Compare And Contrast Hurricane Katrina
Response Comparison: Hurricane Katrina VS. San Bernardino Terrorist Attack
Armstrong, Troy
Union Institute & University
Critical Incident Management-Response Course
Spring 2022-2023 Term
Instructor Ron Santo
Abstract
In comparison, there were many differences between the 2005 Hurricane Katrina response and the December 2015 response to the San Bernardino Terrorist Attacks. There were main strengths and opportunities for improvement identified in both responses specific to emergency services. Furthermore, the utilization of response to address life safety, incident stabilization, property preservation and social-economic impacts continue to play a role in emergency response lessons learned taught today. Response Comparison: Hurricane Katrina
…show more content…
Part of this is because the terrorist attack was isolated, it didn’t span multiple political jurisdictions as Hurricane Katrina did. Furthermore, the terrorist attack was an immediate and tangible threat. With Hurricane Katrina maintaining situational awareness was not effective and there was no common operating picture for the local, state and federal responses. The biggest difference of course would be the physical footprint of each incident. Hurricane Katrina spanned multiple political subdivisions, impacted multiple areas having jurisdiction and made resource availability more limited than that of the San Bernadino incident. Additionally, one was a natural disaster with the other being a terrorist man-made incident. The hazard itself being a difference would result in a variation in the type of response required. The primary agency in a terrorist event may differ from than that of a Hurricane response. While both incident responses had opportunities for improvement, overall the Sand Bernadino response seemed to be more coordinated and effectuated more inter-agency collaboration. When planning for any type of incident, regardless of what type of hazard it is, there will be similarities and differences. Of course, when looking a terroristic event versus a large-scale natural disaster response, some of the same agencies may respond, although the primary responsibilities may vary. Although, interoperable communications and unified command operations can be utilized regardless the type of hazard that is being responded to. For example, Law Enforcement may be in more of a lead role on a terrorist event with Fire/EMS providing support while in a search and rescue operation during the Hurricane the roles may be reversed. Regardless, the response efforts should
9/11: Vulnerabilities In The US Emergency Management System
633 Words | 3 PagesHurricane Katrina shift the position of the Department of Homeland Security from making natural disasters an equally as important as terrorism. This even showed that disaster planning requires a great deal of collaboration. The Department of Homeland Security who swallowed up FEMA where not quick to react to Hurricane Katrina because all their focus was spend on planning for a prevent terrorist attacks. The failure of the disaster response system resulted in over 1,200 lives lost in Louisiana and Mississippi. FEMA failed to work closely with its State and local counterparts and communications between these partners and the public were strained at best.
Pros And Cons Of The Federal Response Plan
227 Words | 1 PagesFinally on this note, the Federal Response Plan (FRP) has been revised into the National Response Plan (NRP). Many of the positive features of the FRP have been retained in the NRP but the focus has been shifted dramatically to responding to a terrorist attack and in doing so, the role of the Federal government has been altered dramatically. The NRP places the lead role in responding to major disasters, terrorist attack or natural disaster, in the hands of Federal officials. In fact, the Federal government now has the authority to respond to an event in a State without a request by the Governor. This alters the traditional role of the Federal government, through the FRP, supporting the actions of State and local government.
9/11 Compare And Contrast
321 Words | 2 PagesThey are the two most known terrorist attacks in America. We know that they’re both terrorist attacks, and have some similarities, but they have many differences. One similarity between the two is they were
Ninth Ward And Response Like Second Disaster
546 Words | 3 PagesIn both “Ninth ward” and “Response like second disaster”, the authors Jewell Parker Rhodes and Anna Badkhen present the real world issue of Hurricane Katrina. How it affected the lives of millions of people, spactiflicle in New Orleans. In the “Ninth ward” it’s about the survival after the hurricane. While in “response like second disaster” it is about the aftermath of the hurricane. How people reacted and how the government reacted.
Hmsc/260 Introduction To Homeland Security Essay
497 Words | 2 PagesIn my opinion the organizations are more comprehensive than other organizations. Innovative ways are being implied to when new technologies are being created and applied. The infrastructures of an organization are complex for FEMA and Department Homeland Security to implement and resolve many type of disaster. To identifying community hazards, specific threats and setting capability targets for each core capability resources to meet the capability
Comparison Between Hurricane Katrina And New Orleans
153 Words | 1 PagesIt was 6:10 in the morning August 28 2005 and New Orleans had just been struck. Homes were being demolished, people were screaming, innocent people were getting killed from the result of the storm surge. . To this day there are 705 people still missing. While people are living there normal lives, they have not yet to know that in the middle of the Atlantic warm air is rising and it is getting replaced by the cooler air. the Not to forget, the hurricane affected their economy because of $81 billion dollars of property damage.
Long Island Research Paper
873 Words | 4 PagesThe storm flooded whole streets in the suburban areas, shutdown subway lines, left millions of homes without power for weeks, closed major airports, and resulted in the evacuation of over 370,000 people in the city (Dolnick NYTimes). Experts believe that the storm also created mini-tornadoes causing even more untold damage that totaled to 15.8 million dollars in damages (Dolnick NYTimes). This storm, that stuck about one year before Sandy, was many New Yorkers’ first experience of a storm that violent. When Irene made contact with New York, it was downgraded to a tropical storm, not a hurricane. This storm is important because it resulted in many policy changes in New York’s legislation in terms of storm preparation and preparedness.
Hurricane Katrina Research Paper
528 Words | 3 PagesAlthough storms like Hurricane Katrina occur once in every one hundred years, being prepared and storing water, food, medicines, and other supplies keep families ready for any disaster. Natural disasters can leave communities without power for days and even for weeks. Being prepared in the event of severe weather and disasters like Hurricane Katrina, can reduce fear and anxiety that accompanies disasters. A crucial element of self-sufficient living is survival. Our government does not have all the resources to be totally prepared to take care of the vast numbers of people in a disaster.
I Survived Hurricane Katrina Essay
1048 Words | 5 Pages“More than 68 million meals were served during the response” (Red Cross Helps When Disaster Strikes”). Feeding the newly homeless and people who now had nothing was also a top priority. Making sure no one starved to death in the middle of a tropical storm was important. Neighboring states offered shelters and meal to anyone affected by the storm. During the storm FEMA, provided daily updates which helped people around the world understand the severity of the storm and what the people were going through.
Hurricane Katrina Social Factors
1329 Words | 6 PagesSocial determinants have become an influential component of innovation within traditional areas of research, from overall health of communities to disaster management. Starting in the 1980’s, researchers began to understand that social contexts, both micro and macro, have a significant impact on both individuals and the community as a whole when discussing response and resilience to disasters. After the chaos of Hurricane Katrina, after the sheer difference of separate populations ability to cope during the disaster area came to light, researchers began to elucidate the social factors which affect disaster response and ways to assess those for future disasters. The three largest areas of concerns that should be considered are social stratification and class, race and
Similarities Between Hurricane Katrina And Super Storm Sandy
170 Words | 1 PagesHurricane Katrina and Super Storm Sandy both brought disaster in their wake, but from the hardships that followed, came the united work force of the local communities that were affected. Journalist Kaid Benfield reported in regards to Katrina, and how the combined effort of local volunteers and provincial resources like the PRC (Preservation Resource Center) or RTNO (Rebuilding Together New Orleans) had brought relief. Work ranged from, rebuilding and inhabiting homes, primarily focusing on the urban poor, to restoring historic neighborhoods with the goal to protect their rich culture. Likewise, environmental journalist Ben Jervey who covered Super Storm Sandy noted similar efforts in regards to locality. Both community leaders and planners
Vancouver Stanley Cup Riot Incident Analysis
700 Words | 3 PagesWhereas, during a natural disaster it may be difficult to gain access to such resources and therefore, some people can be facing this issue for the first time in their lives. Which can result in conflict and lawlessness taking place. For instance, if a natural disaster was to occur in a less developed country such as Afghanistan, the citizens would not be in a sudden shock if they no longer has access to electricity or any other issues since poverty is issue in the country and they have already adapted into living and surviving in such living conditions that may occur during a natural disaster. However, if such was to occur in Ottawa then it would be a completely different situation since many people might be feeling helplessness and panic due to living
Similarities Between Hurricane Katrina And The 2010 Earthquake In Haiti
2082 Words | 9 PagesIntroduction Throughout history, natural disasters have decimated countless communities worldwide. The aftermath of these disasters have caused numerous ongoing debates. In response, countries have developed policies and plans that revolve around mitigation, providing relief, and facilitating recovery efforts after one of these events. Moreover, private and nonprofit organizations have helped immensely with the rehabilitation of communities when disaster strikes. When looking at the history of natural disasters there are two that stand out: Hurricane Katrina in 2005 and the 2010 earthquake in Haiti.
Hurricane Katrina Unpreparedness
911 Words | 4 PagesIn the wake of a dark time, Hurricane Katrina proved to America how crucial preparedness is. Three reasons Hurricane Katrina proved unpreparedness include; The New Orleans poorly built levee system, the prolonged displacement
9/11 2005 Essay
1100 Words | 5 PagesThe 9/11 attacks highlighted the need for improved information sharing among intelligence and law enforcement agencies. The National Incident Management Assistance Teams (IMATs): FEMA established IMATs to provide on-the-ground support during disasters and help coordinate federal resources with state, local, tribal, and territorial governments. These teams assist in disaster response and recovery operations. The National Response Framework (NRF) was introduced in 2008, and it outlines the roles, responsibilities, and coordination mechanisms for federal, state, local, tribal, and territorial entities during incidents requiring a coordinated response. It provides a framework for integrated response efforts which were made to enhance communication capabilities among emergency responders.
More about Compare And Contrast Hurricane Katrina
9/11: Vulnerabilities In The US Emergency Management System
633 Words | 3 PagesPros And Cons Of The Federal Response Plan
227 Words | 1 Pages9/11 Compare And Contrast
321 Words | 2 PagesNinth Ward And Response Like Second Disaster
546 Words | 3 PagesHmsc/260 Introduction To Homeland Security Essay
497 Words | 2 PagesComparison Between Hurricane Katrina And New Orleans
153 Words | 1 PagesLong Island Research Paper
873 Words | 4 PagesHurricane Katrina Research Paper
528 Words | 3 PagesI Survived Hurricane Katrina Essay
1048 Words | 5 PagesHurricane Katrina Social Factors
1329 Words | 6 PagesSimilarities Between Hurricane Katrina And Super Storm Sandy
170 Words | 1 PagesVancouver Stanley Cup Riot Incident Analysis
700 Words | 3 PagesSimilarities Between Hurricane Katrina And The 2010 Earthquake In Haiti
2082 Words | 9 PagesHurricane Katrina Unpreparedness
911 Words | 4 Pages9/11 2005 Essay
1100 Words | 5 Pages