Nonrandom Classroom Assignment Analysis
There is considerable anecdotal evidence that the assignment process of students to teachers in many schools is far from “random”. Many parents have had the experience of requesting a preferred teacher for their child. In many schools, teachers confer to decide on classroom assignments for the incoming students; in others, the decision is made by the principal (in both cases with input from parents). The process rarely appears on its face to resemble simple random assignment. Moreover, there are numerous reasons why it may be of interest to systematically sort weaker and stronger students to different classes. First, it may be helpful in allowing teachers to target their lessons (Duflo et al. (2011)). Allocating certain teachers to the lower-level …show more content…
Assignment of students to schools is clearly not random, and represents another source of potential bias in value-added scores, but is not considered here. (Clotfelter et al. (2006)) I define two kinds of nonrandom classroom assignment practices, tracking and matching, that have often been lumped together in past work but that have different implications for value-added analysis. A school tracks if it assigns students to classrooms on the basis of prior test scores (or other characteristics correlated with them). A school matches if the same teachers tend to get the high-prior-score classrooms year after …show more content…
At another 45%, classroom assignments appear to be purely random. As for other observables, I find that almost all schools balance their classrooms by gender, and probably due to desegregation efforts, little (though nonzero) sorting exists by race.
In a follow-up descriptive analysis, I show that larger schools, schools with and more heterogeneous student populations in terms of achievement and free- and reduced price lunch status, and higher teacher turnover are more likely to engage in tracking & matching. School district effects explain about 30% of the variation in school-level assignment policies, mainly due to the district-level socioeconomic environment.
This paper closely relates to three recent papers. Clotfelter et al. (2006) examine heterogeneity in school matching practices as they relate to teachers' observable characteristics. Kalogrides et al. (2013) estimate correlations between teacher observables and students' lagged scores, within school-grade-year cells. Both papers find evidence for some sorts of matching. Dieterle et al. (2013) distinguish between tracking and matching, as I do, and investigate the sensitivity of different value-added model specifications to these types of nonrandom classroom
Segregation In The 1930's
531 Words | 3 Pages“Public schools were always separate and almost always vastly unequal” (Bell 12). In Georgia, the state spent about $43 per White student while only spending $10 per Black student. Thus, funding for White and Black students were extremely incompatible (“Segregation” 2007 para. #16).
Cutting Through The Hype Chapter Summary
1269 Words | 6 Pages“The intent behind closing these gaps is to break the connection between race or family income and achievement while at the same time continuing to improve the performance of the top students. ”(28) Gaps between race and wealth have always been issues in schools. Historically, children living in poverty are more likely to score lower on tests than those
Huckabee School Case Study
1610 Words | 7 PagesIn some schools spending per student exceeds $10000 per year but the graduation rate is below 50 percent for example in Detroit. Detroit spends about 11100 per year on each student but only 25 percent of their student’s graduate high school. Policymakers should focus on reforming policies and resource allocations to improve student achievement. According to the National Center for Education Statistics 52 percent of public Education expenditures are spent on instruct and this percentage keeps decreasing overtime. Children who benefit from the school choice program usually have higher test scores than their peers.
Summary Of A Troublesome Inheritance By Nicholas Wade
1629 Words | 7 PagesAs perfectly illustrated in Richard Sander and Stuart Taylor’s book Mismatch, underqualified students admitted to more prestigious institutions on the grounds of providing diversity results in a marked increase in those same students struggling in their field of study and even dropping out when compared to their peers who attend schools more closely aligned with their previous
Contrasting Goals Of Pearl Cohn And Hume Fogg
1837 Words | 8 PagesConfidence in the principle of universal equality of educational opportunity is difficult to maintain when one views the breadth of the educational landscape in America. When observing two schools that fall on opposite sides of the spectrum in nearly every measurable aspect, it is crucial to make sense of where such disparity is founded so that the education system can be altered to better society. One such example of a tremendous educational gap is found in the 3.6 miles that span between the Nashville High Schools Pearl Cohn and Hume Fogg. Pearl Cohn, an entertainment magnet school located in a predominantly African American and poor socioeconomic area, has a 69% graduation rate, whereas Hume Fogg, an academic magnet school with 97% of students
Comparing Schools By Achievement Scores In City Club By Macke Reymond
554 Words | 3 PagesMacke Reymond, in the video, “City Club”, describes how it is unfair to compare schools by achievement scores, without taking into account the demographics of the students. Factors that can affect overall achievement include poverty, race, special education, and English language learners. “Student’s come to school with different types of education endowments based on their backgrounds. They might have differences in their basic command of English, vocab, phonetic awareness, numeracy, and so on. These differences in knowledge affect the absolute level of knowledge they have, both when entering school and continuing on.”
Waiting For Superman Rhetorical Analysis
1056 Words | 5 PagesThey would pick the high performing student and avoid weaker students. That is not true. Charter school is basically a public school, which means it opens for public and treats people equally under state law. Charter school enroll all the applicants if there are enough available seats, otherwise lottery is used. In the documentary “Waiting for Superman”, there are a lot of drawing methods, and the probability an applicant gets called is very small.
Texas Accountability System History
1124 Words | 5 PagesCarnoy, Loeb, and Smith (2003) found a weakness in the relationships between TAKS scores and other outcomes such as high school graduation rates and scores on college entrance exams. Other researchers (Klein, Hamilton, McCaffrey, & Steecher, 2000) analyzed increases in scores in Texas on the NAEP, increases that they state political leaders attributed to the accountability system, and found that Texas score improvements in mathematics at grade 8 are not significantly different from those of other states that did not have strong accountability systems in place. In fact their data show evidence that the achievement gap between white students and underrepresented minorities actually increased. Some argue that the data show that the accountability program actually negatively impacts schools that were already academically behind before the implementation of the accountability system (Fassold,
Hidden Intellectualism Summary
762 Words | 4 PagesLevine claims that schools are starting to expand the quality of the student body by the rate of the students standardized test (22). Colleges are not looking to get students who do not apply themselves, but also, colleges are making it harder for the poor students that are trying to better their education. Along the same lines, Graff reminds us of the competition of comparing test scores in school (249). Graff explains, in school scores are made up by one’s reading ability, instead of, like in sports, the actual competition itself or arguing (249). Overall schools are using test scores as a way to compete with education instead of looking out for the best interests of the
Essay On Racial Disparity In Education
840 Words | 4 PagesTracking, a method used by schools to place students in classes with others of similar ability, follows students through their education. If a student was in gifted programs early in their education, tracking would put them in higher classes later. Karolyn Tyson wrote “Tracking has made it possible to have desegregation without integration” (Tyson 6). That means that tracking keeps students of color separate from white students even if they are in the same school. As told in the first paragraph, the disparity can be traced to gifted programs in early education.
The Pros And Cons Of American Education
1580 Words | 7 PagesImagine the United States in its near future: while a select few successful, affluent and influential people take power over the rest of the country and essentially control the way it operates domestically and internationally, the remainder of the population remains at a state comparable to the Great Depression in the 1930s, where unemployment rates are high, few unskilled jobs are available to the public, and the majority of urban residents are forced to rely on soup kitchens and live in shantytowns. The state of most United States schools today is absolutely atrocious, and should they continue to educate the modern generation of children and teens, a dystopian society is bound to arise in what is now considered one of the most powerful and
Cultural Background Analysis
738 Words | 3 PagesCultural background affects a student’s academic achievement by limiting the child’s preparedness for school. Cavanagh points out that how far a child succeeds in school is determined through the “achievement-oriented values, goals, and norms” that the child comes in with. Though the values and goals a student has directly come from his or her family, culture, and what they learn at home. American students who come from families who are immigrants or prefer speaking their own language at home, grow up in a household where English or educational things, like books or learning toys, are limited. “Having at least one parent with more than a high school degree, and attending a school with higher academic press [are] positively associated with”
Private School Stereotypes
1203 Words | 5 PagesDespite the contrasting environment, private school students are no different than public school students. In an online manifesto, If You Send Your Kid to Private school you are bad, Allison Benedikt, an executive editor states, “But many others go private for religious reasons, or because their kids have behavioral or learning issues, or simply because the public school in their district is not so hot”. This proves that private schools are not filled with angels, but rather kids who have behavioral issues and need that extra help. In senior writer and editor John S Kiernan’s, online article, Private Schools vs. Public Schools - Experts Weigh In, Patrick J. Wolf, Ph.D, proclaims, “Private schools also are becoming more diverse, as their enrollments increasingly include minority and low-income students”. Similar to a public school, private schooling have their low, medium and upper class students.
Argumentative Essay On Standardized Testing
1098 Words | 5 PagesSchool rankings are important and taken very seriously, especially in public schools. The higher a school ranks; the more advantages it gains. The government provides high ranking schools with funds or subsidies to help obtain new facilities, advanced technology, and more professionally experienced teachers. If students of a specific school do not achieve certain criterion that raises the school’s ranking, then the school will not gain the benefits of funds or subsidies that are provided by the government. To prevent this failure from becoming a reality, teachers will try and “teach to the test”.
Advantages And Disadvantages Of School-Based Management
1685 Words | 7 Pages8 high levels of professionalism 9 improved student retention and learning. – 10 benefit the community - parents and other stakeholders in shared decision making, interpersonal skills, and management skills 11 inexpensive -change in locus of decision making rather than a large increase in
More about Nonrandom Classroom Assignment Analysis
Segregation In The 1930's
531 Words | 3 PagesCutting Through The Hype Chapter Summary
1269 Words | 6 PagesHuckabee School Case Study
1610 Words | 7 PagesSummary Of A Troublesome Inheritance By Nicholas Wade
1629 Words | 7 PagesContrasting Goals Of Pearl Cohn And Hume Fogg
1837 Words | 8 PagesComparing Schools By Achievement Scores In City Club By Macke Reymond
554 Words | 3 PagesWaiting For Superman Rhetorical Analysis
1056 Words | 5 PagesTexas Accountability System History
1124 Words | 5 PagesHidden Intellectualism Summary
762 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Racial Disparity In Education
840 Words | 4 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of American Education
1580 Words | 7 PagesCultural Background Analysis
738 Words | 3 PagesPrivate School Stereotypes
1203 Words | 5 PagesArgumentative Essay On Standardized Testing
1098 Words | 5 PagesAdvantages And Disadvantages Of School-Based Management
1685 Words | 7 Pages