Playing God Analysis
Playing God
“Playing God has been a common metaphor for describing and redirecting the activities of scientists, physicians, and other health care professionals. They have been criticized for usurping God’s power- for instance, the power over life and death- by letting patients die or by using new reproductive technologies.(1) The metaphor is generally used to identify two aspects of divine activity that should not be imitated by humans: God’s unlimited power to decide and unlimited power to act. Critics frequently focus on human arrogance and rebellion in daring to “play God.” In a typical statement, Paul Ramsey writes: “Men ought not to play God before they learn to be men, and after they have learned to be men they will not play God.” (2)Thus,
…show more content…
For thousands of years, farmers have been using animals that have shown preferable characteristics as breeding stock, be it climatic resilience or suitability to certain climates. This has already been taken to an extreme with the rapid rise of factory farming, which seeks to maximise productivity above all else.
Cloning, is the process of making a genetically identical organism through nonsexual means. The aim of cloning farm animals is to produce replicas of the animals with the highest economic value, for instance the highest-yielding dairy cows or the fastest-growing pigs and it has taken intensive farming even further by treating farm animals as the ultimate commodity and manipulating them at cellular level in order to prioritise their productive characteristics. It has been used for many years to produce plants too (even growing a plant from a cutting is a form of cloning).
Animal cloning has been the subject of various scientific experiments for years but only gained little attention until the birth of the very first cloned mammal in 1996, a sheep named Dolly. Since then, scientists have began to clone other animals like cows and mice. The recent success in cloning animals has sparked fierce debates among politicians, scientists, and the general public about the use, morality and ethnicity of cloning animals, plants and possibly
The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks By Rebecca Skloot
2906 Words | 12 PagesBrianna Sauve Mods 7-8 English Research Project January 21,2015 Cloning is a topic discussed by many people. Cloning is controversial because there are both good and bad things about it. There are issues with the technology used in cloning. There are also scientists cloning embryos, animals, etc for research when that is not allowed. Cloning is tied to the story The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot, because it was mentioned in one of the chapters.
Let Em Play God Analysis
579 Words | 3 PagesIn Cujo, the author, uses imagery to create suspense. In the writing it states “Cujo came out of Joe Camber's garage. Donna stared at him, feeling her breath come to a painless and yet complete stop in her throat. It was the same dog. It was Cujo.
Jonathan Safran Foer Eating Animals Analysis
934 Words | 4 PagesThe farmers breed the animals with desirable traits for many generations compiling and enhancing these traits. “Some traits matter more to the producer, like the ever-important rate of feed conversion; some matter more to the consumer, like how lean
Eugene C. Newman's Argument Against Human Cloning
1552 Words | 7 PagesCloning is an idea that is often portrayed in science fiction as a way to essentially duplicate another living being. It has been making an appearance in the real world as something that could be useful in the medical and scientific fields as a way to bring back animals or to save peoples’ lives. Due to how unique cloning is, it was portrayed in famous parts of the media such as Jurassic Park. Although cloning does sound promising, it does possess a darker side to it, which does raise both moral and ethical issues. There are articles that do discuss cloning in which they either list the benefits of it or tell us about what moral and ethical issues that do come out of cloning.
Frankenstein And The Birthmark
1019 Words | 5 PagesHuman Cloning, an exact replication of an adult human, should be banned in the United States of America because of its possible consequences to society as a whole, as proven by the science fiction novel Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley, and the short story “The Birthmark,” by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Human cloning raises ethical concerns considering how society will react and change due to the clonal population. Subsequently, scientists are forced to ask themselves the question, “If cloning is seen as a way to reproduce the ‘best’ in the human species, who decides which qualities are best?” (Cloning 2). If humans are allowed to clone their offspring, then soon most people would either want their children to look like the idea of ‘perfect’ created
Frankenstein Pros And Cons Of Cloning
846 Words | 4 PagesScientists have cloned various animals to attempt to reproduce an exact replica of the original animal. One major reason why cloning animals is an ongoing issue is that it causes suffering for animals. It is said that “animal surrogates were manifesting adverse outcomes, and cloned animals were having diseases and even high mortality rates. One of these negative results is the large offspring syndrome (LOS), where clones are large at birth since they came
Frankenstein And The Birthmark Analysis
1325 Words | 6 PagesMany believe cloning is a perversion of science, and some are even concerned with a real life Frankenstein situation: “Reproductive cloning… could lead to a Dr. Frankenstein’s vision of lab manufactured humans. To me this is a perversion of science” (Ford 1). Furthermore, in Frankenstein, Dr. Frankenstein detached from the world as he became obsessed with his studies, diminishing his health. A similar thing could happen to scientists who clone if they decide that they are “playing god,” which can be dangerous for the scientists and the clones. Cloning is so controversial and causes an overbearing amount of stress for it to be befitting to the human mind, as Victor Frankenstein puts it, “If the study to which you apply yourself has a tendency to weaken your affections, and to destroy… those simple pleasures in which no alloy can possibly mix, then that study is certainly unlawful… not befitting of the human minds” (Shelley 50).
Jurassic Park: Has Science Gone Too Far?
1817 Words | 8 PagesWith the human mind becoming more intelligent as generations, decades, and centuries elapse, different scientific ideas are evolving and are becoming greater. The question is, “Has science gone too far?” In the article, “Dr. Daedalus”, Rosen thinks of plastic surgery as an art and science and wants to expand the norms of plastic surgery into something more than just your average cosmetic surgery; he wants to put wings on people, but people questioned and disagreed with the notion of putting wings on people and some thought that putting wings on humans was an act of trying to play God. The concept of playing the role of God correlates with the article, “In the Black Chamber”, when the businessmen and scientist wanted to revive extinct species. In both articles, the idea of putting wings on humans and reviving extinct species were questioned whether or not it was playing the role of God.
Cloning In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
1001 Words | 5 PagesThe benefits of cloning in the world far outweigh any of the consequences. Opportunities for cloning to save lives exists everywhere, whether it be in saving an existing life and in the process creating a new life. Science should disregard Victor Frankenstein’s advice of “(seeking) happiness in tranquility and avoid ambition, even if it be only the apparently innocent one of distinguishing yourself in science and discoveries” (Shelley 162), and instead continue to further their research and continue publishing an advocating the use and benefits of
Ethics In Frankenstein
2052 Words | 9 PagesPlaying God as a Fallen Angel As scientific progress continues to charge forward at an increasingly rapid pace, the ethical implications of certain areas of research have become increasingly blatant. Stem cell research is a discipline of science that attempts to procure human stem cells in order to develop new ways to treat various diseases. Stem cells are cells that have not become specialized for a certain role in the body yet and are thought to hold the key to solving countless physiological problems; the downside of researching the cells comes from their origin, which is most often a fetus, and even after technological developments allowing for non-fetal cells to be used, the moral implications have still been debated by many. The ethical
Essay On The Pros And Cons Of Animal Cloning
1084 Words | 5 PagesCloning at the gene level is acceptable and is done extensively in research areas. However, therapeutic cloning and reproductive cloning raises skepticism and debate both in the general society and the scientific community. Among the argument raised is the possibility of cloning human beings; whether the individuals derived are seen as a complete human with the whole set of human rights attached to them. Body >>> Scientific Advantage <<< 2 PAR Fiester (2005) states that most of the animal cloning projects are driven by the goal of meeting human needs such as treatment of diseases, food production, and entertainment. However, there are animal cloning projects aimed at conserving endangered or
Cloning Persuasive Speech
988 Words | 4 PagesCloning might seem like new technology. However, it is nothing new! Many of you must have heard of Dolly the sheep once in your life. Dolly is the very first mammal to be cloned; it was cloned from an adult sheep’s somatic cell. Just like Dolly, many other animal species such as dogs, cats, horses, pigs, rabbits, frogs, wolves, goats, monkeys, and fish, have been cloned and reproduced.
Argumentative Essay: The Ethics Of Human Cloning
1614 Words | 7 PagesMost people in our society, no matter what level of education that they may have, have heard of the cloning, specifically the cloning of Dolly the lamb, and have some notions regarding the idea of cloning humans. "The successes in animal cloning suggest to some that the technology has matured sufficiently to justify its application to human cloning" (Jaenisch et al.). However, not every agrees that human cloning is a something that should be put into practice (Hoskins). There generally seem to be two basic divisions on this issue: those who find it inappropriate and unethical, and those who find it a reasonable and necessary step in the progression of scientific research (Lustig).
Is Human Cloning Is Wrong Essay
1531 Words | 7 PagesHuman cloning tends to take place in unreliable laboratories, with scientists who have limited knowledge on what to do if a step they take is incorrect because they are usually just experimenting in unknown territory. (is this true?? Lots of laws regarding cloning especially in the UK) This leads to major ethical difficulties as scientists are playing with human life. Furthermore, if a clone is made and there is even the slightest mishap, whereby the clone could be inclined to suffer if given the chance to grow, some would strongly oppose due to the fact that human life is so complex and needs a perfect designer, not a person in a laboratory wearing a white coat and plastic goggles.
Human Cloning Be Banned Essay
862 Words | 4 PagesDo you know that based on the scientific studies, 90% human cloning tuned out to be unsuccessful. Human cloning(modifying babies) is a process of producing new identical babies by altering their genomes. Some of studies show that scientists successfully cloned animals such as cows, Pigs, and sheep. For the past 3-5 years human cloning have a lot of debates and controversies between peoples. However Human cloning is dangerous for the new engineered baby and their moms, so it should be banned to prevent new disease, to constantly limit the population of dying human beings, and to stop unnecessary fees to modify babies.
More about Playing God Analysis
The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks By Rebecca Skloot
2906 Words | 12 PagesLet Em Play God Analysis
579 Words | 3 PagesJonathan Safran Foer Eating Animals Analysis
934 Words | 4 PagesEugene C. Newman's Argument Against Human Cloning
1552 Words | 7 PagesFrankenstein And The Birthmark
1019 Words | 5 PagesFrankenstein Pros And Cons Of Cloning
846 Words | 4 PagesFrankenstein And The Birthmark Analysis
1325 Words | 6 PagesJurassic Park: Has Science Gone Too Far?
1817 Words | 8 PagesCloning In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
1001 Words | 5 PagesEthics In Frankenstein
2052 Words | 9 PagesEssay On The Pros And Cons Of Animal Cloning
1084 Words | 5 PagesCloning Persuasive Speech
988 Words | 4 PagesArgumentative Essay: The Ethics Of Human Cloning
1614 Words | 7 PagesIs Human Cloning Is Wrong Essay
1531 Words | 7 PagesHuman Cloning Be Banned Essay
862 Words | 4 Pages