminate against a same sex couple if their faith condemns gay marriage? That is the topic of the debate. The case’s intricacy comes from the fact that ruling in favor of the baker could open the floodgates to many forms of discrimination against many different types of people if someone’s interpretation of the bible condemns that person’s race, sexual orientation, as well as many other characteristics that make humans unique. For that reason justices may change their opinion and vote for the gay couple, but another strong counter argument can be made there as well. The argument being that according to the First Amendment citizens of the United States are granted with freedom of religion and arguably when he denied the couple a wedding cake Jack Phillips was exercising his amendment protected religion.
Lgbtqa Reflection
1082 Words | 5 PagesMany people think the battle for LGBTQA+ rights in the United States ends with our achievement of marriage equality. Unfortunately, it does not end there. In an article written by Jody L. Herman, Christy Mallory, and Bianca D.M. Wilson in March 2016, they state,”Nearly 300,000 transgender youth and adults may be negatively impacted by legislation introduced in 15 states. These bills would limit access to single-sex restrooms and locker rooms at schools and in public places; limit protections based on gender identity; permit individuals and businesses to discriminate against transgender people based on religious and moral beliefs; and limit the ability to change certain vital records documents, such as birth certificates, or enforce the use
More about Civil Rights And Civil Liberties: Obergefell V. Hodges
Obergefell Vs. Hodges: Supreme Court Case Study
168 Words | 1 PagesCase Study: Obergefell Vs. Hodges
1334 Words | 6 PagesDOMA Legislation Analysis
260 Words | 2 PagesEra Of Cooperative Federalism
1810 Words | 8 PagesBrief Summary Of Article By Jack Pitney
1287 Words | 6 PagesCivil Rights Act Of 1964 Essay
1000 Words | 4 PagesCritical Analysis Essay On 13th Amendment
1228 Words | 5 PagesReligion Clauses Dwells The Free Exercise Clause
882 Words | 4 PagesThe Importance Of The First Ten Amendments
483 Words | 2 PagesWhat Are The Arguments Against The Separation Of Church And State
815 Words | 4 PagesCivil Liberties And Civil Rights (2016)
548 Words | 3 PagesKant Vs Foucault Analysis
1116 Words | 5 PagesMinority Rights In America
1008 Words | 5 PagesSCOTUS Argument Against Gay Marriage
1022 Words | 5 PagesLgbtqa Reflection
1082 Words | 5 Pages